Broker rankings
- 100/100 assessed
- 215 evidence grades
- 27 tariff grades T
- 258 penalty grades P
- Data 20 Nov 2026
How scoring works
- Established gradedocumented, or documented and owner-confirmed
- or penalty Plow end of the evidence range, 0 if nothing found
- × weights5 criteria
- Total /10positions 1 to 100
Weighting updated 20 November 2026: company structure 40%; costs, copy trading, A-book and IB-only 15% each. Previously every category was 20%. This is an editorial weighting change; individual broker grades and evidence are unchanged.
Positions are definite. Brokers are numbered 1 to 100 by score, highest first. Where scores are equal, they are listed by name A to Z: the lower number is a listing order, not a better result, and equal scores are marked “equal score”. Each criterion has its own positions 1 to 100 by the same rule.
P is a missing-evidence penalty: where the evidence did not settle a criterion, the lowest grade of its range is used (0 if nothing was established). It is a conservative grade, not a finding that a service is absent, costs are high, trades are internalised or CPA is paid. 193 of the 258 penalty grades are 0; 3 of 100 brokers have all 5 grades from evidence.
T marks 27 tariff assessments. Where no published average settles a broker's costs, the named account's published round-turn commission plus its published minimum or fixed spread (USD 10 a pip, one standard EUR/USD lot) gives a tariff floor, graded on the same cost bands as every other broker. With a variable raw spread only the commission counts and the spread stays extra. The average all-in cost remains unverified. A tariff grade replaces the missing-benchmark penalty within the evidence range; an established average-cost grade always takes precedence. One of them covers a partner route, not a general retail tariff, and says so where it appears.
Positions are global preference-fit positions over the scope documented for each broker. They are not a list of brokers you can open an account with: the country control shows the availability on file and never changes a position. How we rank
Showing all 100, positions on overall fit
-
1overallequal
5.5/10no penalties
Breakdown for BlackBull Markets
- Company structure4Two
- Published costs8TECN Prime: published account tariff. USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named ECN Prime account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The named ECN Prime account comparison and FAQ quote USD 3 per lot per side. A trading-conditions page instead describes the commission per USD 100,000 traded; that unit discrepancy remains disclosed in the evidence. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Black Bull Group Limited (New Zealand, CFD issuer) and BBG Limited (Seychelles); share investing through Black Bull Trade Limited (New Zealand)
Summary Copy trading is documented with sizing, stop control and fees, while both client-contracting entities keep hedging at their own discretion and the average EUR/USD spread is not published.
- Company structure 4Grade 4: twoScope: BlackBull Markets brand, Black Bull Global Limited groupEstablished from documents
The group legal hub publishes account documents for only three companies, two in New Zealand and one in Seychelles, and the group privacy statement describes those two countries' companies as the ones through which the brand provides market access. The same statement lists further group companies in Cyprus, the British Virgin Islands, Mexico and the UK plus a Dubai representative office, but none is disclosed as contracting with clients and the Cyprus companies are not on CySEC's investment-firm list. Two disclosed client-contracting jurisdictions gives 4; the penalty reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 2
3 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: ECN Prime: published account tariff; USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: ECN Prime; BlackBull Markets brand, ECN Prime account, EUR/USD, USD account; commission confirmed for Black Bull Group Limited (New Zealand) in its PDS (see findings rs-blackbull-pds-nz-fees); pricing pages are not entity-specificPublished tariff assessment (ECN Prime); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named ECN Prime account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The named ECN Prime account comparison and FAQ quote USD 3 per lot per side. A trading-conditions page instead describes the commission per USD 100,000 traded; that unit discrepancy remains disclosed in the evidence. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A BlackBull-published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for ECN Prime (or another ordinary retail account: ECN Standard, Raw, Pro), with its period and the entity it applies to.
Account ECN PrimeRound turn commission USD 6
26 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: BlackBull lead/follow copy trading (BlackBull CopyTrader on MT4/MT5 and cTrader Copy); terms cover BBG Limited (Seychelles) and Black Bull Group Limited (New Zealand); country availability not establishedEstablished from documents
The copy trading terms, which name both BBG Limited (Seychelles) and Black Bull Group Limited (New Zealand), document automatic copying of a leader's trades, follower-set trade size or risk level, the option to stop copying at any time and a leader-set performance fee. BlackBull's own help centre adds the cTrader Copy sizing rule (proportional to equity) and stop control, and the CopyTrader page states the platform itself is free. All four elements of the top anchor are documented; which entity contracts with a given follower and which countries are served is not stated.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Black Bull Group Limited (New Zealand), CFDs, PDS 11 September 2026; BBG Limited (Seychelles), CFDs, Client Services Agreement v3.1 May 2024Established from documents
Both client-contracting entities keep hedging as their own choice. The New Zealand PDS says the issuer decides whether, when and how far to hedge and that a client position may be hedged in full, in part or not at all; the Seychelles agreement says the company may hedge at its absolute discretion and is not required to hedge. The help-centre 'strictly non-dealing desk' statement is marketing and is not repeated as a contractual commitment, so the discretionary anchor applies. This does not establish that orders are actually internalised.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: BlackBull Partners (partners.blackbull.com), BlackBull Markets brand programmes; not an entitlement in every countryEstablished from documents
The BlackBull Partners site documents both models side by side: an affiliate programme paid per acquisition (CPA up to US$1,000 per client, also CPC and CPL) and an introducing-broker programme paid on trading volume (rebates and markup, up to US$18 per lot). Both IB/volume-based and CPA remuneration are therefore offered, which is the 4 anchor and confirms the existing grade.
-
2overallequal
Vantora Markets
Profile Best Copy, IB-only 10 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Eligibility not confirmedNew applications unavailable
5.4/101 penalty
Breakdown for Vantora Markets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a complete brand-level list of operating/client-contracting entities, including the identity, jurisdiction and role of the other group company referenced in the public terms. Company incorporation itself is now documented.
- Published costs8TDesignated Livio Swiss route only, not a general retail tariff. USD 6 round-turn commission plus variable raw spread (extra, not verified). Documented-pricing assessment: 8/10 for USD 3 per side / USD 6 round-turn commission, variable raw LP spreads with zero added broker spread markup, and no separate copy subscription, performance or account-maintenance fee. The USD 1 partner payment comes from broker commission and adds no client surcharge. The grade recognises the agreed tariff; it does not claim a measured or published average EUR/USD all-in cost.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment8Contractual per fill acceptance
- IB-only preference10Affirmatively IB only no CPA · owner-confirmed
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Vantoramarkets LTD., Saint Lucia IBC no. 2026-00612. Costs, copy trading, A-book and IB-only grades consistently assess the designated Livio Swiss route. Structure counts the brand’s operating/client-contracting jurisdictions.
Summary Livio Swiss route: USD 6 round-turn commission, raw LP spreads with no broker markup, documented automated copying and a contractual per-fill external acceptance condition. USD 1 per eligible completed lot goes to Livio without client surcharge; the owner confirms CPA is excluded for this route. Average EUR/USD spread and a closed brand-level operating-entity list remain missing.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Vantora Markets brand; Vantoramarkets LTD., Saint Lucia IBC no. 2026-00612Investigated, not settled
This grade also rests on company records that are not published here; the public sources below are listed.
Missing A complete brand-level list of operating/client-contracting entities, including the identity, jurisdiction and role of the other group company referenced in the public terms. Company incorporation itself is now documented.
Count lower bound 1
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: Designated Livio Swiss route only, not a general retail tariff; USD 6 round-turn commission plus variable raw spread (extra, not verified).Scope: Designated Livio Swiss route only; Vantoramarkets LTD.; one standard Forex lot.Partner-route tariff assessment (Livio Swiss route); average spread unverified
Documented-pricing assessment: 8/10 for USD 3 per side / USD 6 round-turn commission, variable raw LP spreads with zero added broker spread markup, and no separate copy subscription, performance or account-maintenance fee. The USD 1 partner payment comes from broker commission and adds no client surcharge. The grade recognises the agreed tariff; it does not claim a measured or published average EUR/USD all-in cost.
Missing A measured or published typical/average EUR/USD raw spread for the designated Livio Swiss route, with the observation period and applicable account group. The USD 6 commission and zero broker spread markup are documented.
Account Designated Livio Swiss route; eligible community accountsSpread basis Variable raw LP spreads; no fixed average or permanent-zero guaranteeBroker spread markup None under clause 5Commission per side USD 3Round turn commission USD 6Average spread published noLower bound cost USD 6Separate copy fee USD 0
1 address tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Internal copier on the designated Livio Swiss route (eligible community accounts opened through the named signup link, under a signed copying mandate); Vantoramarkets LTD., Saint Lucia. Not general accounts.Established from documents
For the designated Livio Swiss route the published partnership agreement documents all four elements: an internal copier that copies new master entries automatically, an equity-proportional sizing formula with a 0.25–1.00 client multiplier, follower pause/disconnect and automatic loss-pause limits, and no separate copy fee. This grade is for that route only; the general client agreement describes copying only as something requiring a separate mandate, and that mandate is not published. The agreement is an unsigned public display copy and shows terms, not observed behaviour.
- A-book commitment 8Grade 8: contractual per fill acceptanceScope: Designated Livio Swiss route only (master portfolio and eligible community accounts in the verified account group); Vantoramarkets LTD., Saint Lucia. General accounts are outside this grade.Established from documents
For the designated Livio Swiss route the partnership agreement commits the broker to hedge each executed fill one-to-one with the liquidity provider, to confirm a client fill only to the extent matching external execution is accepted, and to reject instructions without external acceptance within two seconds. That is a contractual, route-specific per-fill condition with no published hedge records, which is the anchor for 8. It does not extend to general accounts: the execution policy and client agreement let the broker internalise, match, route or hedge at its discretion (anchor 4) unless a route is expressly agreed. The agreement is an unsigned public display copy between the broker, Livio and an unnamed liquidity provider.
- IB-only preference 10Grade 10: affirmatively IB only no CPAScope: Designated Livio Swiss partnership only; Vantoramarkets LTD., Saint Lucia. CPA exclusion is owner-confirmed for this assessed route; no claim about every brand partner.Documented terms + owner confirmation 19 Nov 2026
The assessed programme is the designated Livio Swiss route. Clause 5 documents USD 1 per completed eligible standard lot, paid from the broker’s own USD 6 round-turn commission with no additional client surcharge. On 19 November 2026 the owner affirmatively confirmed that CPA is excluded for this assessed route. Documented volume-based remuneration plus that explicit confirmation meets the IB-only anchor of 10. The public agreement does not itself state a CPA exclusion; that part is owner-confirmed. Other partners’ arrangements are outside this route-specific grade.
Ib USD per completed eligible lot 1Client surcharge USD 0
-
3overallequal
4.7/10no penalties
Breakdown for Markets.com
- Company structure2Three or four
- Published costs8TRetail CFD: published account tariff. USD 6 tariff floor: USD 0 round-turn commission + 0.6 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Retail CFD account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0.6 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The 0.6-pip figure is the advertised retail offering floor; the MT4 and MT5 specification tables give a 1-pip minimum. The 0.6-pip tariff is not asserted for those platform variants. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across the Markets.com group, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and execution all rest on Safecap Investments Limited, Cyprus (HE186196, CySEC licence 092/08), which operates www.markets.com/en/; it was chosen because its investment services agreement, order execution policy, conflicts policy, costs document, trading-conditions tables and social-trading page could all be read. The partner programme is a brand-level programme whose affiliate agreement is made with Clear Consulting Services Limited (British Virgin Islands) for Markets South Africa (Pty) Ltd and whose IB terms name Markets International Ltd (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) and Markets South Africa (Pty) Ltd; for Safecap only a spread-share payment to partners is disclosed. Nothing is carried from the South African or Saint Vincent companies to Safecap or back.
Summary Markets.com names three operating companies (Cyprus, South Africa, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines); for the Cyprus company a partner-provided copy service is documented with sizing rules, performance fees and a trade-level stop, execution is market-making with hedging at the firm's discretion that may be inside the group, the partner programme pays both per-client CPA and spread share, and no average EUR/USD spread is published (only minimums of 0.6 to 1.0 pips, no commission), so the cost grade stays a range.
- Company structure 2Grade 2: three or fourScope: Markets.com group (Safecap Investments Limited, Markets South Africa (Pty) Ltd, Markets International Ltd)Established from documents
The group's own 'Our Group' page lists three companies that operate markets.com, and the Global Offering table and every site footer name the same three: Safecap Investments Limited (Cyprus), Markets South Africa (Pty) Ltd (South Africa) and Markets International Ltd (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines). Each has its own site and legal pack (the Cyprus and Saint Vincent client agreements were opened; the South African one is listed on its legal hub and was not opened). The three former Finalto companies (United Kingdom, Australia, British Virgin Islands) each state that they no longer offer services under the Markets.com brand, so they are not counted. Three operating jurisdictions is the 3–4 band, grade 2; a fourth would not change the grade.
Count lower bound 3
4 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: Retail CFD: published account tariff; USD 6 tariff floor: USD 0 round-turn commission + 0.6 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Safecap Investments Limited, Cyprus; advertised retail CFD EUR/USD floor. The pricing page does not assign the 0.6-pip floor to a platform. MT4 and MT5 publish a separate 1-pip minimum and are not priced at 0.6 here.Published tariff assessment (Retail CFD); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Retail CFD account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0.6 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The 0.6-pip figure is the advertised retail offering floor; the MT4 and MT5 specification tables give a 1-pip minimum. The 0.6-pip tariff is not asserted for those platform variants. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A Safecap-published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to a named platform (MT4, MT5 or the Web Platform) or account, with an observation period.
Round turn commission USD 0
18 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Safecap Investments Limited, Cyprus; Markets Social Trading app with Markets.com MT4/MT5 accounts; service partner Pelican Exchange Europe (CY) Ltd (CySEC 441/24)Established from documents
Safecap's site documents 'Markets Social Trading' as its offer, provided in partnership with Pelican Exchange Europe (CY) Ltd: a client links a Markets.com MT4 or MT5 account, chooses to copy a signal provider and the provider's trades are followed automatically. The page documents three sizing rules, a provider-set performance fee of up to 50% charged monthly above a high watermark, and how to stop following by closing the copied trade. All four elements are documented, which is the anchor for 10. The stop control is described at trade level only; no pause, drawdown limit or separate unfollow step is described, and Safecap's conflicts policy says the copy service is provided by the separate regulated firm, not by Safecap.
2 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Safecap Investments Limited, Cyprus; CFDs on Markets.com Web/Mobile Trader, MT4 and MT5; retail and professional clientsEstablished from documents
Safecap's execution policy and client agreement say it is market maker, principal, sole counterparty and sole execution venue for every CFD trade. The policy says it 'may hedge some or all' of its exposure with liquidity providers under its own hedging strategy, the agreement says it 'may decide' to hedge, including with brokers in its group, and the conflicts policy says hedging may be done with group companies and that exposure may not be fully hedged. Hedging is therefore at the firm's discretion and may stay inside the group, which is the anchor for 4; nothing commits Safecap to route or hedge each trade outside the group.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Markets.com partner programmes at brand level: Affiliate Program (Clear Consulting Services Limited, BVI, for Markets South Africa (Pty) Ltd) and Introducing Broker programme (Markets International Ltd, SVG; Markets South Africa (Pty) Ltd)Established from documents
The brand's partner site advertises a CPA programme paying a one-time amount per qualified referred client and an introducing broker programme paying an ongoing commission of up to 40% on referred clients' trading. The affiliate agreement, made with Clear Consulting Services Limited for Markets South Africa (Pty) Ltd, defines the CPA plan (a flat rate per Qualified Trader), a cost-per-lead plan and a spread share. Both a revenue-share and a per-client payment are documented, which is grade 4. For Safecap itself only a spread share to partners is disclosed; the partner site says the programmes do not apply to all licences.
-
4overallequal
4.7/10no penalties
Breakdown for Tickmill
- Company structure2Three or four
- Published costs8TRaw: published account tariff. USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Raw account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles, FSA licence SD008) for costs, copy trading and execution terms; structure and partner programmes at brand level
Summary Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles) documents automated copying with ratio sizing, follower limits and fees, and a Raw commission of USD 6 per round trip. The typical spread it publishes is not labelled for the Raw account, so the cost grade stays a range. Its client agreement keeps hedging discretionary, and the group spans four jurisdictions with both IB and CPA programmes.
- Company structure 2Grade 2: three or fourScope: Tickmill brand, all entitiesEstablished from documents
The group licences page and the group statement in the site footer both give a closed list of four companies: Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles), Tickmill UK Ltd, Tickmill Europe Ltd (Cyprus) and Tickmill South Africa (Pty) Ltd. Dubai is a representative office of the UK company and is not counted; the former Labuan company, Tickmill Asia Ltd, is on the Labuan FSA list of surrendered licences dated 10 January 2025. Four operating jurisdictions fall in the 3-4 band; if the South African intermediary were left out the count would be three and the grade the same.
Count lower bound 4
1 address tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: Raw: published account tariff; USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Raw; Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles), Raw account, USD, EUR/USD, global sitePublished tariff assessment (Raw); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Raw account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
1 address tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Tickmill Social Trading, Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles), MT4 and MT5 live accounts; not checked for Tickmill UK Ltd or Tickmill Europe LtdEstablished from documents
The Tickmill Social Trading page, whose disclaimer names Tickmill Limited under the Seychelles FSA, documents all four items. Copying is automatic once accounts are connected; the follower sets the copy ratio; the follower can set limits that close positions or stop the subscription and can close copied trades; the service is free apart from a provider's performance fee of at most 50% of profits.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles), OTC FX and CFD contracts; not carried to Tickmill UK Ltd or Tickmill Europe LtdEstablished from documents
The Client Service Agreement of Tickmill Ltd (Seychelles) says the firm deals as principal and may act as a market maker in FX and CFDs. Clause 14.5 lets it, at its reasonable discretion, offset a client position against another client, against a counterparty, or keep a proprietary position. That is discretionary hedging or internalising, which the anchor grades 4; it does not show that the firm actually internalises.
2 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Tickmill brand partner programmes, global site; terms may differ by entity and countryEstablished from documents
Tickmill documents both routes on its own pages: an Introducing Broker programme paying revenue share or a per-lot amount, and a separate Affiliate programme paying CPA per qualified referral. Both documented is exact 4, which confirms the existing grade.
-
5overallequal
Axi
Profile Best Costs, Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
4.2/102 penalties
Breakdown for Axi
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a closed, group-level list of the companies that contract with Axi clients, and the role and jurisdiction of AxiCorp Pte Ltd.
- Published costs10TPremium / Pro: published account tariff. USD 4.50 tariff floor: USD 4.50 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 10/10 for the named Premium / Pro account: USD 4.5 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 4.5 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 (review hold)
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Axi Financial Services (UK) Limited (United Kingdom, FCA 466201) for costs, copy trading and execution; the partner programmes are those published on axi.com/int by AxiTrader LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines).
Summary The UK entity's execution policy commits to a back-to-back trade in all cases, but the only venue it names appears to be a group company, so routing outside the group is unresolved. Its copy-trading app is documented, no average spread is published, the brand spans at least four jurisdictions and the partner programme pays CPA as well as revenue share.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: Axi brand, group levelInvestigated, not settled
Four companies in four jurisdictions each run an Axi site with their own client documents: AxiTrader LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), Axi Financial Services (UK) Limited, AxiCorp Financial Services Pty Ltd (Australia) and Solaris EMEA Ltd (Cyprus). That is at least four, which caps the grade at 2. The UAE site is run by a DFSA-regulated DIFC branch of the Australian company, which the anchor excludes as a branch; if it were counted the total would be five and the grade 0. No source gives a closed list of the group's operating companies, so the count stays a lower bound. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Missing A closed, group-level list of the companies that contract with Axi clients, and the role and jurisdiction of AxiCorp Pte Ltd.
Count lower bound 4
5 addresses tried
- Published costs 10TAssigned tariff grade 10; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–10.Tariff basis: Premium / Pro: published account tariff; USD 4.50 tariff floor: USD 4.50 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Premium / Pro; Axi Financial Services (UK) Limited, Premium (Pro) account, USD account, UK retail clientsPublished tariff assessment (Premium / Pro); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 10/10 for the named Premium / Pro account: USD 4.5 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 4.5 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread for the Premium (Pro) or Standard account of any Axi entity.
Account Premium (Pro in the product schedule), MT4 / MT5 / Axi Trading Platform, Axi Financial Services (UK) LimitedRound turn commission USD 4.5Spread basis advertised minimum ('spreads starting from'); no average or typical figure published
11 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Axi Copy Trading app as offered by Axi Financial Services (UK) Limited to UK clients; mechanics from the UK help centre (fcasupport.axi.com)Established from documents
The UK entity offers the Axi Copy Trading app, run with partner London & Eastern LLP: a follower picks a trader and that trader's trades are mirrored automatically. The UK help centre linked from the UK site documents three sizing rules (fixed size, the provider's size, proportional to equity), a maximum drawdown setting, stopping a copy at any time, and a performance fee set by the provider and deducted weekly. Automation, sizing, follower controls and fees are all documented, which is the top anchor. The help articles name no legal entity and give no maximum fee; this grades documentation, not results.
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: Axi Financial Services (UK) Limited, MT4 and MT5 accounts, UK clients. Not AxiTrader LLC, AxiCorp Financial Services Pty Ltd or Solaris EMEA Ltd.Held as a range by independent review
The UK policy commits to back-to-back dealing, but the named venue appears to be within the Axi group. Onward external-group routing is unresolved. An intra-group booking alone does not establish external liquidity-provider A-book execution. Keep the same 4–6 treatment as the unresolved Capital.com route.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Axi partner programmes as published on axi.com/int by AxiTrader LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), brand levelEstablished from documents
The partner pages on the international site document both models: an introducing broker programme paying a revenue share on referred clients' trading (up to 55%) and an affiliate programme paying a one-time CPA of up to USD 600 per qualified client, plus a hybrid of the two. Both documented gives 4, which confirms the earlier grade. The UK product schedule also allows payments to introducers. These are brand programmes and not an entitlement in every country.
-
6overallequal
Fusion Markets
Profile Best Costs, Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedAustralian company on file
4.2/101 penalty
Breakdown for Fusion Markets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a group-level primary source that lists every operating company of the Fusion Markets / Gleneagle group (the documents refer to a group, subsidiaries and affiliates without naming them), to show whether the count is exactly four or five or more.
- Published costs10USD 4.70 round trip
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Fusion Markets brand as disclosed on fusionmarkets.com: Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited (Vanuatu), Fusion Markets International Ltd (Seychelles), FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd (Australia); and Fusion Markets EU Ltd (Cyprus) on fusionmarkets.com/eu
Summary The Zero account publishes a 0.02-pip average EUR/USD spread plus USD 4.50 round-trip commission and copy trading is documented in detail, while the brand contracts through at least four jurisdictions and its disclosure statements leave hedging to the firm's discretion.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: Fusion Markets brand: Australia, Vanuatu, Seychelles, Cyprus entitiesInvestigated, not settled
Re-reading the global, regional and EU sites and the Australian, Vanuatu and Cyprus documents on 19 November 2026 again finds four operating jurisdictions: Australia (FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd), Vanuatu (Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited), Seychelles (Fusion Markets International Ltd) and Cyprus (Fusion Markets EU Ltd, confirmed on the CySEC register). No fifth jurisdiction was found, but the Cyprus privacy notice and the Vanuatu terms refer to a group, subsidiaries and affiliates that they do not name, and no group-level closed list exists in the public documents, so four stays a lower bound. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Missing A group-level primary source that lists every operating company of the Fusion Markets / Gleneagle group (the documents refer to a group, subsidiaries and affiliates without naming them), to show whether the count is exactly four or five or more.
Count lower bound 4
20 addresses tried
- Published costs 10Grade 10: USD ≤ 5Scope: Zero account, MT4/MT5, USD account, EUR/USD, as published on fusionmarkets.com (Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited, Vanuatu; Fusion Markets International Ltd, Seychelles). Not separately confirmed on the Australian site (redirected) and not applicable to Fusion Markets EU Ltd.Established from documents
The Zero account is the cheapest ordinary retail account with both figures published. The product list on the Trading Conditions page gives EUR/USD an average spread of 0.02 pip for 12-16 October 2026, and the Classic account page states that these product-list averages apply to the Zero account; commission is USD 4.50 per round-turn lot. The average covers one published week, and the Zero page's own all-in estimate of about 0.5 pip (USD 5.00) falls in the same band.
Account Zero (MT4/MT5, USD)Average spread pips 0.02Round turn commission USD 4.5Indicative cost USD 4.7
2 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: cTrader Copy (Zero cTrader account), Fusion+ and DupliTrade as offered on fusionmarkets.com; Fusion+ terms with Gleneagle Securities Pty Ltd, Vanuatu. Not verified for Fusion Markets EU Ltd (its site lists MetaTrader 5 only) or separately for the Australian site.Established from documents
The broker documents cTrader Copy as its own offer with all four elements: trades are mirrored automatically, the follower sets an allocation and results follow in proportion to it, the follower can stop at any time with copied positions closed at market, and performance, management and volume fees are described. Fusion+ (terms made with the Vanuatu entity) and DupliTrade on MT4 are also documented; for Fusion+ the fees and stop/disconnect rights are stated but the sizing formula is not. Sizing is documented as allocation-proportional rather than as a formula.
1 address tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd (Australia) PDS December 2026 and Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited (Vanuatu) PDS December 2026; OTC FX and CFD products. Not Fusion Markets International Ltd (Seychelles) or Fusion Markets EU Ltd (Cyprus).Established from documents
The Australian and the Vanuatu disclosure statements each say the firm deals as principal on a market-making pricing model and may hedge its exposure to clients at any time; the Vanuatu text adds that it may later change that at any time. That is a discretion to hedge with a Hedge Counterparty, not a commitment to hedge every trade. The Seychelles client agreement and the Cyprus execution policy name the company as principal or counterparty and are silent on hedging, so this grade is not carried to those two entities. The Australian and Vanuatu disclosure statements and the Seychelles client agreement read on 18 November 2026 are labelled December 2026; whether they are already in force or are future-dated replacements of the current terms was not established.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Fusion Markets brand partner programmes as published on fusionmarkets.comEstablished from documents
The partners page documents both an Introducing Broker programme paying ongoing commission and rebates on referred clients' trading and a separate Affiliate programme paying on a CPA basis. This confirms the existing grade. These are brand partner programmes, not an entitlement in every country.
-
7overallequal
FXCC
Assessment summary Best Costs, Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
4.2/102 penalties
Breakdown for FXCC
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing whether the Saint Vincent, Nevis and Vanuatu companies operate as brokers or contract with clients for the brand, and a closed list of the group's operating companies.
- Published costs10TECN XL: published account tariff. USD 0 tariff floor: USD 0 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 10/10 for the named ECN XL account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 0 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Actual spreads vary and an average cost is unverified; grade 10 assesses the published tariff floor only.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the name of the broker or brokers to which Central Clearing Ltd (Mwali) transmits client orders, and whether it is a group company.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope FXCC global site (www.fxcc.com) · Central Clearing Ltd, Mwali (Comoros), MISA licence BFX2024085. Costs, copy, A-book and the partner programmes all rest on this company. FX Central Clearing Ltd (Cyprus, www.fxcc.eu) is recorded separately in the facts and is not mixed in. Brand-level feature review, not an account offer; country eligibility not assessed.
Summary FXCC’s global MT5 copy service documents automation, sizing, follower controls and its provider-set fee mechanism. Its ECN XL account tariff is documented separately from the still-unverified average EUR/USD cost. Group structure and the strength of external-routing commitments remain bounded; programme evidence includes both IB and CPA. This is a brand-level feature assessment, not an account-eligibility conclusion.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: FXCC brand: Central Clearing Ltd (Mwali, Comoros) and FX Central Clearing Ltd (Cyprus) counted; Central Clearing LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), Central Clearing Ltd (Nevis) and Central Clearing Ltd (Vanuatu) named, not countedInvestigated, not settled
FXCC's own regulation pages give two companies a client-facing role: Central Clearing Ltd in Mwali (Comoros) for www.fxcc.com and FX Central Clearing Ltd in Cyprus for www.fxcc.eu, the latter confirmed on the CySEC register. Three more companies are named with a registration or licence only, in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Nevis and Vanuatu, and nothing says what they do, so they are not counted. There is no closed list of group companies, so two is a lower bound. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Missing Whether the Saint Vincent, Nevis and Vanuatu companies operate as brokers or contract with clients for the brand, and a closed list of the group's operating companies.
Count lower bound 2
5 addresses tried
- Published costs 10TAssigned tariff grade 10; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–10.Tariff basis: ECN XL: published account tariff; USD 0 tariff floor: USD 0 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: ECN XL; Central Clearing Ltd (Mwali), ECN XL account, MT4/MT5, www.fxcc.comPublished tariff assessment (ECN XL); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 10/10 for the named ECN XL account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 0 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Actual spreads vary and an average cost is unverified; grade 10 assesses the published tariff floor only.
Missing A EUR/USD average or typical spread that FXCC itself publishes as a figure for the ECN XL account of the Mwali company.
Round turn commission USD 0
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Central Clearing Ltd (Mwali), FXCC Copy on MT5 accounts, www.fxcc.com; no copy service is shown on the Cyprus company's siteEstablished from documents
FXCC Copy on MT5 documents all four features: automated replication; Autoscale based on equity and leverage; follower pause, termination and equity/drawdown controls; and provider-set performance fees agreed in the Offer, calculated on new net profits by a high-water mark. FXCC charges no copy-specific subscription, platform or commission fee. The grade measures disclosure of the mechanism, not a low fee or profitability: no numeric provider-fee cap is published.
4 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: Central Clearing Ltd (Mwali), CFD accounts on www.fxcc.com; CFDs Customer Agreement Jul 2025/6 v4.1 and Best Interest Policy Dec 2025 v4.0Investigated, not settled
The Mwali company's client agreement says, for all transactions, that it acts as agent and transmits orders for execution to another broker or brokers, which may pass them to liquidity providers; its execution policy, part of the agreement, says the same. That is a contractual blanket route away from the company itself. The receiving broker is not named, so the documents do not show whether it is outside the group or a group company, which is what separates 6 from 4. No fill-level evidence exists in public documents.
