My Broker Reviews

Broker execution terms and external routing

A principal counterparty can hedge exposure externally. A contractual routing promise is distinct from independent proof of a hedge for every fill. This category grades the commitment in the named contract or partner route; it does not infer live execution from marketing.

60 documented grades · 0 tariff assessments · 40 evidence penalties. Weight in the overall score: 15%.

Category positions run 1–100, grade descending. Equal grades are listed A–Z and marked equal; the listing order does not imply a quality difference.

A-book commitment positions and grades
Category #BrokerCategory gradeOverall # / fitEvidence basis
#1Vantora Markets8/10 #2 · 5.4/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Contractual per fill acceptance

Vantora Markets assessment · 5 cited sources

#2JustMarkets6/10 #51 · 2.4/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Contractual blanket external route

JustMarkets assessment · 8 cited sources

#3equal gradeActivTrades4/10 #73 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

ActivTrades assessment · 3 cited sources

#4equal gradeACY Securities4/10 #12 · 3.9/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

ACY Securities assessment · 5 cited sources

#5equal gradeAdmirals4/10 #46 · 2.4/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Admirals assessment · 3 cited sources

#6equal gradeAlpari4/10 #32 · 2.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Alpari assessment · 2 cited sources

#7equal gradeAMarkets4/10 #18 · 3.6/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

AMarkets assessment · 4 cited sources

#8equal gradeATFX4/10 P#25 · 3.0/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the identity of the liquidity providers of AT Global Markets LLC and whether they are companies of the ATFX group.

ATFX assessment · 2 cited sources

#9equal gradeAxi4/10 P#5 · 4.2/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 (review hold)

Axi assessment · 3 cited sources

#10equal gradeAxiory4/10 P#17 · 3.7/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the identity of the liquidity provider or venue to which Axiory Global Limited sends client orders, whether it is independent of the Axiory and related companies, and whether every client order is passed on.

Axiory assessment · 6 cited sources

#11equal gradeBaxia Markets4/10 #26 · 3.0/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Baxia Markets assessment · 5 cited sources

#12equal gradeBlackBull Markets4/10 #1 · 5.5/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

BlackBull Markets assessment · 4 cited sources

#13equal gradeCapital.com4/10 P#74 · 1.2/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing whether Capital Com SV Investments, the Cyprus group company that executes every UK order as principal, passes the risk on outside the group.

Capital.com assessment · 4 cited sources

#14equal gradeCMC Markets4/10 #75 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

CMC Markets assessment · 4 cited sources

#15equal gradeCMTrading4/10 #30 · 2.8/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

CMTrading assessment · 4 cited sources

#16equal gradeCWG Markets4/10 P#27 · 3.0/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the names of the financial institutions that act as execution venue under clause 22.1, whether any of them is a group company, and whether clause 22.1 or the own-order-book clauses govern a retail CFD order.

CWG Markets assessment · 7 cited sources

#17equal gradeDecode Global4/10 #76 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Decode Global assessment · 2 cited sources

#18equal gradeDeriv4/10 #33 · 2.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Deriv assessment · 5 cited sources

#19equal gradeDoo Prime4/10 #34 · 2.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Doo Prime assessment · 2 cited sources

#20equal gradeDukascopy4/10 #24 · 3.5/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Dukascopy assessment · 4 cited sources

#21equal gradeEBC Financial Group4/10 #35 · 2.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

EBC Financial Group assessment · 4 cited sources

#22equal gradeEightcap4/10 #47 · 2.4/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Eightcap assessment · 3 cited sources

#23equal gradeeToro4/10 #36 · 2.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

eToro assessment · 2 cited sources

#24equal gradeExness4/10 #77 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Exness assessment · 3 cited sources

#25equal gradeFBS4/10 #78 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

FBS assessment · 2 cited sources

#26equal gradeFP Markets4/10 P#28 · 3.0/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing whether any current account type has the Cyprus company itself as execution venue (policy s. 7.1) or every order is passed on as agent (agreement s. 15.1); and the execution and hedging terms of First Prudential Markets Pty Ltd, the affiliated venue that received all retail volume.

