58 brokers with discretionary routing terms
These cited execution policies support the discretionary-or-mixed-routing anchor. The grade describes contractual discretion. It is not proof that a particular client trade was internalised or that the broker did not hedge it.
How this list is ordered
Execution commitment grade, highest first; broker name breaks an equal grade. Overall positions are shown separately.
Numbers on this page are positions within this focused list. The separate overall and category positions refer to the full 100-broker roster.
Find a broker in this list (58)
- ActivTrades
- ACY Securities
- Admirals
- Alpari
- AMarkets
- Baxia Markets
- BlackBull Markets
- CMC Markets
- CMTrading
- Decode Global
- Deriv
- Doo Prime
- Dukascopy
- EBC Financial Group
- Eightcap
- eToro
- Exness
- FBS
- FPG Fortune Prime Global
- Fusion Markets
- FXCM
- FXOpen
- FxPro
- FXTM
- Global Prime
- GO Markets
- HFM
- Hirose Financial
- IC Markets
- IG
- InstaForex
- Interactive Brokers
- Intertrader
- IronFX
- IUX
- JFD Brokers
- Markets.com
- NAGA
- OANDA
- Octa
- Pepperstone
- Plus500
- PU Prime
- Saxo
- Scope Markets
- Spreadex
- StarTrader
- StoneX Trading UK
- Swissquote
- Switch Markets
- T4Trade
- Tickmill
- TMGM
- Trade Nation
- Tradeview Markets
- Trading 212
- Windsor Brokers
- XTB
-
1. ActivTrades
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: ActivTrades PLC, all client orders, United Kingdom
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: ActivTrades PLC, all client orders, United Kingdom
ActivTrades PLC's order execution policy says the firm is the only execution venue, acts as principal and uses liquidity providers for prices and for hedging its own risk. Its conflicts policy says client trades are offset against each other and the remaining exposure may or may not be hedged externally. That is discretionary hedging, not a commitment to route orders out; acting as principal is not by itself counted against it.
policy leaves external hedging to the firm's discretion ('may or may not be hedged externally') -> anchor 'discretionary external transmission or mixed internal-or-external discretion' -> 4
-
2. ACY Securities
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: ACY Capital LLC (St Vincent and the Grenadines, company no. 2610 LLC 2022), contracts for difference, all accounts
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: ACY Capital LLC (St Vincent and the Grenadines, company no. 2610 LLC 2022), contracts for difference, all accounts
ACY Capital LLC's client agreement says the company contracts as principal, acts as a market maker and may enter into an agreement with hedging counterparties after a client trade. Its key information statement adds that hedging counterparties are nominated case by case and are not named. Hedging is thus left to the firm and is not a commitment for each trade; the 'STP mode' wording on the partners site is marketing. No internalisation finding is made, and acting as principal is not treated as evidence of one.
Client agreement lets the firm hedge at its discretion ('may enter into an agreement with Hedging Counterparties') -> 4
-
3. Admirals
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Admirals SC Ltd, Seychelles; forex and CFD contracts
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Admirals SC Ltd, Seychelles; forex and CFD contracts
The client agreement of Admirals SC Ltd, effective 28 September 2026, says the firm deals as principal and may act as market maker in forex and CFDs. Clause 14.5 lets it, at its reasonable discretion, offset a client position against another client, against a counterparty, or keep a proprietary position. That is discretionary hedging or internalising, which the anchor grades 4; it does not show that orders are actually internalised. The UK company's policy reads differently (matched principal, back to back with sister company Admiral Markets A.S.) and is recorded as a source for that entity only.
agreement lets the firm offset with a counterparty, another client or keep the position at its discretion (cl. 14.5) -> discretionary/mixed -> 4
-
4. Alpari
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Parlance Trading Ltd, CFDs on MT4/MT5 (all account types), Comoros (Mwali)
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Parlance Trading Ltd, CFDs on MT4/MT5 (all account types), Comoros (Mwali)
The Terms of Business give Parlance Trading Ltd sole and absolute discretion to choose the hedging policy for any or all client instructions, to act as intermediary with a liquidity provider if it so chooses, and to change that policy at any time without notice. The Client Agreement says the company may be the other side of a trade as a principal on its own account or as a matched principal. Orders can be declined when external liquidity to hedge is lacking, which shows hedging is used but not that every trade is hedged. Discretion between hedging and keeping the position is the anchor for 4. Liquidity providers are not named, so whether any is a group company is not known; that does not change the grade.
hedging policy at the firm's sole discretion, own-account principal or matched principal both allowed -> mixed internal-or-external discretion -> 4
-
5. AMarkets
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: AMarkets LLC (Cook Islands), Standard, ECN and Zero accounts, MetaTrader 4 and 5, CFDs including EUR/USD
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: AMarkets LLC (Cook Islands), Standard, ECN and Zero accounts, MetaTrader 4 and 5, CFDs including EUR/USD
Each CFD is a contract directly between AMarkets LLC and the client. The trading regulations define a liquidity provider as a source of quotes that 'may also be used' to hedge client trades, and give the dealer a right to decline an order the company cannot hedge; nothing commits the company to hedge every trade externally or ties a fill to an external fill. That leaves hedging to the firm's discretion, which is grade 4. The ECN page's statement that every order is executed at the prime broker is a product description outside the contract, and the prime broker is not named, so it is not known whether it is outside the group.
Policy permits hedging through liquidity providers at the firm's discretion ('may also be used to hedge'; right to decline if it cannot hedge) -> exact 4. No contractual blanket external route (6) and no per-fill external condition (8).
-
6. Baxia Markets
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Baxia Global Limited, Seychelles, CFDs on MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5, retail and professional clients
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Baxia Global Limited, Seychelles, CFDs on MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5, retail and professional clients
Baxia Global Limited's execution policy says it will generally pass market orders to a third party, which may be a broker and an affiliated company, and that it may transmit orders to third-party liquidity providers, while it is always principal, sole counterparty and sole execution venue. 'Generally' and 'may' leave the choice with the firm, part of the route can stay inside the group, and the policy mentions internal risk limits on accepting orders; the client agreement lets the firm refuse an order it believes it cannot hedge. That is discretionary external transmission, not a blanket or per-fill commitment. The website's STP and no-dealing-desk wording is marketing and does not change the policy.
policy: orders 'generally' passed to a third party that may be an affiliated company; 'may transmit' to liquidity providers; firm always principal and sole venue -> discretionary or mixed external transmission, possibly intra-group -> exact 4. No contractual blanket external route (6) and no per-fill external condition (8).