Missing The name of the broker or brokers to which Central Clearing Ltd (Mwali) transmits client orders, and whether it is a group company.
5 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: FXCC partner programmes on www.fxccaffiliates.com, Central Clearing Ltd (Mwali); no partner terms of the Cyprus company were readEstablished from documents
FXCC's partner site, provided by the Mwali company, documents an introducing-broker programme that pays a rebate per lot traded by referred clients, and a separate web affiliate programme that pays up to USD 500 per referred active client. Both an IB/volume model and a CPA model are therefore offered. This records the owner's preference only; CPA is a lawful payment model.
-
8overallequal
PU Prime
Assessment summary Best Costs, Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
4.2/101 penalty
Breakdown for PU Prime
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a closed group list of operating companies: whether any company beyond the four licensed entities contracts with clients or executes under the PU Prime name.
- Published costs10TECN: published account tariff. USD 2 tariff floor: USD 2 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 10/10 for the named ECN account: USD 2 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 2 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Australian ECN account on MT5 / MetaTrader Web only. A reference-only spread table is not treated as a published average. The separately quoted Prime commission is not substituted for ECN pricing. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across PU Prime companies, not a single account offer. Costs and execution: PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd (Australia, AFSL 410681), read on www.puprime.au, a site for Australian residents only. Copy: PU Copy Trading as described on the international help centre helpcenter.puprime.com, which says the Australian licence does not cover its services and does not say which of PU Prime Limited (Seychelles), PU Prime Ltd (Mauritius) or PU Prime (Pty) Ltd (South Africa) provides the product. Affiliate: www.puprimepartners.com, which names PU Prime Ltd (Mauritius) and excludes Australian residents. www.puprime.com refused every plain request on 19 Nov 2026 (HTTP 403, bot challenge), so no client agreement, execution policy or account page of the Seychelles, Mauritius or South African company was read; nothing is carried from one company to another.
Summary PU Prime's international help centre documents an automated copy product with sizing modes, follower stops and profit-share fees, and the partner site pays both volume-based IB commission and one-off CPA; the Australian company's hedging policy leaves hedging to its own discretion, no EUR/USD spread labelled as average or typical was found, and the group names four licensed companies in four jurisdictions without a list shown to be complete.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: PU Prime brand, group levelInvestigated, not settled
The brand's own help-centre article says PU Prime operates through four licensed entities: PU Prime Limited (Seychelles), PU Prime Ltd (Mauritius), PU Prime (Pty) Ltd (South Africa) and PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd (Australia). That is at least three to four operating jurisdictions, so the grade cannot be above 2. The list is headed as licensed entities and leaves out the licensed Dubai company, so it is not shown to be a complete list of group companies, and the main site www.puprime.com (footer and legal documents) could not be read to check for a fifth operating company; 0 is therefore not excluded.
Missing A closed group list of operating companies: whether any company beyond the four licensed entities contracts with clients or executes under the PU Prime name.
Count lower bound 4
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 10TAssigned tariff grade 10; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–10.Tariff basis: ECN: published account tariff; USD 2 tariff floor: USD 2 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: ECN; PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd, ECN account on MT5, USD base currency, AustraliaPublished tariff assessment (ECN); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 10/10 for the named ECN account: USD 2 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 2 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Australian ECN account on MT5 / MetaTrader Web only. A reference-only spread table is not treated as a published average. The separately quoted Prime commission is not substituted for ECN pricing. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A EUR/USD spread that the broker labels as average or typical for a named retail account (ECN or Prime), with its observation period.
Account ECN (MT5 / MetaTrader Web), PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd, AustraliaRound turn commission USD 2Lower bound cost USD 2
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: PU Copy Trading (PU Prime App and Client Portal, MTS Copy Trading Account), international side of the brand as documented on helpcenter.puprime.com; providing company not named (Seychelles, Mauritius or South Africa); not PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd, AustraliaEstablished from documents
The international help centre documents PU Copy Trading as the broker's own product in which a copier's account automatically copies a signal provider's trades. It documents three sizing modes (equivalent margin, lot multiplier, fixed lot), follower controls (a stop-loss and take-profit per copied strategy, and stopping a copy) and fees (no subscription fee, the account's normal commission, and a provider-set profit share of up to 50% above a high-water mark). The pages do not name the providing company and the Australian licence does not cover them, so this is not established for PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd.
2 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd, margin FX and CFDs, AustraliaEstablished from documents
PU Prime Trading Pty Ltd is the counterparty to every trade and acts as a market maker. Its Counterparty Risk Hedging Policy says it does not hedge every client position and that the extent of hedging is decided by its risk team and management; the PDS likewise says it 'may choose' to offset exposure in the wholesale market. That is hedging at the firm's discretion. One of its two named hedge counterparties, PU Prime Limited, is a related body corporate, and hedging inside the group would not count as external in any case.
1 address tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: PU Prime partner programmes on www.puprimepartners.com, PU Prime Ltd (Mauritius); not open to Australian residentsEstablished from documents
The brand's partner site documents an Introducing Broker programme paid on the trading volume of referred clients and a CPA Affiliate programme paid once per qualified client (USD 50 to 650 by country tier after a USD 500 deposit and a minimum traded volume), plus a Hybrid programme combining the two. Both IB and CPA are documented, which is grade 4. The site names PU Prime Ltd (Mauritius) and excludes Australian residents; for the Australian company only volume-based Introducer fees are documented.
-
9overallequal
StarTrader
Assessment summary Best Costs, Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
4.2/101 penalty
Breakdown for StarTrader
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a closed list from the group of the companies that open client accounts or execute orders, and in particular whether STARTRADER International Pty Ltd (South Africa) or any United Kingdom or Cyprus company does so today.
- Published costs10TPrime ECN: published account tariff. USD 4 tariff floor: USD 4 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 10/10 for the named Prime ECN account: USD 4 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 4 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Prime ECN requires USD 10,000 balance and no open positions to upgrade by email request. Keeping it requires 5 closed trades and USD 500,000 notional in a 30-day period within 90 days. Condition: USD 10k + activity rules.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review of STARTRADER across its global site startrader.com and its help centre, not a single account offer. The site assigns a client to a company by location and publishes client agreements for three: STARTRADER Limited (Seychelles, FSA licence SD049), STARTRADER Financial Markets Limited (Mauritius, FSC licence GB24203371) and STARTRADER LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, registration 228 LLC 2019). A-book rests on the client agreement of STARTRADER Limited (Seychelles), read in full; the two clauses that carry the grade were also read in the agreements of the other two companies. Copy trading rests on the STAR Copy terms issued by STARTRADER LLC and on brand help-centre articles that name no company. Costs and partner programmes come from brand pages that name no contracting company. The earlier screening looked at STARTRADER Prime Global Pty Ltd (Australia): its site startraderprime.com.au refused every request on 19 Nov 2026 and nothing from its documents is used.
Summary STARTRADER publishes client agreements for companies in three jurisdictions and names a fourth, Australian, company for Australian residents, documents an automated copy product (STAR Copy) with sizing modes, pause and stop controls and a profit-share fee, pays partners both volume rebates and a per-client CPA, and its Seychelles client agreement makes the firm the counterparty with third-party execution arrangements but no commitment to pass orders on; no average EUR/USD spread is published for any account, so the cost grade stays open.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: STARTRADER brand, group level: STARTRADER Limited (Seychelles), STARTRADER Financial Markets Limited (Mauritius), STARTRADER LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), STARTRADER Prime Global Pty Ltd (Australia), STARTRADER International Pty Ltd (South Africa), UAE, Cyprus and UK companiesInvestigated, not settled
Three companies publish their own client agreements on the brand's legal page: STARTRADER Limited (Seychelles), STARTRADER Financial Markets Limited (Mauritius) and STARTRADER LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines). The brand also says Australian residents are served through a separate website operated by STARTRADER Prime Global Pty Ltd, an Australian licence holder, and the LLC agreement names Australia as a jurisdiction with its own regulated company. That is at least four operating jurisdictions, which gives 2 at best. A fifth cannot be excluded: a South African company is named with a licence only, and the documents disagree about the United Kingdom and Cyprus. The brand publishes no closed list of operating companies, so the count is a lower bound and the grade is 0–2.
Missing A closed list from the group of the companies that open client accounts or execute orders, and in particular whether STARTRADER International Pty Ltd (South Africa) or any United Kingdom or Cyprus company does so today.
Count lower bound 4
13 addresses tried
- Published costs 10TAssigned tariff grade 10; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–10.Tariff basis: Prime ECN: published account tariff; USD 4 tariff floor: USD 4 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Prime ECN; STARTRADER brand, startrader.com (pricing pages name no company; the site assigns the contracting company by location), Prime ECN account on MT4 or MT5, EUR/USD, USD accountPublished tariff assessment (Prime ECN); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 10/10 for the named Prime ECN account: USD 4 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 4 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Prime ECN requires USD 10,000 balance and no open positions to upgrade by email request. Keeping it requires 5 closed trades and USD 500,000 notional in a 30-day period within 90 days.
Missing A broker-published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for the Prime ECN, ECN or Standard account, with its observation period, and the ECN account's commission.
Round turn commission USD 4Spread basis advertised minimum for the account; no average or typical figure and no observation period publishedPricing condition USD 10k + activity rules
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: STAR Copy, the brand's own copy-trading product in its app and client portal; terms issued by STARTRADER LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines); product page and help-centre articles are brand-level and name no companyEstablished from documents
STAR Copy is the broker's own product, with terms issued by STARTRADER LLC: once a copier chooses a signal provider, that provider's trades are mirrored in the copier's account automatically. The help centre documents three sizing rules (equivalent used margin, fixed lot, fixed multiplier), follower controls (pause, which keeps positions; stop, which closes them) and the fees (no platform fee; a profit share of 0–50% above a high-water mark set by the provider). All four elements of the anchor are documented, which gives 10. This grades documentation of the product, not results.
3 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: STARTRADER Limited, Seychelles, margin FX and CFDs, all clients, client agreement version 10.26 governed by the law of Seychelles; the same clauses read separately in the agreements of STARTRADER LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) and STARTRADER Financial Markets Limited (Mauritius)Established from documents
The client agreement of STARTRADER Limited (Seychelles) makes every order a contract between the client and the company, accepted at the company's discretion. It says the company has arrangements with unnamed third-party execution providers for the facilitation of transactions, and that the client has no claim over the company's contracts 'if any' with other persons. So outside arrangements exist, but nothing commits the company to pass on each order and 'if any' leaves that to the company: a discretionary policy, which is 4. The help centre's 'STP-ECN, no dealing desk, all orders routed directly to the market' wording is not in the agreement and does not raise the grade. The agreements of STARTRADER LLC and the Mauritius company carry the same two clauses.
5 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: STARTRADER brand partner programmes ('STAR Partners') on startrader.com and the help centre; pages name no contracting company; applications from Australian residents are not accepted on this siteEstablished from documents
The brand documents both kinds of partner payment. Introducing Brokers receive rebates tied to the trading of the clients they refer. Affiliates receive a fixed CPA per qualified referred client, with a published table (USD 100 to 650 by country tier, plus monthly bonuses), and a Hybrid programme combines the two. IB or revenue-share together with CPA is exact 4.
3 addresses tried
-
10overallequal
Trade Nation
Profile Best Costs, Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0
Availability not confirmedAustralian company on file
4.2/10no penalties
Breakdown for Trade Nation
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs10TTN Trader (daytime): published account tariff. USD 5: USD 0 round-turn commission + 0.5 pips published fixed spread. Tariff grade 10/10 for the named TN Trader (daytime) account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published fixed spread 0.5 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 5 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The 0.5-pip fixed band applies 07:00–21:59 GMT+1; the other published bands are 0.6 pip and 5 pips. It is a daytime tariff, not an all-hours average. USD base-account availability was not established; the spread is expressed in the common USD-per-pip benchmark. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and abook rest on Trade Nation Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 158 065 635, AFSL 422661, Australia): costs on its TN Trader / TradingView account, copy on its MT4 account with the TradeCopier app, abook on its Product Disclosure Statement. Structure covers the six Trade Nation companies named on the site; affiliate rests on the brand's global partner pages (site footer led by Trade Nation Financial Markets Ltd, Seychelles) plus the Australian Financial Services Guide.
Summary Trade Nation Australia documents a fixed EUR/USD spread with no commission (0.5 pip in the main session, wider overnight) and a fully described copy app, while it hedges at its own discretion, the brand contracts through six jurisdictions and its partner programme includes CPA. The cost grade depends on which hours are counted.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Trade Nation brand: Trade Nation Australia Pty Ltd, Trade Nation Financial UK Ltd, Trade Nation Europe Empresa de Investimento S.A., Trade Nation Ltd, Trade Nation Financial Markets Ltd, Trade Nation Financial (Pty) LtdEstablished from documents
The site names six Trade Nation companies in six jurisdictions (Australia, United Kingdom, Portugal, Bahamas, Seychelles, South Africa), and each has its own legal hub section with a Client Agreement in that company's name, so each contracts clients. Five or more is grade 0 even as a lower bound. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference and is not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 6
1 address tried
- Published costs 10TAssigned tariff grade 10; average all-in cost evidence remains 6–10.Tariff basis: TN Trader (daytime): published account tariff; USD 5: USD 0 round-turn commission + 0.5 pips published fixed spread.Scope: TN Trader (daytime); Trade Nation Australia Pty Ltd, TN Trader account (same schedule on TradingView), EUR/USD CFD, retail, Australia, main session 07:00–21:59 as stated on the pagePublished tariff assessment (TN Trader (daytime)); fixed published spread
Tariff grade 10/10 for the named TN Trader (daytime) account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published fixed spread 0.5 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 5 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The 0.5-pip fixed band applies 07:00–21:59 GMT+1; the other published bands are 0.6 pip and 5 pips. It is a daytime tariff, not an all-hours average. USD base-account availability was not established; the spread is expressed in the common USD-per-pip benchmark. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing How a time-banded fixed spread is to be graded (the published schedule has no all-hours average of its own); whether the Australian entity offers a USD account; and which FX CFDs carry the commission reserved in PDS s. 13.4.
Account TN Trader account (fixed spreads; TradingView sheet identical), Trade Nation Australia Pty LtdSpread basis published fixed spread, not an averageRound turn commission USD 0Pricing condition 07:00–21:59 GMT+1
5 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Trade Nation Australia Pty Ltd, TradeCopier app linked to an MT4 account (variable spreads, not the TN Trader account used for costs), AustraliaEstablished from documents
The Australian site documents TradeCopier as Trade Nation's own app that automatically copies chosen signal accounts onto a client's Trade Nation MT4 account. Its FAQ documents the sizing rules (proportional by equity, mirror master size, fixed size), follower controls (stop copying, soft-stop and hard-stop max drawdown) and fees (performance fee up to 50% on a high watermark, charged to the copier's account). All four elements are documented, which is the anchor for 10. This is a documentation grade, not a view on results or fills.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Trade Nation Australia Pty Ltd, CFDs and margin FX on TN Trader and MT4, AustraliaEstablished from documents
The Australian PDS says the firm uses the market maker model, offers no direct market access, is counterparty to every trade, nets opposing client positions and hedges the remainder with external counterparties once its risk limits are reached; it also says it may or may not hedge a given customer trade. The Client Agreement says it takes the opposite side of client trades and may hedge. That is hedging at the firm's discretion, the anchor for 4; it does not show how much is actually kept in house.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Trade Nation Partners programme, global site (footer led by Trade Nation Financial Markets Ltd, Seychelles); referrer payments of Trade Nation Australia Pty Ltd per its FSGEstablished from documents
The brand's partner FAQ lists spread share, revenue share and cost per acquisition (CPA) as commission options, and the partners page offers an Introducing Broker route and an affiliate route with CPA or hybrid models. The Australian Financial Services Guide separately discloses volume-based payments to introducing brokers. Both revenue-share and CPA are documented, which is the anchor for 4.
-
11overallequal
Tradeview Markets
Assessment summary Best Costs, Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0
Availability not confirmed
4.2/101 penalty
Breakdown for Tradeview Markets
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs10TEDGE: published account tariff. USD 4 tariff floor: USD 4 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 10/10 for the named EDGE account: USD 4 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 4 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing a statement that CPA or a per-client payment is, or is not, paid.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not an account offer for any country. Costs, copy and abook rest on Tradeview Ltd (Cayman Islands, CIMA licence 585163), which operates tradeviewmarkets.com, its help centre and partner page and issues the English client agreement. That agreement lets Tradeview open the account at 'an appropriate Tradeview entity' of its choosing, and the help centre pages do not name the contracting company, so the product criteria describe the Tradeview Markets offer as published on Tradeview Ltd's site. Structure counts the whole brand: Tradeview Ltd (Cayman), Tradeview Europe Ltd (Malta), TVM Global Ltd (Labuan), Tradeview Financial Markets S.A.C. (Peru) and iLC Brokers Ltd (Mauritius). No fact of Tradeview Europe, TVM Global, the Peru company or iLC Brokers is used for costs, copy, abook or affiliate.
Summary Tradeview Markets documents its own automated copy service (CommuniTraders) with sizing, pause and drawdown controls and a performance fee, its Cayman client agreement leaves execution as counterparty or through other counterparties to the firm's discretion, and the brand runs through at least five operating jurisdictions; costs remain open because only minimum EUR/USD spreads are published, and the affiliate grade stays a range because an IB rebate programme is documented while CPA was not found.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Tradeview brand, all companies listed on tradeviewmarkets.com/en/company/regulation/Established from documents
The brand's regulation page names companies 'independently trading under the Tradeview brand', and five of them have an operating role in documents: Tradeview Ltd (Cayman, client agreement), Tradeview Europe Ltd (Malta, retail CFD accounts), TVM Global Ltd (Labuan, own client agreement as counterparty), Tradeview Financial Markets S.A.C. (Peru, publishes the Spanish site and states it provides OTC derivative services) and iLC Brokers Ltd (Mauritius, investment dealer with live-account registration). Five or more operating jurisdictions is 0 even as a lower bound, so no closed list is needed.
Count lower bound 5
2 addresses tried
- Published costs 10TAssigned tariff grade 10; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–10.Tariff basis: EDGE: published account tariff; USD 4 tariff floor: USD 4 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: EDGE; Tradeview Ltd (tradeviewmarkets.com), EDGE, ILC and XLev accounts, EUR/USD, USD basePublished tariff assessment (EDGE); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 10/10 for the named EDGE account: USD 4 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 4 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A EUR/USD average or typical spread that Tradeview Ltd ties to a named ordinary retail account (EDGE, ILC or XLev).
Account EDGE, MetaTrader 4/5, USD base (cheapest commission among ordinary accounts; no minimum deposit published)Round turn commission USD 4
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Tradeview Markets CommuniTraders, MT4/MT5 accounts, presented on Tradeview Ltd's site and help centreEstablished from documents
CommuniTraders is Tradeview's own copy-trading platform for MT4/MT5 accounts: a provider's trades are copied automatically into follower accounts. The help centre documents the sizing rule (Fixed Lots or Proportional with a risk ratio and lot limits), follower controls (pause via Copy status, Unfollow, drawdown protection) and fees (provider performance fee of 0 to 50 % of follower profits, settled monthly). All four elements are documented, which is the top anchor. MultiMAM is a managed account and is not counted.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Tradeview Ltd, Cayman Islands, client agreement (July 2024 edition, current server copy), all OTC accounts incl. EDGEEstablished from documents
Tradeview Ltd's client agreement lets Tradeview execute every order as counterparty itself or as a broker with other counterparties it chooses, and says OTC contracts are entered into as principal. That is internal-or-external discretion in the contract, which is the anchor for 4. The help centre's description of EDGE orders filled against several liquidity providers is not a contractual commitment and does not name the providers or say whether they are outside the group, so it does not raise the grade.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Tradeview brand IB programme (tradeviewpartners.com, tradeviewmarkets.com/en/partners/, help centre)Investigated, not settled
Tradeview runs an Introducing Broker programme (Tradeview Partners) that pays rebates per lot or per million USD traded, revenue splits or mark-ups; Tradeview Ltd's partner page describes rebate and commission structures. No CPA or per-funded-client payment appears on any partner page read, but nothing says CPA is not offered, so the range is 4–10.
Missing A statement that CPA or a per-client payment is, or is not, paid.
2 addresses tried
-
12overallequal
ACY Securities
Assessment summary Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
3.9/101 penalty
Breakdown for ACY Securities
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing whether ACY Securities SA Pty Ltd takes on clients or runs a brokerage under the brand, and whether any group document gives a closed list of operating companies.
- Published costs8TProZero: published account tariff. USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named ProZero account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The account comparison gives USD 6 round turn while one body-text block gives USD 7; both tariff figures fall in grade 8. The table value is shown, and the conflict remains in the underlying evidence. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across ACY Securities' global site (acy.com), not a single account offer. Costs, copy and execution rest on ACY Capital LLC (St Vincent and the Grenadines, company no. 2610 LLC 2022), the company the site says non-Australian clients may be onboarded with. It was chosen because the Tradingcup copy service is stated to be unavailable to Australian retail clients, so only this company has all three product criteria documented. The earlier row named ACY Securities Australia (ACY Securities Pty Ltd, AFSL 403863): its documents were read and its figures are kept apart in facts; nothing is carried between the two companies or to ACY Securities SA Pty Ltd (South Africa). The partner programme pages name both ACY Securities Pty Ltd and ACY Capital LLC. The site was read from a connection outside Europe and Australia; acy.com served its /en pages without redirect, and each page's data holds an Australian set and an international set of values.
Summary ACY Capital LLC's client agreement describes the firm as a market maker that may hedge with unnamed counterparties; the brand documents automated copying through Tradingcup with sizing, pause and stop controls and fees (not for Australian retail clients), advertises both CPA and revenue-share partner payments, names client-contracting companies in at least two jurisdictions with a South African company's role open, and publishes a USD 6 round-turn ProZero commission but no account-labelled average EUR/USD spread.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: ACY Securities brand: ACY Securities Pty Ltd (Australia), ACY Capital LLC (St Vincent and the Grenadines); ACY Securities SA Pty Ltd (South Africa) named, role openInvestigated, not settled
ACY's own site says Australian residents are onboarded with ACY Securities Pty Ltd and non-Australians may be onboarded with ACY Capital LLC of St Vincent and the Grenadines, and its legal page publishes client documents for exactly these two companies. That is two client-contracting jurisdictions. The site also lists ACY Securities SA Pty Ltd in South Africa with an FSCA number but states no client or brokerage role for it, and the group site quotes a second ASIC licence number without naming its holder, so the count is a lower bound and a licence alone does not raise it. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Missing Whether ACY Securities SA Pty Ltd takes on clients or runs a brokerage under the brand, and whether any group document gives a closed list of operating companies.
Count lower bound 2
5 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: ProZero: published account tariff; USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: ProZero; ACY Capital LLC (St Vincent and the Grenadines), ProZero account on MT4/MT5, EUR/USD, USD account; figures read from the international set of the acy.com account tablePublished tariff assessment (ProZero); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named ProZero account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The account comparison gives USD 6 round turn while one body-text block gives USD 7; both tariff figures fall in grade 8. The table value is shown, and the conflict remains in the underlying evidence. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread that the page ties to the ProZero account of ACY Capital LLC.
Account ProZero (MT4/MT5), international set, ACY Capital LLCRound turn commission USD 6
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Tradingcup copy trading of ACY Securities, MT4/MT5 accounts; clients of ACY Capital LLC (St Vincent and the Grenadines); stated as not available to Australian retail clientsEstablished from documents
ACY Securities runs its own copy platform, Tradingcup, for MT4 and MT5 accounts. Its terms call it an automated execution service, and its FAQ documents two sizing rules (Smart Scaling by balance ratio and Exact Copy), follower controls to pause, to stop and to set an account-level stop loss, and the subscription and performance fees set by the signal provider. The platform states that copy trading is not available to Australian retail clients, so the grade is scoped to clients of ACY Capital LLC. This grades documented features, not results.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: ACY Capital LLC (St Vincent and the Grenadines, company no. 2610 LLC 2022), contracts for difference, all accountsEstablished from documents
ACY Capital LLC's client agreement says the company contracts as principal, acts as a market maker and may enter into an agreement with hedging counterparties after a client trade. Its key information statement adds that hedging counterparties are nominated case by case and are not named. Hedging is thus left to the firm and is not a commitment for each trade; the 'STP mode' wording on the partners site is marketing. No internalisation finding is made, and acting as principal is not treated as evidence of one.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: ACY Partners programme (www.acypartners.com), brand level; footer names ACY Securities Pty Ltd and ACY Capital LLCEstablished from documents
The ACY Partners site documents both models. Its home page headlines a CPA payment of up to USD 2,000 for affiliates, and its Introducing Broker page offers a revenue share of over 50% through commission and spread rebates on referred clients' trading. Both being documented gives 4. The pages name both ACY companies in the footer and do not tie a programme to one of them.
1 address tried
-
13overallequal
GO Markets
Profile Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0
Availability not confirmedAustralian company on file
3.9/10no penalties
Breakdown for GO Markets
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs8USD 6 round trip
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope GO Markets Pty Ltd (MU) (Mauritius, FSC licence GB19024896, site gomarkets.com/en) for costs, copy trading and execution. Partner programmes are brand-level: the CPA page is on the Mauritius site, the IB page was read on the Australian site. GO Markets Pty Ltd (Australia, AFSL 254963) was cross-checked separately: same published EUR/USD figures and the same hedging discretion, but it lists cTrader Copy only.
Summary The Mauritius company documents a low published EUR/USD cost on GO Plus+ and a fully described MetaTrader copy product, but the brand contracts through at least five jurisdictions, hedges at its own discretion and runs a CPA programme beside its IB programme.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: GO Markets brand, all regional sites on gomarkets.comEstablished from documents
Five regional sites each publish their own client terms under a different company: GO Markets Pty Ltd (Australia), GO Markets Ltd (Cyprus), GO Markets Pty Ltd (MU) (Mauritius), GO Markets International Ltd (Seychelles) and GO Markets LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines). The group's own description names only the three regulated entities in Australia, Cyprus and Mauritius, so it is not a closed list and five is a lower bound. Five or more client-contracting jurisdictions is grade 0; this reflects the owner's simplicity preference and is not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 5
1 address tried
- Published costs 8Grade 8: USD over 5 to 7Scope: GO Markets Pty Ltd (MU), Mauritius, GO Plus+ account, EUR/USD, USD accountEstablished from documents
GO Markets Pty Ltd (MU) publishes an average EUR/USD spread of 0.1 pips on GO Plus+ and a commission of US$2.50 per side for USD accounts, giving USD 6 per standard lot round trip. The commission-free Standard account averages 0.9 pips (USD 9), so GO Plus+ is the cheaper ordinary retail account; no per-platform commission difference is published, and the Australian cTrader page states the same US$2.50. The averages are one month of data from February 2026, stated as indicative and about nine months old.
Account GO Plus+ (GO Markets Pty Ltd (MU); one commission published for the account, no per-platform variant)Average spread pips 0.1Round turn commission USD 5Indicative cost USD 6Spread basis published average, one month of data (1-28 February 2026), stated as indicative
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: GO Markets Pty Ltd (MU), Mauritius, MetaTrader Copy Trading (MT4/MT5)Established from documents
GO Markets Pty Ltd (MU) documents MetaTrader Copy Trading with all four elements: copied trades open and close automatically, positions are sized pro rata to equity, the follower can stop copying at any time and close copied trades manually, and fees are described (no extra platform fee on the product page, provider-set performance and management fees; the terms also allow platform, deposit and withdrawal fees under a website fee schedule). Fee amounts are set per provider and no schedule with figures was found. This is documented for the Mauritius company only: the Australian company lists cTrader Copy with automation and an equity-to-equity model but states no fees or stop control on its page.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: GO Markets Pty Ltd (MU), Mauritius, Margin FX and CFDsEstablished from documents
The Mauritius Disclosure Statement says GO Markets is product issuer and principal, that it is at the firm's discretion whether it places an offsetting order to hedge a client position, and that it hedges some transactions while keeping some risk as open positions. Its Execution Policy describes liquidity access through the group's counterparties without committing to route each order externally. Discretionary hedging in policy is grade 4; it does not show how much is actually internalised. The Australian company's PDS and hedging policy say the same for that entity.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: GO Markets brand partner programmes (CPA page: Mauritius site; IB page: Australian site)Established from documents
The brand documents both models. The affiliate programme on the Mauritius site pays CPA per qualified client, up to US$500 by country tier plus monthly volume bonuses. The Introducing Broker programme pays volume-based rebates of 0.2 to 0.5 pips or 20% to 50% of commission, up to US$5 per lot. Both documented is grade 4, which confirms the existing row; the Australian site's menu lists the IB programme without the CPA affiliate page.
-
14overallequal
3.9/10no penalties
Breakdown for Pepperstone
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs8USD 7 round trip
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across two companies, not a single account offer. Costs: Razor on cTrader, published identically by Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas) and Pepperstone Limited (UK). Copy trading: documented for Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas) only; no UK copy-trading documents were found. A-book: the UK and Bahamas execution policies. Structure and partner programmes are brand level. Nothing here describes a UK or Swiss account.
Summary Razor on cTrader publishes a USD 7 EUR/USD round trip and the Bahamas entity documents automated copy trading with sizing, stop controls and fees, while the group runs at least five operating jurisdictions and pays CPA as well as revenue share.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Pepperstone brand, all regionsEstablished from documents
Current regional pages each name a different company that provides client accounts: Pepperstone Group Limited (Australia), Pepperstone Limited (UK), Pepperstone EU Limited (Cyprus), Pepperstone GmbH (Germany) and Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas). That is five operating jurisdictions as a lower bound, which is exact 0. A DIFC company and a Kenyan company are also named but were not needed for the count; the UAE onshore company only introduces clients and is not counted.
Count lower bound 5
2 addresses tried
- Published costs 8Grade 8: USD over 5 to 7Scope: Razor CFD account on cTrader, USD account; Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas) and Pepperstone Limited (UK)Established from documents
The Razor account publishes a EUR/USD average spread of 0.1 pip (August 2026, all sessions) and, on cTrader, a commission of USD 6 per standard lot round trip. Both figures are published identically for Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas) and Pepperstone Limited (UK). The result is USD 7.00, the top edge of the >5-7 band; Razor on MT4/MT5 in USD would be USD 8 (grade 6) and Standard USD 11 (grade 4).
