My Broker Reviews

PU Prime vs StarTrader

Any two or three of all 100. Positions and scores are the ones on the ranking.

Comparison

AOverall #8 of 100PU Prime4.2/10Assessment summary · 1 penalty · 1 tariff gradeEqual score with 6 othersAvailability not confirmed · Switzerland
BOverall #9 of 100StarTrader4.2/10Assessment summary · 1 penalty · 1 tariff gradeEqual score with 6 othersAvailability not confirmed · Switzerland

Equal totals: 4.2 each. PU Prime is listed first (#8) only because equal scores are listed A to Z; that is not a quality difference.

A PU Prime, B StarTrader: grades out of 10 per criterion
CriterionGrades (0–10)HigherWeighted
Structure 40%A, PU Prime: 0 out of 10, missing-evidence penalty. B, StarTrader: 0 out of 10, missing-evidence penalty.
Why

A PU Prime: Penalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a closed group list of operating companies: whether any company beyond the four licensed entities contracts with clients or executes under the PU Prime name.

B StarTrader: Penalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a closed list from the group of the companies that open client accounts or execute orders, and in particular whether STARTRADER International Pty Ltd (South Africa) or any United Kingdom or Cyprus company does so today.

Equal0
Costs 15%A, PU Prime: 10 out of 10, documented tariff assessment. B, StarTrader: 10 out of 10, documented tariff assessment.
Why

A PU Prime: ECN: published account tariff. USD 2 tariff floor: USD 2 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 10/10 for the named ECN account: USD 2 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 2 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Australian ECN account on MT5 / MetaTrader Web only. A reference-only spread table is not treated as a published average. The separately quoted Prime commission is not substituted for ECN pricing. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.

B StarTrader: Prime ECN: published account tariff. USD 4 tariff floor: USD 4 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 10/10 for the named Prime ECN account: USD 4 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 4 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Prime ECN requires USD 10,000 balance and no open positions to upgrade by email request. Keeping it requires 5 closed trades and USD 500,000 notional in a 30-day period within 90 days. Condition: USD 10k + activity rules.

Equal0
Copy 15%A, PU Prime: 10 out of 10. B, StarTrader: 10 out of 10.
Why

A PU Prime: Automation sizing controls fees

B StarTrader: Automation sizing controls fees

Equal0
A-book 15%A, PU Prime: 4 out of 10. B, StarTrader: 4 out of 10.
Why

A PU Prime: Discretionary or mixed routing

B StarTrader: Discretionary or mixed routing

Equal0
IB-only 15%A, PU Prime: 4 out of 10. B, StarTrader: 4 out of 10.
Why

A PU Prime: IB and CPA

B StarTrader: IB and CPA

Equal0
Sum = PU Prime total − StarTrader total0

Weighted = grade difference × weight. Positive favours PU Prime. It adds up to the difference in totals. P marks a missing-evidence penalty: the low end of the evidence range. T marks a documented tariff assessment; the average all-in spread cost remains unverified.

What separates PU Prime and StarTrader?

The overall result follows the published weights: Structure 40% · Costs 15% · Copy 15% · A-book 15% · IB-only 15%. The contributions below explain the score difference; they are not a universal recommendation.

These brokers have the same overall total and equal grades on the categories documented for both. Their named account terms can still differ within a grade band.

  • Company structure: 0P vs 0P; no difference in the weighted total. At least one grade includes an evidence penalty; this is not proof of the corresponding service or cost difference.
  • Published costs: 10T vs 10T; no difference in the weighted total. Tariff grades compare published terms; average all-in costs remain unverified.
  • Copy trading: 10 vs 10; no difference in the weighted total.
  • A-book commitment: 4 vs 4; no difference in the weighted total.
  • IB-only preference: 4 vs 4; no difference in the weighted total.