-
7. BlackBull Markets
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Black Bull Group Limited (New Zealand), CFDs, PDS 11 September 2026; BBG Limited (Seychelles), CFDs, Client Services Agreement v3.1 May 2024
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Black Bull Group Limited (New Zealand), CFDs, PDS 11 September 2026; BBG Limited (Seychelles), CFDs, Client Services Agreement v3.1 May 2024
Both client-contracting entities keep hedging as their own choice. The New Zealand PDS says the issuer decides whether, when and how far to hedge and that a client position may be hedged in full, in part or not at all; the Seychelles agreement says the company may hedge at its absolute discretion and is not required to hedge. The help-centre 'strictly non-dealing desk' statement is marketing and is not repeated as a contractual commitment, so the discretionary anchor applies. This does not establish that orders are actually internalised.
Policy lets the firm hedge or not at its discretion (NZ PDS s. 5, 2.3; Seychelles CSA cl. 5.1(a)) -> discretionary external transmission -> 4
-
8. CMC Markets
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: CMC Markets UK plc, CFD margin trades on the Next Generation platform and MetaTrader 4, United Kingdom
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: CMC Markets UK plc, CFD margin trades on the Next Generation platform and MetaTrader 4, United Kingdom
The order execution policy of CMC Markets UK plc says the company is the sole execution venue and the counterparty to every client trade, at prices its own platform generates, and that no other venue is used. Its terms of business refer to hedges it enters into where it deems them necessary or appropriate, with no undertaking to hedge each client trade externally. That is hedging at the firm's discretion, which the anchor grades 4. The group annual report corroborates this (natural hedging across client flow, external hedging applied selectively through prime brokers) but the grade rests on the UK company's own documents. The hedging wording sits in a definition and a corporate-actions clause rather than in a dedicated hedging clause; acting as principal is not by itself treated as B-book.
Sole execution venue and principal (not B-book by itself) + client agreement leaves hedging to the firm's discretion ('deem necessary or appropriate') + no contractual external routing -> discretionary internal-or-external -> 4
-
9. CMTrading
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: GCMT Limited (Seychelles), retail client agreement, all account types including ECN conditions; South African clients reach the same principal through GCMT SA as agent (a group company)
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: GCMT Limited (Seychelles), retail client agreement, all account types including ECN conditions; South African clients reach the same principal through GCMT SA as agent (a group company)
The Seychelles client agreement calls GCMT Limited a market maker that is principal to every order and the only execution venue, and its hedging clause covers the hedges the firm deems necessary. The group's partner agreement adds that the company decides at its sole discretion which positions to hedge, when and where. That is hedging at the firm's discretion, which the anchor grades 4. The ECN page's description of orders passed to banks and prime brokers is marketing with no matching clause in the agreement; nothing excludes external hedging, so the grade is not 0.
Principal and market maker with hedging at the firm's discretion in the contract -> 4. No contractual blanket external route -> not 6; external hedging not excluded -> not 0.
-
10. Decode Global
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Decode Global Limited (Vanuatu); Margin FX contracts and CFDs; all account types (STD, PRO, CENT are not distinguished in the documents); country eligibility not assessed
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Decode Global Limited (Vanuatu); Margin FX contracts and CFDs; all account types (STD, PRO, CENT are not distinguished in the documents); country eligibility not assessed
Decode Global Limited contracts as principal and is the counterparty to every trade, which alone does not establish a B-book. Its disclosure statement says it may hedge some of the market risk with outside counterparties and may, at its discretion, choose not to hedge a client's transactions; it also says prices come from a market making pricing model. Hedging at the firm's discretion, with no commitment to route or hedge any trade externally, is the anchor for 4.
Principal (not B-book by itself) + policy wording 'may … hedge some of the market risk' and 'may in our discretion, choose not to hedge' -> discretionary external hedging -> 4. Not 6: no blanket external routing or hedging commitment. Not 0: external hedging is not excluded.
-
11. Deriv
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Deriv (BVI) Ltd, Deriv MT5 Standard and Zero Spread accounts, British Virgin Islands
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Deriv (BVI) Ltd, Deriv MT5 Standard and Zero Spread accounts, British Virgin Islands
The additional terms of Deriv (BVI) Ltd say the company is the counterparty, acts either as agent or as principal and sole execution venue, and that a Deriv MT5 order may be passed to a liquidity provider. Passing orders on is allowed but not promised, which is the discretionary anchor. The provider is not named.
Counterparty; agent or principal; order 'may be passed through' to a liquidity provider -> discretion to route or keep -> 4
-
12. Doo Prime
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: D Prime Vanuatu Limited, all account types (Cent, STP, ECN)
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: D Prime Vanuatu Limited, all account types (Cent, STP, ECN)
The execution policy says the company acts as principal at all times, is the sole counterparty and sole execution venue, and only reserves a right to transmit client orders to third-party liquidity providers. The client agreement adds that it may delegate transactions to another executing broker, which may be a related company or an unaffiliated third party. External transmission is therefore at the firm's discretion and nothing commits it to route every order outside the group. 'Direct market access' and '20 top global banks and liquidity providers' on the pricing page are marketing statements and do not change this.
policy reserves a right, not a duty, to transmit orders to third-party liquidity providers; delegation may be to a related company -> discretionary external transmission -> 4
-
13. Dukascopy
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Dukascopy Bank SA, all trading accounts (JForex, MetaTrader 4 and 5, FIX API), Switzerland
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Dukascopy Bank SA, all trading accounts (JForex, MetaTrader 4 and 5, FIX API), Switzerland
The Marketplace Trading Conditions of Dukascopy Bank SA make the bank the legal counterparty of every trade and give it the right to hedge client trades partially, fully or not at all, at its sole discretion; the client accepts that trades will not necessarily be hedged with external counterparties. The best-execution annex confirms the bank executes as principal and acts at its own discretion. A policy that leaves hedging to the firm's discretion is the anchor for 4. The ECN marketplace and '20+ banks' wording is marketing and adds no commitment. This does not show that the bank internalises any given trade.
client contract s. 7.1 (x) and s. 12.1 (vii): hedging partial, full or none at the bank's sole discretion -> 'discretionary external transmission or mixed internal-or-external discretion in policy' -> 4
-
14. EBC Financial Group
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: EBC Financial (MU) Limited, Mauritius, forex and CFDs under the Execution Policy (June 2026) published on ebc.com; the policy does not differ by account type
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: EBC Financial (MU) Limited, Mauritius, forex and CFDs under the Execution Policy (June 2026) published on ebc.com; the policy does not differ by account type
The execution policy on ebc.com, issued by the Mauritius company, says the firm always acts as principal and reserves its right to transmit client orders to third-party liquidity providers, remaining sole counterparty and sole execution venue. A reserved right leaves the choice with the firm: it is neither a blanket external route nor a condition on each fill. The risk notice adds that the firm is counterparty to every trade and that prices carry a mark-up where applicable. No liquidity provider is named. The brand's statement that the UK company passes all orders to liquidity providers concerns a different company that does not serve retail clients and is not carried over.
policy: principal at all times; 'reserve our right to transmit' orders to third-party liquidity providers; firm is sole counterparty and venue -> discretionary external transmission -> exact 4. No contractual blanket external route (6) and no per-fill external condition (8).