Account Razor (cTrader)Average spread pips 0.1Round turn commission USD 6Indicative cost USD 7
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas); CopyTrading by Pepperstone on MT4/MT5 (cTrader Copy also offered)Established from documents
Pepperstone Markets Limited documents CopyTrading by Pepperstone for MT4/MT5 as its own offer: trades are copied automatically, the follower chooses proportional-by-equity, mirror or fixed sizing, can stop copying at any time and set a drawdown stop, and pays a performance fee of up to 50% above a high watermark. Its Copy Trading Terms confirm automated execution and fee deduction. This is documented for the Bahamas company only; the UK site has no copy trading page or terms.
1 address tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Pepperstone Limited (UK) and Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas); CFD ordersEstablished from documents
The execution policies of Pepperstone Limited (UK) and Pepperstone Markets Limited (Bahamas) use the same wording: the firm is principal and the only execution venue, the group offsets client risk internally in a central risk book within limits, and hedges with external venues when it cannot. That is internal-or-external discretion in policy, not a blanket or per-fill external commitment.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Pepperstone brand, global partner site; availability varies by jurisdictionEstablished from documents
The partner site documents an Introducing Broker programme paying a share of revenue and an Affiliate programme paying a fixed CPA of USD 300 to 800 per referral, plus a hybrid of both. Both models documented gives 4. The site notes that some programmes are not available in the EEA, UK or Australia.
-
15overallequal
TMGM
Profile Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedAustralian company on file
3.9/101 penalty
Breakdown for TMGM
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing whether Trademax Global Markets (KE) Pty Ltd is a current operating company of the brand, which would make five jurisdictions and an exact 0, and whether any group document gives a closed list of operating companies.
- Published costs8TEDGE: published account tariff. USD 7 tariff floor: USD 7 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named EDGE account: USD 7 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 7 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across TMGM's global site, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and execution were read on www.tmgm.com/en, whose legal page publishes client documents for Trademax Global Limited (Vanuatu, VFSC 40356) only and whose product schedule is headed VFSC; the execution documents are that company's. The account page and the copy-trading manual name no single legal entity. Trademax Australia Limited (ASIC), which the earlier row assessed, could not be read on 19 Nov 2026 (its /en-au addresses redirect to the home page and www.tmgm.com.au refused the request); nothing is carried to or from it, Trademax Global Markets (SE) Limited (Seychelles) or Trademax Global Markets (International) Pty Ltd (Mauritius).
Summary Trademax Global Limited's hedging policy says it does not hedge all client trades and names a group company as its only hedging counterparty; the brand documents an automated copy service with sizing, follower stops and fees, pays both CPA and per-lot IB commissions, names companies in at least four jurisdictions, and publishes a USD 7 Edge commission but no average spread.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: TMGM brand: Trademax Australia Limited (Australia), Trademax Global Limited (Vanuatu), Trademax Global Markets (SE) Limited (Seychelles), Trademax Global Markets (International) Pty Ltd (Mauritius)Investigated, not settled
TMGM's own site names four companies trading as TMGM, each under its own regulator: Australia, Vanuatu, Seychelles and Mauritius. That is one more than the earlier row counted and still gives 0–2. The list is not worded as a closed list of group companies, and the site's language file holds an undisplayed footer text for a fifth company in Kenya, so the count stays a lower bound. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Missing Whether Trademax Global Markets (KE) Pty Ltd is a current operating company of the brand, which would make five jurisdictions and an exact 0, and whether any group document gives a closed list of operating companies.
Count lower bound 4
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: EDGE: published account tariff; USD 7 tariff floor: USD 7 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: EDGE; TMGM global site (www.tmgm.com/en), EDGE account on MT4/MT5, EUR/USD, USD; the account page names no single legal entity, and the site's product schedule and legal documents are those of Trademax Global Limited (Vanuatu)Published tariff assessment (EDGE); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named EDGE account: USD 7 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 7 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread that the page ties to the EDGE account.
Account EDGE (MT4/MT5)Round turn commission USD 7
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: TMGM Copy Trading on the global site (www.tmgm.com/en), MT4/MT5 accounts via the TMGM client portal and app; legal entity not named in the product documentsEstablished from documents
TMGM offers its own 'TMGM Copy Trading' through the client portal for MT4 and MT5 accounts. Its user manual documents automatic copying of a provider's trades, three sizing rules, follower controls to suspend or unsubscribe with automatic profit and loss thresholds, and the registration, management and performance fees with their maximums. The manual names no legal entity; it is linked from the global site, whose legal documents are those of Trademax Global Limited. This grades documented features, not results.
1 address tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Trademax Global Limited (Vanuatu, VFSC 40356), margin FX and CFDs, all accounts on MT4/MT5Established from documents
Trademax Global Limited's hedging counterparty policy says the company does not hedge all client transactions and carries a residual unhedged position within its own limits, hedging when exposure exceeds them. Its only named hedging counterparty is Trademax Australia Limited, a company of the same group. The client agreement makes the company principal to every trade, and the best execution policy's no-dealing-desk and ECN wording is not a routing commitment. No internalisation finding is made.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: TMGM Partners programme (www.tmgmpartners.com), brand level; the pages name no legal entity or countryEstablished from documents
The TMGM Partners site documents both models: a CPA affiliate programme paying a one-time commission of up to USD 600 per qualified referred client, and an introducing broker programme paying up to USD 10 per lot on referred clients' trading volume. The earlier row had only the revenue-share side, so its 4–10 range is now an exact 4. The address the earlier row cited now redirects to the home page.
1 address tried
-
16overallequal
3.9/102 penalties
Breakdown for VT Markets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–7 · missing a group-level closed list of operating companies consistent with the client agreement's reference to separate regulated companies in other jurisdictions.
- Published costs8TRaw ECN: published account tariff. USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Raw ECN account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the identity of the related liquidity provider, the share of orders it receives and whether it passes them on outside the VT Markets group.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope VT Markets Limited (Mauritius, FSC licence GB23202269, company no. 201902 GBC) for costs, copy and abook: the client agreement, execution policy, key facts summary and copy-trading terms are all this company's, and the en-asia account and copy pages name it as the product supplier. Brand-level feature review, not an account offer for any country; structure and affiliate are brand-level.
Summary VT Markets serves clients through VT Markets Limited in Mauritius; its copy trading is documented in full and both IB and CPA partner programmes are named, while costs (only minimum spreads published), execution (all orders go to liquidity providers, one of them related) and the number of operating jurisdictions are not settled by the documents and stay ranges.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–7. Not a finding.Scope: VT Markets brand, all regional sites read from a non-European connectionInvestigated, not settled
The brand's entity list names four companies, but only VT Markets Limited in Mauritius deals with clients as product supplier; the South African company acts solely as an intermediary for it, the Dubai branch only introduces and promotes, and the Cyprus company provides payment services. The Mauritius client agreement, however, refers to other jurisdictions where VT Markets operates a separate regulated company, which the footer list does not show, so the list is not a confirmed closed list. One operating jurisdiction is a lower bound, which gives 0 to the one-jurisdiction grade (7 for Mauritius). This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not safety.
Missing A group-level closed list of operating companies consistent with the client agreement's reference to separate regulated companies in other jurisdictions.
Count lower bound 1
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: Raw ECN: published account tariff; USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Raw ECN; VT Markets Limited (Mauritius), Raw ECN account, MT4/MT5, USD base, global sitePublished tariff assessment (Raw ECN); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Raw ECN account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing An average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for the Raw ECN account, with its observation period.
Account Raw ECN (MT4, MT5), VT Markets LimitedRound turn commission USD 6Spread basis advertised minimum only ('Spread from 0.0 pips'; 'spreads start from 0.0 pips on major currency pairs')
4 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: VT Markets Limited (Mauritius), copy trading in the VT Markets app, global siteEstablished from documents
VT Markets Limited runs its own copy-trading platform in the VT Markets app: its copy-trading terms say selected providers' trades are replicated automatically in the copier's account without further confirmation. The sizing rule is a copier-chosen Used Margin Multiple of 0.1 to 50 times the strategy's default margin, copiers can pause or unfollow a provider and close copied positions, and fees are a provider-set profit share of 0 to 50% on gains above a high-water mark. Automation, sizing, controls and fees are all documented, which gives 10.
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: VT Markets Limited (Mauritius), all client orders, MT4/MT5Investigated, not settled
VT Markets Limited's Best Execution Policy, which forms part of its client agreement, says the firm has appointed liquidity providers to whom all orders will be transmitted for execution by straight-through processing; that is a blanket external-route statement with no per-fill condition. The same policy says one of those liquidity providers has common shareholdings with VT Markets, without naming it, saying what share of orders it receives or whether it passes them outside the group, and the Key Facts Summary says the firm acts as a market maker mainly in case of system failure. A route to a related company alone is 4, so the grade is 4 to 6 until that provider's role is known.
Missing The identity of the related liquidity provider, the share of orders it receives and whether it passes them on outside the VT Markets group.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: VT Markets brand partner programmes, global siteEstablished from documents
The brand documents an Introducing Broker programme that pays ongoing commissions on the trading activity of referred clients. Its partnership menu also lists a 'CPA Affiliates' programme, and the Pro ECN page treats clients under CPA affiliates, Hybrid partners and IBs as separate categories, so a CPA channel exists alongside IB. Both documented gives 4; the CPA programme page itself refused retrieval, so its payout trigger and amounts were not read.
2 addresses tried
-
17overallequal
3.7/102 penalties
Breakdown for Axiory
- Company structure4Two
- Published costs6USD 8.70 round trip
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the identity of the liquidity provider or venue to which Axiory Global Limited sends client orders, whether it is independent of the Axiory and related companies, and whether every client order is passed on.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Axiory Global Limited (Belize, Belize FSC licence no. 4496214), the company that owns and operates www.axiory.com. Costs, copy and execution all rest on this company's website and its Terms on Investment Services (last updated 25 September 2026). Brand-level feature review with a scope on every factor, not an account offer for any country. Tradit Limited (Mauritius, FSC Mauritius licence GB21026376) is the second operating company; its terms and site were read for structure only and nothing is carried between the two companies. The partner agreement is made jointly by both companies.
Summary Axiory Global Limited (Belize) publishes labelled average spreads that put EUR/USD at about USD 8.70 on its Zero account, names two operating companies in a closed list and pays partners both per-lot rebates and CPA. Its orders go "to the open market" with no provider named, and the only copy feature described is MetaTrader Signals, which Axiory says is not associated with it.
- Company structure 4Grade 4: twoScope: Axiory brand, group levelEstablished from documents
The footer on every page of the brand's site says Axiory operates through two authorised entities and lists them: Axiory Global Limited in Belize and Tradit Limited in Mauritius. The legal hub publishes client documents for exactly these two companies, each issues its own client terms, Tradit runs its own client site, the licence page names the same two, and the partner agreement is made by the two together. Two Cyprus companies named in the footer have another stated role (card processing and its co-owner), and an English company named in a legacy statistics frame is described as the website owner; none is among the entities through which the brand operates, so the count is two operating jurisdictions.
Count lower bound 2
3 addresses tried
- Published costs 6Grade 6: USD over 7 to 10Scope: Axiory Global Limited (operator of www.axiory.com), Zero account on MT4, MT5 or cTrader, EUR/USD, USD account; brand-level price list, not an offer for a countryEstablished from documents
The account comparison table gives an average EUR/USD spread for each account column; for the Zero account it is 0.0, and the Zero commission schedule sets EUR/USD at USD 8.70 per lot, which the Zero page says is a round-trip fee. That is USD 8.70 for one lot, the cheapest of the four trading accounts (USD 10 minimum deposit, open to any client). The Zero page describes zero spreads as an aim for over 90% of the day, so the 0.0 may understate the true mean; the Nano account, whose 0.3 pip average is labelled in two tables, comes to USD 9 and the same grade. Standard (USD 13) and Max (USD 20) are dearer.
Account Zero (MT4, MT5 or cTrader; the commission schedule gives one EUR/USD figure for all platforms)Average spread pips 0Round turn commission USD 8.7Indicative cost USD 8.7
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Axiory Global Limited (operator of www.axiory.com), live MT4 and MT5 accounts, desktop terminals; MetaTrader Trading Signals operated by MetaQuotesInvestigated, not settled
Axiory's site has a page and FAQ about MetaTrader Signals that describe automatic copying, proportional sizing, unsubscribing and subscription fees. Axiory also states that Signals is not associated with Axiory. A third-party feature of the platform counts for this criterion only where the broker documents it as its own offer, and here the broker disclaims it. No Axiory copy product of its own was found, and nothing says copy trading is not offered, so the grade is open.
Missing An Axiory-documented copy service of its own (terms or product page naming Axiory as the provider), or a statement that copy trading is not offered.
3 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: Axiory Global Limited, Belize, all trading accounts under its Terms on Investment Services of 25 September 2026Investigated, not settled
Axiory Global Limited's client terms say, for all accounts, that orders are sent to the open market and filled at the best available price, and they refer to covering transactions with a liquidity provider; that is a contractual statement of external transmission rather than marketing. But 'open market' is undefined, no liquidity provider or venue is named, the terms do not state the firm's capacity or commit to hedge each order, and the firm keeps sole discretion to refuse to transmit. Whether the route ends outside the Axiory companies is therefore not documented, which leaves the grade between 4 and 6.
Missing The identity of the liquidity provider or venue to which Axiory Global Limited sends client orders, whether it is independent of the Axiory and related companies, and whether every client order is passed on.
6 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Axiory Partner Programme, Axiory Global Limited and Tradit Limited jointlyEstablished from documents
The partner agreement of October 2026, made by Axiory Global Limited and Tradit Limited together, sets out both mechanisms in one schedule: a lot rebate paid per closed lot traded by referred clients, with a 10% share of sub-partners' commissions, and a CPA commission of up to USD 1,000 per referred client. Both IB-style volume pay and CPA are documented.
-
18overallequal
3.6/101 penalty
Breakdown for AMarkets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–7 · missing a group statement that enumerates all AMarkets operating companies (for example 'the group consists of ...', audited accounts or a subsidiary list), and any current document showing whether AMarkets LTD (Mwali) or AMarkets LTD (Saint Vincent) contracts with, executes for or clears for clients.
- Published costs6USD 8 round trip
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope AMarkets · AMarkets LLC, Cook Islands (registration LLC14486/2023): the company named in the customer agreement, the MetaTrader 4 and 5 trading regulations, the copy trading regulations and both partner agreements, so costs, copy, abook and affiliate all rest on it. Brand-level feature review with a scope on every factor, not an account offer; the brand's restriction list excludes EU/EEA countries, Switzerland, the UK and the US.
Summary Documented at AMarkets LLC (Cook Islands): an own copy trading service with a sizing rule, a loss limit and a profit fee, an indicative USD 8 EUR/USD round trip on the ECN account, hedging left to the firm's discretion, and both a revenue-share and a CPA partner programme; the number of operating jurisdictions is not settled (one found, two more companies listed without a stated function).
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–7. Not a finding.Scope: AMarkets brand as a whole: AMarkets LLC (Cook Islands), AMarkets LTD (Mwali), AMarkets LTD (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines)Investigated, not settled
Every client, payment, AML, privacy, risk and dispute document re-read names one contracting company, AMarkets LLC (Cook Islands), and the customer agreement says the same on the global site, eleven more regional subdomains and the Russian-language site. The group's regulation page, repeated in every footer, still names AMarkets LTD (Mwali, licensed as a brokerage and clearing company) and AMarkets LTD (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) with no stated role and no statement that the group consists only of these three. One operating jurisdiction found and no closed list keeps the range at 0 up to the one-jurisdiction grade.
Missing A group statement that enumerates all AMarkets operating companies (for example 'the group consists of ...', audited accounts or a subsidiary list), and any current document showing whether AMarkets LTD (Mwali) or AMarkets LTD (Saint Vincent) contracts with, executes for or clears for clients.
Count lower bound 1
21 addresses tried
- Published costs 6Grade 6: USD over 7 to 10Scope: AMarkets LLC (Cook Islands), ECN account, MetaTrader 4 or MetaTrader 5, EUR/USD, USD accountEstablished from documents
The EURUSD specification page gives figures per platform and account type. On the ECN account, on both MetaTrader 4 and 5, it states an average spread of 0.3 and a commission of 5 USD, which matches the USD 2.5 per lot per side on the accounts page; that is USD 8 a round trip. ECN is the cheapest of the three ordinary retail accounts: Zero (MT5 only) shows an average of 0 with an 11 USD commission, USD 11, and Standard shows an average of 1.7 with no commission, USD 17. The page prints the spread without a unit and without an observation period; pips is read from the accounts page, where the same ECN minimum appears as 'from 0.2 pips'.
Account ECN (MetaTrader 5; same figures on MetaTrader 4), AMarkets LLCAverage spread pips 0.3Round turn commission USD 5Indicative cost USD 8
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: AMarkets LLC (Cook Islands), AMarkets Copy Trading service (own product, strategies run on MetaTrader accounts)Established from documents
The copy trading regulations of AMarkets LLC describe the company's own service in which a trader's orders are placed automatically on investors' accounts. They document the sizing rule (trader volume times the equity ratio times an investor-set Copy ratio, with examples), follower controls (a Loss limit that disconnects and closes positions, and unsubscribing at any time) and the fees (a trader's profit fee on a high-water mark plus normal trading commissions). All four elements are documented in the contract terms.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: AMarkets LLC (Cook Islands), Standard, ECN and Zero accounts, MetaTrader 4 and 5, CFDs including EUR/USDEstablished from documents
Each CFD is a contract directly between AMarkets LLC and the client. The trading regulations define a liquidity provider as a source of quotes that 'may also be used' to hedge client trades, and give the dealer a right to decline an order the company cannot hedge; nothing commits the company to hedge every trade externally or ties a fill to an external fill. That leaves hedging to the firm's discretion, which is grade 4. The ECN page's statement that every order is executed at the prime broker is a product description outside the contract, and the prime broker is not named, so it is not known whether it is outside the group.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: AMarkets LLC (Cook Islands), Agent (Revenue Share) and Webmaster (CPA) partner programmesEstablished from documents
The partner page offers two programmes and each has its own agreement with AMarkets LLC. The Agent programme pays a share of the company's revenue on every closed trade of a referred client. The Webmaster programme pays one-off amounts per verified registration and per funded, verified client who reaches a trading turnover. Revenue share and CPA are both documented, which is grade 4.
-
19overallequal
IC Markets
Profile Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0
Availability not confirmedAvailability not confirmedAustralian company on file
3.6/10no penalties
Breakdown for IC Markets
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs6USD 8 round trip
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Raw Trading Ltd (Seychelles) for the assessed retail product and partner programme; group structure additionally covers Australia, Cyprus, Bahamas and Kenya. No EU IB programme is inferred from Global partner terms.
Summary Raw Trading Ltd documents automated copying with sizing rules and fees and publishes a USD 8 EUR/USD round trip on its MetaTrader Raw Spread account, while the brand runs five regional companies, pays CPA as well as revenue share and keeps discretion over hedging.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: IC Markets / IC brand, all regional companiesEstablished from documents
Five regional sites each name a different company that is licensed locally, publishes its own legal documents and opens accounts: Raw Trading Ltd (Seychelles), International Capital Markets Pty Ltd (Australia), IC Markets Ltd (Bahamas), IC Markets (EU) Ltd (Cyprus) and IC Markets (KE) Limited (Kenya). Five or more operating jurisdictions is grade 0 even as a lower bound, so no closed group list is needed. This confirms the existing grade and reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not safety.
Count lower bound 5
- Published costs 6Grade 6: USD over 7 to 10Scope: Raw Trading Ltd, Seychelles; Raw Spread account on MetaTrader 4/5, USD accountEstablished from documents
Raw Trading Ltd publishes both figures for its MetaTrader Raw Spread account: a 0.1 pip average EUR/USD spread and USD 3.50 per lot per side, which is USD 8 per round-trip lot. The cTrader Raw Spread account charges USD 3 per USD 100,000 traded per side (USD 6.59 round trip at the ECB rate of 1.0989), but its own page attributes the 0.1 pip average to MetaTrader and gives no cTrader average; if the same average applied it would cost USD 7.59, the same band. Raw Pro (USD 3 round trip, USD 5,000 minimum deposit) and Raw Pro+ (USD 2, USD 100,000) publish only 'from 0.0' spreads, so they cannot be graded. The spreads table's EUR/USD average of 0.01 is not used because the same table shows a Standard average below its own minimum.
Account Raw Spread account, MetaTrader 4/5, USD (Raw Trading Ltd, Seychelles)Average spread pips 0.1Round turn commission USD 7Indicative cost USD 8
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Raw Trading Ltd, Seychelles; IC Social (powered by Pelican Trading) on MetaTrader 4/5Established from documents
For Raw Trading Ltd, IC Social on MetaTrader 4/5 is the product that documents all four items: copying a signal provider's trades, four sizing rules (proportional by equity, mirror, fixed, 0.1–10 multiplier), a performance fee of up to 50%, and a copier-side control to unlink the trading account in the app. The stop control is thin: the page documents disconnecting the account, not pausing or stopping a single signal, and does not say what happens to open copied trades. The cTrader Copy page documents automation, equity-proportional sizing and fees but no stop control; the ZuluTrade page documents automation, ZuluGuard and free following but no sizing rule; Signal Start documents automation only.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Raw Trading Ltd, Seychelles; all clients and platformsEstablished from documents
The Raw Trading Ltd order execution policy (October 2026, v1.5) says the firm acts as principal and may execute an order itself or, where appropriate and depending on instrument, platform and market conditions, transmit it in its own name to a liquidity provider. The client agreement contains no undertaking to hedge, and the firm's help centre states that it does not hedge every position. That is discretion between internal and external handling, which is the anchor for 4; acting as principal is not taken as B-book. This confirms the existing grade.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Raw Trading Ltd, Seychelles; IC Partners programmesEstablished from documents
The IC Partners site, published by Raw Trading Ltd, documents two programmes: an Affiliate Program that pays a fixed commission per referred client and is described as a CPA model, and an Introducing Broker Program that pays commission on clients' trading activity with a Revenue Share volume incentive. Both models documented is the anchor for 4. This confirms the existing grade.
-
20overallequal
Moneta Markets
Assessment summary Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
3.6/103 penalties
Breakdown for Moneta Markets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing whether Moneta Markets Capital Ltd (UK), Moneta Markets Trading Limited (Mauritius) and Moneta Markets Limited (Hong Kong) contract with clients or execute for the brand, and a closed list of the group's operating companies.
- Published costs6PAll-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 6–10 · missing a statement that the published 'ECN Avg Spread' applies to the Ultra ECN account (or a separate Ultra ECN average), and a ruling on whether a tier granted on request at the firm's discretion counts as an ordinary retail account.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the identity of the liquidity provider with common shareholdings, the share of client orders sent to it and whether it hedges those orders with counterparties outside the group.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across the Moneta Markets international site, not a single account offer; country eligibility not assessed. Execution (abook) and copy rest on Moneta Markets Ltd (Saint Lucia, international business company no. 2023-00068), from its own client documents and the CopyTrader terms. Costs and partner programmes come from the international site's pricing and partner pages, which name several companies and no single contracting company. Pages were read on www.monetamarketsvn.com, a second official domain of the same site linked from the home page, because www.monetamarkets.com answered a bot challenge after the first request. Moneta Markets South Africa (Pty) Ltd and Moneta Markets Capital Ltd (United Kingdom) are separate companies; nothing is carried to or from them.
Summary Automated copying with a sizing rule, follower controls and profit-share fees is documented, and both IB rebates and CPA are offered; the execution policy sends all orders to liquidity providers, one of them related by shareholding, the lowest cost tied to a named account is USD 8.60 on Prime ECN while a cheaper opt-in tier has no average labelled for it, and two operating jurisdictions are documented with three further companies unsettled.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: Moneta Markets brand, all companies named on the international siteInvestigated, not settled
The brand's legal hub publishes client document sets for two companies, Moneta Markets Ltd (Saint Lucia) and Moneta Markets South Africa (Pty) Ltd, and the regulation page calls the brand a trading name of each, so two operating jurisdictions are documented. The site also names an FCA-authorised UK company said to serve UK clients through its own website, a Mauritius FSC licensee and a Hong Kong company, with no client documents or stated function that could be read; the UK site answered HTTP 401 on every request. No closed list of operating companies was found, so two is a lower bound and the grade is 0 to 4.
Missing Whether Moneta Markets Capital Ltd (UK), Moneta Markets Trading Limited (Mauritius) and Moneta Markets Limited (Hong Kong) contract with clients or execute for the brand, and a closed list of the group's operating companies.
Count lower bound 2
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 6PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 6–10. Not a finding.Scope: Moneta Markets international site; Prime ECN and Ultra ECN accounts (PRO Trader, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, AppTrader), EUR/USD, USD account; the pricing pages do not name the contracting companyInvestigated, not settled
The spreads page gives EUR/USD an 'ECN Avg Spread' of 0.26 pips and, under its 'TRUE ECN' commission tab, USD 6 round turn per lot on a USD account. That matches the Prime ECN account (USD 3 per lot per side, USD 50 minimum deposit) and comes to USD 8.60, grade 6. The Ultra ECN account charges USD 1 per lot per side and is granted on request with a USD 20,000 balance and no professional-status condition, so it is not excluded as a tier; but the page does not label the average for Ultra ECN, which advertises only spreads from 0 pips, so that account has a lower bound of USD 2 and no exact cost. If the same ECN average applies to it the cost is USD 4.60, grade 10. Direct STP (average 1.36 pips, no commission) costs USD 13.60. All three accounts list the same platforms, with no platform-specific commission.
Missing A statement that the published 'ECN Avg Spread' applies to the Ultra ECN account (or a separate Ultra ECN average), and a ruling on whether a tier granted on request at the firm's discretion counts as an ordinary retail account.
Account Prime ECN (documented floor) and Ultra ECN (cheaper tier, average not labelled); same platforms listed for both
5 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Moneta Markets Ltd as named in the CopyTrader terms ('Monet Markets Ltd', no registration number given); CopyTrader mobile app, international siteEstablished from documents
CopyTrader is the broker's own copy service, and its terms document all four elements: a signal provider's trades are applied to the copier's account automatically; trades are sized as a proportion of the funds the copier allots; the copier can close copied trades manually at any time; and the provider takes a profit share of 0% to 50% above a high-water mark, settled weekly. The brand's explainer page adds the follower-set risk ratio and says copying can be stopped with one click. The stop-copying statement comes from that explainer, while the manual-close control is in the terms.
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: Moneta Markets Ltd (Saint Lucia), margin FX and CFD orders on MT4/MT5. Not Moneta Markets South Africa (Pty) Ltd or Moneta Markets Capital Ltd, and not Gold Derivative Contracts under the addendum.Investigated, not settled
Moneta Markets Ltd's Best Execution Policy, which says it forms part of the client agreement, describes the firm as an agency broker and says it has appointed liquidity providers to whom all orders will be transmitted for execution; that is a blanket external-route statement with no per-fill condition. The same policy discloses that one liquidity provider has common shareholdings with Moneta Markets, without naming it, saying what share of orders it receives or saying whether it passes them on, and the Key Facts Summary says the firm acts as a market maker 'mainly due to system failure'. A route to a related company alone is 4, so the grade is 4 to 6 until that provider's role is known. The policy is dated March 2023 and is the version the legal hub serves today. The August 2026 addendum's discretionary-hedge wording covers Gold Derivative Contracts only and is not applied to forex.
Missing The identity of the liquidity provider with common shareholdings, the share of client orders sent to it and whether it hedges those orders with counterparties outside the group.
5 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Moneta Markets brand, international site partner programmes (no contracting company named on the partner pages)Established from documents
The brand's partner pages document both models. The Introducing Broker Program pays rebates on the trades of referred clients for as long as they trade, and the CPA Affiliate Program pays a fixed amount per qualified first-time depositor (minimum deposit and 2 FX lots traded), up to USD 1,200. Both documented gives 4.
-
21overallequal
3.6/102 penalties
Breakdown for Octa
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a closed list of the companies that operate the Octa brand, and whether the Comoros and Mauritius licence holders named only by label currently contract with or execute for clients.
- Published costs6USD 10 round trip
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing either a documented payment per referred or funded client (CPA), for example under a Special Offer or Commission Program, or an affirmative statement that Octa pays partners only on traded volume.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Versustrategy Inc., Saint Lucia (business registration 2025-00917), operator of octabroker.com: the one legal entity used for costs, copy and abook. Brand-level feature review with a scope on every factor, not an account offer. Structure looks across the brand's companies (Versustrategy Inc. and Octa Markets Inc. in Saint Lucia, Octa Markets Cyprus Ltd in Cyprus, Orinoco Capital (PTY) Ltd in South Africa); no fact from one company is used for another.
Summary For Versustrategy Inc. in Saint Lucia the documents give a commission-free account with a published EUR/USD average spread of 1 pip (USD 10 a round trip), an own copy service with sizing, stop controls and fees documented, and a client agreement that leaves hedging to the firm's sole discretion; two broker jurisdictions and a South African intermediary are evidenced without a closed group list, and a per-lot IB programme is documented while neither CPA nor its exclusion is.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: Octa brand: Versustrategy Inc. and Octa Markets Inc. (Saint Lucia), Octa Markets Cyprus Ltd (Cyprus), Orinoco Capital (PTY) Ltd (South Africa)Investigated, not settled
Two operating jurisdictions are evidenced by companies that contract with clients as the broker: Saint Lucia (Versustrategy Inc. for octabroker.com; Octa Markets Inc. for its own clients and as execution venue for the South African route) and Cyprus (Octa Markets Cyprus Ltd, confirmed on the CySEC register under the trade name Octa). A third, Orinoco Capital (PTY) Ltd in South Africa, contracts with clients as a licensed intermediary; whether an intermediary counts as an operating brokerage company has not been ruled (the same question is open for easyMarkets and JustMarkets). The legal page's source also carries labels for a Comoros and a Mauritius licence, but those blocks are not rendered and no client document for them could be opened. No closed list of group companies is published, so at least 2 gives 0–4; counting the intermediary would give 0–2.
Missing A closed list of the companies that operate the Octa brand, and whether the Comoros and Mauritius licence holders named only by label currently contract with or execute for clients.
