My Broker Reviews

CMTrading vs FXCM

Any two or three of all 100. Positions and scores are the ones on the ranking.

Comparison

AOverall #30 of 100CMTrading2.8/10Assessment summary · 3 penaltiesEqual score with 1 otherAvailability not confirmed · Switzerland
BOverall #79 of 100FXCM1.2/10Profile · 3 penaltiesEqual score with 13 othersAvailability not confirmed · Switzerland

CMTrading is ahead by 1.6 points. CMTrading leads on Structure (+1.6).

A CMTrading, B FXCM: grades out of 10 per criterion
CriterionGrades (0–10)HigherWeighted
Structure 40%A, CMTrading: 4 out of 10. B, FXCM: 0 out of 10.
Why

A CMTrading: Two

B FXCM: Five or more

A CMTrading +4+1.6
Costs 15%A, CMTrading: 0 out of 10, missing-evidence penalty. B, FXCM: 0 out of 10, missing-evidence penalty.
Why

A CMTrading: Published tariff: USD 10 round-turn commission plus spread. All-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–4 · missing an average or typical EUR/USD spread that the broker labels for a named account (ECN or standard), and the unit of the ECN commission (per standard lot or other).

B FXCM: Published tariff: USD 0 round-turn commission plus spread. Penalty: nothing established

Equal0
Copy 15%A, CMTrading: 0 out of 10, missing-evidence penalty. B, FXCM: 0 out of 10, missing-evidence penalty.
Why

A CMTrading: Penalty: nothing established

B FXCM: Penalty: nothing established

Equal0
A-book 15%A, CMTrading: 4 out of 10. B, FXCM: 4 out of 10.
Why

A CMTrading: Discretionary or mixed routing

B FXCM: Discretionary or mixed routing

Equal0
IB-only 15%A, CMTrading: 4 out of 10, missing-evidence penalty. B, FXCM: 4 out of 10, missing-evidence penalty.
Why

A CMTrading: Penalty: low end of 4–10 · missing an affirmative statement that the partner programme pays no CPA, or a published CPA plan.

B FXCM: Penalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the commission plan of the FXCM affiliate programme (whether it pays a fixed amount per referred client) and the legal entity that runs it.

Equal0
Sum = CMTrading total − FXCM total+1.6

Weighted = grade difference × weight. Positive favours CMTrading. It adds up to the difference in totals. P marks a missing-evidence penalty: the low end of the evidence range.

What separates CMTrading and FXCM?

The overall result follows the published weights: Structure 40% · Costs 15% · Copy 15% · A-book 15% · IB-only 15%. The contributions below explain the score difference; they are not a universal recommendation.

  • Company structure: 4 vs 0; 1.6 weighted points in favour of CMTrading.
  • Published costs: 0P vs 0P; no difference in the weighted total. At least one grade includes an evidence penalty; this is not proof of the corresponding service or cost difference.
  • Copy trading: 0P vs 0P; no difference in the weighted total. At least one grade includes an evidence penalty; this is not proof of the corresponding service or cost difference.
  • A-book commitment: 4 vs 4; no difference in the weighted total.
  • IB-only preference: 4P vs 4P; no difference in the weighted total. At least one grade includes an evidence penalty; this is not proof of the corresponding service or cost difference.

CMTrading: account, pricing and evidence

CMTrading / GCMT Limited (Seychelles, FSA SD070) for costs, copy and abook; structure and affiliate are brand-level (GCMT Group Ltd). Brand-level feature review, not an account offer; country eligibility not assessed.

Cost basis

Evidence penalty: costs 0/10 (P, missing-evidence penalty). This is a lower-bound evidence penalty, not a measurement of realised trading costs. An exact comparable cost grade is not established in the current assessment. Unresolved evidence: An average or typical EUR/USD spread that the broker labels for a named account (ECN or standard), and the unit of the ECN commission (per standard lot or other).

CMTrading assessment · 3 cited sources

Pricing terms and limitations

Only minimum EUR/USD spreads are published. ECN conditions show 'as low as 0.1' with USD 5 per leg on Premium and USD 7 per leg on Gold accounts; the standard Gold, Premium and VIP accounts show commission 0 and 'as low as 1.9'; Basic and Trader spreads are only labelled 'Regular' and 'Plus'. No average or typical spread is published for any account, so the cheapest minimum caps the grade and nothing fixes it from below.

Cheapest documented minimum: Premium ECN 0.1 pip × USD 10 = USD 1 + 2 legs × USD 5 = at least USD 11 -> band >10–15 at best -> at most 4. Gold ECN at least USD 1 + USD 14 = USD 15 (at most 4). Standard Gold/Premium/VIP at least 1.9 × USD 10 = USD 19 (at most 2). No average -> 0–4.

Copy product and execution scope

GCMT Limited (Seychelles) and the CMTrading websites; brand level

CMTrading assessment · 3 cited sources

GCMT Limited (Seychelles), retail client agreement, all account types including ECN conditions; South African clients reach the same principal through GCMT SA as agent (a group company)

CMTrading assessment · 4 cited sources

Copy and execution findings

Copy trading is named but not described. The Seychelles client agreement says the company will provide the service of copy trading, the partner site mentions 'our very own copytrading platform', and a general article explains social trading with reference to platforms such as MetaTrader 5. None of them names a product or documents automation, sizing, follower controls or fees, and nothing states that copying is not offered.

The Seychelles client agreement calls GCMT Limited a market maker that is principal to every order and the only execution venue, and its hedging clause covers the hedges the firm deems necessary. The group's partner agreement adds that the company decides at its sole discretion which positions to hedge, when and where. That is hedging at the firm's discretion, which the anchor grades 4. The ECN page's description of orders passed to banks and prime brokers is marketing with no matching clause in the agreement; nothing excludes external hedging, so the grade is not 0.