-
15. Eightcap
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Eightcap Global Limited (The Bahamas), Client Agreement, CFDs including FX. Not carried to the Seychelles, Mauritius, Saint Vincent, UK, Australian or Cyprus companies.
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Eightcap Global Limited (The Bahamas), Client Agreement, CFDs including FX. Not carried to the Seychelles, Mauritius, Saint Vincent, UK, Australian or Cyprus companies.
The Bahamas client agreement says the company acts as principal and Market Maker, sets the quotes and may assume the risk of the client's trading. It also defines external liquidity providers as hedging counterparties that can take trades for risk management and lets client funds be used for hedging with them. The firm can therefore keep or hedge client risk at its own discretion, with no commitment to pass trades on. The providers are not named, so no intra-group route can be identified.
principal and market maker that 'may assume the risk', with hedging at liquidity providers permitted but not committed -> internal-or-external discretion in the agreement -> exact 4
-
16. eToro
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: eToro (UK) Ltd clients, United Kingdom; counterparty eToro (Europe) Ltd, Cyprus; CFDs and other OTC instruments
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: eToro (UK) Ltd clients, United Kingdom; counterparty eToro (Europe) Ltd, Cyprus; CFDs and other OTC instruments
eToro (UK) Ltd executes client orders as agent with eToro (Europe) Ltd as counterparty. The eToro Europe policy annexed to the UK policy says the firm may hedge a position back-to-back with another firm or venue but is under no obligation to, and the UK client terms say the firm is not required to hedge. Hedging is at the firm's discretion and nothing commits it to external routing, which is the anchor for 4; this does not show that it actually internalises.
policy lets the firm hedge or not at its discretion (no contractual external route) -> exact 4
-
17. Exness
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Exness (SC) Ltd, all CFD account types, Seychelles entity
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Exness (SC) Ltd, all CFD account types, Seychelles entity
The Exness (SC) Ltd Client Agreement says that, depending on account type, the company either takes the other side of the trade itself or passes the order to a third party and is then not the counterparty. It does not commit any named account to external routing, and the key facts statement describes the company as the counterparty to all CFD trades. A mixed internal-or-external model set out in the agreement is the anchor for 4. The account pages that might name an externally routed account type could not be read.
Client agreement: counterparty or third-party transmission depending on account type, no named account committed to external routing -> anchor 'mixed/internal-or-external in policy' -> 4.
-
18. FBS
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Tradestone Ltd, CFDs and forex on MT5 (Standard and Cent accounts), Cyprus (EU)
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Tradestone Ltd, CFDs and forex on MT5 (Standard and Cent accounts), Cyprus (EU)
Tradestone Ltd's client terms say that after a trade it may, at its reasonable discretion, offset the position with another client or a counterparty or keep a proprietary position. Its execution policy says it is always the client's counterparty and the sole execution venue, and that it hedges market risk with other venues without committing to do so for each trade. Discretion between hedging and keeping the position is the anchor for 4. The liquidity providers named are LMAX Broker Europe Ltd, EXT Ltd and Finalto Financial Services Limited; the documents do not present them as group companies.
policy and terms leave offsetting externally or retaining the position to the firm's discretion -> mixed internal-or-external discretion -> 4
-
19. FPG Fortune Prime Global
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Fortune Prime Limited (Vanuatu); Margin FX contracts and CFDs; all account types (ECN and PRO are not distinguished in the documents); country eligibility not assessed
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Fortune Prime Limited (Vanuatu); Margin FX contracts and CFDs; all account types (ECN and PRO are not distinguished in the documents); country eligibility not assessed
Fortune Prime Limited contracts as principal and describes itself as a market maker and product issuer; acting as principal alone does not establish a B-book. Its disclosure statement says it may hedge its liability for client positions at its sole discretion and has no obligation to do so. The terms define a hedging partner as a counterparty to which trades are passed back to back, but no clause commits the company to pass client trades to one. Hedging at the firm's discretion is the anchor for 4.
Principal and market maker (not B-book by itself) + 'may at our sole discretion, Hedge … no obligation to do so' -> discretionary external hedging -> 4. Not 6: the 'Hedging Partner' definition is not an undertaking to route, and the disclosure statement denies any obligation. Not 0: external hedging is not excluded.
-
20. Fusion Markets
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd (Australia) PDS December 2026 and Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited (Vanuatu) PDS December 2026; OTC FX and CFD products. Not Fusion Markets International Ltd (Seychelles) or Fusion Markets EU Ltd (Cyprus).
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd (Australia) PDS December 2026 and Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited (Vanuatu) PDS December 2026; OTC FX and CFD products. Not Fusion Markets International Ltd (Seychelles) or Fusion Markets EU Ltd (Cyprus).
The Australian and the Vanuatu disclosure statements each say the firm deals as principal on a market-making pricing model and may hedge its exposure to clients at any time; the Vanuatu text adds that it may later change that at any time. That is a discretion to hedge with a Hedge Counterparty, not a commitment to hedge every trade. The Seychelles client agreement and the Cyprus execution policy name the company as principal or counterparty and are silent on hedging, so this grade is not carried to those two entities. The Australian and Vanuatu disclosure statements and the Seychelles client agreement read on 18 November 2026 are labelled December 2026; whether they are already in force or are future-dated replacements of the current terms was not established.
policy lets the firm hedge at its discretion ('may hedge ... at any time') -> exact 4
-
21. FXCM
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Stratos Markets Limited, CFD and spread-bet accounts, United Kingdom. Not Stratos Global LLC, Stratos Europe Limited, Stratos Trading Pty. Limited or Stratos Light Ltd.
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Stratos Markets Limited, CFD and spread-bet accounts, United Kingdom. Not Stratos Global LLC, Stratos Europe Limited, Stratos Trading Pty. Limited or Stratos Light Ltd.
The UK company's terms of business say it deals as principal and market maker and make the order execution policy part of the agreement. That policy says the firm is the sole execution venue and that, at its discretion, it may hedge some or all of its market risk with third parties, with client trades hedged individually, in aggregate or not at all. A policy that leaves hedging to the firm's discretion is the 4 anchor. The firm's 2025 prudential disclosure says firm positions are fully hedged, but that describes practice in one year, names no counterparty and is not a contractual commitment, so it does not raise the grade.
execution policy s. 3.2: hedging 'at our discretion', individually, in aggregate or not at all -> discretionary or mixed routing -> 4; no blanket or per-fill external commitment -> not 6 or 8
-
22. FXOpen
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: FXOpen EU Ltd, Cyprus, CFDs on the ECN account for retail and professional clients, under the Order Execution Policy of April 2022 (V.5) and the Terms and Conditions
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: FXOpen EU Ltd, Cyprus, CFDs on the ECN account for retail and professional clients, under the Order Execution Policy of April 2022 (V.5) and the Terms and Conditions
FXOpen EU's execution policy, which is part of the client agreement, says the company is always the counterparty to every trade and the sole execution venue, and that it may pass an order to another company of its group or to a third-party broker. Its list of execution venues contains the company itself, the group company FXOpen Ltd and two outside firms, and the client agreement says orders are executed on an own-account basis and/or in an STP/ECN model. The documents therefore leave it to the company whether an order is kept or passed on, and where; the ECN description on the website does not change that.