Count lower bound 2
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 6Grade 6: USD over 7 to 10Scope: Versustrategy Inc., MetaTrader 5 account (identical figures for the OctaTrader and MetaTrader 4 accounts), USD account, EUR/USD, Saint LuciaEstablished from documents
Octa's three ordinary accounts (OctaTrader, MetaTrader 5, MetaTrader 4) charge no commission and take the cost as a spread markup. Each platform's EURUSD page shows, in visible text, a minimum spread of 0.7 and an average spread of 1, with a pip price of USD 10 per lot; the three pages give the same figures, so no platform is cheaper. One pip with no commission is USD 10 a round trip. The unit is not printed in the block itself but follows from the page's own quote (bid 1.09676, ask 1.09686, spread 1), and no observation period is given.
Account MetaTrader 5 account, Versustrategy Inc. (the OctaTrader and MetaTrader 4 accounts publish the same EUR/USD figures)Average spread pips 1Round turn commission USD 0Indicative cost USD 10
4 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Versustrategy Inc., Octa Copy (own product, Copier Area and copy trading app), Saint LuciaEstablished from documents
Octa Copy is the broker's own service with terms published on octabroker.com, and the Customer Agreement of Versustrategy Inc. names it as a programme of the company. The terms document all four elements: a Master's orders trigger orders on the Copier's account whether or not the Copier is signed in, the Copier sets the invested amount and a copy proportion, can close any copied trade and stop copying, and pays the Master 0% to 50% of the gain plus a 0.2 pip spread markup.
2 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Versustrategy Inc., OctaTrader, MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 accounts, Saint LuciaEstablished from documents
The Customer Agreement of Versustrategy Inc. says the company is principal, sole counterparty and sole execution venue, and that it may offset client positions with third-party liquidity providers but is not obliged to and may keep some or all of the risk at its sole discretion. That is discretionary hedging in the contract, which the anchors grade 4. The website FAQ calls the broker non-dealing-desk and ECN and says all orders are offset, but that is marketing and the agreement governs.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Octa IB Program and Invite a Friend program, Versustrategy Inc., Saint LuciaInvestigated, not settled
The Introducing Broker Agreement of Versustrategy Inc. (version 2.0, effective 24 August 2026) and the FAQ document an IB programme paid per valid lot traded by introduced clients, at rates by asset and IB rank, and a separate Invite a Friend programme pays clients USD 1 per lot traded by friends. No payment per referred or funded client was found, but the agreement also allows Special Offers, a Commission Program and a Master IB Program on unpublished terms, and nothing says CPA is not offered. Absence is not proof, so the range is 4–10.
Missing Either a documented payment per referred or funded client (CPA), for example under a Special Offer or Commission Program, or an affirmative statement that Octa pays partners only on traded volume.
6 addresses tried
-
22overallequal
RoboForex
Profile Best Costs, Copy 10 · weakest Structure, A-book 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
3.6/103 penalties
Breakdown for RoboForex
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–7 · missing a group-level list of the companies that contract with RoboForex clients, or a statement that RoboForex Ltd is the only one.
- Published costs10USD 3.17 round trip
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a statement in RoboForex Ltd's client documents of how client orders are executed: as principal or agent, whether each order or the net exposure is hedged, and with which counterparties outside the group.
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing either a RoboForex Ltd document that offers a CPA or per-client payment, or a statement that its partner programmes pay revenue share only.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope RoboForex Ltd (Belize, states FSC Belize licence 9759600, roboforex.com) for all five criteria: the Prime account on MetaTrader 4 or 5 for costs, the Copy Trading Service for copy, the Order Execution Policy in its Client Agreement for execution and the Infinity partner programme for affiliate. A brand-level feature review, not an account offer for any country.
Summary RoboForex Ltd (Belize) is the only company the RoboForex-branded sites contract through, its Prime account publishes a 0.1-pip average EUR/USD spread with a commission of USD 10 per million per side, and its Copy Trading Service documents sizing, a pause control and fees; its execution policy does not say how orders are hedged, and only revenue-share partner pay was found, with CPA neither documented nor excluded.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–7. Not a finding.Scope: RoboForex brand: RoboForex Ltd, BelizeInvestigated, not settled
Every RoboForex-branded site, the documents hub and the Client Agreement name one client-contracting company, RoboForex Ltd (Belize). The agreement also refers to an unnamed "group of companies", the separately branded RoboMarkets companies belong to the same wider group, and no closed list of the RoboForex group was found. One jurisdiction is therefore a lower bound: if RoboForex Ltd is the only operating company the grade is 7; it is lower if another company contracts with RoboForex clients.
Missing A group-level list of the companies that contract with RoboForex clients, or a statement that RoboForex Ltd is the only one.
Count lower bound 1
5 addresses tried
- Published costs 10Grade 10: USD ≤ 5Scope: RoboForex Ltd (Belize), Prime account, MetaTrader 4 or MetaTrader 5, EUR/USD, USD accountEstablished from documents
The contract specification for EURUSD on the Prime account states an average spread of 0.1 pip and a commission of 10 per million; the help centre defines that as USD 10 per USD 1,000,000 traded, charged on opening and on closing. One lot is EUR 100,000, so at the help centre's own example rate of 1.08585 the round-trip commission is USD 2.17 and the total about USD 3.17, and it stays below USD 5 at any EUR/USD rate under 2.00. Prime is an ordinary retail account (minimum deposit 10 USD) with the same rate on MetaTrader 4 and 5; the ECN account comes to about USD 5.34 and the commission-free Pro account to USD 13.
Account Prime (MetaTrader 4 or MetaTrader 5), RoboForex LtdAverage spread pips 0.1Round turn commission USD 2.17Indicative cost USD 3.17
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: RoboForex Ltd (Belize), Copy Trading Service (formerly CopyFX), real MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and R StocksTrader accountsEstablished from documents
RoboForex Ltd's help centre describes the Copy Trading Service as automatic copying of a Trader's trades to subscribed Investors. It documents three sizing modes (proportional to equity with a coefficient, a volume multiplier, a fixed lot), a Pause control that stops new trades being copied while the subscription stays in place, and a performance fee that each Trader sets as a share of profit. Copying runs on MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and R StocksTrader accounts within the same platform. These are documented product features, not a view on results.
1 address tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: RoboForex Ltd (Belize), MetaTrader accounts (Prime, ECN, Pro, ProCent)Investigated, not settled
The Order Execution Policy inside RoboForex Ltd's Client Agreement describes order types and Market Execution but does not say whether client orders are hedged, passed to outside liquidity providers or kept on the firm's own book. The risk disclosure says only that a bank or broker through whom the company executes transactions, or the company itself, may operate in the same market, and refers to an undefined 'Execution Venue'. The website offers an account called ECN and counts eight unnamed liquidity providers, which is marketing without a contractual routing commitment.
Missing A statement in RoboForex Ltd's client documents of how client orders are executed: as principal or agent, whether each order or the net exposure is hedged, and with which counterparties outside the group.
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: RoboForex Ltd (Belize), Infinity partner programme and Partner AgreementInvestigated, not settled
RoboForex Ltd's Infinity partner programme pays a share of the spread on referred clients' closed trades (stated as up to 85%) and 30% of swaps, and the Partner Agreement calculates commission daily on referrals' closed transactions. No CPA or per-client payment appears on the partner page, in the Partner Agreement or among the titles of the help centre's partnership questions, and none of them says CPA is excluded; the agreement also allows other programme types and special conditions. Revenue share is documented, and CPA is neither documented nor ruled out.
Missing Either a RoboForex Ltd document that offers a CPA or per-client payment, or a statement that its partner programmes pay revenue share only.
5 addresses tried
-
23overallequal
Traders Trust
Assessment summary Best Costs, Copy 10 · weakest Structure, A-book 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
3.6/103 penalties
Breakdown for Traders Trust
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing whether TTCM Traders Capital Limited (Bermuda) contracts with or operates accounts for trading clients, and a closed list of the brand's operating companies.
- Published costs10TVIP: published account tariff. USD 3 tariff floor: USD 3 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 10/10 for the named VIP account: USD 3 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 3 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. VIP requires a USD 5,000 minimum wallet balance. The website API labels its averages as seeded data, so those values are not treated as measured averages; the advertised minimum and per-side commission are used. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Condition: USD 5k wallet minimum.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a contractual statement of how Traders Trust Ltd handles client orders: blanket external routing or hedging, discretion to keep or hedge, or exclusion of external routing, and whether any venue is a group company.
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing whether any Traders Trust partner plan pays a fixed amount per funded client (CPA), or an affirmative statement that CPA is not offered.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Traders Trust (traders-trust.com) · candidate only · brand-level feature review across companies, not a single account offer for any country. The client agreement, conflicts policy and the whole legal hub (labelled 'Seychelles Entity') belong to Traders Trust Ltd, Seychelles, company 8429440-1, FSA Securities Dealer licence SD141; A-book rests on that agreement. Costs rest on the brand's account, FAQ and spreads pages, which name no company in the body; the footer and legal hub point to Traders Trust Ltd. The copy-trade terms name Traders Trust Ltd and TTCM Traders Capital Limited (Bermuda, 54135) together as 'Traders Trust'. The partner loyalty and refer-a-friend terms are issued by TTCM Traders Capital Limited (Bermuda). The former Cyprus firm TTCM Traders Trust Capital Markets Ltd lost its CySEC authorisation in 2026 and is not reviewed as a current route.
Summary The Social Trader copy service documents automation, sizing, follower controls and performance fees (copy 10); a VIP EUR/USD average of 0.1 pip appears only in a spreads table stamped by a site-seeding generator, so costs stay open with 10 as the conditional reading, and the company count, the execution route (the agreement only says principal or agent) and whether any CPA is paid stay ranges.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Traders Trust brand; Traders Trust Ltd (Seychelles), TTCM Traders Capital Limited (Bermuda), ABS Advanced Backoffice Services Ltd (Cyprus), former TTCM Traders Trust Capital Markets Ltd (Cyprus)Investigated, not settled
One operating brokerage company is documented: Traders Trust Ltd in Seychelles, the FSA-licensed counterparty of the client agreement and the only company with client documents on the legal hub. The footer also names TTCM Traders Capital Limited in Bermuda, which runs the partner loyalty and refer-a-friend promotions and is named beside the Seychelles company in the copy-trade terms, but no document says it contracts with trading clients. A Cyprus back-office company is named too. The footer is not presented as a closed list, so one found gives 0 to the one-Seychelles grade of 6.
Missing Whether TTCM Traders Capital Limited (Bermuda) contracts with or operates accounts for trading clients, and a closed list of the brand's operating companies.
Count lower bound 1
5 addresses tried
- Published costs 10TAssigned tariff grade 10; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–10.Tariff basis: VIP: published account tariff; USD 3 tariff floor: USD 3 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: VIP; Traders Trust brand VIP account, MT4/MT5, USD, EUR/USD; account pages name no company, the legal hub and footer point to Traders Trust Ltd (Seychelles)Published tariff assessment (VIP); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 10/10 for the named VIP account: USD 3 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 3 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. VIP requires a USD 5,000 minimum wallet balance. The website API labels its averages as seeded data, so those values are not treated as measured averages; the advertised minimum and per-side commission are used. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing An average EUR/USD spread for a named Traders Trust account that the broker shows to be observed over a stated period.
Account VIP account (MT4 server Live 3 or MT5), USD; minimum wallet balance USD 5,000Round turn commission USD 3Pricing condition USD 5k wallet minimum
3 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Traders Trust Social Trader / Copy Trade service on MT5 accounts and MT4 server Live3; terms name Traders Trust Ltd (Seychelles) and TTCM Traders Capital Limited (Bermuda) jointly as 'Traders Trust'Established from documents
The broker documents its own copy service. The Copy Trade terms describe an auto-trading system that copies a provider's master account to subscribers' accounts in real time, and the Social Trader manual sets out sizing (autoscale against equity with a ratio multiplier, and a maximum open volume). It also gives follower controls (suspend, unsubscribe, total-loss, floating-loss and profit levels) and a provider-set performance fee charged monthly by default. Automation, sizing, controls and fees are all documented.
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Traders Trust Ltd, Seychelles; Client Services Agreement for all accountsInvestigated, not settled
Traders Trust Ltd's client agreement says the company acts as principal or agent and is always the client's contractual counterparty, and that it may decline orders it cannot hedge. It names no execution venue or liquidity provider and contains no commitment to pass or hedge orders outside the company, nor a clause giving it discretion to keep them. No order execution policy is published. The 'STP / No Dealing Desk' label on the account page is marketing, so the grade stays at the range for such statements.
Missing A contractual statement of how Traders Trust Ltd handles client orders: blanket external routing or hedging, discretion to keep or hedge, or exclusion of external routing, and whether any venue is a group company.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Traders Trust brand partner programmes: IB programme (site, no company named; client agreement of Traders Trust Ltd, Seychelles, cl. 18.2); Partner Loyalty Program and Refer a Friend run by TTCM Traders Capital Limited (Bermuda)Investigated, not settled
An introducing-broker programme paying per lot traded by referred clients is documented (up to USD 10 per lot, multi-level), and the client agreement lets Traders Trust Ltd pay introducing brokers and affiliates. A partner loyalty bonus run by the Bermuda company pays a percentage of direct clients' net deposits once at least five new funded clients are reached; that is a deposit-share bonus, not a fixed payment per funded client. The USD 100 refer-a-friend reward is a client referral reward. No CPA plan was found, but nothing states CPA is excluded.
Missing Whether any Traders Trust partner plan pays a fixed amount per funded client (CPA), or an affirmative statement that CPA is not offered.
3 addresses tried
-
24overallequal
3.5/102 penalties
Breakdown for Dukascopy
- Company structure2Three or four
- Published costs10USD 4.10 round trip · ≥ USD 3m deposit/equity or ≥ USD 3b 30-day volume
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing whether a fixed per-client payment exists for FX or CFD referrals, or a ruling on whether the binary-options payment counts for the brand.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Dukascopy Bank SA (Geneva, Switzerland; FINMA-supervised bank and securities firm): costs, copy and abook all rest on this one entity and its site www.dukascopy.com/swiss. Structure and affiliate are brand-level. Brand-level feature review, not an account offer; no fact from Dukascopy Europe IBS AS (Latvia) or Dukascopy Japan K.K. (Japan) is used for a grade.
Summary JForex pricing supports a 10/10 cost grade only at the lowest published commission tier: at least USD 3m deposit/equity or USD 3b 30-day volume. Entry pricing is higher. Copy-product scope and the full set of partner incentives remain unresolved. This is preference fit, with account conditions shown beside the costs.
- Company structure 2Grade 2: three or fourScope: Dukascopy group, all jurisdictionsEstablished from documents
The group's own documents give a closed list. The 2025 annual report says the bank fully owns two subsidiaries offering online brokerage, Dukascopy Europe IBS AS in Riga and Dukascopy Japan K.K. in Tokyo, and the group page lists the same two as the subsidiaries active in online trading. With the bank itself in Geneva that is three operating brokerage companies in three jurisdictions, which is the 3–4 band. The two other companies in the participations table are both in Geneva and are not brokers, so they do not change the count. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference and is not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 3
- Published costs 10Grade 10: USD ≤ 5Scope: Dukascopy Bank SA, JForex self-trader account, lowest published tier: ≥ USD 3m deposit/equity or ≥ USD 3b 30-day volume; USD account, EUR/USD on SWFX, Switzerland.Established from documents
The 10/10 grade requires the lowest published self-trader commission tier: at least USD 3 million in net deposit or equity, or USD 3 billion traded over 30 days. The bank’s all-hours EUR/USD Month-period average is 0.30 pip in its EUR/USD data record dated 19 November 2026. The USD 5 per million per-side commission produces about USD 1.10 round trip at the dated 18 November ECB rate, giving about USD 4.10 including spread. Entry-tier pricing is about USD 10.68 (grade 4). The shared protocol selects the cheapest published eligible retail tier; no professional-status, invitation or negotiated-pricing requirement was found.
Account JForex self-trader, lowest tier (≥ USD 3m deposit/equity or ≥ USD 3b 30-day volume)Commission per side USD 0.55Round turn commission USD 1.1Average spread pips 0.3Indicative cost USD 4.1Pricing condition ≥ USD 3m deposit/equity or ≥ USD 3b 30-day volume
10 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Dukascopy Bank SA, JForex and MetaTrader accounts, SwitzerlandInvestigated, not settled
No current copy service of Dukascopy Bank SA could be documented. A 2018 terms document still on the bank's server describes Signal Trading, which automatically replicated the trades of Dukascopy Community members, free of subscription fee and with a compulsory account stop-loss; it was available only to Community members. The bank closed the Community on 27 February 2026, the Signal Trading page now redirects to the general trading page, and the current menu and site map list no copy or signal product. That points to the service having ended, but no page says so and none says that copying, including through a third party, is not offered, so the grade cannot be 0. The old terms are not used as evidence of a current offer.
Missing Whether Dukascopy Bank SA still offers Signal Trading or any other automated copying after the Community closed on 27 February 2026, or a statement that it offers none, including through third parties.
10 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Dukascopy Bank SA, all trading accounts (JForex, MetaTrader 4 and 5, FIX API), SwitzerlandEstablished from documents
The Marketplace Trading Conditions of Dukascopy Bank SA make the bank the legal counterparty of every trade and give it the right to hedge client trades partially, fully or not at all, at its sole discretion; the client accepts that trades will not necessarily be hedged with external counterparties. The best-execution annex confirms the bank executes as principal and acts at its own discretion. A policy that leaves hedging to the firm's discretion is the anchor for 4. The ECN marketplace and '20+ banks' wording is marketing and adds no commitment. This does not show that the bank internalises any given trade.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Dukascopy brand: Business Introducer Program of Dukascopy Bank SA (Switzerland) and Dukascopy Europe IBS AS (Latvia); the per-client option applies to binary-options clients of Dukascopy Bank SA onlyInvestigated, not settled
For FX and CFD accounts Dukascopy documents an introducer programme paid as a share of revenue, up to 50%. The only fixed per-client payment found is USD 30 for a referred binary-options client, a different product that is not offered in the EU. Whether a per-client payment on another product makes the brand's partner model "IB and CPA" for this review has not been ruled, so the grade stays a range: IB documented, CPA for the assessed product neither found nor excluded.
Missing Whether a fixed per-client payment exists for FX or CFD referrals, or a ruling on whether the binary-options payment counts for the brand.
2 addresses tried
-
25overallequal
3.0/101 penalty
Breakdown for ATFX
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs2TStandard: published account tariff. USD 18 tariff floor: USD 0 round-turn commission + 1.8 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 2/10 for the named Standard account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 1.8 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 18 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the identity of the liquidity providers of AT Global Markets LLC and whether they are companies of the ATFX group.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across ATFX's sites, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and execution all rest on AT Global Markets LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, company number 333 LLC 2020), whose client documents are the only ones published on www.atfx.com/en and which maintains the ATFX CopyTrade service on atcopytrade.com. The partner programme was read on the same /en site. AT Global Markets (UK) Limited (FCA 760555), which the earlier screening row named, serves professional clients and eligible counterparties only and is used here for the structure count alone; nothing is carried from it or from the Australian, South African, Mauritian, Cypriot or Seychelles companies to AT Global Markets LLC.
Summary ATFX names operating companies in at least five jurisdictions; for AT Global Markets LLC the copy service is documented with automation, sizing, follower controls and fees, the partner page describes both a per-funded-client commission and volume rebates, the one published account shows a 1.8 pip minimum EUR/USD spread with no average, and the terms describe a pass-through to liquidity providers that are not named.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: ATFX brand, group level; Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Australia, United Kingdom, South Africa, MauritiusEstablished from documents
ATFX's own pages show operating brokerage companies in at least five jurisdictions, each with a documented role and not only a licence: AT Global Markets LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) publishes the client terms of the /en site; AT Global Markets (Australia) Pty Ltd issues its own Product Disclosure Statement and account terms; AT Global Markets (UK) Limited contracts as principal with professional clients; AT Global Markets SA (Pty) Ltd is a South African OTC derivatives provider with its own client terms; and AT Global Markets Intl Ltd (Mauritius) is named as product supplier and principal for clients introduced by ATFX Africa. Five or more is grade 0 even as a lower bound, so no closed list is needed. Companies in Cyprus, Seychelles, Hong Kong, the UAE and Cambodia are named with a licence only and were not needed for the count.
Count lower bound 5
- Published costs 2TAssigned tariff grade 2; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–2.Tariff basis: Standard: published account tariff; USD 18 tariff floor: USD 0 round-turn commission + 1.8 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Standard; AT Global Markets LLC (global /en site), Standard account on MT4, EUR/USD, USD account, Saint Vincent and the GrenadinesPublished tariff assessment (Standard); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 2/10 for the named Standard account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 1.8 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 18 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A EUR/USD average or typical spread that ATFX publishes and labels for a named ordinary retail account of AT Global Markets LLC.
Account Standard account (MT4), AT Global Markets LLCRound turn commission USD 0Average spread published no
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: AT Global Markets LLC, ATFX CopyTrade (atcopytrade.com), Saint Vincent and the GrenadinesEstablished from documents
ATFX CopyTrade is the broker's own leader/follower service, maintained by AT Global Markets LLC under published terms. The terms document automatic execution without follower confirmation, pro-rata sizing with follower-set subscription, maximum open volume and risk-management parameters, unilateral termination of a subscription, and fees: a provider-set performance fee of at most 40% of net profit above a high-water mark, with no ATFX commission for the service. The product page adds that a follower can pause or stop copying. This is documentation of features only; no fills or returns were verified.
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: AT Global Markets LLC, all client transactions under its Standard Terms of Business, Saint Vincent and the GrenadinesInvestigated, not settled
The client agreement of AT Global Markets LLC states, as a general description of how it deals, that it either passes trades straight through to its liquidity providers or matches them on its own ECN and never takes the other side (cl. 7.6), while acting as principal (cl. 3.1). That is a contractual blanket pass-through, which would be 6 if the providers are outside the group. Neither the agreement nor the execution policy names a liquidity provider, clause 10.4 allows the firm or an associate to act for the counterparty, and the execution policy says it does not route orders to specific liquidity providers. Whether the route leaves the ATFX group is therefore open, and a route to a group company alone would be 4.
Missing The identity of the liquidity providers of AT Global Markets LLC and whether they are companies of the ATFX group.
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: ATFX Introducing Broker Program, global /en site (AT Global Markets LLC)Established from documents
The Introducing Broker Program page says ATFX introducing brokers are paid by two methods: an introductory commission when an introduced client opens and funds an account, and rebates on the volume those clients trade. By mechanism that is a per-funded-client payment alongside volume-based IB commissions, and the client agreement of AT Global Markets LLC likewise allows a one-off fee or ongoing commissions to a referring partner. The page does not use the term CPA and publishes no amounts; no separate affiliate programme page was found on the site.
-
26overallequal
Baxia Markets
Assessment summary Best Costs 8 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
3.0/102 penalties
Breakdown for Baxia Markets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing whether Baxia Limited (Bahamas) contracts with clients or executes orders under the Baxia Markets brand, and a group-level statement that the Seychelles and Bahamas companies are the only group companies.
- Published costs8TBX Zero: published account tariff. USD 6 tariff floor: USD 5 round-turn commission + 0.1 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named BX Zero account: USD 5 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0.1 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing how copied volume is sized, what stop or pause control a follower has, the fees a follower pays, and whether the service is offered on MT5 accounts.
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review of Baxia Markets, not a single account offer. A-book rests on the execution policy and client agreement of Baxia Global Limited (Seychelles, FSA licence SD104), the only company whose client documents the brand publishes. Costs, copy and partner programmes come from brand website pages that name no contracting company; the same website publishes only Baxia Global Limited's client documents. Baxia Limited (Bahamas) is listed as a second regulated company; no client documents for it were found and nothing from it is used.
Summary The Seychelles company's execution policy leaves external routing to the firm's discretion and the brand documents both IB rebates and a CPA affiliate deal; spreads are published only as minimums, and the group structure and the mechanics of MetaTrader signal copying are not settled by the documents.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Baxia Markets brand; Baxia Global Limited (Seychelles) and Baxia Limited (Bahamas)Investigated, not settled
One client-contracting company is documented: Baxia Global Limited in Seychelles, the only company with client documents on the legal page and listed by the Seychelles regulator as a securities dealer. The brand also lists Baxia Limited in the Bahamas as a regulated company, and the execution policy calls it a related company that holds platform software licences, but no document read says it contracts with clients or executes orders, and a licence alone does not raise the count. The brand's 'Entities' section lists exactly these two companies without saying the list is complete, so one jurisdiction is a lower bound: 6 if Seychelles is the only operating jurisdiction, 4 if the Bahamas company also operates, lower if there are others.
Missing Whether Baxia Limited (Bahamas) contracts with clients or executes orders under the Baxia Markets brand, and a group-level statement that the Seychelles and Bahamas companies are the only group companies.
Count lower bound 1
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: BX Zero: published account tariff; USD 6 tariff floor: USD 5 round-turn commission + 0.1 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: BX Zero; Baxia Markets brand website (client documents on the site are those of Baxia Global Limited, Seychelles; the pricing pages name no company), BX Zero account on MT4/MT5, EUR/USD, USD accountPublished tariff assessment (BX Zero); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named BX Zero account: USD 5 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0.1 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A broker-published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for BX Zero or BX Standard, with its observation period.
Account BX Zero, MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 (same commission on both), Baxia Markets brand websiteRound turn commission USD 5Spread basis advertised minimum; no average or typical figure published
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Baxia Markets brand website, MetaTrader Signals on MetaTrader 4 accounts; the page names no company (client documents on the site are those of Baxia Global Limited, Seychelles, and do not describe signals copying)Investigated, not settled
The brand's own page presents MetaTrader Signals as available on its MT4 accounts: open a Baxia MT4 real account, subscribe to a signal provider and the provider's trades are copied to the account. That is taken as documented leader/follower copying. The page mentions that providers charge nothing or a monthly subscription fee but gives no amounts, and documents no sizing rule and no follower stop or pause control, so the grades above 4 are possible and not established. The evidence is one short page that never uses the word 'automatic' for signals and carries a third-party notice; the MAM account is a manager tool and is not counted.
Missing How copied volume is sized, what stop or pause control a follower has, the fees a follower pays, and whether the service is offered on MT5 accounts.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Baxia Global Limited, Seychelles, CFDs on MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5, retail and professional clientsEstablished from documents
Baxia Global Limited's execution policy says it will generally pass market orders to a third party, which may be a broker and an affiliated company, and that it may transmit orders to third-party liquidity providers, while it is always principal, sole counterparty and sole execution venue. 'Generally' and 'may' leave the choice with the firm, part of the route can stay inside the group, and the policy mentions internal risk limits on accepting orders; the client agreement lets the firm refuse an order it believes it cannot hedge. That is discretionary external transmission, not a blanket or per-fill commitment. The website's STP and no-dealing-desk wording is marketing and does not change the policy.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Baxia Markets brand partner programmes (website pages name no contracting company; the Baxia Global Ltd client agreement, cl. 15, allows fees to introducing brokers and affiliates)Established from documents
The brand documents both models. The Introducing Broker programme pays a rebate for each trade that referred clients close, and the Regional Representative programme extends those commissions to a region. The Forex Affiliate Program pays up to USD 800 per referred account under a negotiated deal, which the page itself labels CPA. Both IB and CPA documented gives 4. The refer-a-friend bonus is a client referral reward and is not counted as either.
-
27overallequal
CWG Markets
Assessment summary Best Costs 8 · weakest Structure 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
3.0/104 penalties
Breakdown for CWG Markets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–7 · missing whether CWG MARKETS SA (PTY) LTD (South Africa) and CWG Markets Ltd (United Kingdom) open client accounts or execute orders under the brand today, and a group statement that lists every operating company.
- Published costs8TECN: published account tariff. USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named ECN account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The account-level spread floor is advertised generally, not as an observed EUR/USD average. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing how copied volume is sized, what stop or pause control a follower has, and what a follower pays, stated on a product page or in product terms for CWG Copy Trading.
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the names of the financial institutions that act as execution venue under clause 22.1, whether any of them is a group company, and whether clause 22.1 or the own-order-book clauses govern a retail CFD order.
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing whether the brand pays partners per funded client (CPA) in any programme, or a statement that it does not.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review of CWG Markets as presented on cwgmarkets.com, not a single account offer. A-book rests on the order execution policy of CWG Markets Ltd (Vanuatu, VFSC company no. 41694), the only company whose client documents the site publishes. Costs, copy trading and partner programmes come from pages of the same site that name no contracting company. The earlier screening looked at the UK company (CWG Markets Ltd, FCA FRN 785129): its site cwgmarkets.co.uk could not be read on 19 Nov 2026 and nothing from it is used. CWG MARKETS SA (PTY) LTD (South Africa) is named by the site; no client documents for it were found and nothing from it is used.
Summary The site publishes client documents only for CWG Markets Ltd (Vanuatu): its execution policy names third financial institutions as the execution venue for CFDs while also describing the firm's own order book, the ECN account publishes a minimum spread and USD 6 round-trip commission with no average, automated copy trading and a volume-based introducing-broker programme are described without full terms, and the roles of the South African and UK companies are not settled by the documents.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–7. Not a finding.Scope: CWG Markets brand; CWG Markets Ltd (Vanuatu), CWG MARKETS SA (PTY) LTD (South Africa), CWG Markets Ltd (United Kingdom)Investigated, not settled
One client-contracting company is documented: CWG Markets Ltd in Vanuatu, the company behind every client document on the site and listed as an active financial dealer by the Vanuatu regulator. The site's footer text says the group consists of that company and CWG MARKETS SA (PTY) LTD in South Africa, for which only a licence is stated, and the same footer refers to a UK company (an authorised firm with a London address) without listing it; the UK company exists at Companies House, but its own site could not be read. A licence or registration alone does not raise the count and the group's list leaves out a company it names elsewhere, so one jurisdiction is a lower bound: 7 if Vanuatu is the only operating jurisdiction, 4 if the South African or the UK company also operates, 2 if both do, lower if there are more.
Missing Whether CWG MARKETS SA (PTY) LTD (South Africa) and CWG Markets Ltd (United Kingdom) open client accounts or execute orders under the brand today, and a group statement that lists every operating company.