FP Markets assessment · 3 cited sources

#27equal gradeFPG Fortune Prime Global4/10 #65 · 1.8/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

FPG Fortune Prime Global assessment · 4 cited sources

#28equal gradeFusion Markets4/10 #6 · 4.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Fusion Markets assessment · 4 cited sources

#29equal gradeFXCC4/10 P#7 · 4.2/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the name of the broker or brokers to which Central Clearing Ltd (Mwali) transmits client orders, and whether it is a group company.

FXCC assessment · 5 cited sources

#30equal gradeFXCM4/10 #79 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

FXCM assessment · 3 cited sources

#31equal gradeFXGT4/10 P#80 · 1.2/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the name of the market maker that takes the other side of FXGT.com trades and whether it is a group company; the Order Execution Policy of GT Global Ltd; confirmation that s. 28.15 is in the version of the terms now in force.

FXGT assessment · 1 cited source

#32equal gradeFXOpen4/10 #48 · 2.4/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

FXOpen assessment · 6 cited sources

#33equal gradeFxPro4/10 #66 · 1.8/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

FxPro assessment · 4 cited sources

#34equal gradeFXTM4/10 #49 · 2.4/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

FXTM assessment · 3 cited sources

#35equal gradeGlobal Prime4/10 #59 · 2.1/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Global Prime assessment · 4 cited sources

#36equal gradeGO Markets4/10 #13 · 3.9/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

GO Markets assessment · 4 cited sources

#37equal gradeHFM4/10 #37 · 2.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

HFM assessment · 3 cited sources

#38equal gradeHirose Financial4/10 #63 · 2.0/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Hirose Financial assessment · 6 cited sources

#39equal gradeIC Markets4/10 #19 · 3.6/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

IC Markets assessment · 4 cited sources

#40equal gradeIG4/10 #67 · 1.8/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

IG assessment · 3 cited sources

#41equal gradeINFINOX4/10 P#38 · 2.7/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing whether the liquidity providers and the prime broker that receive INFINOX Global Limited's client orders are outside the INFINOX group, and whether the blanket transmission clause or the discretionary clause of the policy governs.

INFINOX assessment · 5 cited sources

#42equal gradeInstaForex4/10 #39 · 2.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

InstaForex assessment · 3 cited sources

#43equal gradeInteractive Brokers4/10 #81 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Interactive Brokers assessment · 5 cited sources

#44equal gradeIntertrader4/10 #82 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Intertrader assessment · 6 cited sources

#45equal gradeIronFX4/10 #50 · 2.4/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

IronFX assessment · 1 cited source

#46equal gradeIUX4/10 #83 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

IUX assessment · 4 cited sources

#47equal gradeJFD Brokers4/10 #68 · 1.8/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

JFD Brokers assessment · 3 cited sources

#48equal gradeMarkets.com4/10 #3 · 4.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Markets.com assessment · 3 cited sources

#49equal gradeMoneta Markets4/10 P#20 · 3.6/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the identity of the liquidity provider with common shareholdings, the share of client orders sent to it and whether it hedges those orders with counterparties outside the group.

Moneta Markets assessment · 8 cited sources

#50equal gradeMultiBank Group4/10 P#69 · 1.8/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing which of the two statements governs, and the identity of the executing brokers and hedging counterparties (group companies or outside firms).

