CMTrading: account, pricing and evidence
CMTrading / GCMT Limited (Seychelles, FSA SD070) for costs, copy and abook; structure and affiliate are brand-level (GCMT Group Ltd). Brand-level feature review, not an account offer; country eligibility not assessed.
Cost basis
Evidence penalty: costs 0/10 (P, missing-evidence penalty). This is a lower-bound evidence penalty, not a measurement of realised trading costs. An exact comparable cost grade is not established in the current assessment. Unresolved evidence: An average or typical EUR/USD spread that the broker labels for a named account (ECN or standard), and the unit of the ECN commission (per standard lot or other).
CMTrading assessment · 3 cited sources
Pricing terms and limitations
Only minimum EUR/USD spreads are published. ECN conditions show 'as low as 0.1' with USD 5 per leg on Premium and USD 7 per leg on Gold accounts; the standard Gold, Premium and VIP accounts show commission 0 and 'as low as 1.9'; Basic and Trader spreads are only labelled 'Regular' and 'Plus'. No average or typical spread is published for any account, so the cheapest minimum caps the grade and nothing fixes it from below.
Cheapest documented minimum: Premium ECN 0.1 pip × USD 10 = USD 1 + 2 legs × USD 5 = at least USD 11 -> band >10–15 at best -> at most 4. Gold ECN at least USD 1 + USD 14 = USD 15 (at most 4). Standard Gold/Premium/VIP at least 1.9 × USD 10 = USD 19 (at most 2). No average -> 0–4.
Copy product and execution scope
GCMT Limited (Seychelles) and the CMTrading websites; brand level
CMTrading assessment · 3 cited sources
GCMT Limited (Seychelles), retail client agreement, all account types including ECN conditions; South African clients reach the same principal through GCMT SA as agent (a group company)
CMTrading assessment · 4 cited sources
Copy and execution findings
Copy trading is named but not described. The Seychelles client agreement says the company will provide the service of copy trading, the partner site mentions 'our very own copytrading platform', and a general article explains social trading with reference to platforms such as MetaTrader 5. None of them names a product or documents automation, sizing, follower controls or fees, and nothing states that copying is not offered.
The Seychelles client agreement calls GCMT Limited a market maker that is principal to every order and the only execution venue, and its hedging clause covers the hedges the firm deems necessary. The group's partner agreement adds that the company decides at its sole discretion which positions to hedge, when and where. That is hedging at the firm's discretion, which the anchor grades 4. The ECN page's description of orders passed to banks and prime brokers is marketing with no matching clause in the agreement; nothing excludes external hedging, so the grade is not 0.
What remains unresolved?
- Published costs: An average or typical EUR/USD spread that the broker labels for a named account (ECN or standard), and the unit of the ECN commission (per standard lot or other).
- Copy trading: A broker document that describes the copy service: that follower trades open automatically, how they are sized, how a follower stops or pauses, and what is charged.
- IB-only preference: An affirmative statement that the partner programme pays no CPA, or a published CPA plan.
Read the full CMTrading assessment summary
Deriv: account, pricing and evidence
Brand-level review across Deriv group companies, not a single account offer: costs and A-book on Deriv (BVI) Ltd (Deriv MT5 Standard and Zero Spread accounts, British Virgin Islands); copy on Deriv (SVG) LLC (Deriv cTrader, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), because the General Terms link cTrader accounts to that company only. Deriv Investments (Europe) Limited (Malta) is counted for structure and its execution wording is recorded as a fact only; deriv.com/eu redirected to the global site from this connection.
Cost basis
Evidence penalty: costs 0/10 (P, missing-evidence penalty). This is a lower-bound evidence penalty, not a measurement of realised trading costs. An exact comparable cost grade is not established in the current assessment. Unresolved evidence: A Deriv-published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to a named retail account, and the client commission per lot on the Zero Spread account.
Deriv assessment · 3 cited sources
Pricing terms and limitations
Deriv publishes only minimum spreads for its MT5 accounts (Standard from 0.1 pips, Financial from 0.2, Swap-Free from 0.3, Zero Spread from 0) and a platform-level EUR/USD minimum of 0.6 pip with a target spread in percent; no average or typical EUR/USD spread is published for any account. The Zero Spread account charges a commission whose client amount is not stated on the pages read, so neither bound of the range can be narrowed.
No broker-published average or typical EUR/USD spread -> no exact grade. Zero Spread: from 0 pips + commission of unpublished amount -> dollar lower bound only above 0 -> upper bound 10; no upper bound on dollars -> lower bound 0. For comparison only: Standard with the 0.6 pip platform minimum would be at least USD 6, but the table is not labelled for the account and the Zero Spread account may be cheaper.
Copy product and execution scope
Deriv (SVG) LLC, Deriv cTrader copy trading, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (General Terms cl. 2.3.8.3 link cTrader CFD accounts to this company)
Deriv assessment · 6 cited sources
Deriv (BVI) Ltd, Deriv MT5 Standard and Zero Spread accounts, British Virgin Islands
Deriv assessment · 5 cited sources
Copy and execution findings
Deriv presents copy trading as part of its own Deriv cTrader platform and documents that trades are copied automatically in real time, that copied size follows the ratio of provider equity to copier equity, that the copier can stop, pause or set an equity stop loss, and that providers charge performance, management and volume fees with no extra charge from Deriv. All four elements are documented, which is the 10 anchor. The sizing rule comes from Deriv blog posts dated November 2023 that are still published.
The additional terms of Deriv (BVI) Ltd say the company is the counterparty, acts either as agent or as principal and sole execution venue, and that a Deriv MT5 order may be passed to a liquidity provider. Passing orders on is allowed but not promised, which is the discretionary anchor. The provider is not named.
What remains unresolved?
- Published costs: A Deriv-published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to a named retail account, and the client commission per lot on the Zero Spread account.
- IB-only preference: Whether the CPA plan for affiliates registered under Deriv Investments (Europe) Limited is currently offered, or a statement that CPA is not offered.
Read the full Deriv assessment summary