Count lower bound 1
11 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: ECN: published account tariff; USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: ECN; CWG Markets brand, cwgmarkets.com (client documents on the site are those of CWG Markets Ltd, Vanuatu; the pricing pages name no company), ECN account, EUR/USD, USD accountPublished tariff assessment (ECN); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named ECN account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The account-level spread floor is advertised generally, not as an observed EUR/USD average. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A broker-published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for the ECN or the Standard account, with its observation period.
Round turn commission USD 6Spread basis advertised minimum for the account, all instruments; no average or typical figure published
10 addresses tried
- Copy trading 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: CWG Markets brand, CWG Copy Trading in the client zone of cwgmarkets.com; the pages name no company (client documents on the site are those of CWG Markets Ltd, Vanuatu, and do not describe copy trading)Investigated, not settled
The brand presents Copy Trading as its own feature, and the landing page it links to says a follower chooses a signal provider and the provider's trades are then replicated automatically in the follower's account. That documents automated leader/follower copying. No sizing rule is documented; a fee of USD 1 to 15 per lot and a drawdown stop setting appear only in the site's glossary, which is general text that also describes accounts the site does not offer, and stop/start wording sits in script text that the current page may not display. The higher grades are therefore possible and not established.
Missing How copied volume is sized, what stop or pause control a follower has, and what a follower pays, stated on a product page or in product terms for CWG Copy Trading.
8 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: CWG Markets Ltd, Vanuatu, CFDs, all clients; governed by the law of VanuatuInvestigated, not settled
The execution policy of CWG Markets Ltd (Vanuatu) says that for CFD orders one or more third financial institutions will be the execution venue and not the company; read alone that is a blanket external route. The same policy says the company runs its own trading venue with an order book in which orders are matched, is always the counterparty, and may at its discretion decline to transmit an order; it does not name the institutions, and the list it promises was not found, so a route to a group company cannot be excluded. That leaves 6 if clause 22.1 governs and the venues are outside the group, and 4 if the own-venue clauses apply to CFDs or the venue is a group company. The site's ECN, STP and no-dealing-desk wording is marketing and does not decide it.
Missing The names of the financial institutions that act as execution venue under clause 22.1, whether any of them is a group company, and whether clause 22.1 or the own-order-book clauses govern a retail CFD order.
6 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: CWG Markets brand partner programmes on cwgmarkets.com (pages name no contracting company)Investigated, not settled
The brand documents an introducing-broker programme for 'Introducing Brokers and Affiliates' with a multi-tier commission structure that grows with the partner's network and trading volume, on custom deals; the glossary describes IB commission as revenue per lot traded by a referral. No page read mentions a payment per funded client, and none says such payments are not offered. IB pay documented and CPA not found gives 4–10, because not finding CPA is not proof that it is not offered, least of all where deals are custom.
Missing Whether the brand pays partners per funded client (CPA) in any programme, or a statement that it does not.
6 addresses tried
-
28overallequal
FP Markets
Profile Best Costs, Copy 6 · weakest Structure 0
Availability not confirmedAustralian company on file
3.0/102 penalties
Breakdown for FP Markets
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs6USD 7.60 round trip
- Copy trading6PPenalty: low end of 6–10 · missing how a follower's copied volume is sized (the copy modes and their rules), a current statement of follower stop/pause controls, and which licensed entity offers Social Trading to followers.
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing whether any current account type has the Cyprus company itself as execution venue (policy s. 7.1) or every order is passed on as agent (agreement s. 15.1); and the execution and hedging terms of First Prudential Markets Pty Ltd, the affiliated venue that received all retail volume.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope First Prudential Markets Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC 371/18) for costs and execution; FP Markets Ltd (Saint Lucia) publishes the partner and Social Trading pages. Pages of First Prudential Markets Pty Ltd (Australia) on fpmarkets.com refused retrieval on 18 Nov 2026.
Summary The Cyprus entity publishes an average Raw EUR/USD spread and an agreement that says orders are executed as agent, while the group spans at least five jurisdictions and pays CPA as well as rebates.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: FP Markets brand, group levelEstablished from documents
The brand's own footer disclosure says FP Markets operates through entities in Seychelles, Australia, South Africa and Kenya, and the EU site is run by a separate CySEC-authorised Cyprus company. That is at least five operating jurisdictions, so the grade is 0 even as a lower bound. A Saint Lucia company operates the group websites and is not needed for the count. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 5
- Published costs 6Grade 6: USD over 7 to 10Scope: First Prudential Markets Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC 371/18), Raw account on MT4, USD account, EEA retail clientsEstablished from documents
The Cyprus entity publishes typical (average) MT4 spreads for November 2026: EUR/USD averages 0.16 pips on the Raw account and 1.26 pips on Standard. Raw commission is USD 3 per lot per side, USD 6 round trip, on a USD account. That gives USD 7.60 per round-trip lot on Raw, the cheaper of the two ordinary retail accounts. The Australian entity's account pages refused retrieval today, so its AUD 3.50 per side Raw account is not graded here.
Account Raw (MT4), First Prudential Markets Ltd (Cyprus)Average spread pips 0.16Round turn commission USD 6Indicative cost USD 7.6Spread basis published 'typical' average, table dated November 2026
2 addresses tried
- Copy trading 6PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 6–10. Not a finding.Scope: FP Markets Social Trading (MT4/MT5) as published by FP Markets Ltd (Saint Lucia); the entity contracting with followers is not stated. Not First Prudential Markets Ltd (Cyprus).Investigated, not settled
FP Markets Ltd (Saint Lucia) documents FP Markets Social Trading on MT4 and MT5: followers subscribe and a provider's trades are copied automatically, and providers set a performance fee of 0% to 50% charged per trade, day, week or month. The pages mention copy modes and allocation methods without stating a sizing rule, and the follower on/off control appears only on an archived 19 March 2026 copy because fpmarkets.com refused retrieval today. Automation plus fees gives at least 6; sizing and current follower controls are unverified. The Cyprus entity's site has no copy-trading page, so nothing here is established for that entity.
Missing How a follower's copied volume is sized (the copy modes and their rules), a current statement of follower stop/pause controls, and which licensed entity offers Social Trading to followers.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: First Prudential Markets Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC 371/18), CFD accounts, EEA clients. Not the Australian, Seychelles, South African or Kenyan entities.Investigated, not settled
The Cyprus entity's client agreement says it executes every CFD order as agent at a third-party execution venue and not as principal against the client. Its execution policy, which forms part of that agreement, says that depending on the account type either the company or a third-party liquidity provider is the venue, and that the venue list can be changed at the company's discretion. In 2024 all retail volume went to First Prudential Markets Pty Ltd, an affiliated Australian company whose own hedging terms could not be read today. The blanket agency wording supports 6; the either/or venue clause supports 4.
Missing Whether any current account type has the Cyprus company itself as execution venue (policy s. 7.1) or every order is passed on as agent (agreement s. 15.1); and the execution and hedging terms of First Prudential Markets Pty Ltd, the affiliated venue that received all retail volume.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: FP Markets partner programme (fpmarketspartners.com, operated by FP Markets Ltd, Saint Lucia), brand levelEstablished from documents
The brand's partner site documents both models: volume-based rebates for introducing brokers and a one-off CPA per qualified client for affiliates, plus a hybrid of the two. Both documented gives 4. The Cyprus client agreement also allows a fee to introducers. These are brand programmes and not an entitlement in every country.
-
29overallequal
2.9/104 penalties
Breakdown for Trade.com
- Company structure2Three or four
- Published costs0PAll-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to a named TCM Ltd account, and the FX commission (if any).
- Copy trading6PPenalty: low end of 6–10 · missing how the follower's allocation is turned into position size (proportional, fixed ratio or other).
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the identity of TCM's current CFD liquidity provider(s) and whether any is a group company, or policy wording committing every order to a third-party provider.
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing whether any Trade.com partner programme pays a fixed amount per funded client (CPA), or an affirmative statement that it does not.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across Trade.com companies, not a single account offer. Costs, copy trading, the A-book commitment and the partner terms rest on one company, Trade Capital Markets (TCM) Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC 227/14), whose EU-site pages (read through the site's own page API, because this connection is redirected from /en/eu/ to the global site) and current legal PDFs could be read. Company structure rests on the group's FY2025 disclosure report by Trade Capital Holding (TCH) Ltd and the live group-licence page. The global route, Lead Capital Global Ltd (Mauritius, FSC C119023948), is recorded in facts only; nothing is carried from one company to another.
Summary The Trade Capital group lists four investment firms in four jurisdictions; for its Cyprus company TCM Ltd, a copy-trading app with allocation, stop and profit-share fee is documented, CFDs are executed back-to-back with a liquidity provider whose outside-group status is not settled for the current policy, published EUR/USD spreads are minimums only (at least USD 8 a lot), and introducers are paid a share of spread while CPA was not found.
- Company structure 2Grade 2: three or fourScope: Trade.com brand; Trade Capital Holding (TCH) Ltd group, FY2025 and live site 19 Nov 2026Established from documents
The group's FY2025 disclosure report gives its own list of the investment firms it consolidates: Trade Capital Markets (TCM) Ltd in Cyprus, Trade Capital UK (TCUK) Ltd in the UK, Trade Capital Markets (TCM) North America LLC in the US and Lead Capital Global Ltd in Mauritius. The live Trade.com group-licence page lists the same four. Three are clearly operating brokerages (Cyprus and Mauritius serve the Trade.com brand, the US firm is an approved retail equity broker-dealer). The UK firm still exists and is FCA-listed on the brand page, but the earlier screening read a notice that it has ceased regulated business, so the count is 3 or 4. Both fall in the 3–4 band, so the grade is 2.
Count lower bound 3
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Trade Capital Markets (TCM) Ltd, Cyprus; Classic account tiers (WebTrader and MT5 not priced separately on the page), EUR-sized accountsInvestigated, not settled
TCM Ltd's account page shows four retail tiers with EUR/USD spreads of 1.9 (Silver), 1.4 (Gold), 1.0 (Platinum) and 0.8 pips (Exclusive, EUR 100,000 account size), and labels all of them as minimums. No FX commission is listed on the account page or the forex page ('no commissions'), although the fees page mentions a commission on FX without an amount. No average or typical EUR/USD spread is published, so only a lower bound applies: the cheapest minimum, 0.8 pips, means at least USD 8 a round-trip lot, which caps the grade at 6.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to a named TCM Ltd account, and the FX commission (if any).
Account Exclusive (TCM Ltd, EUR 100,000 account size)
5 addresses tried
- Copy trading 6PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 6–10. Not a finding.Scope: Trade Capital Markets (TCM) Ltd, Cyprus; TRADE.com Copy Trading app, MT5 live accountInvestigated, not settled
TCM Ltd presents TRADE.com Copy Trading as its own app linked to the client's MT5 live account: trades of a chosen trader are copied automatically according to the follower's allocation. The page also documents the fee basis (a performance fee as a percentage of profits, shown before copying) and the follower's control to adjust or stop copying at any time. It says sizing follows the allocation but does not describe how the allocation converts into trade size, and no copy terms were found, so the sizing rule is unverified.
Missing How the follower's allocation is turned into position size (proportional, fixed ratio or other).
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: Trade Capital Markets (TCM) Ltd, Cyprus; CFDs, retail clientsInvestigated, not settled
TCM Ltd's 2026 execution policy commits to matched-principal (back-to-back) execution for CFDs: each client order is filled by TCM and at the same time placed as an identical order with the designated liquidity provider. That is at least a back-to-back route (4). Whether the route leaves the group is not settled for the current documents: the policy names no external provider (its provider table lists TCM itself) and allows for an intra-group venue, and the client agreement says TCM 'may' pass orders to third-party liquidity providers. The 2024 execution quality statement says TCM had no close links with any of its five venues, but that is a past year and the venues are unnamed.
Missing The identity of TCM's current CFD liquidity provider(s) and whether any is a group company, or policy wording committing every order to a third-party provider.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Trade Capital Markets (TCM) Ltd, Cyprus; introducer remuneration and Partnership ProgrammeInvestigated, not settled
TCM Ltd's client agreement says it pays partners (associates, business introducers, tied agents) a percentage of the spread, a fixed fee or another agreed method; a share of spread paid to introducers is an IB/revenue-share arrangement. Its Partnership Programme page advertises monthly commissions but states no trigger, and no per-funded-client (CPA) payment was found. Absence is not proof, so the range is 4–10.
Missing Whether any Trade.com partner programme pays a fixed amount per funded client (CPA), or an affirmative statement that it does not.
4 addresses tried
-
30overallequal
CMTrading
Assessment summary Best 3 criteria 4 · weakest Costs, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.8/103 penalties
Breakdown for CMTrading
- Company structure4Two
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 10 round-turn commission plus spread. All-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–4 · missing an average or typical EUR/USD spread that the broker labels for a named account (ECN or standard), and the unit of the ECN commission (per standard lot or other).
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing an affirmative statement that the partner programme pays no CPA, or a published CPA plan.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope CMTrading / GCMT Limited (Seychelles, FSA SD070) for costs, copy and abook; structure and affiliate are brand-level (GCMT Group Ltd). Brand-level feature review, not an account offer; country eligibility not assessed.
Summary The group's own partner agreement lists two operating companies and the Seychelles client agreement makes the firm a market maker that hedges at its own discretion; only minimum spreads are published, copy trading is named without a description, and a revenue-share referral programme is documented while CPA was not found.
- Company structure 4Grade 4: twoScope: CMTrading brand, GCMT Group Ltd and subsidiariesEstablished from documents
The group's own partner agreement says GCMT Group Ltd is the parent of a group operating under two licensed companies: GCMT Limited (Seychelles) and GCMT SA (Pty) Ltd (South Africa). The legal hub publishes client agreements for exactly these two, and the South African one is signed with GCMT SA as agent while the Seychelles company is issuer and principal. Other named companies have a stated non-brokerage role and are not counted (UAE introducer, Cyprus payment company, holding company). Caveat: the Seychelles agreement locates the company's own trading desk at a Limassol address; it is described as operated by GCMT Limited, so it is treated as premises and not as a third operating company.
Count lower bound 2
2 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: CMTrading website pricing; entity per footer GCMT Limited (Seychelles); ECN conditions on a Premium account, USD account, platform not stated on the pageInvestigated, not settled
Only minimum EUR/USD spreads are published. ECN conditions show 'as low as 0.1' with USD 5 per leg on Premium and USD 7 per leg on Gold accounts; the standard Gold, Premium and VIP accounts show commission 0 and 'as low as 1.9'; Basic and Trader spreads are only labelled 'Regular' and 'Plus'. No average or typical spread is published for any account, so the cheapest minimum caps the grade and nothing fixes it from below.
Missing An average or typical EUR/USD spread that the broker labels for a named account (ECN or standard), and the unit of the ECN commission (per standard lot or other).
Account ECN conditions on a Premium account (deposit USD 85,000+); platform not stated on the pricing pageAverage spread published noRound turn commission USD 10Lower bound cost USD 11
5 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: GCMT Limited (Seychelles) and the CMTrading websites; brand levelInvestigated, not settled
Copy trading is named but not described. The Seychelles client agreement says the company will provide the service of copy trading, the partner site mentions 'our very own copytrading platform', and a general article explains social trading with reference to platforms such as MetaTrader 5. None of them names a product or documents automation, sizing, follower controls or fees, and nothing states that copying is not offered.
Missing A broker document that describes the copy service: that follower trades open automatically, how they are sized, how a follower stops or pauses, and what is charged.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: GCMT Limited (Seychelles), retail client agreement, all account types including ECN conditions; South African clients reach the same principal through GCMT SA as agent (a group company)Established from documents
The Seychelles client agreement calls GCMT Limited a market maker that is principal to every order and the only execution venue, and its hedging clause covers the hedges the firm deems necessary. The group's partner agreement adds that the company decides at its sole discretion which positions to hedge, when and where. That is hedging at the firm's discretion, which the anchor grades 4. The ECN page's description of orders passed to banks and prime brokers is marketing with no matching clause in the agreement; nothing excludes external hedging, so the grade is not 0.
1 address tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: CMTrading brand partner programmes (GCMT Group Ltd); individual partner terms are separateInvestigated, not settled
The Business Referral programme (formerly IB programme) pays partners a monthly share of the net revenue of referred clients, and the partner site describes commission and rebates tied to the network's trading volume. No CPA payment was found in the agreement or on the partner pages, but the agreement leaves the rate to each partner's profile and nothing states that CPA is not offered. A separate Refer a Friend bonus for clients is recorded by mechanism only.
Missing An affirmative statement that the partner programme pays no CPA, or a published CPA plan.
4 addresses tried
-
31overallequal
Spreadex
Assessment summary Best 3 criteria 4 · weakest Costs, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.8/103 penalties
Breakdown for Spreadex
- Company structure4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the stated function of Spreadex Danmark APS: whether it is an operating or client-contracting brokerage company, or a company with no client business of its own.
- Published costs0PAll-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–8 · missing an average or typical EUR/USD spread that Spreadex publishes for its CFD account, with the observation period; and a plain statement that forex CFDs carry no commission.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not an account offer: Spreadex Limited (St Albans, England; company 03720378; FCA firm reference 190941 by its own statement), financial spread betting and CFD accounts under its Financial Spread Betting and CFD Customer Agreement last updated 28 October 2026. Costs, copy, abook and affiliate all rest on this one company; structure is read at group level from the 2025 accounts of the ultimate parent, Spreadex.Com Limited. The sports betting business of the same company is out of scope.
Summary One UK company contracts every financial client, its policy lets it choose whether to hedge (A-book 4) and both a CPA deal and volume- or outcome-based introducer commission are documented (affiliate 4); the cost is open because only a minimum EUR/USD spread of 0.6 is published (0–8), no copy service is described or excluded (0–10), and structure stays 4–10 until the function of the Danish subsidiary on the parent's list is read.
- Company structure 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Spreadex.Com Limited group (Spreadex brand), group level, year to 31 May 2025 accounts and pages read 19 November 2026Investigated, not settled
Group boundary: Spreadex.Com Limited (England and Wales, no controlling party above it) and its subsidiaries. Its 2025 accounts list exactly three: Spreadex Limited, Sporting Index Limited and Spreadex Danmark APS. Spreadex Limited is the only company that contracts financial spread betting and CFD clients, and Sporting Index Limited is an English sports spread betting company, so the United Kingdom is the one jurisdiction established. The accounts state no function for Spreadex Danmark APS. The Danish site read today is sports betting only and names Spreadex Ltd as the Danish licensee, so nothing shows the Danish company as an operating brokerage; but its function is not stated in any document I could read and the Danish company register refused the request. With a closed list the count is therefore one (grade 10) or two (grade 4). This reflects the owner's simplicity preference and is not a safety finding.
Missing The stated function of Spreadex Danmark APS: whether it is an operating or client-contracting brokerage company, or a company with no client business of its own.
Count lower bound 1
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–8. Not a finding.Scope: Spreadex Limited, CFD Account (single account type; Spreadex platform, TradingView connection), Spot EUR/USD CFD, 10 contracts = one standard lot, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
Spreadex Limited has one ordinary account for CFDs, with no tiers, and prices EUR/USD as a variable spread 'from 0.6' on the forex page, the CFD market information table and the EUR/USD market sheet. That is a minimum. No average or typical EUR/USD spread is published: the spread betting table's introduction mentions average widths but the table shows only the 'from' column. The forex CFD example in the cost disclosure charges spread and funding only, and no forex commission is listed. A minimum of 0.6 means at least USD 6 for one lot, so the grade cannot be above 8, and without an average there is no exact grade.
Missing An average or typical EUR/USD spread that Spreadex publishes for its CFD account, with the observation period; and a plain statement that forex CFDs carry no commission.
Account CFD Account (the single ordinary account; Spreadex platform, TradingView connection), Spreadex LimitedLower bound cost USD 6
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Spreadex Limited, Spreadex platform and TradingView connection, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No page or term of Spreadex Limited read today describes a service that copies a leader's trades into a follower's account. The platform page lists Spreadex's own platform and a TradingView connection, with no MetaTrader, cTrader or copy feature; the only signal product is Autochartist trade suggestions, which are manual signals and do not count. The site map and the customer agreement contain no reference to copy, social or mirror trading. Nothing says copy trading is not offered, including through third parties, so the range stays open.
Missing Either a Spreadex Limited document describing an automated leader/follower service with its sizing rule, follower controls and fees, or an explicit statement that no copy trading, including third-party integrations, is offered.
7 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Spreadex Limited, financial spread bets and CFDs on the Betting Account and CFD Account, retail and professional clients, United KingdomEstablished from documents
Spreadex Limited's execution policy, which its customer agreement incorporates, says the firm manages its risk as a market maker, is the client's only execution venue and may choose to hedge all or part of an order in the underlying market. The agreement adds that it frequently hedges with other institutions and may also hedge a client's short position internally against other clients, at its discretion. That is discretionary, mixed handling written into the policy: grade 4. It does not show that any given trade is kept in-house. The venues it names are outside firms, not group companies, but there is no commitment to route every order to them.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Spreadex Limited, Spreadex Affiliate Scheme and introducer commissions for financial spread betting and CFD clients, United KingdomEstablished from documents
Both models are documented for Spreadex Limited's financial trading business. Its affiliate scheme page, addressed to introducing brokers and webmasters, offers several commission structures including a CPA arrangement and says commissions are paid for new trading accounts. Its customer agreement says it may pay a person who introduced a client a commission based on the volume and/or outcome of that client's business, which is ongoing pay tied to trading. Both documented gives 4. The ongoing side rests on a permissive clause in the client terms, and no rates or partner agreement are published.
2 addresses tried
-
32overallequal
Alpari
Assessment summary Best Costs 10 · weakest Structure, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.7/103 penalties
Breakdown for Alpari
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a group-level primary source that lists every operating company of the Alpari brand and says how Alpari Eurasia LLC relates to Parlance Trading Ltd; and the regulator entries for both companies.
- Published costs10TPro ECN: published account tariff. USD 5 tariff floor: USD 5 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 10/10 for the named Pro ECN account: USD 5 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 5 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. This is the published Pro ECN account floor. The EUR/USD MT5 instrument table uses points without defining the conversion to pips; no pair-specific average or zero-spread execution is asserted. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Pro ECN requires a USD 500 minimum deposit.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing either a document or page of Parlance Trading Ltd that offers CPA (which would make the grade 4), or an affirmative statement that the partner programme pays rebates only and no CPA (which would make it 10).
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not an account offer: Parlance Trading Ltd (Mwali/Mohéli, Comoros Union, licence T2023236 as stated by the company, alpari.com) for costs, PAMM, execution terms and the partner programme; structure at brand level, which also takes in Alpari Eurasia LLC (Belarus, alpari.by). No fact from the Belarus company is used for the product criteria.
Summary Parlance Trading Ltd's Terms of Business leave the hedging policy to the company's sole discretion and its partner agreement documents per-lot and spread-share rebates with no CPA found; a PAMM service is described but its classification as copy trading is a judgement, only minimum spreads are published, and the jurisdiction count is a lower bound.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: Alpari brand, all disclosed operating companiesInvestigated, not settled
Two operating companies in two jurisdictions use the Alpari brand in their own current disclosures: Parlance Trading Ltd in the Comoros Union (Mwali), which contracts with clients of alpari.com, and Alpari Eurasia LLC in Belarus, which runs alpari.by with its own account-opening agreements. No group-level list of companies was found and neither site states how the two companies are related, so two is a lower bound: two gives 4, three or four give 2, five or more give 0. Neither regulator register could be opened, so both licences rest on the companies' own statements.
Missing A group-level primary source that lists every operating company of the Alpari brand and says how Alpari Eurasia LLC relates to Parlance Trading Ltd; and the regulator entries for both companies.
Count lower bound 2
8 addresses tried
- Published costs 10TAssigned tariff grade 10; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–10.Tariff basis: Pro ECN: published account tariff; USD 5 tariff floor: USD 5 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Pro ECN; Parlance Trading Ltd, Pro ECN account, MT4 and MT5, USD account, EUR/USDPublished tariff assessment (Pro ECN); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 10/10 for the named Pro ECN account: USD 5 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 5 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. This is the published Pro ECN account floor. The EUR/USD MT5 instrument table uses points without defining the conversion to pips; no pair-specific average or zero-spread execution is asserted. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Pro ECN requires a USD 500 minimum deposit.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for a named Parlance Trading Ltd account (Pro ECN or another).
Account Pro ECN (MT4 and MT5), Parlance Trading LtdRound turn commission USD 5Lower bound cost USD 5Average spread published no
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Parlance Trading Ltd, PAMM service (separate investment account), Comoros (Mwali)Investigated, not settled
What Alpari documents is a PAMM service: investors place funds with a manager and results are allocated in proportion to each share of a pooled account. That is pooled management, not automated copying of a leader's trades into a follower's own account, and the rubric does not count managed or model portfolios. No leader/follower copy product was found for Parlance Trading Ltd, and nothing says copy trading is not offered, so the grade is open.
Missing An Alpari-documented service that copies a leader's trades automatically into a follower's own account, or a statement that copy trading is not offered.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Parlance Trading Ltd, CFDs on MT4/MT5 (all account types), Comoros (Mwali)Established from documents
The Terms of Business give Parlance Trading Ltd sole and absolute discretion to choose the hedging policy for any or all client instructions, to act as intermediary with a liquidity provider if it so chooses, and to change that policy at any time without notice. The Client Agreement says the company may be the other side of a trade as a principal on its own account or as a matched principal. Orders can be declined when external liquidity to hedge is lacking, which shows hedging is used but not that every trade is hedged. Discretion between hedging and keeping the position is the anchor for 4. Liquidity providers are not named, so whether any is a group company is not known; that does not change the grade.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Parlance Trading Ltd, Alpari Partners (Introducing Partnership) programmeInvestigated, not settled
Parlance Trading Ltd's Introducing Partnership Agreement of October 2025 pays introducers rebates as a fixed USD amount per lot and/or a percentage of the spread or commission, by tier, with sub-introducer levels. The partner page describes the same thing as commission each time a referred client trades. No CPA or per-client payment appears in the agreement, on the partner pages or in the help centre, but nothing states that CPA is not offered, and absence is not proof. Introducing-broker pay documented and CPA not found gives 4-10.
Missing Either a document or page of Parlance Trading Ltd that offers CPA (which would make the grade 4), or an affirmative statement that the partner programme pays rebates only and no CPA (which would make it 10).
5 addresses tried
-
33overallequal
Deriv
Assessment summary Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.7/102 penalties
Breakdown for Deriv
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing whether the CPA plan for affiliates registered under Deriv Investments (Europe) Limited is currently offered, or a statement that CPA is not offered.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across Deriv group companies, not a single account offer: costs and A-book on Deriv (BVI) Ltd (Deriv MT5 Standard and Zero Spread accounts, British Virgin Islands); copy on Deriv (SVG) LLC (Deriv cTrader, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), because the General Terms link cTrader accounts to that company only. Deriv Investments (Europe) Limited (Malta) is counted for structure and its execution wording is recorded as a fact only; deriv.com/eu redirected to the global site from this connection.
Summary Nine disclosed client-contracting jurisdictions give the lowest structure grade; Deriv cTrader copy trading is documented with automation, sizing, follower controls and fees, and the BVI terms leave passing orders to a liquidity provider to the firm's discretion, while no average EUR/USD spread is published and it is not settled whether a CPA plan is still offered.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Deriv brand, group levelEstablished from documents
The General Terms name eight companies a client may contract with, each in a different jurisdiction and each with its own governing law, and the EU supplementary terms add a Malta company. Nine client-contracting jurisdictions is above the threshold of five, which gives 0 without needing a closed group list.
Count lower bound 9
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Deriv (BVI) Ltd, Deriv MT5 Standard and Zero Spread accounts, EUR/USD, British Virgin Islands (Standard is also linked to Deriv (SVG) LLC)Investigated, not settled
Deriv publishes only minimum spreads for its MT5 accounts (Standard from 0.1 pips, Financial from 0.2, Swap-Free from 0.3, Zero Spread from 0) and a platform-level EUR/USD minimum of 0.6 pip with a target spread in percent; no average or typical EUR/USD spread is published for any account. The Zero Spread account charges a commission whose client amount is not stated on the pages read, so neither bound of the range can be narrowed.
Missing A Deriv-published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to a named retail account, and the client commission per lot on the Zero Spread account.
10 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Deriv (SVG) LLC, Deriv cTrader copy trading, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (General Terms cl. 2.3.8.3 link cTrader CFD accounts to this company)Established from documents
Deriv presents copy trading as part of its own Deriv cTrader platform and documents that trades are copied automatically in real time, that copied size follows the ratio of provider equity to copier equity, that the copier can stop, pause or set an equity stop loss, and that providers charge performance, management and volume fees with no extra charge from Deriv. All four elements are documented, which is the 10 anchor. The sizing rule comes from Deriv blog posts dated November 2023 that are still published.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Deriv (BVI) Ltd, Deriv MT5 Standard and Zero Spread accounts, British Virgin IslandsEstablished from documents
The additional terms of Deriv (BVI) Ltd say the company is the counterparty, acts either as agent or as principal and sole execution venue, and that a Deriv MT5 order may be passed to a liquidity provider. Passing orders on is allowed but not promised, which is the discretionary anchor. The provider is not named.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Deriv partner programme on deriv.com (global site); the CPA document concerns affiliates registered under Deriv Investments (Europe) Limited and clients with an EU accountInvestigated, not settled
The current partner page documents revenue-share and volume-based payments: 40% of revenue on options, 30% of exchange trading fees, a per-turnover commission on CFDs and 7.5% of referred partners' commissions. A CPA plan (USD 100 once a referred EU-account client has deposited USD 100) appears only in an undated PDF on Deriv's document host whose other rates no longer match the partner page, and the current affiliate terms have no CPA clause. Whether CPA is still offered is therefore open, and nothing states that it is not.
Missing Whether the CPA plan for affiliates registered under Deriv Investments (Europe) Limited is currently offered, or a statement that CPA is not offered.
9 addresses tried
-
34overallequal
Doo Prime
Assessment summary Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.7/102 penalties
Breakdown for Doo Prime
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a closed list of the D Prime brand's operating companies, and whether the Seychelles licence holder (Doo Financial Lite SC Limited) and D Prime Mauritius Limited still take D Prime clients.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not an account offer. The brand now trades as D Prime (dooprime.com; formerly Doo Prime). Costs, copy, abook and affiliate rest on D Prime Vanuatu Limited (Vanuatu, VFSC company number 700238), the company named in the client agreement and in the footer of dooprime.com. Structure is a brand-level count across D Prime's own sites (Vanuatu, Mauritius, Seychelles); nothing from the Mauritius or Seychelles company is used for the product criteria.