MultiBank Group assessment · 6 cited sources

#51equal gradeNAGA4/10 #40 · 2.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

NAGA assessment · 4 cited sources

#52equal gradeOANDA4/10 #84 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

OANDA assessment · 3 cited sources

#53equal gradeOcta4/10 #21 · 3.6/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Octa assessment · 4 cited sources

#54equal gradePepperstone4/10 #14 · 3.9/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Pepperstone assessment · 2 cited sources

#55equal gradePlus5004/10 #91 · 0.6/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Plus500 assessment · 4 cited sources

#56equal gradePU Prime4/10 #8 · 4.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

PU Prime assessment · 3 cited sources

#57equal gradeSaxo4/10 #85 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Saxo assessment · 4 cited sources

#58equal gradeScope Markets4/10 #41 · 2.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Scope Markets assessment · 2 cited sources

#59equal gradeSpreadex4/10 #31 · 2.8/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Spreadex assessment · 4 cited sources

#60equal gradeSquaredFinancial4/10 P#42 · 2.7/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing which execution route (counterparty or third-party transmission) applies to the SquaredPro and SquaredElite accounts.

SquaredFinancial assessment · 5 cited sources

#61equal gradeStarTrader4/10 #9 · 4.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

StarTrader assessment · 11 cited sources

#62equal gradeStoneX Trading UK4/10 #86 · 1.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

StoneX Trading UK assessment · 3 cited sources

#63equal gradeSwissquote4/10 #55 · 2.4/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Swissquote assessment · 4 cited sources

#64equal gradeSwitch Markets4/10 #56 · 2.4/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Switch Markets assessment · 4 cited sources

#65equal gradeT4Trade4/10 #61 · 2.1/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

T4Trade assessment · 4 cited sources

#66equal gradeTickmill4/10 #4 · 4.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Tickmill assessment · 1 cited source

#67equal gradeTMGM4/10 #15 · 3.9/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

TMGM assessment · 4 cited sources

#68equal gradeTrade Nation4/10 #10 · 4.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Trade Nation assessment · 2 cited sources

#69equal gradeTrade.com4/10 P#29 · 2.9/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the identity of TCM's current CFD liquidity provider(s) and whether any is a group company, or policy wording committing every order to a third-party provider.

Trade.com assessment · 5 cited sources

#70equal gradeTradeview Markets4/10 #11 · 4.2/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Tradeview Markets assessment · 2 cited sources

#71equal gradeTrading 2124/10 #93 · 0.6/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Trading 212 assessment · 2 cited sources

#72equal gradeVT Markets4/10 P#16 · 3.9/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the identity of the related liquidity provider, the share of orders it receives and whether it passes them on outside the VT Markets group.

VT Markets assessment · 5 cited sources

#73equal gradeWindsor Brokers4/10 #44 · 2.7/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

Windsor Brokers assessment · 2 cited sources

#74equal gradeXTB4/10 #62 · 2.1/10Documented grade
Why this grade?

Discretionary or mixed routing

XTB assessment · 7 cited sources

#75equal gradeZFX4/10 P#45 · 2.7/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the name of the broker(s) to which the Seychelles company transmits orders, whether it is a Zeal Group company, and whether that company routes onward outside the group.

ZFX assessment · 4 cited sources

#76equal gradeAdroFx0/10 P#94 · 0.0/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing adroFx's own order execution policy, or any clause saying whether client orders are hedged or passed to a party outside the group.

AdroFx assessment · 2 cited sources

#77equal gradeAvaTrade0/10 P#87 · 0.6/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

AvaTrade assessment · 3 cited sources

#78equal gradeBDSwiss0/10 P#72 · 1.5/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

BDSwiss assessment

#79equal gradeBullwaves0/10 P#58 · 2.1/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing an applicable execution/hedging policy that binds the assessed account to an external-group route.

Bullwaves assessment · 3 cited sources

#80equal gradeeasyMarkets0/10 P#64 · 1.8/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–4 · missing whether EF Worldwide Ltd (BVI) hedges or passes on client positions at all, and if so whether the counterparty is a group company or a firm outside the group.

easyMarkets assessment · 4 cited sources

#81equal gradeFinam0/10 P#95 · 0.0/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

Finam assessment · 2 cited sources

#82equal gradeFintana0/10 P#96 · 0.0/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

Fintana assessment

#83equal gradeFOREX.com0/10 P#97 · 0.0/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

FOREX.com assessment

#84equal gradeFortrade0/10 P#88 · 0.6/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

Fortrade assessment · 2 cited sources

#85equal gradeHeadway0/10 P#60 · 2.1/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing any statement by JAROCEL PTY LTD of how client orders are executed: its capacity, whether positions are hedged or passed to outside liquidity providers, and whether that is discretionary or contractual.