Principal and sole execution venue; transmission to a group company or outside broker is a 'may', with the firm itself on the venue list; client agreement: own account 'and/or' STP/ECN -> internal or external at the firm's discretion -> 4
-
23. FxPro
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: FxPro Global Markets Ltd (Bahamas), CFDs, all platforms; not carried to FxPro UK Limited or FxPro Financial Services Ltd
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: FxPro Global Markets Ltd (Bahamas), CFDs, all platforms; not carried to FxPro UK Limited or FxPro Financial Services Ltd
The Order Execution Policy of FxPro Global Markets Ltd, which the client agreement makes part of the contract, says the firm acts as principal at all times, is the sole execution venue, and may transmit orders to third-party liquidity providers. 'May' leaves external transmission to the firm's discretion, and its conflicts policy describes a department that manages the firm's own exposure as principal. That is discretionary external transmission, which the anchor grades 4; it does not show that the firm actually internalises. No-dealing-desk wording on the website was not graded.
policy: principal at all times + 'may transmit your orders ... to third party LPs' -> discretionary external transmission -> 4
-
24. FXTM
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Exinity Limited, CFDs on MT4 and MT5 (all account types), Mauritius
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Exinity Limited, CFDs on MT4 and MT5 (all account types), Mauritius
The Terms of Business for the MetaTrader platform give the company sole and absolute discretion to choose the hedging policy for any or all client instructions, to act as intermediary with a liquidity provider if it so chooses, and to change that policy at any time without notice. The Client Agreement says the company may be the other side of a trade as a principal on its own account or as a matched principal. Orders can be declined when the company cannot hedge with a liquidity provider, which shows hedging is used but not that every trade is hedged. Discretion between hedging and keeping the position is the anchor for 4. Liquidity providers are not named, so whether any is a group company is not known; that does not change the grade.
hedging policy at the firm's sole discretion; own-account principal or matched principal both allowed -> mixed internal-or-external discretion -> 4
-
25. Global Prime
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited t/a Global Prime (Vanuatu), PDS and Financial Product Service Terms dated 28 February 2023; OTC FX and CFD products. Not FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd (Australia).
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited t/a Global Prime (Vanuatu), PDS and Financial Product Service Terms dated 28 February 2023; OTC FX and CFD products. Not FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd (Australia).
The Vanuatu PDS says the firm deals as principal on a market-making pricing model and 'may hedge' its exposure to clients at any time and may later change that at any time, with a Hedge Counterparty chosen case by case. That is a discretion to hedge, not a commitment to pass every trade on, and the client terms add no routing commitment. Website statements about passing on the best rates are marketing and do not change the grade. No execution or hedging policy is published for this entity, and the Australian entity's documents were not retrievable, so the grade is not carried to it.
policy lets the firm hedge at its discretion ('may hedge ... at any time', 'may later change that') -> exact 4
-
26. GO Markets
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: GO Markets Pty Ltd (MU), Mauritius, Margin FX and CFDs
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: GO Markets Pty Ltd (MU), Mauritius, Margin FX and CFDs
The Mauritius Disclosure Statement says GO Markets is product issuer and principal, that it is at the firm's discretion whether it places an offsetting order to hedge a client position, and that it hedges some transactions while keeping some risk as open positions. Its Execution Policy describes liquidity access through the group's counterparties without committing to route each order externally. Discretionary hedging in policy is grade 4; it does not show how much is actually internalised. The Australian company's PDS and hedging policy say the same for that entity.
policy leaves hedging of each client order to the firm's discretion (hedge some, keep some) -> discretionary external transmission / mixed -> 4
-
27. HFM
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: HF Markets (SV) Ltd, OTC FX and CFD contracts; not carried to HF Markets (UK) Ltd or other group companies
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: HF Markets (SV) Ltd, OTC FX and CFD contracts; not carried to HF Markets (UK) Ltd or other group companies
HF Markets (SV) Ltd always acts as principal and is the sole execution venue. Its Terms of Business let it, at its reasonable discretion, offset a client position against another client, against a counterparty, or keep a proprietary position, and its Client Agreement says it may transmit orders to third-party liquidity providers. That is discretionary hedging or internalising, which the anchor grades 4; it does not show that the firm actually internalises.
policy allows offset with a counterparty or retention of the position at the firm's discretion (Terms of Business cl. 6.4; Client Agreement cl. 6.1, 19.3) -> discretionary/mixed -> 4
-
28. Hirose Financial
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Hirose Financial UK Ltd, margined FX and metals (CFDs), retail and professional clients, United Kingdom; onward routing: Hirose Tusyo Inc., Japan
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Hirose Financial UK Ltd, margined FX and metals (CFDs), retail and professional clients, United Kingdom; onward routing: Hirose Tusyo Inc., Japan
Hirose Financial UK Ltd's execution policy, which is part of the client agreement, says the firm is principal and sole venue and hedges each client trade at once, back to back, with Hirose Tusyo Inc.; the 2024 RTS 28 report shows 100% of orders going there. Hirose Tusyo Inc. is the firm's parent, so this is a route to a group company, which alone is 4 under the reviewer's rule. Onward routing is not left open: the parent's annual report says it covers positions with outside counterparties only in principle, offsets matching positions internally and earns that internal-offset income also on flow from firms it acts as counterparty for.
Matched principal, back-to-back hedge of every trade with the parent Hirose Tusyo Inc. (group company) -> intra-group route alone = 4. Onward hedging by the parent is documented as mixed (internal offset first, outside cover for the remainder), not unresolved -> stays 4, not 4–6. No per-fill external condition (8); external routing not excluded (not 0).