Summary Automated copy trading with sizing modes, follower stop controls and fees is documented, and both an IB and a CPA partner programme are published; the execution policy leaves external transmission to the firm's discretion, no average EUR/USD spread or ECN commission amount is published, and the brand names at least three operating jurisdictions without a closed list.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: D Prime (formerly Doo Prime) brand; Doo Group companies outside the brand are not countedInvestigated, not settled
D Prime's own sites disclose three jurisdictions. The client agreement is with D Prime Vanuatu Limited. The brand's Chinese-language site says a client may establish a business relationship with any of its regulated entities and lists a Seychelles company (FSA SD090), D Prime Mauritius Limited (Mauritius FSC C119023907) and the Vanuatu company; the English licences page lists the Seychelles and Vanuatu numbers. The lists differ between the two sites, the Seychelles licence holder is Doo Financial Lite SC Limited, which trades under the Doo Financial brand, and no closed list of D Prime operating companies exists, so the count is a lower bound of three. If the Seychelles company were not accepted as a D Prime company the bound would be two (0–4).
Missing A closed list of the D Prime brand's operating companies, and whether the Seychelles licence holder (Doo Financial Lite SC Limited) and D Prime Mauritius Limited still take D Prime clients.
Count lower bound 3
8 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: D Prime Vanuatu Limited; Cent, STP and ECN accounts (MT4, MT5, D Prime InTrade, TradingView), USDInvestigated, not settled
D Prime publishes only minimum spreads: from 1 pip on Cent and STP with no commission, and from 0.0 pips on ECN, where a transaction fee applies but no amount per lot is given. No average or typical EUR/USD spread is published for any account, so there is no exact grade. The STP minimum alone would cap that account at 6, but the ECN account has no usable dollar lower bound, so the brand's range stays open.
Missing A EUR/USD average or typical spread labelled for the ECN (or STP) account, and the ECN commission per lot.
Spread basis advertised minimums only; EUR/USD is not named in any spread figure
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: D Prime Vanuatu Limited; SmartPicks Copytrading (MT5) on dooprime.com and the First Schedule of its client agreement; sizing modes from the D Prime help centre (MT4 and MT5)Established from documents
D Prime documents its own automated leader/follower product, SmartPicks Copytrading on MT5: followers copy Master Traders automatically in real time. The site and the client agreement's First Schedule document follower sizing (allocation size and direction; equity proportion, multiplier or fixed modes in the help centre), stop controls (stop copying at any time, lot and drawdown limits, an equity stop-copying level, Max Loss detach) and fees (performance fee on a high-water mark, registration and management fees, deducted automatically). PAMM, offered beside it, is not counted. The help-centre article is titled 'Flexible CopyTrading' and names no legal entity; the grade does not depend on it alone, since the site page and the agreement already state automation, size configuration, stop control and fees.
1 address tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: D Prime Vanuatu Limited, all account types (Cent, STP, ECN)Established from documents
The execution policy says the company acts as principal at all times, is the sole counterparty and sole execution venue, and only reserves a right to transmit client orders to third-party liquidity providers. The client agreement adds that it may delegate transactions to another executing broker, which may be a related company or an unaffiliated third party. External transmission is therefore at the firm's discretion and nothing commits it to route every order outside the group. 'Direct market access' and '20 top global banks and liquidity providers' on the pricing page are marketing statements and do not change this.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: D Prime brand partner programmes on dooprime.com (site of D Prime Vanuatu Limited)Established from documents
D Prime publishes two partner programmes on dooprime.com. The Introducing Broker programme pays commissions based on referred clients' trading activity through rebate tiers and revenue-sharing models. The CPA Affiliate Program pays a fixed amount per qualified referred account. Both IB or revenue share and CPA are documented.
-
35overallequal
EBC Financial Group
Assessment summary Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.7/102 penalties
Breakdown for EBC Financial Group
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing which companies contract with clients who open an account through ebc.com (the footer says the client chooses an entity), in particular whether EBC Financial Group (SVG) LLC, the South African company and the Comoros company open client accounts or execute orders; and a group statement that lists all operating companies.
- Published costs0PAll-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–8 · missing a broker-published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for the Professional or the Standard Account with its observation period, and whether the Professional Account's 6 USD/lot commission is per side or per round trip.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across EBC Financial Group companies, not a single account offer. A-book rests on the Execution Policy published on ebc.com, which is issued by EBC Financial Group (MU) Limited (Mauritius, FSC reference GB24203273). Costs, copy trading and partner programmes come from ebc.com pages and the brand's help centre, which name no contracting company; the site's Website Terms say EBC Financial (MU) Limited owns ebc.com, while the site footer names EBC Financial Group (SVG) LLC first and says the Mauritius company's website is maintained separately. EBC Financial Group (UK) Ltd, the company in the earlier screening, accepts professional clients and eligible counterparties only and is used for the structure count alone; nothing from the UK or Cayman company is used for costs, copy or A-book.
Summary The execution policy published on ebc.com (Mauritius company) leaves external routing to the firm's discretion, the brand documents its own copy-trading service with sizing rules, a loss limit that pauses copying and provider fees, and it documents both IB rebates and a per-referral affiliate payment; spreads are published only as account minimums, and the documents show at least three operating jurisdictions without settling the role of four further named companies.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: EBC Financial Group brand, group levelInvestigated, not settled
Three client-contracting companies are documented by their own pages or documents: the Mauritius company (issuer of the execution policy on ebc.com), the Cayman company ('CFD Accounts are provided by') and the UK company (accounts for professional clients and eligible counterparties). The ebc.com footer names four more companies whose role is not settled: the SVG LLC, named first for the global site but not named in any client document read; the Australian company, which offers advice and dealing services and says it is not a product issuer; and the South African and Comoros companies, shown with a licence only. The footer list is introduced with 'including' and is not a closed list. At least three jurisdictions gives 2 at best; if two of the unsettled companies operate, the count reaches five and the grade is 0.
Missing Which companies contract with clients who open an account through ebc.com (the footer says the client chooses an entity), in particular whether EBC Financial Group (SVG) LLC, the South African company and the Comoros company open client accounts or execute orders; and a group statement that lists all operating companies.
Count lower bound 3
9 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–8. Not a finding.Scope: ebc.com and the brand help centre (pages name no contracting company; legal documents on the site are those of EBC Financial (MU) Limited, Mauritius), Professional Account on MT4/MT5, USD accountInvestigated, not settled
No average or typical EUR/USD spread is published for either account. The accounts page and the help centre give only a 'Lowest' or 'Minimum' spread per account, with no instrument named: 0.0 pips with 6 USD/lot commission on the Professional Account and 1.1 pips with no commission on the Standard Account, both on MT4/MT5. Neither page says whether the 6 USD is per side or per round trip. On the cheapest reading the Professional Account costs at least USD 6, so the grade cannot be above 8; the Standard Account costs at least USD 11, which caps it at 4. A minimum gives no exact grade.
Missing A broker-published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for the Professional or the Standard Account with its observation period, and whether the Professional Account's 6 USD/lot commission is per side or per round trip.
Account Professional Account (PRO), MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 (one figure for both), ebc.comSpread basis advertised account minimum; no average or typical figure published
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: ebc.com and the brand help centre, EBC Copy Trading Community in the user centre, MT4/MT5 trading accounts (read-only and PAMM accounts excluded); the pages name no contracting companyEstablished from documents
The brand runs its own copy-trading service, the EBC Copy Trading Community, and documents all four elements. Copying is automatic: when the provider opens or closes a position the follower's account does the same. Sizing is by fund ratio, a multiple of the provider's volume or a fixed volume, each with a formula. A follower can stop or adjust copying at any time and sets a Maximum Loss that closes the copied positions and pauses the strategy. Fees are a provider-set performance fee of 0–20% on a high-water mark and a management fee of at most USD 150 per cycle. This grades what is documented, not results or fill quality.
2 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: EBC Financial (MU) Limited, Mauritius, forex and CFDs under the Execution Policy (June 2026) published on ebc.com; the policy does not differ by account typeEstablished from documents
The execution policy on ebc.com, issued by the Mauritius company, says the firm always acts as principal and reserves its right to transmit client orders to third-party liquidity providers, remaining sole counterparty and sole execution venue. A reserved right leaves the choice with the firm: it is neither a blanket external route nor a condition on each fill. The risk notice adds that the firm is counterparty to every trade and that prices carry a mark-up where applicable. No liquidity provider is named. The brand's statement that the UK company passes all orders to liquidity providers concerns a different company that does not serve retail clients and is not carried over.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: EBC Financial Group brand partner programmes on ebc.com; the pages name no contracting company and no partner agreement is publishedEstablished from documents
The partner page documents both models. The Introducing Broker (IB) model pays rebates and a commission share for referred clients. The Affiliate Partner programme pays an amount for each successful referral, up to about USD 730, when clients deposit and trade through the affiliate's link, which is a payment per acquired client. Both documented gives 4. The page does not use the letters CPA and neither programme publishes a rate table or agreement; the Strategy Provider model and the Creator Incentive Programme are not referral commissions of either kind.
-
36overallequal
eToro
Profile Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
2.7/101 penalty
Breakdown for eToro
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 0 round-turn commission plus spread. All-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a broker-published average or typical EUR/USD market spread (or all-in charge) labelled for the eToro investment account of eToro (UK) Ltd.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope eToro (UK) Ltd (United Kingdom), which executes client trades as agent with eToro (Europe) Ltd (Cyprus) as counterparty; partner programme of eToro Group Limited
Summary CopyTrader is documented in full, but the group contracts with clients in at least six jurisdictions, hedging is at the firm's discretion and the published EUR/USD charge is a minimum of about USD 11 per lot.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: eToro brand, group levelEstablished from documents
eToro's terms page gives separate client terms for clients of six entities: Cyprus, United Kingdom, Australia, Seychelles, Abu Dhabi Global Market and Singapore. Its regulation page lists a licensed dealing entity in each of those and a US broker-dealer. Five or more client-contracting jurisdictions is grade 0 even as a lower bound; e-money and wallet companies are not counted.
Count lower bound 6
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: eToro (UK) Ltd, eToro investment account (single retail account type, USD; Club tiers do not change the currency CFD price), EUR/USD CFD; pricing page is global, read for eToro (UK) Ltd clientsInvestigated, not settled
eToro still publishes the EUR/USD CFD charge only as 0.005% of position value per side, labelled the lowest possible scenario, with a separate variable market spread for which no figure is published and no commission. The Club tiers open to retail clients change conversion, crypto and other fees but list no different price for currency CFDs, so the single investment account is the cheapest eligible tier. The UK and EU FX CFD KIDs give only cost illustrations on a notional amount, not a labelled average or typical spread, so the minimum of about USD 10.97 per lot keeps the range at 0-4.
Missing A broker-published average or typical EUR/USD market spread (or all-in charge) labelled for the eToro investment account of eToro (UK) Ltd.
Account eToro investment account (single retail account type), USDLower bound cost USD 10.97Round turn commission USD 0Average spread published no
17 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: eToro (UK) Ltd, CopyTrader (own product), United Kingdom; follower controls from the global CopyTrader pageEstablished from documents
Schedule E of the UK client terms says a copy order lets the firm recreate the copied account automatically and pro rata, with the allocated amount spread in the same proportion as the copied account, and fees charged on the same basis as the copied trades. The CopyTrader page documents that the follower can stop or pause the copy, set a copy stop loss and add or remove funds, and that there is no additional copy charge. Automation, sizing, follower controls and fees are all documented.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: eToro (UK) Ltd clients, United Kingdom; counterparty eToro (Europe) Ltd, Cyprus; CFDs and other OTC instrumentsEstablished from documents
eToro (UK) Ltd executes client orders as agent with eToro (Europe) Ltd as counterparty. The eToro Europe policy annexed to the UK policy says the firm may hedge a position back-to-back with another firm or venue but is under no obligation to, and the UK client terms say the firm is not required to hedge. Hedging is at the firm's discretion and nothing commits it to external routing, which is the anchor for 4; this does not show that it actually internalises.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: eToro Partners affiliate programme; eToro Group Limited with eToro (Europe) Ltd, eToro (UK) Ltd, eToro AUS Capital Pty Ltd and eToro Singapore Pte. Ltd.Established from documents
The eToro Group Limited Affiliate Program Agreement, last updated 18 March 2026 and linked from the partner site's terms page, defines CPA as a one-time fixed amount per qualifying first-time depositor. The same agreement provides for fees calculated as a percentage of Net Revenues from referred customers' trading, which is a revenue share. Both models are documented, so the grade is 4; the rates themselves are not public.
-
37overallequal
HFM
Profile Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
2.7/102 penalties
Breakdown for HFM
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing an affirmative statement that CPA is not offered, or a current HFM page or agreement that documents a CPA plan.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope HF Markets (SV) Ltd (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, company no. 22747 IBC 2015) for copy trading and execution terms; its costs could not be read; structure and partner programmes at brand level. The earlier row used HF Markets (UK) Ltd, whose legal documents were refused to plain requests on this check.
Summary HF Markets (SV) Ltd documents automated copying with sizing rules, a follower rescue level and a capped performance fee, while its terms keep hedging discretionary, the brand spans at least five jurisdictions and its spreads could not be read.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: HFM brand, all entitiesEstablished from documents
Five operating companies in five jurisdictions were confirmed from regulator registers and the companies' own current documents: HF Markets (SV) Ltd (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), HF Markets (UK) Ltd, HF Markets (Europe) Ltd (Cyprus), HF Markets (Seychelles) Ltd and HFM Investments Limited (Kenya). The group footer also names HF Markets SA (PTY) Ltd in South Africa, and a Dubai company could not be checked because the DFSA register refused the request. Five or more is exact 0 even as a lower bound, which confirms the existing grade; the Cyprus payment-services company is not counted.
Count lower bound 5
4 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: HF Markets (SV) Ltd, retail accounts, USD, EUR/USDNot established
No account or spread page of HF Markets (SV) Ltd could be read: hfm.com and the group site return a Cloudflare challenge to plain requests, and the company's legal documents refer to the website for spreads and commissions. Without a spread labelled for a named account there is no grade and no bound. For comparison only, the UK sister company's cost document (Version 2024/01) shows a USD 6 round-turn commission on its Zero account and example spreads of 0.3 pip (Zero) and 1.2 pips (Premium); these are examples from another entity and do not narrow the range.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for a named HF Markets (SV) Ltd retail account (Zero, Pro or Premium) and that account's commission per lot.
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: HF Markets (SV) Ltd, Copy Trading service (Copy Premium, Copy Cent, Copy Pro accounts); not checked for HF Markets (UK) Ltd, HF Markets (Europe) Ltd or other group companiesEstablished from documents
The Copy Trading Agreement of HF Markets (SV) Ltd (Version 2026_07) documents all four items for the company's own service. A provider's orders are opened on the follower's account by the system; size follows a Proportional method with a follower-set allocation or a Multiplier method; the follower sets a Rescue Level that closes all copied trades, can close copied trades and can unfollow; the documented charge is a provider performance fee capped at 50% of net profit.
2 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: HF Markets (SV) Ltd, OTC FX and CFD contracts; not carried to HF Markets (UK) Ltd or other group companiesEstablished from documents
HF Markets (SV) Ltd always acts as principal and is the sole execution venue. Its Terms of Business let it, at its reasonable discretion, offset a client position against another client, against a counterparty, or keep a proprietary position, and its Client Agreement says it may transmit orders to third-party liquidity providers. That is discretionary hedging or internalising, which the anchor grades 4; it does not show that the firm actually internalises.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: HFM Partners programme, international site; Affiliate's Agreement of HF Markets (SV) Ltd (Asia version)Investigated, not settled
The HFM Partners pages and the 2026 Affiliate's Agreement of HF Markets (SV) Ltd document volume-based pay: a 60% revenue share, up to USD 30 per lot and a share of sub-affiliates' commission. CPA is not mentioned on the pages read or anywhere in the agreement, but the agreement allows a different commission structure per campaign and nothing states that CPA is not offered. IB documented and CPA not found gives 4-10, which confirms the existing range.
Missing An affirmative statement that CPA is not offered, or a current HFM page or agreement that documents a CPA plan.
4 addresses tried
-
38overallequal
INFINOX
Profile Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUnavailable to new retail applicants
2.7/104 penalties
Breakdown for INFINOX
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a group-level closed list of the companies that contract with clients, and today's confirmation of the UK company's client scope.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing whether the liquidity providers and the prime broker that receive INFINOX Global Limited's client orders are outside the INFINOX group, and whether the blanket transmission clause or the discretionary clause of the policy governs.
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing whether the Affiliate Program pays CPA (a fixed amount per referred client), or an affirmative statement that it does not.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across INFINOX Global Limited (Anguilla) for copy trading and execution terms and the shared global website infinox.com/global (INFINOX Limited, Mauritius, and INFINOX Global Limited, Anguilla) for account pricing and partner pages; not a single account offer. Infinox Capital Limited (United Kingdom) could not be re-read on 19 Nov 2026 because infinox.co.uk refused requests.
Summary IX Social copy trading is documented with automation, sizing, unsubscribe control and fees for INFINOX Global Limited (Anguilla); published costs cannot be graded because no average spread is tied to an account and the ECN commission is not published, and routing outside the group and the existence of CPA are not settled.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: INFINOX brand: INFINOX Limited (Mauritius), INFINOX Global Limited (Anguilla), Infinox Capital Limited (United Kingdom)Investigated, not settled
The global site publishes client agreements for two companies, INFINOX Limited (Mauritius) and INFINOX Global Limited (Anguilla), and the brand's regulation page adds the FCA; the UK company Infinox Capital Limited is on the UK company register. That is at least three operating jurisdictions, which the anchor grades 0 to 2. No closed list of group companies was found, so the count is a lower bound. The UAE company is described as a marketing and introducing entity and the Cyprus company as a payment services provider, so neither is counted.
Missing A group-level closed list of the companies that contract with clients, and today's confirmation of the UK company's client scope.
Count lower bound 3
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: INFINOX global website (INFINOX Limited, Mauritius, and INFINOX Global Limited, Anguilla; the page says commission may vary by entity), STP and ECN accounts, MT4/MT5, EUR/USDInvestigated, not settled
The account page gives only minimum spreads: STP from 0.9 pips with commission from 0, and ECN from 0.2 pips with a commission whose amount is not published. The only average, 0.3 pip for EURUSD on the product page, sits in a Forex tab with no account label, so it cannot be used. On the STP account alone the minimum gives at least USD 9 and so at most grade 6, but the ECN account may be cheaper and its commission is unknown, so no bound tighter than 0 to 10 holds for the brand's cheapest retail account.
Missing The ECN round-trip commission per standard lot in USD, and an average or typical EUR/USD spread that the page ties to the STP or the ECN account.
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: INFINOX Global Limited (Anguilla), IX Social, MT4/MT5 accounts; product page on the shared global websiteEstablished from documents
IX Social is INFINOX's own leader/follower product. The product page documents automatic replication of a provider's trades, three sizing rules (proportional, multiplier, fixed lot), a follower's instant unsubscribe with the choice to keep or close positions, and a provider performance fee of up to 50%. The IX Social terms of business of INFINOX Global Limited confirm automated execution and high-water-mark performance fees.
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: INFINOX Global Limited (Anguilla), CFD and margin FX accounts on MT4/MT5Investigated, not settled
The Anguilla company's documents point two ways. Its client agreement says trades will be transmitted to its liquidity providers, and its trade copying terms say each client trade is offset at once with a liquidity provider reached through a prime broker, which reads as a blanket external route (6). Its best execution policy, which is part of the same agreement, makes a transaction on the firm's own account a matter of sole discretion (4), the agreement allows an affiliate as intermediate broker, and the retail site says orders are routed through IXO Prime, the group's own liquidity service. Neither the liquidity providers nor the prime broker are named, so routing outside the group is not settled. No clause makes a client fill depend on a provider's acceptance, so 8 is not reached.
Missing Whether the liquidity providers and the prime broker that receive INFINOX Global Limited's client orders are outside the INFINOX group, and whether the blanket transmission clause or the discretionary clause of the policy governs.
6 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: INFINOX brand partner programmes on the global website (INFINOX Limited, Mauritius, and INFINOX Global Limited, Anguilla; entity not specified on the pages)Investigated, not settled
The global site documents an introducing broker programme paid by rebates with sub-IB tiers, and the Anguilla client agreement says part of a client's charges may go to an introducing broker. An Affiliate Program is named on the partner hub with no payment model. No readable page states that CPA is offered or that it is excluded, and the UK-domain affiliate pages refused requests, so the range for IB documented with CPA not found applies.
Missing Whether the Affiliate Program pays CPA (a fixed amount per referred client), or an affirmative statement that it does not.
8 addresses tried
-
39overallequal
InstaForex
Assessment summary Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.7/102 penalties
Breakdown for InstaForex
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing what Insta Global Ltd. (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) does for clients, and a group statement that enumerates every operating company behind the InstaForex brand.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope InstaForex · InstaFinance Ltd, British Virgin Islands (reg. 1811672, BVI FSC licence SIBA/L/14/1082): the company named in the Public Offer Agreement, the Partnership Agreement and the CPA Agreement on www.instaforex.com, so costs, copy, abook and affiliate all rest on it. The ForexCopy agreement names 'InstaFintech Group' as the company and supplements that Public Offer Agreement. Brand-level feature review with a scope on every factor, not an account offer. The Cyprus company Instant Trading EU Ltd (www.instaforex.eu) is counted for structure only; none of its terms or figures are used for another factor.
Summary Documented at InstaFinance Ltd (BVI): an own ForexCopy service with automatic copying, a follower-set copying ratio, unsubscribing and manual closing, and trader commissions; a client agreement with no routing commitment that refers to positions the company has not hedged; and both a per-trade partner commission and a CPA programme. No average EUR/USD spread is published for its accounts, and the number of operating jurisdictions is not settled (two found, a third company listed without a stated role).
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: InstaForex brand as a whole: InstaFinance Ltd (British Virgin Islands), Instant Trading EU Ltd (Cyprus), Insta Global Ltd. (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines)Investigated, not settled
Two companies in two jurisdictions contract with clients under the InstaForex brand: InstaFinance Ltd in the British Virgin Islands, named in the Public Offer Agreement of the global site, and Instant Trading EU Ltd in Cyprus, which states that it provides investment services under the brand and is on the CySEC register. The global site's footer also lists Insta Global Ltd. in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines without saying what it does, and the brand publishes no closed list of group companies. At least two jurisdictions gives 0 to the two-jurisdiction grade.
Missing What Insta Global Ltd. (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) does for clients, and a group statement that enumerates every operating company behind the InstaForex brand.
Count lower bound 2
10 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: InstaFinance Ltd (British Virgin Islands), Insta.Standard, Insta.Pro, Insta.Zero and Insta.Raw accounts, EUR/USD, USD accountInvestigated, not settled
InstaFinance Ltd publishes only 'from' spreads for its accounts: on EUR/USD from 0.00006 on Insta.Standard and 0.00004 on Insta.Pro with no commission, and from 0 on Insta.Zero and Insta.Raw with a commission. The specification table repeats the same values under a column defined only as 'Spread', and no page gives an average or typical spread or an observation period, so there is no exact grade. The cheapest minimum, USD 4 on Insta.Pro, still leaves the top grade possible, so the range stays 0 to 10. The agreement's statement that the company uses a fixed spread is older wording that conflicts with the 'from' labels on the current accounts page and is not treated as an average.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to a named InstaFinance Ltd account, with its observation period, and a statement of whether the Insta.Raw and Insta.Zero commission is charged per side or once per round trip and on which lot size.
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: InstaForex global site: accounts of InstaFinance Ltd (British Virgin Islands) under the Public Offer Agreement; the ForexCopy agreement names InstaFintech Group as the company. ForexCopy system (own product), MetaTrader 4 accounts only.Established from documents
The ForexCopy agreement describes the company's own system that copies a Trader's orders to a Follower's account automatically, and sets out the fees a Trader can charge (per profitable trade, per 0.01 lot, profit share or a daily commission) and the Follower's ways to stop: cancelling the subscription and closing copied trades himself. The brand's ForexCopy pages document the sizing rule: the Follower sets a copying ratio, and can use a lot range or a fixed lot. All four elements are documented in the brand's own documents. PAMM is not counted, and ForexCopy is not available on MetaTrader 5 accounts.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: InstaFinance Ltd (British Virgin Islands), all live accounts under the Public Offer Agreement (Insta.Standard, Insta.Pro, Insta.Zero, Insta.Raw), currency pairs and CFDsEstablished from documents
The Public Offer Agreement of InstaFinance Ltd contains no commitment to route or hedge client orders externally and names no execution venue or liquidity provider; the company is the dealer and executes on its own server with requotes. Two clauses let the company adjust a client's results where a trade or position 'has not been hedged by the Company', which shows that hedging is done for some positions and not others at the company's choice. That is hedging at the firm's discretion, grade 4. No separate order execution policy is published for this company.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: InstaFinance Ltd (British Virgin Islands), InstaForex partner programmes (Introducing Broker / affiliate, and CPA)Established from documents
InstaFinance Ltd publishes two partner agreements. The Partnership agreement pays a commission on every trade of a referred client, per lot, whether or not the client profits. The CPA Agreement pays a one-off fixed amount per new active trader, scaled by the client's initial deposit up to USD 2,000. An ongoing per-lot programme and a CPA programme are both documented, which is grade 4.
-
40overallequal
NAGA
Assessment summary Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.7/101 penalty
Breakdown for NAGA
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 0 round-turn commission plus spread. Penalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across the NAGA group, not a single account offer. Costs, copy trading and the A-book commitment are assessed for NAGA Markets Europe Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC licence 204/13, naga.com/eu, residents of the European Economic Area except Belgium), the company with the most public documents. Company structure rests on the NAGA EU site's own list of other group entities and on the 2025 annual report of the listed parent, The NAGA Group AG (Hamburg). The partner programme is the NAGA Partners site joinnaga.com, operated by NAGA Capital Ltd (Seychelles); only the introducer clause is taken from the Cyprus company's own client agreement. Nothing from NAGA Capital Ltd's client terms is carried to NAGA Markets Europe Ltd.
Summary NAGA Markets Europe documents an automated copy product with sizing, pause controls and a profit-based copier fee, while the group's own documents show brokerage companies in at least five jurisdictions, the Cyprus terms let the firm cover client trades internally, within the group or with outside providers at its choice, the partner site names both CPA and revenue share, and no EUR/USD average spread labelled for an account was found, so the cost grade stays open.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: NAGA brand and The NAGA Group AG, group levelEstablished from documents
The NAGA EU site itself lists four companies that each operate a NAGA site: Cyprus, Seychelles, South Africa and Abu Dhabi. The parent's 2025 annual report adds Naga Global LLC in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines as an operating subsidiary running online brokerage for clients outside the EU, which makes five NAGA jurisdictions. The same report shows client money held through subsidiaries in five jurisdictions when the Neotrades company in Mauritius is included, so the group reaches five even if the Saint Vincent company is set aside; five or more is grade 0.
Count lower bound 5
3 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: NAGA Markets Europe Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC 204/13), CFD on EUR/USD, EEA retail clients, all VIP levels; no account named by any sourceInvestigated, not settled
NAGA Markets Europe still publishes no EUR/USD spread labelled as average or typical for a named account or VIP level. The new evidence gives clear minima with a stated unit (0.6 pips on the home page, 0.5 pips on the tight-spreads page), but the lowest, 0.5 pips with no commission, is USD 5.00, which sits in the top band and so does not lower the upper bound. The January 2026 key information document shows an EUR/USD spread cost that it calls an indicative illustration with no account named, so it is recorded but not graded.
Missing An EUR/USD spread that NAGA Markets Europe itself labels as average or typical for a named VIP level or account, with its unit and observation period. Failing that, a published maximum or average that would cap the dollar cost; the minima found (0.5 and 0.6 pips) cannot narrow the range because USD 5.00 is already in the top band.
Account none graded; no source ties an EUR/USD average or typical spread to a VIP level (Iron to Crystal) or accountRound turn commission USD 0
14 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: NAGA Markets Europe Ltd, NAGA Autocopy on the NAGA platform, EEA clientsEstablished from documents
NAGA Markets Europe's client agreement and site describe NAGA Autocopy as automatic copying of a chosen lead trader, with two sizing rules (a percentage of the leader's trade size or a fixed amount per trade). The follower can pause copying, close copied trades by hand and change stop loss and take profit per trade. The costs policy sets a copier fee as a share of profit on profitable closed copied trades, and the VIP page gives the rate per level, 20% down to 7.5%.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: NAGA Markets Europe Ltd, CFDs, retail clients in the EEAEstablished from documents
The client agreement makes NAGA Markets Europe the only execution venue and sole counterparty, with a right but no duty to pass orders to outside liquidity providers, and says client trades are covered in part or in full inside the company or with related group companies. The execution policy lists the company itself and four outside firms as CFD venues and lets it choose between sending an order out and executing as principal. That is routing at the firm's discretion, with no contractual commitment to hedge outside the group.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: NAGA brand partner programme (joinnaga.com, operated by NAGA Capital Ltd, Seychelles); introducer clause of NAGA Markets Europe Ltd, CyprusEstablished from documents
The NAGA partner site, to which the partner links on both the EU and the global site lead, names CPA, revenue share and hybrid payout models for affiliates, content creators and business introducers. NAGA Markets Europe's own client agreement says introducers are paid a fee per activated account. Both a per-client and a revenue-share model are therefore documented for the brand, which is grade 4.