What remains unresolved?

  • Published costs: An average or typical EUR/USD spread that the broker labels for a named account (ECN or standard), and the unit of the ECN commission (per standard lot or other).
  • Copy trading: A broker document that describes the copy service: that follower trades open automatically, how they are sized, how a follower stops or pauses, and what is charged.
  • IB-only preference: An affirmative statement that the partner programme pays no CPA, or a published CPA plan.

Read the full CMTrading assessment summary

FXCM: account, pricing and evidence

Brand-level review across the FXCM companies, not a single account offer. Costs and execution are assessed for Stratos Markets Limited (United Kingdom, FCA 217689); the introducing-broker terms are those in that company's terms of business; no copy-trading product could be tied to any FXCM company. The UK site now carries a notice that new trading accounts are provided through Trade Nation (read as processed text only), so the UK documents describe the terms of the existing UK company, not a new-account offer.

Cost basis

Evidence penalty: costs 0/10 (P, missing-evidence penalty). This is a lower-bound evidence penalty, not a measurement of realised trading costs. An exact comparable cost grade is not established in the current assessment. Unresolved evidence: A published average or typical EUR/USD spread that the page ties to the standard account (or to the Active Trader account) of a named FXCM company, with its period.

FXCM assessment · 1 cited source

Pricing terms and limitations

The UK company's ordinary retail account is the standard CFD account: no commission, cost carried in the spread. Its rate card publishes no spread figure at all, neither a minimum nor an average, and refers to the trading platform. The Active Trader account charges USD 2.50 per side per 100k (USD 5 round trip) but is open only to clients the firm designates, so it is not treated as an ordinary retail account. The spread pages on the website are live widgets that could not be read. With no minimum and no account-labelled average, the range is not narrowed.

Standard CFD account: commission nil; no minimum and no average or typical EUR/USD spread published for the account -> no dollar figure -> 0–10

Copy product and execution scope

FXCM brand; checked for Stratos Markets Limited (United Kingdom) and Stratos Global LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines)

FXCM assessment

Stratos Markets Limited, CFD and spread-bet accounts, United Kingdom. Not Stratos Global LLC, Stratos Europe Limited, Stratos Trading Pty. Limited or Stratos Light Ltd.

FXCM assessment · 3 cited sources

Copy and execution findings

No automated copy-trading product could be found in the documents of any FXCM company. The UK and Saint Vincent terms of business and rate cards do not mention copy trading, ZuluTrade, signals or mirroring, and the platform and account pages that could be read (as processed text) list Trading Station, MetaTrader 4, TradingView and API trading only. Nothing says copy trading is not offered, and silence is not that statement, so the criterion stays open.

The UK company's terms of business say it deals as principal and market maker and make the order execution policy part of the agreement. That policy says the firm is the sole execution venue and that, at its discretion, it may hedge some or all of its market risk with third parties, with client trades hedged individually, in aggregate or not at all. A policy that leaves hedging to the firm's discretion is the 4 anchor. The firm's 2025 prudential disclosure says firm positions are fully hedged, but that describes practice in one year, names no counterparty and is not a contractual commitment, so it does not raise the grade.

What remains unresolved?

  • Published costs: A published average or typical EUR/USD spread that the page ties to the standard account (or to the Active Trader account) of a named FXCM company, with its period.
  • Copy trading: Either a current FXCM page or document that describes an automated copy service offered by a named FXCM company, or an explicit statement that no copy trading (including third-party integrations such as ZuluTrade or MetaTrader Signals) is offered.
  • IB-only preference: The commission plan of the FXCM affiliate programme (whether it pays a fixed amount per referred client) and the legal entity that runs it.

Read the full FXCM profile

This comparison is compiled from the site’s published documentary assessments, not a live trading test. The source date on a broker page and the date this comparison was generated are separate. Verify the exact company, platform, account and country terms before treating a feature as available.

How scoring works
  1. Established gradedocumented, or documented and owner-confirmed
  2. or penalty Plow end of the evidence range, 0 if nothing found
  3. × weights5 criteria
  4. Total /10positions 1 to 100

Weighting updated 20 November 2026: company structure 40%; costs, copy trading, A-book and IB-only 15% each. Previously every category was 20%. This is an editorial weighting change; individual broker grades and evidence are unchanged.

Positions are definite. Brokers are numbered 1 to 100 by score, highest first. Where scores are equal, they are listed by name A to Z: the lower number is a listing order, not a better result, and equal scores are marked “equal score”. Each criterion has its own positions 1 to 100 by the same rule.

P is a missing-evidence penalty: where the evidence did not settle a criterion, the lowest grade of its range is used (0 if nothing was established). It is a conservative grade, not a finding that a service is absent, costs are high, trades are internalised or CPA is paid. 193 of the 258 penalty grades are 0; 3 of 100 brokers have all 5 grades from evidence.

T marks 27 tariff assessments. Where no published average settles a broker's costs, the named account's published round-turn commission plus its published minimum or fixed spread (USD 10 a pip, one standard EUR/USD lot) gives a tariff floor, graded on the same cost bands as every other broker. With a variable raw spread only the commission counts and the spread stays extra. The average all-in cost remains unverified. A tariff grade replaces the missing-benchmark penalty within the evidence range; an established average-cost grade always takes precedence. One of them covers a partner route, not a general retail tariff, and says so where it appears.

Positions are global preference-fit positions over the scope documented for each broker. They are not a list of brokers you can open an account with: the country control shows the availability on file and never changes a position. How we rank

Start from a comparison

Browse all 175 published broker pairs · Explore focused broker lists