How we rank
All 100 brokers on five criteria, weighted. The ranking measures fit with five stated preferences, read from documents.
Weighting updated 20 November 2026: company structure 40%; costs, copy trading, A-book and IB-only 15% each. Previously every category was 20%. This is an editorial weighting change; individual broker grades and evidence are unchanged.
The five criteria
- Company structure40%
Your preference for fewer disclosed operating jurisdictions; this is not a safety score.
Grades: 10 = one European; 6 = one Seychelles or Saint Lucia; 7 = one other; 4 = two; 2 = three or four; 0 = five or more.
- Published costs15%
Indicative EUR/USD intraday cost: one standard lot, USD account, quoted spread plus round-trip commission. Not a live cost test.
Grades: 10 = USD<=5; 8 = USD>5 7; 6 = USD>7 10; 4 = USD>10 15; 2 = USD>15 20; 0 = USD>20.
- Copy trading15%
Automated leader copying, sizing, follower controls and fees for the named entity/product. Not a profitability rating.
Grades: 10 = automation sizing controls fees; 8 = automation sizing fees; 6 = automation with sizing or fees; 4 = automation only; 0 = confirmed no automated leader copying.
- A-book commitment15%
What the named route commits to do with exposure. Principal dealing is not proof of B-book; marketing is not fill evidence.
Grades: 10 = independently reconciled per fill; 8 = contractual per fill acceptance; 6 = contractual blanket external route; 4 = discretionary or mixed routing; 0 = explicitly no external routing.
- IB-only preference15%
Preference for volume/revenue IB remuneration without CPA. Neither model guarantees aligned incentives or establishes fraud.
Grades: 10 = affirmatively IB only no CPA; 4 = IB and CPA; 0 = CPA only or confirmed no program.
Missing evidence
Where the documents establish a grade, that grade is used: 215 of 500 grades. Where research left a range, the lowest grade of that range is used, and 0 where nothing could be established: 258 grades, marked P. A penalty is a conservative grade, not a finding: it does not show that a service is absent, that costs are high, that trades are internalised or that CPA is paid. The evidence range stays with every penalty grade under “Evidence and sources”.
Some grades are documented terms plus a confirmation from the owner of this review; they say so where they appear.
T marks 27 tariff assessments. Where no published average settles a broker's costs, the named account's published round-turn commission plus its published minimum or fixed spread (USD 10 a pip, one standard EUR/USD lot) gives a tariff floor, graded on the same cost bands as every other broker. With a variable raw spread only the commission counts and the spread stays extra. The average all-in cost remains unverified. A tariff grade replaces the missing-benchmark penalty within the evidence range; an established average-cost grade always takes precedence. One of them covers a partner route, not a general retail tariff, and says so where it appears. A tariff grade does not assert that the average spread is zero or that the average all-in cost equals the floor. Every other cost grade keeps its own basis: an established average, or a missing-evidence penalty.
Positions
The total is the weighted sum of the five grades. Brokers are numbered 1 to 100 by total, highest first, with no shared or skipped numbers. Where totals are equal, the brokers are listed by name A to Z: the lower number is a listing order, not a better result, and every equal score is marked “equal score”. Each criterion has its own positions 1 to 100 by the same rule. A search hides rows but never renumbers them.
What the ranking is not
It is not a safety rating, a recommendation, a live execution test or a list of brokers you can open an account with. Positions are global, over the scope documented for each broker (one company, account or partner route per criterion, named under its evidence). Availability by country is shown separately and never changes a position. An earlier proposed safety rubric is not in use.
Evidence levels
- Regulator record
- An independent regulator register or notice.
- Observed
- Records or tests we hold, with method, sample size and dates published.
- Broker document
- The broker's own published terms, policy, agreement or page. A commitment or disclosure, not proof of how any order was handled.
- Not verified
- Missing, refused or not yet checked.
The numbers
- 100
- RankedEvery name on the research list.
- 40
- Broker profiles10 of them with eligibility and account terms still open.
- 60
- Assessment summariesFive criteria; eligibility and protection by country not confirmed.
- 215
- Evidence gradesOf 500.
- 27
- Tariff assessmentsPublished commission and spread terms of a named account or route; average all-in cost unverified.
- 258
- Penalty grades193 of them 0.
- 0
- Eligibility confirmedFor any applicant in any country.
Brands and companies
A brand is a trading name. The company is the legal entity whose documents were reviewed, and one company can run several brands: StoneX Financial Ltd is behind FOREX.com and StoneX Trading UK; FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd is behind Fusion Markets and Global Prime. Where a company's documents exclude your country, or eligibility is open, it is the company reviewed, not your contracting party.
Featured is not ranked
The guide follows one copied trade on one partner route as an editorial example. It does not change any position.