3 addresses tried
-
41overallequal
Scope Markets
Assessment summary Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.7/102 penalties
Breakdown for Scope Markets
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing either a description of a CPA or per-funded-client payment by RS Global Ltd, or an affirmative statement that its partner programme pays volume rebates only.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Scope Markets · candidate only · brand-level feature review, not an account offer for any country. Costs, copy, A-book and affiliate all rest on one company: RS Global Ltd, Belize (Financial Services Commission of Belize; the site states registration number 1943611, the Terms and Conditions state 000005695), read on its global site www.scopemarkets.com/global and in its Terms and Conditions (version 11.2026). The other Scope Markets companies found (Scope Capital Ltd., Saint Lucia; SCFM Limited, Kenya; Scope Markets SA (Pty) Ltd, South Africa; Scope Markets Global Limited, Seychelles) are counted for structure only; nothing from their documents is used for costs, copy, A-book or affiliate. Read from a connection outside Europe: the root address redirected to the /int site of the Saint Lucia company, so every /global page was requested by its full address and checked for the RS Global Ltd footer.
Summary RS Global Ltd documents an automated copy service (Scope Copy) with copy settings, an Uncopy control and provider performance fees (copy 10), and its terms let it fill orders either as agent or as market maker with no external route committed (A-book 4); the brand has client-contracting companies in at least five jurisdictions (structure 0); costs stay 0-10 because no EUR/USD average or typical spread is labelled for a named account, and affiliate stays 4-10 because a volume-rebate introducing-broker programme is documented and no statement on CPA was found.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Scope Markets brand (Rostro Group); operating companies as disclosed on the brand's own sitesEstablished from documents
Five Scope Markets companies in five jurisdictions each run their own site and publish their own client documents: RS Global Ltd (Belize), Scope Capital Ltd. (Saint Lucia), SCFM Limited (Kenya), Scope Markets SA (Pty) Ltd (South Africa) and Scope Markets Global Limited (Seychelles). The brand's licences page adds that the licence a client gets depends on the entity behind the website used. Five or more operating jurisdictions is 0 even as a lower bound, so no closed group list is needed.
Count lower bound 5
3 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: RS Global Ltd, Belize; Classic and Pro accounts on MetaTrader 4 and 5, USDInvestigated, not settled
RS Global Ltd publishes no EUR/USD average, typical or minimum spread for a named account. The accounts page gives no spread for Classic, Cent or Pro and no commission for Pro. The forex page shows one unlabelled table with the figure 10 in the EUR/USD 'Spread' column, called indicative, with no unit, no account label and a blank commission. An unlabelled table gives no exact grade and there is no minimum to set an upper bound, so the range stays 0-10.
Missing A EUR/USD average or typical spread that RS Global Ltd labels for the Classic or the Pro account, and the Pro account's round-trip commission per standard lot.
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: RS Global Ltd, Belize; Scope Copy (PLUGIT technology) on MetaTrader 4 and 5 live accountsEstablished from documents
The global site of RS Global Ltd presents Scope Copy as its copy-trading service and documents all four points: trades of a chosen provider are copied automatically in real time; the copier can copy trades as they are or set a maximum lot size; the copier stops with an 'Uncopy' button and can close a copied trade; providers charge a performance fee of 10% to 50% on a high-water-mark basis, deducted weekly. The sizing description is one FAQ sentence and the full settings are only visible after login; PAMM and MAM pages on the same site are not counted.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: RS Global Ltd, Belize; CFD and forex orders under the Terms and Conditions 11.2026Established from documents
The Terms and Conditions of RS Global Ltd say the company acts as counterparty to client transactions and will effect orders either as broker (agent) or as market maker (principal), and may act as both. Nothing says which applies to a given order, no external venue is named and no order execution policy is published on the Belize legal page; the perpetual-CFD schedule says only that the company 'may' enter into a corresponding transaction with a third party. That is internal-or-external discretion in the contract, which is 4. The MAM page's 'Access to STP' line is marketing and does not change this.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: RS Global Ltd, Belize; Introducing Broker Program (Scope Markets Partners Program)Investigated, not settled
RS Global Ltd documents an Introducing Broker Program that pays a rebate on the trading volume of introduced clients, and its terms say the company may pay commission to an introducer. No page read mentions CPA or a payment per funded client, and none says CPA is not offered. An IB programme with CPA not found is 4-10, because absence is not proof.
Missing Either a description of a CPA or per-funded-client payment by RS Global Ltd, or an affirmative statement that its partner programme pays volume rebates only.
6 addresses tried
-
42overallequal
SquaredFinancial
Assessment summary Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.7/103 penalties
Breakdown for SquaredFinancial
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing the group's own closed list of operating brokerage companies, and the date on which the Cyprus company stops having clients.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing which execution route (counterparty or third-party transmission) applies to the SquaredPro and SquaredElite accounts.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope SquaredFinancial · candidate only · brand-level feature review across SQ Sey Ltd (Seychelles, FSA SD024, sqfin.com) and Squared Financial (CY) Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC 329/17, squaredfinancial.com), not a single account offer. Costs, copy, A-book and affiliate rest on SQ Sey Ltd, the company that currently takes new clients. The Cyprus company has stopped taking new clients and is winding down; it is used for the structure count only. No fact is carried from one company to the other.
Summary SQ Sey Ltd (Seychelles) documents an automated copy service with sizing, stop controls and a provider-set performance fee, and a partner programme with both revenue share and CPA; its client agreement says it is either the counterparty or passes orders to a third party depending on an account type that is not mapped to its two retail accounts, no average EUR/USD spread is published, and the group's full company list was not found, so costs and structure stay ranges.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: SquaredFinancial brand; SQ Sey Ltd (Seychelles) and Squared Financial (CY) Ltd (Cyprus)Investigated, not settled
Two operating companies under the SquaredFinancial name were read in primary sources: SQ Sey Ltd in Seychelles, which runs sqfin.com and takes new clients, and Squared Financial (CY) Ltd in Cyprus, which runs squaredfinancial.com, has stopped taking new clients and is winding down existing ones while CySEC still lists its licence as under examination for voluntary renunciation. The brand says it has licences in 'various jurisdictions' and the Cyprus site refers to a parent company and its subsidiaries, but no list of group companies was found, so two is a lower bound and the grade is 0 to 4. The Cyprus company is counted because it is still licensed and still has client relationships on the check date; the withdrawal is not complete.
Missing The group's own closed list of operating brokerage companies, and the date on which the Cyprus company stops having clients.
Count lower bound 2
8 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: SQ Sey Ltd, Seychelles; SquaredElite and SquaredPro accounts (MT4, MT5, mobile app), USD accountInvestigated, not settled
SQ Sey Ltd publishes two ordinary retail accounts: SquaredElite with spreads from 0.0 pips and USD 5 per lot commission, and SquaredPro with spreads from 1.2 pips and no commission. Both spread figures are minimums: the comparison table's row is headed 'Average Spread (EUR/USD)' but its values read 'From 0.0 pips' and 'From 1.2 pips'. The contract specification table gives EURUSD 0.3 pips (SquaredElite) and 1.1 pips (SquaredPro) under a column headed only 'Spread (pips)', which is not labelled average or typical, so it is recorded and not graded. The commission basis (per side or round trip) is not stated, so the lowest cost the minimum allows on SquaredElite is USD 5, which does not narrow the grade.
Missing A broker-published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for SquaredElite or SquaredPro at SQ Sey Ltd, and whether the USD 5 per lot commission is per side or for the round trip.
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: SQ Sey Ltd, Seychelles; Copy Trading (page says 'Powered by Pelican') on MT4 and MT5 accountsEstablished from documents
SQ Sey Ltd presents copy trading as its own offer on sqfin.com: a follower links an MT4 or MT5 account and the chosen strategy's trades are mirrored automatically. The page documents the sizing rules (fixed lot, same as the signal, proportional to equity), the follower's controls (stop copying at any time, soft stop, hard stop, automatic pause at a drawdown limit) and the fee (a performance fee of 1% to 50% set by the signal provider and paid by copiers). All four elements are documented, which is the anchor for 10. This grades documentation only, not results.
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: SQ Sey Ltd, Seychelles; SquaredPro and SquaredElite accounts, CFD ordersInvestigated, not settled
The SQ Sey Ltd client agreement says that, depending on the type of client account, the company either executes the order as counterparty and is itself the execution venue, or transmits it to a third party and is not the counterparty. Neither the agreement nor the website says which route applies to SquaredPro or SquaredElite. If a retail account is of the transmitting type and the third party is outside the group, that is a contractual external route (6); if it is of the counterparty type, or the choice is the firm's, it is 4. The best execution policy lists five outside venues it "is able to" use and says it deals as agent or on its own account. The mapping decides the grade and is not published.
Missing Which execution route (counterparty or third-party transmission) applies to the SquaredPro and SquaredElite accounts.
2 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: SQ Sey Ltd, Seychelles; partners.sqfin.com (Introducing Brokers and Affiliates programmes)Established from documents
The SQ Sey Ltd partner site documents both models. Introducing Brokers earn a share of revenue on their referred clients' trading (revenue share, up to 60% of spread, commission, hybrid deals), and Affiliates are paid CPA for every client who joins, with a deposit grace period. Both an IB or revenue-share programme and a CPA programme documented is the anchor for 4.
-
43overallequal
Vantage
Profile Best Costs 8 · weakest Structure, A-book 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
2.7/103 penalties
Breakdown for Vantage
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing whether a fifth jurisdiction has a client-contracting Vantage company today: the function of Vantage Prime Trading Limited (Saint Lucia), the current status of Vantage International Group Limited (Cayman Islands) and its relation to the Mauritius licence, and the Australian company's current client documents.
- Published costs8TRAW ECN: published account tariff. USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named RAW ECN account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading6PPenalty: low end of 6–10 · missing the rule that sets a copier's trade volume (the copy modes and how each is calculated) in a Vantage Global Limited document.
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing any term in a Vantage Global Limited document that says how forex and CFD client orders are routed or hedged (externally, internally or at the firm's discretion).
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Vantage Global Limited (Vanuatu, VFSC, company 700271) for costs, copy and execution. Its documents and pages were read on www.vantagemarketapac.com, the brand's Russian-language international site, whose notice says an account opened on the site is with Vantage Global Limited. www.vantagemarkets.com and vantagemarkets.co.uk refused retrieval on 19 Nov 2026. Vantage Global Prime LLP (United Kingdom) and Vantage Markets (Pty) Ltd (South Africa) are separate companies; nothing is carried to or from them.
Summary Vantage Global Limited documents an automated copy service with profit-share fees and follower stops and a USD 6 round-trip Raw ECN commission, but it publishes no labelled average spread and no hedging commitment, and the brand spans at least four jurisdictions and pays CPA as well as IB rebates.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: Vantage brand, group levelInvestigated, not settled
The brand's readable pages disclose client-contracting companies in Vanuatu and South Africa (each with its own client agreement), name the UK firm Vantage Global Prime LLP as a separate firm that opens accounts on its own site, and describe a Mauritius-licensed investment dealer operating under the brand. That is at least four jurisdictions, so the grade is 0 to 2. A fifth is likely but not proven from documents that could be read today: the Saint Lucia company is named without a function, the Cayman licensee appears only on a regulator list of 30 June 2025, and the Australian pages refused retrieval. The Cyprus company is a payment and services company and is not counted. This confirms the existing range and replaces its jurisdiction list; it reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Missing Whether a fifth jurisdiction has a client-contracting Vantage company today: the function of Vantage Prime Trading Limited (Saint Lucia), the current status of Vantage International Group Limited (Cayman Islands) and its relation to the Mauritius licence, and the Australian company's current client documents.
Count lower bound 4
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: RAW ECN: published account tariff; USD 6 tariff floor: USD 6 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: RAW ECN; Vantage Global Limited (Vanuatu), RAW ECN account (MT4/MT5), USD account, as published on www.vantagemarketapac.comPublished tariff assessment (RAW ECN); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named RAW ECN account: USD 6 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread that the page labels as such for the RAW ECN account of Vantage Global Limited.
Account RAW ECN (MT4/MT5), Vantage Global Limited (Vanuatu)Round turn commission USD 6Spread basis advertised minimum only ('from 0.0')
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 6PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 6–10. Not a finding.Scope: Vantage Copy Trading (own product, Vantage app), Vantage Global Limited (Vanuatu)Investigated, not settled
Vantage Global Limited's own copy trading terms document automatic leader/follower copying in the Vantage app: once a copier selects a signal provider, the provider's signals are applied to the copier's account without further action. Fees are documented (a profit share of 0% to 50% set by the signal provider on a high-water-mark basis) and so are follower controls (stop a copy order with one tap, own stop loss and take profit, manual close at any time). The readable pages mention '3 ways to copy' and a share of allocated funds but do not state how copied volume is sized; the help-centre article on copy modes refused retrieval. Automation plus fees gives at least 6, and a documented sizing rule would make it 10.
Missing The rule that sets a copier's trade volume (the copy modes and how each is calculated) in a Vantage Global Limited document.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Vantage Global Limited (Vanuatu), margin FX and CFD accounts. Not Vantage Markets (Pty) Ltd (South Africa) or Vantage Global Prime LLP (UK).Investigated, not settled
Vantage Global Limited's client agreement makes every trade an OTC derivatives contract between the client and Vantage, and its risk notice calls a CFD a principal-to-principal contract; acting as principal alone does not establish a B-book. The agreement mentions arrangements with third-party execution providers only 'for the facilitation of transactions and settlements' and contains no routing or hedging commitment, and no execution policy is published for this company. The site names its accounts Standard STP and RAW ECN and says raw spreads come from pricing providers, which is marketing and gives 0 to 6. An April 2026 addendum says Vantage may hedge at its discretion and is not obliged to, but it covers Gold Derivative Contracts only. The South African sister company's policy says all orders are transmitted to liquidity providers; that is a different company and is not carried over.
Missing Any term in a Vantage Global Limited document that says how forex and CFD client orders are routed or hedged (externally, internally or at the firm's discretion).
5 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Vantage partner programmes (partners.vantagemarkets.com), brand levelEstablished from documents
The brand's partner site documents both models side by side: an Introducing Broker programme paying volume-based rebates of up to USD 8 per lot and a CPA Affiliate programme paying up to USD 1,200 per referred client, plus a hybrid of the two. Both documented gives 4, which confirms the existing grade. These are brand programmes and not an entitlement in every country.
-
44overallequal
Windsor Brokers
Assessment summary Best Copy 10 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.7/102 penalties
Breakdown for Windsor Brokers
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a closed list of the companies operating the Windsor Brokers brand.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review of windsorbrokers.com, not a single account offer. Copy and A-book rest on Windsor Brokers International Ltd (Seychelles FSA, SD072) and its Client Account Agreement; costs use the brand account page (rest-of-world figures, which the page separates from Kenya figures); affiliate is brand-level. WB Trade EU Ltd (Cyprus, formerly Windsor Brokers Ltd) now trades as WB Trade and is not part of this review.
Summary Copy trading (WB Copy Trading) is fully documented and both IB rebates and CPA are offered; the Seychelles agreement makes the firm counterparty with discretionary cover, while EUR/USD costs stay open because no average or typical spread could be read.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: Windsor Brokers brand (windsorbrokers.com), all named entitiesInvestigated, not settled
The brand's own legal page names four operating companies in four jurisdictions: Seychelles, Jordan, Kenya and the British Virgin Islands; the Seychelles regulator confirms the Seychelles company and trade name. The list is introduced with 'including', so it is not closed, and four is only a lower bound. The Cyprus company WB Trade EU Ltd (formerly Windsor Brokers Ltd) now trades under its own brand for EU clients only and is not counted.
Missing A closed list of the companies operating the Windsor Brokers brand.
Count lower bound 4
2 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: windsorbrokers.com accounts, rest-of-world pricing (Seychelles route), MT4/MT5, EUR/USDInvestigated, not settled
The account page publishes only minimum spreads: Prime from 1.0 pip with no commission, Zero from 0.0 plus USD 8 round turn (rest of world), Zero VIP from 0.0 plus USD 5 round turn with the deposit 'on enquiry'. Typical spreads are said to be in the Product Outline, but that table loads by script on the product page and the Product Outline and trading conditions PDFs could not be read. The VIP tier has no documented professional or invitation-only basis, so its USD 5 minimum keeps the upper bound at 10; without VIP the minimums would cap the grade at 6.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to the Prime, Zero or Zero VIP account, and whether Zero VIP is an ordinary retail tier.
Account none graded (Prime, Zero, Zero VIP compared)Round turn commission USD Prime 0; Zero 8 (rest of world; 7 Kenya); Zero VIP 5
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Windsor Brokers International Ltd, Seychelles, WB Copy TradingEstablished from documents
The Seychelles client agreement sets out WB Copy Trading as the company's own platform: provider trades are copied automatically into the follower account pro rata, with a follower-set volume range and risk settings. Followers can close all or all unprofitable trades and unsubscribe at any time, and the product page adds suspending a copied trade. Fees are a provider-set performance fee on profit above a high-water mark, charged weekly.
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Windsor Brokers International Ltd, Seychelles, CFDs (all accounts)Established from documents
The Seychelles client agreement makes the company counterparty to every client transaction and refers to covering its trades with other counterparties and to the price at which it hedged a trade, without any commitment to route or hedge client orders externally. The brand's own FAQ says it is neither STP nor ECN and may act as principal or broker. That is discretionary internal-or-external handling, which is exactly 4; no execution venue is named and the Order Execution Policy itself is not public.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Windsor Brokers brand partner programmes (windsorbrokers.com)Established from documents
Windsor Brokers runs an Introducing Broker programme paying a share of spread revenue (up to 60%) on referred clients' trading. Its Web Affiliate programme offers Cost Per Acquisition (a fixed amount per qualifying new client), revenue share (10% to 50%) and a hybrid. Both IB revenue share and CPA are documented, which is exactly 4.
-
45overallequal
2.7/104 penalties
Breakdown for ZFX
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a group-level closed list of Zeal Group operating brokerage companies, and whether any company beyond Seychelles and the UK has a ZFX role.
- Published costs0PAll-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–6 · missing whether the 0.2 / 1.3 pip EURUSD figures are typical or minimum spreads, and whether the ECN USD 7 commission is per side or per round turn.
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the name of the broker(s) to which the Seychelles company transmits orders, whether it is a Zeal Group company, and whether that company routes onward outside the group.
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing a statement that CPA or a per-client payment is, or is not, paid.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope ZFX · candidate · brand-level feature review, not an account offer for any country. Costs, copy, A-book and affiliate all rest on Zeal Capital Market (Seychelles) Limited (FSA Seychelles SD027), which operates www.zfx.com, is named as the client's counterparty and holds the trade names ZFX and Traze; it does not serve EU residents. Structure also counts Zeal Capital Market (UK) Limited (FCA 768451, status 'applied to cancel'), a group execution broker for professional clients only; no UK retail fact is carried to the Seychelles account or the reverse.
Summary ZFX documents an automated copy-trading service with sizing, pause and fee terms through its Seychelles company and an IB/volume-based partner programme, while its operating-company count, EUR/USD cost and order routing remain open ranges: the product guide's 'typical' spreads equal the account page's 'minimum' spreads, the USD 7 ECN commission basis is not stated, and the client agreement's transmission to unnamed brokers conflicts with the execution policy's principal wording.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: ZFX brand, Zeal Group operating brokerage companiesInvestigated, not settled
Two operating brokerage companies are documented: Zeal Capital Market (Seychelles) Limited, the client-contracting company behind www.zfx.com, and Zeal Capital Market (UK) Limited, which its 2025 accounts describe as a matched-principal CFD execution broker earning most of its fee income from a fellow group company. ZFX says it operates 'multiple regulated companies' but publishes no closed list, so two is a lower bound. The Traze sister brand's South African intermediary is a Zeal Group company but no ZFX document gives it a role, so it is not counted; counting it would only narrow the range to 0–2.
Missing A group-level closed list of Zeal Group operating brokerage companies, and whether any company beyond Seychelles and the UK has a ZFX role.
Count lower bound 2
3 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Zeal Capital Market (Seychelles) Limited, Standard STP and ECN accounts, ZFX MT4, USDInvestigated, not settled
The March 2025 product guide gives a per-account 'Typical Spread' for EURUSD of 1.3 pips on Standard STP (no commission) and 0.2 pips on ECN plus USD 7 'per standard lot'. But the account page labels exactly these figures as minimum spreads, and neither source says whether the USD 7 is per side or round turn. Read as typical, the cheapest account is ECN at USD 9 (grade 6) if the commission is round turn, or Standard STP at USD 13 (grade 4) if it is per side. Read as minimums, they only cap the grade at 6, so the range stays 0–6.
Missing Whether the 0.2 / 1.3 pip EURUSD figures are typical or minimum spreads, and whether the ECN USD 7 commission is per side or per round turn.
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: ZFX Copy Trading, Zeal Capital Market (Seychelles) Limited, MT4 accountsEstablished from documents
ZFX runs its own copy-trading platform (copytrading.zfx.com) for MT4 accounts, where trades of a chosen provider are copied automatically into the follower's account. The help pages and the linked follower guide document sizing rules (ratio multiplier, autoscale by balance or equity, fixed multiply, lots proportion), follower controls (Suspend pauses copying, unsubscribe with keep-or-close choice for open copies, copy direction) and fees (performance fee set by the provider, capped at 40% private / 30% public).
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: Zeal Capital Market (Seychelles) Limited, all ZFX accountsInvestigated, not settled
The client agreement of the Seychelles company (s. 4.3) says it acts as agent and will transmit client orders for execution to another broker or brokers, who may pass them to other liquidity providers. That is a blanket contractual route, but the brokers are not named: the group's UK company is a matched-principal execution broker paid mostly by a fellow group company, so the route may run through a group company first. The execution policy contradicts the agreement by calling the firm principal and sole venue, with no hedging commitment. A route to a group company alone is 4; 6 needs the onward routing outside the group to be documented.
Missing The name of the broker(s) to which the Seychelles company transmits orders, whether it is a Zeal Group company, and whether that company routes onward outside the group.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: ZFX partner programmes, Zeal Capital Market (Seychelles) LimitedInvestigated, not settled
ZFX documents an IB programme that pays a share of spread revenue on STP and Cent accounts and USD per lot on ECN, multi-level, and an affiliate programme also paid on referred clients' trading volume. No CPA (per funded client) rate was found, but there is no statement that CPA is excluded, and IB 'Mode B' and 'customised' programmes are undescribed. The client refer-a-friend bonus pool is a client reward, not CPA or IB.
Missing A statement that CPA or a per-client payment is, or is not, paid.
2 addresses tried
-
46overallequal
Admirals
Profile Best Costs 8 · weakest Structure, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
2.4/102 penalties
Breakdown for Admirals
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing whether Admirals KE Limited (Kenya) contracts with clients today. The two group sources disagree.
- Published costs8USD 7 round trip
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established (review hold)
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Admirals SC Ltd (Seychelles, FSA securities dealer licence SD073) for costs, copy trading and A-book; structure and partner programme are brand-level. The broker site strips the regulator parameter and served this entity; the UK and Cyprus retail pages could not be selected.
Summary Admirals SC Ltd publishes a EUR/USD cost of about USD 7 on Zero.MT5 and keeps hedging at its own discretion. Its FAQ says copy trading is not a built-in feature, which leaves third-party copy integrations unresolved. The partner page pays both revenue share and CPA.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: Admirals brand, Admirals Group AS consolidation groupInvestigated, not settled
The group's 2025 annual report lists six licensed investment companies: Estonia, United Kingdom, Cyprus, Jordan, Kenya and Seychelles. Estonia gave up its licence on 28 April 2026, which leaves four that clearly operate (United Kingdom, Cyprus, Jordan, Seychelles). Kenya is the open point: the annual report labels Admirals KE Ltd 'Investment services', while the group's regulation page says no business has been conducted in Kenya yet. Four jurisdictions is grade 2 and five is grade 0, so the range stays 0-2, now on a lower bound of four instead of three.
Missing Whether Admirals KE Limited (Kenya) contracts with clients today. The two group sources disagree.
Count lower bound 4
4 addresses tried
- Published costs 8Grade 8: USD over 5 to 7Scope: Admirals SC Ltd, Seychelles; Zero.MT5 account, EUR/USD, standard commission tier (up to USD 10 million monthly volume)Established from documents
For Admirals SC Ltd the EUR/USD contract specification gives Zero.MT5 a typical spread of 0.00001, which is 0.1 pip, and a commission of USD 3.0 per lot per side; the commissions page confirms that the round trip is double. That is USD 1 of spread plus USD 6 of commission, USD 7 in total, which sits on the upper edge of the 5-7 band. Zero.MT4 shows the same figures; Trade.MT5 is dearer at a typical 0.9 pip with no commission (USD 9, grade 6). The page could only be read through the WebFetch tool because curl was refused, so the cached copy is a text reading, not raw HTML.
Account Zero.MT5 (MetaTrader 5), Admirals SC LtdAverage spread pips 0.1Spread basis published 'Typical Spread' 0.00001 in price units; 1 pip = 0.0001Round turn commission USD 6Indicative cost USD 7
3 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Admirals SC Ltd, Seychelles; MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 and the Admirals platformHeld as a range by independent review
The reviewed FAQ wording denies copy/social trading as a built-in feature. That wording does not by itself exclude every broker-documented third-party automated-copy integration. Current product scope needs verification; no zero is assigned.
3 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Admirals SC Ltd, Seychelles; forex and CFD contractsEstablished from documents
The client agreement of Admirals SC Ltd, effective 28 September 2026, says the firm deals as principal and may act as market maker in forex and CFDs. Clause 14.5 lets it, at its reasonable discretion, offset a client position against another client, against a counterparty, or keep a proprietary position. That is discretionary hedging or internalising, which the anchor grades 4; it does not show that orders are actually internalised. The UK company's policy reads differently (matched principal, back to back with sister company Admiral Markets A.S.) and is recorded as a source for that entity only.
2 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Admirals brand partner programme (page footer names Admirals Europe Ltd, Admiral Markets UK Ltd and Admirals SC Ltd); CPA only for listed country groupsEstablished from documents
The partner page documents both models. Revenue share pays a part of the spread or commission of referred clients, by default 30% on Zero and 50% on Trade accounts, and CPA pays a fixed EUR 600, 300 or 200 per qualifying client by country group; there are also per-lead and flat placement fees. Both IB-style revenue share and CPA documented is grade 4, which confirms the existing grade. The page was read through the WebFetch tool because curl was refused.
2 addresses tried
-
47overallequal
Eightcap
Profile Best Costs 8 · weakest Structure, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
2.4/101 penalty
Breakdown for Eightcap
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs8TRaw: published account tariff. USD 7 tariff floor: USD 7 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Raw account: USD 7 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 7 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Eightcap Global Limited (The Bahamas, SCB SIA-F220): costs, copy, abook and affiliate rest on this company, which owns and operates www.eightcap.com and publishes the client agreement and partner terms read here. Sister companies (Seychelles, Mauritius, Saint Vincent, United Kingdom, Australia, Cyprus) are counted for structure only. The UK, Australian and EU sites redirected to the global site from this connection, so Eightcap Group Ltd (UK), the entity in the earlier row, could not be assessed.
Summary Eightcap Global Limited's Raw account costs at least USD 7.00 per EUR/USD round-trip lot with no average spread labelled for the account, its agreement makes it a market maker that may keep client risk, its partner terms offer both CPA and IB plans, and the brand contracts through at least six jurisdictions.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Eightcap brand: Eightcap Global Limited (Bahamas), Eightcap International Ltd (Seychelles), Eightcap International Trading (Mauritius), CLMarkets Limited t/a Eightcap International (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), Eightcap Group Ltd (United Kingdom), Eightcap Pty Ltd (Australia), Eightcap EU Ltd (Cyprus)Established from documents
The brand's own legal hub publishes separate client agreements for four companies in Seychelles, Mauritius, the Bahamas and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines. The FCA record shows a separately authorised UK firm with its own client site, and the FAQ refers to clients of the ASIC-regulated Australian company; the About page also lists a CySEC-regulated Cyprus company. That is at least six client-contracting jurisdictions, so the grade is 0 even as a lower bound. This corrects the earlier 0-2, which counted three jurisdictions; it reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 6
3 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: Raw: published account tariff; USD 7 tariff floor: USD 7 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Raw; Eightcap Global Limited (The Bahamas), Raw account, USD account, EUR/USD, as published on www.eightcap.com. Not the UK, Australian or Cyprus companies, whose pricing pages could not be opened.Published tariff assessment (Raw); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Raw account: USD 7 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 7 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing An average or typical EUR/USD spread that Eightcap labels for the Raw account of Eightcap Global Limited (the chart figure of 0.096 has no account label or unit).
Account Raw (MT4, MT5, TradingView, TradeLocker listed; USD account)Round turn commission USD 7Lower bound cost USD 7
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Eightcap Global Limited (The Bahamas), as published on www.eightcap.comInvestigated, not settled
No automated leader/follower copying is described anywhere on the global site: the platform, MetaTrader, TradingView, TradeLocker, account and FAQ pages mention expert advisors and TradingView's 'social trading access' but no copy service. The Bahamas client agreement only disclaims liability for third-party signal providers and social trading platforms, which is not a statement that copying is not offered. The Seychelles sister company's agreement says third-party trade copiers are not offered; that is a different company and does not cover an own product, so it does not justify a 0.
Missing Either a description by Eightcap Global Limited of an automated copy service it offers, or its explicit statement that no automated copying, including third-party integrations, is offered.
8 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Eightcap Global Limited (The Bahamas), Client Agreement, CFDs including FX. Not carried to the Seychelles, Mauritius, Saint Vincent, UK, Australian or Cyprus companies.Established from documents
The Bahamas client agreement says the company acts as principal and Market Maker, sets the quotes and may assume the risk of the client's trading. It also defines external liquidity providers as hedging counterparties that can take trades for risk management and lets client funds be used for hedging with them. The firm can therefore keep or hedge client risk at its own discretion, with no commitment to pass trades on. The providers are not named, so no intra-group route can be identified.
2 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Eightcap Global Limited (The Bahamas), Partner Programme, as published on www.eightcap.comEstablished from documents
The partners page documents an Introducing Broker programme paying rebates of up to 50% of the brokerage fee and a separate Affiliate programme paying CPAs of up to USD 600. The Partners Programme terms of Eightcap Global Limited list both a CPA Plan and an IB Plan in their fee schedule. This narrows the earlier 4-10, which had found only the IB side.
1 address tried
-
48overallequal
FXOpen
Assessment summary Best Costs 8 · weakest Structure, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.4/103 penalties
Breakdown for FXOpen
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing whether FXOpen Ltd (England) still operates as a brokerage or as an execution company for the group, and a closed list of the FXOpen group's operating companies.