-
29. IC Markets
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Raw Trading Ltd, Seychelles; all clients and platforms
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Raw Trading Ltd, Seychelles; all clients and platforms
The Raw Trading Ltd order execution policy (October 2026, v1.5) says the firm acts as principal and may execute an order itself or, where appropriate and depending on instrument, platform and market conditions, transmit it in its own name to a liquidity provider. The client agreement contains no undertaking to hedge, and the firm's help centre states that it does not hedge every position. That is discretion between internal and external handling, which is the anchor for 4; acting as principal is not taken as B-book. This confirms the existing grade.
policy lets the firm execute directly or transmit to liquidity providers at its discretion (ss. 3.1, 12.1) -> discretionary external transmission -> 4
-
30. IG
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: IG Markets Limited, CFDs, retail client, United Kingdom
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: IG Markets Limited, CFDs, retail client, United Kingdom
The execution policy, which forms part of IG Markets Limited's terms of business, says the firm acts as principal, market maker and sole execution venue for CFDs and may choose whether to hedge part or all of a client contract in the underlying market. It adds that orders are auto-accepted without reference to the firm's exposure where possible, and that large orders may be worked in the market. The client agreement confirms the principal and market-maker capacity and sets no duty to hedge. Hedging at the firm's discretion is grade 4 by the anchor; this does not establish how much the firm actually internalises.
Binding policy: principal and sole execution venue; 'may choose whether to hedge part or all' -> discretionary internal-or-external handling -> 4
-
31. InstaForex
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: InstaFinance Ltd (British Virgin Islands), all live accounts under the Public Offer Agreement (Insta.Standard, Insta.Pro, Insta.Zero, Insta.Raw), currency pairs and CFDs
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: InstaFinance Ltd (British Virgin Islands), all live accounts under the Public Offer Agreement (Insta.Standard, Insta.Pro, Insta.Zero, Insta.Raw), currency pairs and CFDs
The Public Offer Agreement of InstaFinance Ltd contains no commitment to route or hedge client orders externally and names no execution venue or liquidity provider; the company is the dealer and executes on its own server with requotes. Two clauses let the company adjust a client's results where a trade or position 'has not been hedged by the Company', which shows that hedging is done for some positions and not others at the company's choice. That is hedging at the firm's discretion, grade 4. No separate order execution policy is published for this company.
No contractual external route (not 6) and no per-fill external condition (not 8); no clause excluding hedging (not 0); agreement refers to trades 'not hedged by the Company' (cl. 5.6, 5.18.1) -> hedge-or-not at the firm's discretion -> exact 4.
-
32. Interactive Brokers
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Interactive Brokers (U.K.) Limited, Covered Products account (FX Spot and Forex CFDs, carried by IBUK), United Kingdom. The principal trading account carried by Interactive Brokers LLC has the same clause (IBUK and IBLLC Client Agreement cl. E12.6, G5.3).
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Interactive Brokers (U.K.) Limited, Covered Products account (FX Spot and Forex CFDs, carried by IBUK), United Kingdom. The principal trading account carried by Interactive Brokers LLC has the same clause (IBUK and IBLLC Client Agreement cl. E12.6, G5.3).
IBUK's agreement for the account it carries says that in a Spot FX trade the client may be buying from or selling to a group affiliate that can make or lose money on the trade, and that IBUK itself is a counterparty only on a riskless basis. Its OTC clauses and execution policy let it route to affiliates or to unaffiliated third parties and hedge through either. So IBUK stays flat, but the other side can be a group company, another client or an outside bank, and nothing commits the fill to a party outside the group. Under the rule that A-book means outside the group, this mixed route is grade 4; it does not show that any particular trade is kept in the group.
Riskless at IBUK, offset per trade with an affiliate, another customer or a third-party bank (mixed internal-or-external, affiliate may keep the risk) -> no blanket external route (not 6), no per-fill external condition (not 8) -> 4. Onward routing by the affiliate is described as its own profit or loss, not left unresolved -> stays 4, not 4–6.
-
33. Intertrader
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Alvar Financial Services Limited (Gibraltar), spread bets and CFDs, customer agreement as published on alvarfinancial.com plus the execution summary on intertrader.com; Tau Markets Ltd (Mauritius), retail CFD and FX account, /row route
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Alvar Financial Services Limited (Gibraltar), spread bets and CFDs, customer agreement as published on alvarfinancial.com plus the execution summary on intertrader.com; Tau Markets Ltd (Mauritius), retail CFD and FX account, /row route
Both companies' terms leave the handling of client exposure to the firm. Alvar Financial Services Limited, which trades as Intertrader, deals as principal and its customer agreement says it may choose at its sole discretion not to hedge a client's contract with its affiliates or external liquidity providers. Tau Markets Ltd's retail agreement says it is a market maker and the only execution venue, while its execution policy says orders are transmitted to third-party venues and also that the company functions as a market maker; the agreement prevails over the website, so no external route is committed to. Neither names a venue or makes a per-trade commitment.
Alvar (Gibraltar): cl. 16.1 discretion not to hedge, with affiliates and/or external providers -> 4. Tau Markets (Mauritius): market maker and sole execution venue in the agreement, external transmission and market making both stated in the execution policy -> mixed internal-or-external in policy -> 4. Brand level: 4 on both routes.
-
34. IronFX
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Notesco (BVI) Limited, STP-ECN accounts (Raw ECN, ECN VIP) and live accounts, MetaTrader 4, British Virgin Islands
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Notesco (BVI) Limited, STP-ECN accounts (Raw ECN, ECN VIP) and live accounts, MetaTrader 4, British Virgin Islands
The client agreement of Notesco (BVI) Limited makes the company the contractual counterparty and speaks of an STP-ECN order being passed to liquidity providers only 'in case the Company transmits' it; it also lets the company move a client to STP/ECN execution at its own discretion. That is transmission at the firm's discretion, not a contractual blanket external route, and the account names STP/ECN add nothing on their own. The liquidity providers are not named, so whether they are outside the group is not shown, which could not raise the grade above 4 in any case.
Discretionary external transmission in the client agreement (s. 14.4 'in case the Company transmits', s. 7.5 discretion to move execution to STP/ECN) -> 4
-
35. IUX
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: IUX Markets (MU) Ltd, Mauritius; CFDs on all account types
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: IUX Markets (MU) Ltd, Mauritius; CFDs on all account types
The Mauritius client agreement makes the company principal and execution venue for CFDs and says only that nothing restricts it from hedging client positions wholly or in part with third parties, which leaves hedging to the firm. Its risk management policy says straight-through processing is in place and all trades are fully offset by the liquidity provider, but the same clause list describes hedging 'if and when this is needed', natural hedging between clients and open-position exposure, and the liquidity provider is not named. Read together the documents describe discretionary, mixed internal-or-external handling, not a contractual blanket external route.
Principal and execution venue (not B-book by itself) + contractual permission to hedge 'wholly or in part' + policy mixing full offset with hedging when needed and client netting -> discretionary or mixed -> 4.
-
36. JFD Brokers
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: JFD Group Ltd, retail and professional clients, single live account (MT4+ or MT5+), Cyprus / EEA
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: JFD Group Ltd, retail and professional clients, single live account (MT4+ or MT5+), Cyprus / EEA
JFD Group Ltd's best-execution policy and client agreement say the same thing: on some occasions the company deals as principal and is the sole execution venue (its 'Dealing Desk Execution Model'), and on others it may decide at its own discretion to place the order with a third-party execution venue to manage its risk. That is discretionary external transmission, not a contractual external route, whatever agency or DMA wording appears elsewhere. No execution venue is named in either document, so whether a venue is a group company cannot be said.