PU Prime: account, pricing and evidence

Brand-level review across PU Prime companies, not a single account offer. Costs and execution: PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd (Australia, AFSL 410681), read on www.puprime.au, a site for Australian residents only. Copy: PU Copy Trading as described on the international help centre helpcenter.puprime.com, which says the Australian licence does not cover its services and does not say which of PU Prime Limited (Seychelles), PU Prime Ltd (Mauritius) or PU Prime (Pty) Ltd (South Africa) provides the product. Affiliate: www.puprimepartners.com, which names PU Prime Ltd (Mauritius) and excludes Australian residents. www.puprime.com refused every plain request on 19 Nov 2026 (HTTP 403, bot challenge), so no client agreement, execution policy or account page of the Seychelles, Mauritius or South African company was read; nothing is carried from one company to another.

Cost basis

ECN: USD 2.00 round-turn commission + 0-pip published minimum spread; USD 2.00 tariff floor. Average all-in cost unverified.

PU Prime assessment · 5 cited sources

Pricing terms and limitations

Tariff grade 10/10 for the named ECN account: USD 2 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 2 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Australian ECN account on MT5 / MetaTrader Web only. A reference-only spread table is not treated as a published average. The separately quoted Prime commission is not substituted for ECN pricing. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.

Published tariff: 0 pip × USD 10 + USD 2 round-turn commission = USD 2 tariff floor -> existing cost band grade 10. No average spread is assumed.

Copy product and execution scope

PU Copy Trading (PU Prime App and Client Portal, MTS Copy Trading Account), international side of the brand as documented on helpcenter.puprime.com; providing company not named (Seychelles, Mauritius or South Africa); not PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd, Australia

PU Prime assessment · 8 cited sources

PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd, margin FX and CFDs, Australia

PU Prime assessment · 3 cited sources

Copy and execution findings

The international help centre documents PU Copy Trading as the broker's own product in which a copier's account automatically copies a signal provider's trades. It documents three sizing modes (equivalent margin, lot multiplier, fixed lot), follower controls (a stop-loss and take-profit per copied strategy, and stopping a copy) and fees (no subscription fee, the account's normal commission, and a provider-set profit share of up to 50% above a high-water mark). The pages do not name the providing company and the Australian licence does not cover them, so this is not established for PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd.

PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd is the counterparty to every trade and acts as a market maker. Its Counterparty Risk Hedging Policy says it does not hedge every client position and that the extent of hedging is decided by its risk team and management; the PDS likewise says it 'may choose' to offset exposure in the wholesale market. That is hedging at the firm's discretion. One of its two named hedge counterparties, PU Prime Limited, is a related body corporate, and hedging inside the group would not count as external in any case.

What remains unresolved?

  • Company structure: A closed group list of operating companies: whether any company beyond the four licensed entities contracts with clients or executes under the PU Prime name.

Read the full PU Prime assessment summary

StarTrader: account, pricing and evidence

Brand-level feature review of STARTRADER across its global site startrader.com and its help centre, not a single account offer. The site assigns a client to a company by location and publishes client agreements for three: STARTRADER Limited (Seychelles, FSA licence SD049), STARTRADER Financial Markets Limited (Mauritius, FSC licence GB24203371) and STARTRADER LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, registration 228 LLC 2019). A-book rests on the client agreement of STARTRADER Limited (Seychelles), read in full; the two clauses that carry the grade were also read in the agreements of the other two companies. Copy trading rests on the STAR Copy terms issued by STARTRADER LLC and on brand help-centre articles that name no company. Costs and partner programmes come from brand pages that name no contracting company. The earlier screening looked at STARTRADER Prime Global Pty Ltd (Australia): its site startraderprime.com.au refused every request on 19 Nov 2026 and nothing from its documents is used.

Cost basis

Prime ECN: USD 4.00 round-turn commission + 0-pip published minimum spread; USD 4.00 tariff floor. Average all-in cost unverified. Condition: USD 10k + activity rules.

StarTrader assessment · 8 cited sources

Pricing terms and limitations

Tariff grade 10/10 for the named Prime ECN account: USD 4 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 4 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Prime ECN requires USD 10,000 balance and no open positions to upgrade by email request. Keeping it requires 5 closed trades and USD 500,000 notional in a 30-day period within 90 days.