Headway assessment · 4 cited sources

#86equal gradeHYCM0/10 P#89 · 0.6/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

HYCM assessment · 1 cited source

#87equal gradeiFOREX0/10 P#57 · 2.2/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–4 · missing whether the group-level statement that client positions are not hedged externally counts as the assessed route explicitly excluding external hedging, given that iCFD Limited's own agreement keeps discretion to hedge with another financial firm.

iFOREX assessment · 5 cited sources

#88equal gradeLibertex0/10 P#90 · 0.6/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

Libertex assessment · 2 cited sources

#89equal gradeM4Markets0/10 P#52 · 2.4/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a term or policy of Trinota Markets (Global) Limited saying whether client orders are passed to or hedged with an outside party, whether that is at the company's discretion, and whether the venue is a group company.

M4Markets assessment · 4 cited sources

#90equal gradeMarkets4you0/10 P#53 · 2.4/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a contractual statement, for the Classic Pro account at E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc., of whether client orders are passed to external liquidity providers, hedged, or may be internalised at the firm's discretion; and who operates MarketPlace.

Markets4you assessment · 7 cited sources

#91equal gradeNordFX0/10 P#54 · 2.4/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing any contractual statement by NordFX Ltd on whether client orders are passed to outside liquidity providers, hedged or internalised, and at whose discretion.

NordFX assessment · 4 cited sources

#92equal gradeRoboForex0/10 P#22 · 3.6/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a statement in RoboForex Ltd's client documents of how client orders are executed: as principal or agent, whether each order or the net exposure is hedged, and with which counterparties outside the group.

RoboForex assessment · 5 cited sources

#93equal gradeSkilling0/10 P#98 · 0.0/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

Skilling assessment · 2 cited sources

#94equal gradeSway Markets0/10 P#99 · 0.0/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

Sway Markets assessment

#95equal gradeThinkMarkets0/10 P#92 · 0.6/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing what the UK terms and order execution policy commit to: whether the firm may hedge or internalise at its discretion, the named execution venue or hedge counterparty, and whether TF Global Markets (Aust) Pty Ltd passes the positions on outside the group.

ThinkMarkets assessment · 2 cited sources

#96equal gradeTraders Trust0/10 P#23 · 3.6/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a contractual statement of how Traders Trust Ltd handles client orders: blanket external routing or hedging, discretion to keep or hedge, or exclusion of external routing, and whether any venue is a group company.

Traders Trust assessment · 4 cited sources

#97equal gradeTriumphFX0/10 P#100 · 0.0/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: nothing established

TriumphFX assessment · 6 cited sources

#98equal gradeVantage0/10 P#43 · 2.7/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing any term in a Vantage Global Limited document that says how forex and CFD client orders are routed or hedged (externally, internally or at the firm's discretion).

Vantage assessment · 6 cited sources

#99equal gradeWorld Forex0/10 P#70 · 1.8/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing an execution policy or client-agreement clause of Exispro LTD that commits to, or excludes, passing orders to or hedging them with outside parties.

World Forex assessment · 2 cited sources

#100equal gradeXM0/10 P#71 · 1.8/10Evidence penalty
Why this grade?

Penalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a statement by XM Global Limited of whether it hedges client exposure at all, and if so with whom (inside or outside the group).

XM assessment · 3 cited sources

Related broker lists

Positions are global preference-fit positions, not confirmation that an account is available in your country. Read the weights and evidence rules. P marks an evidence penalty; T marks a tariff assessment with average all-in cost unverified.