Policy and agreement let the firm choose at its discretion between principal dealing and transmission to a third-party venue -> discretionary / mixed -> 4
-
37. Markets.com
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Safecap Investments Limited, Cyprus; CFDs on Markets.com Web/Mobile Trader, MT4 and MT5; retail and professional clients
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Safecap Investments Limited, Cyprus; CFDs on Markets.com Web/Mobile Trader, MT4 and MT5; retail and professional clients
Safecap's execution policy and client agreement say it is market maker, principal, sole counterparty and sole execution venue for every CFD trade. The policy says it 'may hedge some or all' of its exposure with liquidity providers under its own hedging strategy, the agreement says it 'may decide' to hedge, including with brokers in its group, and the conflicts policy says hedging may be done with group companies and that exposure may not be fully hedged. Hedging is therefore at the firm's discretion and may stay inside the group, which is the anchor for 4; nothing commits Safecap to route or hedge each trade outside the group.
Policy and contract: principal and sole venue; 'may hedge some or all' at its discretion; counterparty may be a group company -> discretionary / mixed internal-or-external -> 4
-
38. NAGA
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: NAGA Markets Europe Ltd, CFDs, retail clients in the EEA
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: NAGA Markets Europe Ltd, CFDs, retail clients in the EEA
The client agreement makes NAGA Markets Europe the only execution venue and sole counterparty, with a right but no duty to pass orders to outside liquidity providers, and says client trades are covered in part or in full inside the company or with related group companies. The execution policy lists the company itself and four outside firms as CFD venues and lets it choose between sending an order out and executing as principal. That is routing at the firm's discretion, with no contractual commitment to hedge outside the group.
Policy and agreement allow internal cover, cover with group companies or transmission to outside providers at the firm's discretion -> discretionary or mixed anchor -> 4
-
39. OANDA
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: OANDA Europe Limited, retail CFD and spread-bet orders on all its platforms, United Kingdom
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: OANDA Europe Limited, retail CFD and spread-bet orders on all its platforms, United Kingdom
The UK execution policy says OANDA Europe Limited is the sole trading venue, acts as matched principal, and that OANDA group companies may manage their risk as market maker and may choose to hedge some or all of a client's orders. The terms of business add that the firm may execute hedging transactions and frequently hedges with other institutions. A matched-principal route to a group company with hedging outside the group left to discretion is the anchor for 4.
matched principal to OANDA group companies (inside the group) + group 'may choose to hedge ... some or all' (discretionary, possibly partial) -> discretionary external transmission -> 4
-
40. Octa
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Versustrategy Inc., OctaTrader, MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 accounts, Saint Lucia
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Versustrategy Inc., OctaTrader, MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 accounts, Saint Lucia
The Customer Agreement of Versustrategy Inc. says the company is principal, sole counterparty and sole execution venue, and that it may offset client positions with third-party liquidity providers but is not obliged to and may keep some or all of the risk at its sole discretion. That is discretionary hedging in the contract, which the anchors grade 4. The website FAQ calls the broker non-dealing-desk and ECN and says all orders are offset, but that is marketing and the agreement governs.
Contract leaves hedging or retaining risk to the firm's sole discretion -> exact 4. Principal status alone is not used against the broker; the FAQ's ECN wording does not raise the grade.
-
41. Pepperstone
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Pepperstone Limited (UK) and Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas); CFD orders
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Pepperstone Limited (UK) and Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas); CFD orders
The execution policies of Pepperstone Limited (UK) and Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas) use the same wording: the firm is principal and the only execution venue, the group offsets client risk internally in a central risk book within limits, and hedges with external venues when it cannot. That is internal-or-external discretion in policy, not a blanket or per-fill external commitment.
policy lets the group offset internally or hedge externally at its discretion -> 4
-
42. Plus500
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Plus500UK Ltd, CFDs on the Plus500 trading platform, retail client, United Kingdom
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Plus500UK Ltd, CFDs on the Plus500 trading platform, retail client, United Kingdom
Plus500UK Ltd deals as principal and sole execution venue, and its execution policy says an identical hedge trade is booked with its parent, Plus500 Ltd, for each client trade. That is a back-to-back route to a group company, which by the reviewer's rule is 4 on its own. Onward routing is not left open: the same policy speaks of Plus500 Ltd either executing a hedge or retaining the principal risk, and the group's annual report says not all net client exposure is hedged. The user agreement only says the firm may hedge with a financial institution. Routing outside the group is therefore discretionary, which is grade 4; this does not establish how much is actually kept in-house.
Per-trade identical hedge with the parent (group company) = intra-group back-to-back -> 4; onward hedge by the parent is discretionary ('executes a hedge or retains the principal risk') -> stays 4, not 4-6
-
43. PU Prime
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd, margin FX and CFDs, Australia
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd, margin FX and CFDs, Australia
PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd is the counterparty to every trade and acts as a market maker. Its Counterparty Risk Hedging Policy says it does not hedge every client position and that the extent of hedging is decided by its risk team and management; the PDS likewise says it 'may choose' to offset exposure in the wholesale market. That is hedging at the firm's discretion. One of its two named hedge counterparties, PU Prime Limited, is a related body corporate, and hedging inside the group would not count as external in any case.
Policy leaves hedging to the firm's discretion (not every position hedged; extent set by risk management) -> mixed internal-or-external discretion -> 4
-
44. Saxo
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Saxo Bank (Switzerland) Ltd., rolling FX spot and other OTC products, Switzerland
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Saxo Bank (Switzerland) Ltd., rolling FX spot and other OTC products, Switzerland
The Swiss execution policy fixes one route: every order is transmitted to the parent, Saxo Bank A/S, with the Swiss bank dealing as riskless principal in OTC products and using no other venue. That is a blanket route, but to a group company, which for this review is not an external route. What the parent then does is documented and is discretionary: it hedges elsewhere only as it considers most efficient and runs an internal flow aggregation book, and the Swiss General Terms keep hedging at the bank's absolute discretion, including client-against-client offsets and proprietary positions. There is no commitment to route outside the group and no per-fill external hedge condition.
All orders to Saxo Bank A/S (group parent): intra-group route alone -> 4. Onward routing is documented as discretionary, not unresolved -> stays 4, not 4–6.