Published tariff: 0 pip × USD 10 + USD 4 round-turn commission = USD 4 tariff floor -> existing cost band grade 10. No average spread is assumed.

Copy product and execution scope

STAR Copy, the brand's own copy-trading product in its app and client portal; terms issued by STARTRADER LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines); product page and help-centre articles are brand-level and name no company

StarTrader assessment · 8 cited sources

STARTRADER Limited, Seychelles, margin FX and CFDs, all clients, client agreement version 10.26 governed by the law of Seychelles; the same clauses read separately in the agreements of STARTRADER LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) and STARTRADER Financial Markets Limited (Mauritius)

StarTrader assessment · 11 cited sources

Copy and execution findings

STAR Copy is the broker's own product, with terms issued by STARTRADER LLC: once a copier chooses a signal provider, that provider's trades are mirrored in the copier's account automatically. The help centre documents three sizing rules (equivalent used margin, fixed lot, fixed multiplier), follower controls (pause, which keeps positions; stop, which closes them) and the fees (no platform fee; a profit share of 0–50% above a high-water mark set by the provider). All four elements of the anchor are documented, which gives 10. This grades documentation of the product, not results.

The client agreement of STARTRADER Limited (Seychelles) makes every order a contract between the client and the company, accepted at the company's discretion. It says the company has arrangements with unnamed third-party execution providers for the facilitation of transactions, and that the client has no claim over the company's contracts 'if any' with other persons. So outside arrangements exist, but nothing commits the company to pass on each order and 'if any' leaves that to the company: a discretionary policy, which is 4. The help centre's 'STP-ECN, no dealing desk, all orders routed directly to the market' wording is not in the agreement and does not raise the grade. The agreements of STARTRADER LLC and the Mauritius company carry the same two clauses.

What remains unresolved?

  • Company structure: A closed list from the group of the companies that open client accounts or execute orders, and in particular whether STARTRADER International Pty Ltd (South Africa) or any United Kingdom or Cyprus company does so today.

Read the full StarTrader assessment summary

This comparison is compiled from the site’s published documentary assessments, not a live trading test. The source date on a broker page and the date this comparison was generated are separate. Verify the exact company, platform, account and country terms before treating a feature as available.

How scoring works
  1. Established gradedocumented, or documented and owner-confirmed
  2. or penalty Plow end of the evidence range, 0 if nothing found
  3. × weights5 criteria
  4. Total /10positions 1 to 100

Weighting updated 20 November 2026: company structure 40%; costs, copy trading, A-book and IB-only 15% each. Previously every category was 20%. This is an editorial weighting change; individual broker grades and evidence are unchanged.

Positions are definite. Brokers are numbered 1 to 100 by score, highest first. Where scores are equal, they are listed by name A to Z: the lower number is a listing order, not a better result, and equal scores are marked “equal score”. Each criterion has its own positions 1 to 100 by the same rule.

P is a missing-evidence penalty: where the evidence did not settle a criterion, the lowest grade of its range is used (0 if nothing was established). It is a conservative grade, not a finding that a service is absent, costs are high, trades are internalised or CPA is paid. 193 of the 258 penalty grades are 0; 3 of 100 brokers have all 5 grades from evidence.

T marks 27 tariff assessments. Where no published average settles a broker's costs, the named account's published round-turn commission plus its published minimum or fixed spread (USD 10 a pip, one standard EUR/USD lot) gives a tariff floor, graded on the same cost bands as every other broker. With a variable raw spread only the commission counts and the spread stays extra. The average all-in cost remains unverified. A tariff grade replaces the missing-benchmark penalty within the evidence range; an established average-cost grade always takes precedence. One of them covers a partner route, not a general retail tariff, and says so where it appears.

Positions are global preference-fit positions over the scope documented for each broker. They are not a list of brokers you can open an account with: the country control shows the availability on file and never changes a position. How we rank

Start from a comparison

Browse all 175 published broker pairs · Explore focused broker lists