-
45. Scope Markets
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: RS Global Ltd, Belize; CFD and forex orders under the Terms and Conditions 11.2026
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: RS Global Ltd, Belize; CFD and forex orders under the Terms and Conditions 11.2026
The Terms and Conditions of RS Global Ltd say the company acts as counterparty to client transactions and will effect orders either as broker (agent) or as market maker (principal), and may act as both. Nothing says which applies to a given order, no external venue is named and no order execution policy is published on the Belize legal page; the perpetual-CFD schedule says only that the company 'may' enter into a corresponding transaction with a third party. That is internal-or-external discretion in the contract, which is 4. The MAM page's 'Access to STP' line is marketing and does not change this.
Contract allows agent or market-maker capacity at the company's choice, no committed external route -> anchor 'mixed internal-or-external discretion in policy' -> 4
-
46. Spreadex
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Spreadex Limited, financial spread bets and CFDs on the Betting Account and CFD Account, retail and professional clients, United Kingdom
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Spreadex Limited, financial spread bets and CFDs on the Betting Account and CFD Account, retail and professional clients, United Kingdom
Spreadex Limited's execution policy, which its customer agreement incorporates, says the firm manages its risk as a market maker, is the client's only execution venue and may choose to hedge all or part of an order in the underlying market. The agreement adds that it frequently hedges with other institutions and may also hedge a client's short position internally against other clients, at its discretion. That is discretionary, mixed handling written into the policy: grade 4. It does not show that any given trade is kept in-house. The venues it names are outside firms, not group companies, but there is no commitment to route every order to them.
Principal and sole execution venue (policy; Rule 13) + 'may choose to hedge all or part' (policy) + 'frequently hedge' and internal hedging at discretion (Rules 34(2), 24(3)) = hedging at the firm's discretion, no blanket or per-fill external commitment -> 4
-
47. StarTrader
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: STARTRADER Limited, Seychelles, margin FX and CFDs, all clients, client agreement version 10.26 governed by the law of Seychelles; the same clauses read separately in the agreements of STARTRADER LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) and STARTRADER Financial Markets Limited (Mauritius)
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: STARTRADER Limited, Seychelles, margin FX and CFDs, all clients, client agreement version 10.26 governed by the law of Seychelles; the same clauses read separately in the agreements of STARTRADER LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) and STARTRADER Financial Markets Limited (Mauritius)
The client agreement of STARTRADER Limited (Seychelles) makes every order a contract between the client and the company, accepted at the company's discretion. It says the company has arrangements with unnamed third-party execution providers for the facilitation of transactions, and that the client has no claim over the company's contracts 'if any' with other persons. So outside arrangements exist, but nothing commits the company to pass on each order and 'if any' leaves that to the company: a discretionary policy, which is 4. The help centre's 'STP-ECN, no dealing desk, all orders routed directly to the market' wording is not in the agreement and does not raise the grade. The agreements of STARTRADER LLC and the Mauritius company carry the same two clauses.
cl. 1.3: order is an OTC contract between client and company (counterparty; not B-book by itself); cl. 3.1(d)–(f): acceptance at the company's discretion, not conditional on an outside fill -> no per-fill external condition (not 8); cl. 2.7(g): arrangements with third-party execution providers exist, cl. 2.7(f): contracts 'if any' with other persons -> no blanket external route committed (not 6), external hedging not excluded (not 0), left to the firm -> discretionary -> 4. Providers unnamed, so a group route cannot be excluded; that also gives 4. If the reviewer requires an express 'may hedge at our discretion' clause for 4, the agreement's wording would instead leave the marketing-only range 0–6.
-
48. StoneX Trading UK
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: StoneX Financial Ltd trading as StoneX Trading, Standard and MT4 accounts (CFD, spread bet and FX under the General Terms), United Kingdom
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: StoneX Financial Ltd trading as StoneX Trading, Standard and MT4 accounts (CFD, spread bet and FX under the General Terms), United Kingdom
The April 2026 terms of StoneX Financial Ltd say the firm deals as principal, is the client's only execution venue and that the client does not trade on any external market. The only hedging statement is that the firm hedges against large trades, which is selective hedging at the firm's choice and no commitment to pass every trade on. That is discretionary, mixed handling in the policy: grade 4. It does not show that the firm internalises any given trade. A separate DMA service fills only after an order with a liquidity provider, but its providers are unnamed and it is not the Standard or MT4 route.
Principal and sole execution venue (Annex 3) + 'hedging against large Trades' (Annex 1 s. 8) = hedging at the firm's discretion, no blanket or per-fill external commitment -> 4
-
49. Swissquote
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Swissquote Bank SA, Forex and CFD transactions on all its platforms, Switzerland
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Swissquote Bank SA, Forex and CFD transactions on all its platforms, Switzerland
Swissquote Bank SA's Forex and CFD Execution Policy says the bank is the client's counterparty on every transaction and decides in its sole discretion whether to hedge its exposure at all, to what extent, when, and how; hedges go to third-party liquidity providers it selects, and the client is not told whether a hedge was made. The Special Terms confirm the bank acts as principal and promise no external routing. A policy that leaves hedging or internalising to the firm's discretion is the anchor for 4. This does not show that the bank actually internalises any given trade.
execution policy s. 4.1 and 5.1: hedging at the bank's sole discretion (whether, how much, when) -> 'discretionary external transmission or mixed internal-or-external discretion in policy' -> 4
-
50. Switch Markets
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Switch Markets Pty Ltd on behalf of Royal ETP LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) as named in the Account Terms, Product Disclosure Statement and Financial Services Guide of 24 Dec 2020; margin FX and CFDs; all account types (Standard and Pro are not distinguished); not a document of Royal CM LTD
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Switch Markets Pty Ltd on behalf of Royal ETP LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) as named in the Account Terms, Product Disclosure Statement and Financial Services Guide of 24 Dec 2020; margin FX and CFDs; all account types (Standard and Pro are not distinguished); not a document of Royal CM LTD
The client documents published on the site say Switch makes a market on behalf of the principal, which is counterparty to every trade; acting as principal alone does not establish a B-book. The Financial Services Guide then says the principal earns a ticket fee on the Switch client trades it hedges and may also profit where it has kept the risk of a trade 'in the form of a B-book strategy', and the Account Terms allow for a trade that is not hedged at all or only in part. Hedging or keeping the risk is therefore at the firm's choice, with no commitment to route any trade externally, which is the anchor for 4. These documents name Royal ETP LLC as the principal; the footer names Royal CM LTD, for which no execution document is published on the site.
Principal and market making (not B-book by itself) + 'trades it hedges' alongside 'taken on the risk of your trade in the form of a B-book strategy' + 'might not have fully or even partly hedged' -> mixed internal-or-external at the firm's discretion -> 4. Not 6: no blanket external routing or hedging commitment. Not 0: external hedging is provided for, not excluded.
-
51. T4Trade
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Tradeco Limited (Seychelles); all T4Trade accounts under the Order Execution Policy 2026/001 and Client Services Agreement 2026/002
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Tradeco Limited (Seychelles); all T4Trade accounts under the Order Execution Policy 2026/001 and Client Services Agreement 2026/002
Tradeco Limited's order execution policy says the company always acts as principal and is the sole execution venue, with most trades priced and executed by its own internal systems. The policy, the client agreement and the conflicts policy each refer to financial institutions the company uses as hedging liquidity or price providers, but none commits it to hedge or pass on any order, and none excludes hedging. Hedging is thus left to the firm, which is the anchor for 4; acting as principal is not by itself counted against it, and the 'STP' in an account name is not a contractual route.
Principal and sole execution venue (not B-book by itself) + hedging providers referred to in policy and contract with no undertaking to hedge each trade or all trades -> hedging at the firm's discretion -> 4. No contractual blanket external route -> not 6; external hedging not excluded -> not 0. Providers unnamed, so whether any is a group company is not shown; that could not raise the grade.
-
52. Tickmill
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles), OTC FX and CFD contracts; not carried to Tickmill UK Ltd or Tickmill Europe Ltd
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles), OTC FX and CFD contracts; not carried to Tickmill UK Ltd or Tickmill Europe Ltd
The Client Service Agreement of Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles) says the firm deals as principal and may act as a market maker in FX and CFDs. Clause 14.5 lets it, at its reasonable discretion, offset a client position against another client, against a counterparty, or keep a proprietary position. That is discretionary hedging or internalising, which the anchor grades 4; it does not show that the firm actually internalises.
policy allows offset with a counterparty or retention of the position at the firm's discretion -> discretionary/mixed -> 4
-
53. TMGM
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Trademax Global Limited (Vanuatu, VFSC 40356), margin FX and CFDs, all accounts on MT4/MT5
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Trademax Global Limited (Vanuatu, VFSC 40356), margin FX and CFDs, all accounts on MT4/MT5
Trademax Global Limited's hedging counterparty policy says the company does not hedge all client transactions and carries a residual unhedged position within its own limits, hedging when exposure exceeds them. Its only named hedging counterparty is Trademax Australia Limited, a company of the same group. The client agreement makes the company principal to every trade, and the best execution policy's no-dealing-desk and ECN wording is not a routing commitment. No internalisation finding is made.
Policy leaves hedging to the firm's discretion (not all client trades hedged) -> 4; the only named hedging route is to a group company, which alone is also 4
-
54. Trade Nation
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Trade Nation Australia Pty Ltd, CFDs and margin FX on TN Trader and MT4, Australia
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Trade Nation Australia Pty Ltd, CFDs and margin FX on TN Trader and MT4, Australia
The Australian PDS says the firm uses the market maker model, offers no direct market access, is counterparty to every trade, nets opposing client positions and hedges the remainder with external counterparties once its risk limits are reached; it also says it may or may not hedge a given customer trade. The Client Agreement says it takes the opposite side of client trades and may hedge. That is hedging at the firm's discretion, the anchor for 4; it does not show how much is actually kept in house.
Policy: principal / market maker, net hedging with external counterparties above internal risk limits, 'may or may not choose to hedge' -> discretionary internal-or-external -> 4
-
55. Tradeview Markets
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Tradeview Ltd, Cayman Islands, client agreement (July 2024 edition, current server copy), all OTC accounts incl. EDGE
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Tradeview Ltd, Cayman Islands, client agreement (July 2024 edition, current server copy), all OTC accounts incl. EDGE
Tradeview Ltd's client agreement lets Tradeview execute every order as counterparty itself or as a broker with other counterparties it chooses, and says OTC contracts are entered into as principal. That is internal-or-external discretion in the contract, which is the anchor for 4. The help centre's description of EDGE orders filled against several liquidity providers is not a contractual commitment and does not name the providers or say whether they are outside the group, so it does not raise the grade.
Contract allows execution as counterparty or with other counterparties at the firm's discretion -> mixed/discretionary -> 4
-
56. Trading 212
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Trading 212 UK Ltd, CFD account on the Trading 212 platform, retail client, United Kingdom
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Trading 212 UK Ltd, CFD account on the Trading 212 platform, retail client, United Kingdom
The UK execution policy, which is part of the client agreement, says Trading 212 UK Ltd is always the principal counterparty and sole execution venue for CFD orders and that it 'may choose' to hedge part or all of its CFDs, with external third parties or with other group companies such as Trading 212 Markets (Ireland) Limited. The disclosure notice repeats that it may hedge or offset with the Irish group company. Hedging is therefore discretionary and may stay inside the group; nothing commits the firm to route any trade outside the group. That is the anchor for discretionary or mixed internal-or-external hedging, grade 4. It does not establish how much the firm actually keeps on its own book.
Principal on every CFD trade; hedging 'part or all' at the firm's choice, with external parties or group companies -> discretionary, mixed internal or external -> 4. No blanket external route (6) and no per-fill external condition (8).
-
57. Windsor Brokers
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: Windsor Brokers International Ltd, Seychelles, CFDs (all accounts)
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: Windsor Brokers International Ltd, Seychelles, CFDs (all accounts)
The Seychelles client agreement makes the company counterparty to every client transaction and refers to covering its trades with other counterparties and to the price at which it hedged a trade, without any commitment to route or hedge client orders externally. The brand's own FAQ says it is neither STP nor ECN and may act as principal or broker. That is discretionary internal-or-external handling, which is exactly 4; no execution venue is named and the Order Execution Policy itself is not public.
Counterparty with discretionary cover / principal-or-broker discretion, no contractual external route -> 4
-
58. XTB
Documented commitment: discretionary or mixed routing. Scope: XTB Limited, CFDs on the Standard account, retail client, United Kingdom
Scope, calculation and sources
Scope: XTB Limited, CFDs on the Standard account, retail client, United Kingdom
XTB Limited is the client's counterparty and sole execution venue for CFDs and its terms say it deals on a matched principal basis. Its filed accounts name the other side: every client trade is offset by an equal trade with its parent, XTB S.A., a group company, which by the reviewer's rule is 4 on its own. Onward routing is not left open: the parent describes a market-maker model that hedges only when its limits are exceeded, the UK specification table calls the business a market-maker model, and the UK terms say only that the firm 'frequently' hedges with other institutions. Routing outside the group is therefore discretionary; this does not establish how much is actually kept in-house.
Matched principal with the parent for all client trades = back-to-back to a group company -> 4; onward hedging by the parent is limit-based and discretionary (market-maker model) -> stays 4, not 4-6
What to check before choosing an account
Separate the client’s execution venue from the group’s hedge venue. Read the policy’s discretion, aggregation and counterparty wording before treating an ECN, STP or A-book marketing label as an execution finding.
See all 100 a-book commitment assessments · Build a comparison
Positions are global preference-fit positions, not confirmation that an account is available in your country. Read the weights and evidence rules. P marks an evidence penalty; T marks a tariff assessment with average all-in cost unverified.