- Published costs8TECN: published account tariff. USD 5.48 tariff floor: USD 5.48 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named ECN account: USD 5.48 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 5.48 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Commission is EUR 2.50 per side, EUR 5 round trip, converted using the dated ECB EUR/USD reference of 1.0968 on 18 November 2026. This is a dated USD comparison, not a fixed USD fee or current FX quote; a spread mark-up is also permitted by the policy. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the partnership agreement or a full commission schedule, showing whether any payment per referred or funded client (CPA) exists, or a statement that it does not.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across FXOpen companies, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and execution rest on FXOpen EU Ltd (Cyprus, registration HE 310300, CySEC licence 194/13 as stated by the company), the operator of fxopen.com/en-cy/ and the only FXOpen company that publishes an order execution policy. FXOpen Ltd (England, FCA firm reference 579202 as stated by the company), the company named in the earlier screening, was not used: its own site says it is not accepting new account applications. The partner programme sits on a separate brand site and says it is not available to clients of FXOpen EU and FXOpen UK, so the affiliate factor describes the brand's programme outside those two companies. Nothing is carried from one company to another.
Summary FXOpen EU Ltd's execution policy makes it principal and sole execution venue with a right, not a duty, to pass orders to a group company or outside brokers; it publishes a EUR/USD minimum spread and a commission of EUR 2.50 per side but no average spread, its copy offer and the number of operating companies are not settled by the documents, and the partner site documents a percentage commission on referred clients' trades with no CPA found.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: FXOpen brand, group levelInvestigated, not settled
Two FXOpen companies are plainly taking clients in their own names: FXOpen EU Ltd in Cyprus and FXOpen Markets Limited in Nevis. The group page also lists FXOpen Ltd in England, and FXOpen EU's execution policy names it as an execution venue, but the UK site says it is not accepting new account applications and carries a notice that all accounts are closed, so its present operating role is not established. The group page introduces its companies with 'including', so there is no closed list; the count is at least two and the grade stays a range.
Missing Whether FXOpen Ltd (England) still operates as a brokerage or as an execution company for the group, and a closed list of the FXOpen group's operating companies.
Count lower bound 2
8 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: ECN: published account tariff; USD 5.48 tariff floor: USD 5.48 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: ECN; FXOpen EU Ltd, Cyprus, ECN account on MT4, MT5 or TickTrader (market orders), EUR/USD, USD account; brand-level price list, not an offer for a countryPublished tariff assessment (ECN); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named ECN account: USD 5.48 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 5.48 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Commission is EUR 2.50 per side, EUR 5 round trip, converted using the dated ECB EUR/USD reference of 1.0968 on 18 November 2026. This is a dated USD comparison, not a fixed USD fee or current FX quote; a spread mark-up is also permitted by the policy. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A EUR/USD average or typical spread published by FXOpen EU Ltd and labelled for its ECN account, with its observation period.
Account ECN account (MT4, MT5 or TickTrader; one commission rate for all balances)Round turn commission USD 5.48Lower bound cost USD 5.48
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: FXOpen EU Ltd, Cyprus, ECN account on MT4, MT5 and TickTrader. The PAMM service of FXOpen Markets Limited (Nevis) is recorded for that company only.Investigated, not settled
FXOpen EU says it is unable to provide PAMM or social trading, which reads as a statement that it has no copy service of its own. The same site's platform table ticks 'Trading signals' for MetaTrader 4 and 5 without describing the feature, so the statement cannot be taken to cover third-party platform features, and a feature that is only named is not documented copying. The Nevis company's 'Masters and Followers' service is a PAMM service, which is not leader/follower trade copying under the protocol and belongs to another company.
Missing What the 'Trading signals' feature ticked for MT4 and MT5 on the FXOpen EU site is, and whether FXOpen EU's statement that it cannot provide social trading is meant to exclude it.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: FXOpen EU Ltd, Cyprus, CFDs on the ECN account for retail and professional clients, under the Order Execution Policy of April 2022 (V.5) and the Terms and ConditionsEstablished from documents
FXOpen EU's execution policy, which is part of the client agreement, says the company is always the counterparty to every trade and the sole execution venue, and that it may pass an order to another company of its group or to a third-party broker. Its list of execution venues contains the company itself, the group company FXOpen Ltd and two outside firms, and the client agreement says orders are executed on an own-account basis and/or in an STP/ECN model. The documents therefore leave it to the company whether an order is kept or passed on, and where; the ECN description on the website does not change that.
2 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: FXOpen Partnership Program on fxopenaffiliate.com (brand level; stated as not available to clients of FXOpen EU and FXOpen UK), and the introducer clause of FXOpen EU Ltd's client agreementInvestigated, not settled
The brand's partner site documents a commission of 20% to 50% on the trades of referred clients, paid for as long as they trade, which is IB-style revenue or volume pay. No payment per referred or funded client was found on the site, but the partnership agreement itself is signed individually and not published, the site offers personalised terms, and nothing says CPA is not offered. The programme is stated as not available to clients of FXOpen EU and FXOpen UK; FXOpen EU's client agreement only says introducers may be paid commission.
Missing The partnership agreement or a full commission schedule, showing whether any payment per referred or funded client (CPA) exists, or a statement that it does not.
5 addresses tried
-
49overallequal
2.4/102 penalties
Breakdown for FXTM
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a group-level primary source that lists every operating company of the FXTM brand, and the FCA record showing whether Exinity UK Limited currently has permission to deal with clients.
- Published costs8TAdvantage: published account tariff. USD 7 tariff floor: USD 7 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Advantage account: USD 7 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 7 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. This is the published Advantage account floor. The EUR/USD MT5 instrument table uses points without defining the conversion to pips; no pair-specific average or zero-spread execution is asserted. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Advantage requires a minimum deposit of 500 USD/EUR/GBP.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not an account offer: Exinity Limited (Mauritius, Financial Services Commission Investment Dealer licence C113012295 as stated by the company, fxtm.com) for costs, copy trading, execution terms and the partner programmes; structure at brand level, which also takes in Exinity Capital East Africa Ltd (Kenya) and Exinity UK Ltd (United Kingdom), both named in the brand's Client Agreement. No fact from the Kenya or UK company is used for the product criteria.
Summary Exinity Limited's Terms of Business leave the hedging policy to the company's sole discretion, and the brand documents both an introducing-broker rebate programme and a CPA affiliate programme; for costs only a minimum spread and a general 'typically 0.0 on major pairs' statement were found for the Advantage account, no copy-trading service is documented or excluded, and the count of three operating jurisdictions is a lower bound.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: FXTM brand, all disclosed operating companiesInvestigated, not settled
The brand's Client Agreement of 13 August 2025 has a separate schedule for three contracting companies in three jurisdictions: Exinity Limited (Mauritius), Exinity Capital East Africa Limited (Kenya) and Exinity UK Limited (United Kingdom). No document says that these three are the whole of the brand: the footers of fxtm.com and of the group website list regulatory notices that differ from the agreement, and the group says it is also regulated in Bahrain without naming a company. Three is therefore a lower bound: three or four give 2, five or more give 0. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference and is not a safety finding.
Missing A group-level primary source that lists every operating company of the FXTM brand, and the FCA record showing whether Exinity UK Limited currently has permission to deal with clients.
Count lower bound 3
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: Advantage: published account tariff; USD 7 tariff floor: USD 7 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Advantage; Exinity Limited, Advantage account, MT4 and MT5, USD account, EUR/USDPublished tariff assessment (Advantage); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Advantage account: USD 7 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 7 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. This is the published Advantage account floor. The EUR/USD MT5 instrument table uses points without defining the conversion to pips; no pair-specific average or zero-spread execution is asserted. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. Advantage requires a minimum deposit of 500 USD/EUR/GBP.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for a named Exinity Limited account: the 'Average Spread' value the contract specifications show for EURUSD on Advantage MT4 or MT5.
Account Advantage (MT4 and MT5), Exinity LimitedRound turn commission USD 7Lower bound cost USD 7Average spread published no
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Exinity Limited, fxtm.com, MauritiusInvestigated, not settled
No automated leader/follower copy service of Exinity Limited is documented on the current site: the navigation, the sitemap, the help centre, the Client Agreement and the Terms of Business describe none, and the former product address returns 'not found'. The only copy-trading page is a general learning article that names no FXTM service, and the app's trading signals are ideas the client places by hand. Nothing says that copy trading is not offered, so the grade stays open.
Missing Either an FXTM page or document that describes an automated copy service (how copying works, sizing, follower controls, fees), or a statement by the company that it offers no copy trading, including through third parties.
8 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Exinity Limited, CFDs on MT4 and MT5 (all account types), MauritiusEstablished from documents
The Terms of Business for the MetaTrader platform give the company sole and absolute discretion to choose the hedging policy for any or all client instructions, to act as intermediary with a liquidity provider if it so chooses, and to change that policy at any time without notice. The Client Agreement says the company may be the other side of a trade as a principal on its own account or as a matched principal. Orders can be declined when the company cannot hedge with a liquidity provider, which shows hedging is used but not that every trade is hedged. Discretion between hedging and keeping the position is the anchor for 4. Liquidity providers are not named, so whether any is a group company is not known; that does not change the grade.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Exinity Limited, FXTM Partners (introducing broker) and FXTM Affiliate programmesEstablished from documents
Both models are documented for the brand. The FXTM Partners Agreement of October 2025 pays introducing brokers rebates as a fixed USD amount per lot and/or a percentage of the spread or commission, by tier, and the partner page describes ongoing commission on every trade. A separate FXTM Affiliate programme pays CPA, a one-time payout of up to USD 600 for each referred customer who meets the qualification criteria. Introducing-broker pay and CPA both documented is the anchor for 4.
3 addresses tried
-
50overallequal
2.4/103 penalties
Breakdown for IronFX
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a group-level list of the brand's operating entities, and whether a UK (or other) company still contracts with clients under the IronFX name.
- Published costs4PAll-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 4–10 · missing whether ECN VIP is open to an ordinary retail client (minimum deposit, eligibility); whether the Raw ECN USD 6 per lot is per side or round turn; and a statement that the per-account average applies to EUR/USD.
- Copy trading4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the sizing or allocation rule for followers and the performance-fee rate and calculation.
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across two companies, not a single account offer: costs, copy, abook and affiliate rest on Notesco (BVI) Limited (BVI FSC licence SIBA/L/24/1175, ironfx.co, MetaTrader 4); Notesco Financial Services Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC 125/10, ironfx.eu) is used for structure only, because its Pillar III disclosure says it accepts no retail clients and its account and spread pages could not be read.
Summary For Notesco (BVI) Limited the terms leave transmission of STP/ECN orders to liquidity providers conditional and both IB commissions and CPA are advertised, while the number of operating jurisdictions (at least two), the retail EUR/USD cost and the copy-trading sizing rule are not settled by the documents read.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: IronFX brand: Notesco Financial Services Ltd (Cyprus), Notesco (BVI) Limited (British Virgin Islands), Notesco SA (Pty) Limited (South Africa, intermediary)Investigated, not settled
Two companies contract with clients under the brand on their own documents: Notesco Financial Services Ltd in Cyprus and Notesco (BVI) Limited in the British Virgin Islands. A South African company, Notesco SA (Pty) Limited, is a licensed intermediary whose clients contract with the BVI company, and the UK site could not be read. No group-level list of operating entities was found, so the count is a lower bound of two and the grade is a range.
Missing A group-level list of the brand's operating entities, and whether a UK (or other) company still contracts with clients under the IronFX name.
Count lower bound 2
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Notesco (BVI) Limited, Standard Floating / Raw ECN / ECN VIP accounts, MetaTrader 4, EUR/USD, British Virgin IslandsInvestigated, not settled
For Notesco (BVI) Limited on MT4 the account page labels an average forex spread per account: Standard Floating 1.2 pips with no commission, Raw ECN 0 pips with a commission published as USD 6 per lot, ECN VIP 0.3 pips with no commission; the EUR/USD row of the spread table shows the same figures per account. Standard Floating therefore gives USD 12 (grade 4) as the floor, but the cheaper accounts cannot be graded exactly: the ECN VIP page gives no minimum deposit or eligibility, so it is not shown to be an ordinary retail account, and the Raw ECN schedule does not say whether USD 6 is per side or round turn. The average is labelled 'on Forex' rather than EUR/USD and all figures are called indicative, so a stricter reading would keep 0–10.
Missing Whether ECN VIP is open to an ordinary retail client (minimum deposit, eligibility); whether the Raw ECN USD 6 per lot is per side or round turn; and a statement that the per-account average applies to EUR/USD.
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Notesco (BVI) Limited, TradeCopier, British Virgin IslandsInvestigated, not settled
Notesco (BVI) Limited documents its own TradeCopier product as automated copying of Strategy Providers, with follower controls (maximum loss limits with automatic closure; subscribe, pause, unsubscribe). It says providers receive performance fees but gives no rate, and it describes no sizing or allocation rule. Automation is therefore documented (4 at least); if the performance-fee statement is accepted as fee documentation the floor is 6, and 10 needs the sizing rule.
Missing The sizing or allocation rule for followers and the performance-fee rate and calculation.
4 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Notesco (BVI) Limited, STP-ECN accounts (Raw ECN, ECN VIP) and live accounts, MetaTrader 4, British Virgin IslandsEstablished from documents
The client agreement of Notesco (BVI) Limited makes the company the contractual counterparty and speaks of an STP-ECN order being passed to liquidity providers only 'in case the Company transmits' it; it also lets the company move a client to STP/ECN execution at its own discretion. That is transmission at the firm's discretion, not a contractual blanket external route, and the account names STP/ECN add nothing on their own. The liquidity providers are not named, so whether they are outside the group is not shown, which could not raise the grade above 4 in any case.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Notesco (BVI) Limited, IB and Affiliate programmes on ironfx.co, British Virgin IslandsEstablished from documents
The partner pages of Notesco (BVI) Limited document an Introducing Broker programme paid on the traded volume of referred clients and an Affiliate programme paid by CPA. Both models are offered, which is the rubric's grade 4.
-
51overallequal
JustMarkets
Assessment summary Best Costs, A-book 6 · weakest Structure, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.4/102 penalties
Breakdown for JustMarkets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a ruling on whether a licensed intermediary that is a party to the client agreement counts as an operating brokerage company.
- Published costs6USD 8 round trip
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment6Contractual blanket external route
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across five JustMarkets companies, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and abook rest on JustMarkets Ltd, Cyprus (HE 361312, CySEC licence 401/21, justmarkets.eu), the company for which the most could be documented. Structure covers the whole brand. Affiliate rests on the partner agreements of Just Global Markets Ltd. (Seychelles) and Just Global Markets (MU) Limited (Mauritius), because the Cyprus company publishes no partner terms. Figures of the Seychelles company are recorded in facts and are not used for the Cyprus grades.
Summary JustMarkets contracts with clients through companies in four jurisdictions, with a South African intermediary as a possible fifth, and documents both a per-trade IB programme and a CPA affiliate programme; its Cyprus company publishes a 0.8-pip average EUR/USD spread on the commission-free Pro account and an execution policy that passes client orders to named outside venues, while no document read says whether automated copy trading is offered.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: JustMarkets brand, all companiesInvestigated, not settled
Separate current client agreements name four companies in four jurisdictions as the contracting party: JustMarkets Ltd (Cyprus), Just Global Markets Ltd. (Seychelles), Just Global Markets (MU) Limited (Mauritius) and Just Global Markets (VG) Limited (British Virgin Islands). Four operating jurisdictions is 2 at most. A fifth company, Just Global Markets (Pty) Ltd in South Africa, is a named party to the South African client agreement as the licensed intermediary that does onboarding and intermediary services and operates justmarkets.co.za. Whether a licensed intermediary counts as an operating brokerage company has not been ruled (the same question is open for easyMarkets): if it counts, the brand has five and the grade is 0; if not, four and the grade is 2. The group's own list omits the South African company and is not closed, so 2 is an upper bound either way.
Missing A ruling on whether a licensed intermediary that is a party to the client agreement counts as an operating brokerage company.
Count lower bound 4
4 addresses tried
- Published costs 6Grade 6: USD over 7 to 10Scope: JustMarkets Ltd (Cyprus), Pro account, MT5, USD account, EUR/USD, Cyprus / EEAEstablished from documents
On justmarkets.eu the forex table has an account selector, and under the tab labelled Pro the EURUSD row shows an average spread of 0.8 pips with no commission; the page says the figures are averages from prior trading days. That is USD 8 a round trip. The Raw Spread tab shows 0.2 pips, and the account page sets its commission at 3 units of the base currency per lot per side, so USD 8 or slightly more: the same band. Caveat for the reviewer: the Raw Spread tab's own commission column shows 0, the cost disclosure's example table has the two account labels reversed, and the EURUSD instrument page shows an unlabelled 0.6 pips, so a browser re-check of the rendered table is advisable; the Seychelles company's accounts are cheaper (USD 6) but belong to another company.
Account Pro (MT5), JustMarkets LtdAverage spread pips 0.8Round turn commission USD 0Indicative cost USD 8
3 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: JustMarkets Ltd (Cyprus), MT5 accounts, Cyprus / EEANot established
No page or document read for JustMarkets Ltd describes a copy-trading, social-trading or signals service: the EU sitemap, account page, legal hub and client agreement do not mention one, and the Pillar III report says portfolio management is licensed but not active. The same is true of the South African site, the Seychelles client agreement and the help centre. None of them says that automated copying is not offered, including through third-party integrations, so the grade stays open.
Missing Whether JustMarkets Ltd (or the brand) offers automated leader/follower copying, own or integrated, or states that it does not, including MetaTrader Signals.
9 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 6Grade 6: contractual blanket external routeScope: JustMarkets Ltd (Cyprus), all CFD orders, MT5, Cyprus / EEAEstablished from documents
The Order Execution Policy of JustMarkets Ltd, which the client agreement makes part of the contract, says the company does not execute client orders on own account as principal and transmits them or arranges their execution with a third party, and that it shall only use three named venues: Finalto, LMAX Broker Limited and LMAX Broker Europe Limited. Its RTS 28 statement says it has no ownership ties with these venues, so the route is outside the group, and the CySEC licence does not include dealing on own account. This is a blanket external route in the contract documents; no clause makes each client fill conditional on the venue's fill, and nothing public reconciles fills.
2 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: JustMarkets brand partner programmes: Just Global Markets Ltd. (Seychelles) Introducing Broker Agreement and Affiliate Agreement; Just Global Markets (MU) Limited (Mauritius) Affiliate Agreement. Not the Cyprus company's own programme.Established from documents
The Seychelles company's Introducing Broker Agreement pays the IB on every closed trade of referred clients, as a fixed amount per lot or a percentage of the spread. Its separate Affiliate Agreement pays a fixed CPA per Qualified Trader by first-deposit band, and the Mauritius company has the same Affiliate Agreement, which its current client agreement lists. Both models are documented for the brand, which is 4. The Cyprus company publishes no partner terms; its client agreement says introducers are paid a percentage of the spread and partners and affiliates fixed fees, without stating the trigger.
4 addresses tried
-
52overallequal
M4Markets
Assessment summary Best Costs, Copy 6 · weakest Structure, A-book 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.4/103 penalties
Breakdown for M4Markets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a closed list of the group's operating companies, and whether Oryx Finance Ltd contracts with or executes for clients or only introduces them to another group company.
- Published costs6USD 9 round trip
- Copy trading6PPenalty: low end of 6–10 · missing how copied positions are sized for a follower, and how a follower stops or pauses copying (and what happens to open copied trades).
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a term or policy of Trinota Markets (Global) Limited saying whether client orders are passed to or hedged with an outside party, whether that is at the company's discretion, and whether the venue is a group company.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope M4Markets · candidate only · brand-level feature review, not an account offer for any country. Costs, copy, A-book and affiliate rest on m4markets.com and the client documents of Trinota Markets (Global) Limited, Seychelles, company number 8425037-1, FSA licence SD035, whose client agreement names m4markets.com as its website. This replaces the earlier screening line (Harindale Ltd, Cyprus EU route): the Seychelles company is the one for which the most can be documented, because its site publishes per-account average spreads, a social-trading page and partner pages, while the navigation of m4markets.eu lists no social-trading or partner page. Harindale Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC 301/16, services to EEA residents) is counted for structure only; nothing from its documents is used for costs, copy, A-book or affiliate.
Summary Trinota Markets (Global) Limited publishes a per-account average EUR/USD spread that puts its Premium account at an indicative USD 9 per standard lot round trip (costs 6), and the brand's site documents both a volume-based introducing-broker programme and a CPA affiliate programme (affiliate 4); copy trading (6–10), A-book (0–6) and company structure (0–4) stay ranges, because the social-trading page gives no sizing rule or follower stop controls, the Seychelles company publishes no execution policy beyond a 'No Dealing Desk' support-centre statement, and two operating companies were found with no closed group list.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: M4Markets brand, all companies the brand namesInvestigated, not settled
Two companies are shown to run a brokerage under the brand: Trinota Markets (Global) Limited in Seychelles, the contracting company of m4markets.com and on the Seychelles regulator's list, and Harindale Ltd in Cyprus, which is the counterparty to its EEA clients and is on CySEC's register with the M4Markets trade name. Oryx Finance Ltd in Dubai calls itself a marketing and introducing entity, so it is not counted, and VHTM Services Limited is listed with an address and no function. The brand introduces its entity list with 'including' and publishes no closed list of group companies, so two is a lower bound and the grade stays 0–4.
Missing A closed list of the group's operating companies, and whether Oryx Finance Ltd contracts with or executes for clients or only introduces them to another group company.
Count lower bound 2
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 6Grade 6: USD over 7 to 10Scope: Trinota Markets (Global) Limited, Seychelles; Premium account, MT4/MT5, USD, EUR/USD, one standard lot round trip; not a country offerEstablished from documents
The global site's spread table has an 'Avg' column under each account heading. For EUR/USD it shows 0.00004 (0.4 pip) under Premium Account and the same under Raw Spread Account, and 0.00016 (1.6 pips) under Standard Account. Premium charges USD 5 per round trip and Raw Spread USD 7, so Premium is the cheapest account a retail client can open: its only stated condition is a USD 10,000 minimum deposit, which is not an eligibility bar. Raw Spread comes to USD 11 (grade 4) and Standard to USD 16 (grade 2). The table gives no observation period.
Account Premium (MT4/MT5), USD account; minimum deposit USD 10,000Average spread pips 0.4Round turn commission USD 5Indicative cost USD 9
- Copy trading 6PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 6–10. Not a finding.Scope: Trinota Markets (Global) Limited, Seychelles; M4 Social Trading, MT4/MT5Investigated, not settled
The broker presents M4 Social Trading as its own service in the client area and its own app, on MT4 and MT5: a follower chooses a Trading Mentor and copies that mentor's trades, and the app listing linked from the page says leaders' strategies are replicated automatically. Fees are stated: the service is free of charge and the mentor takes a share of the follower's profits, at a rate shown per mentor. No sizing rule is given for the product (the page's FAQ speaks only of what copy trading 'usually' does), and nothing says how a follower stops or pauses, so the grade runs from 6 to 10.
Missing How copied positions are sized for a follower, and how a follower stops or pauses copying (and what happens to open copied trades).
7 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Trinota Markets (Global) Limited, Seychelles; CFDs on m4markets.comInvestigated, not settled
The client agreement of Trinota Markets (Global) Limited says the company deals with the client as principal or as agent and is the client's counterparty; it contains no undertaking to pass or hedge trades with an outside party and no statement of when a trade is kept in-house. The only description of routing is a support-centre answer calling the execution model fully automated 'No Dealing Desk' with liquidity from banks and hedge funds, which is a non-binding statement. The legal page lists no order execution policy for this company, so the grade stays at the range for marketing statements alone.
Missing A term or policy of Trinota Markets (Global) Limited saying whether client orders are passed to or hedged with an outside party, whether that is at the company's discretion, and whether the venue is a group company.
5 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: M4Markets brand; partner programmes on m4markets.com (Trinota Markets (Global) Limited); partner territories depend on the campaign and legal entityEstablished from documents
The brand's site documents both kinds of partner payment. The introducing-broker programme pays commission on the trading volume of referred clients, and a separate page titled 'CPA Affiliate Program' pays per referred client who qualifies, with a hybrid of revenue share and CPA for selected partners. The client agreement also allows fees to introducing brokers and affiliates.
-
53overallequal
Markets4you
Assessment summary Best Costs, Copy 6 · weakest Structure, A-book 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.4/103 penalties
Breakdown for Markets4you
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–7 · missing a group-level list of the companies that contract with clients or execute orders under the Markets4you brand, and the function of Trade4you International (Mauritius).
- Published costs6TClassic Pro: published account tariff. USD 8 tariff floor: USD 7 round-turn commission + 0.1 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 6/10 for the named Classic Pro account: USD 7 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0.1 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 8 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Other named fixed-spread accounts were not priced in the accessible documents; the grade covers Classic Pro, not an assertion that every possible tier has been priced. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading6PPenalty: low end of 6–10 · missing a statement of how the follower's copied trade size is determined (same lots, proportional to funds, or a follower-set ratio) beyond the maximum-lot cap.
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a contractual statement, for the Classic Pro account at E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc., of whether client orders are passed to external liquidity providers, hedged, or may be internalised at the firm's discretion; and who operates MarketPlace.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Markets4you (formerly Forex4you) · E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc., British Virgin Islands (company 1384287, BVI FSC licence SIBA/L/12/1027): the company named in the client agreement, the partnership agreement and the footers of the brand's sites, so costs, copy, abook and affiliate all rest on it. Brand-level feature review with a scope on every factor, not an account offer; the brand's footer excludes residents of the US, Japan, Canada, Australia and the European Economic Area. The global site www.markets4you.com refused every request, so the pages read are the brand's Thai-language mirror www.markets4you.asia (same company in the footer) and the English PDFs it hosts.
Summary Documented at E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc. (BVI): the Share4you copy service with automated mirroring, a follower lot cap, a suspend right and leader fees, and both a revenue-share IB programme and a CPA affiliate programme; no average EUR/USD spread is published (minimum only), the client documents contain no routing or hedging commitment, and the number of operating jurisdictions is not settled (one found, a Mauritius company named without a stated function).
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–7. Not a finding.Scope: Markets4you brand; E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc. (British Virgin Islands) and Trade4you International (Mauritius)Investigated, not settled
One client-contracting company is documented: E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc. in the British Virgin Islands, named in the client agreement and in every site footer read. The brand's regulation page also names Trade4you International, a Mauritius company with an FSC Mauritius licence, without saying whether it contracts with clients or executes orders; a licence alone does not raise the count. There is no closed group list, so one jurisdiction is a lower bound and the grade is 0 to the one-other-jurisdiction grade of 7. The group's offices mentioned in the company history (India, Thailand, Vietnam) are not counted.
Missing A group-level list of the companies that contract with clients or execute orders under the Markets4you brand, and the function of Trade4you International (Mauritius).
Count lower bound 1
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 6TAssigned tariff grade 6; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–10.Tariff basis: Classic Pro: published account tariff; USD 8 tariff floor: USD 7 round-turn commission + 0.1 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Classic Pro; E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc., British Virgin Islands; Classic Pro and Classic Standard accounts, MetaTrader 4 and 5, EUR/USD, USD accountPublished tariff assessment (Classic Pro); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 6/10 for the named Classic Pro account: USD 7 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0.1 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 8 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Other named fixed-spread accounts were not priced in the accessible documents; the grade covers Classic Pro, not an assertion that every possible tier has been priced. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing The EUR/USD spread of the Classic Fixed account, and a broker-published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for any account.
Account Classic Pro (MetaTrader 4 and 5), cheapest by published minimum; no account has a published averageRound turn commission USD 7Average spread published no
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 6PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 6–10. Not a finding.Scope: Share4you copy service of Markets4you, E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc., British Virgin Islands; MT4 and MT5 follower accountsInvestigated, not settled
Share4you is the broker's own leader/follower service: the Share4you agreement has the follower authorise the firm to mirror a Leader's trades in the follower's account on MT4 and MT5, and the copy trading page calls it fully automated. Fees are documented (a commission on each copied trade under the published list; the Share4you site states a leader commission per copied lot or 5%–50% of profit), and so are follower controls (either side may suspend following; the follower may close or modify trades). For sizing the agreement gives only a follower-set maximum volume in lots; how the size of a copied trade is otherwise set is not stated in any document read, so the grade is 6 (automation and fees) to 10 (if a sizing rule is documented).
Missing A statement of how the follower's copied trade size is determined (same lots, proportional to funds, or a follower-set ratio) beyond the maximum-lot cap.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc., British Virgin Islands; Classic Pro, Classic Standard and Cent Pro accounts (the accounts the site says trade on MarketPlace)Investigated, not settled
The client agreement and the Regulation of E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc. say nothing about where orders are executed or hedged: the Regulation describes a dealer who processes orders, may reject them or propose a new price, and the legal page lists no order execution policy. The only statements about external liquidity are marketing: a 'proprietary liquidity aggregator' (MarketPlace) on which Cent Pro, Classic Pro and Classic Standard accounts are said to trade, and FIX connections to unnamed regulated European liquidity providers. The partner agreement refers to the firm's cost of hedging clients' transactions but commits the firm to nothing towards clients. Marketing alone gives 0–6.
Missing A contractual statement, for the Classic Pro account at E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc., of whether client orders are passed to external liquidity providers, hedged, or may be internalised at the firm's discretion; and who operates MarketPlace.
5 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc., British Virgin Islands; Introducing Broker, Multi-Level and CPA Affiliate programmesEstablished from documents
The brand documents both models at E-Global Trade & Finance Group, Inc.: an Introducing Broker programme and a Multi-Level programme that pay an ongoing share of the spread and commission on referred clients' trades, and a CPA Affiliate Program that pays a one-off fixed amount per qualified client. The partnership agreement of the same company pays remuneration under the chosen programme out of client commissions and spreads. Both IB/revenue share and CPA documented gives 4.
1 address tried
-
54overallequal
NordFX
Assessment summary Best Costs, Copy 6 · weakest Structure, A-book 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.4/103 penalties
Breakdown for NordFX
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing whether Nord Premium LTD (Mauritius) contracts with or executes for clients of the brand, and a group statement that enumerates all operating companies of Nord Group.
- Published costs6USD 7.68 round trip
- Copy trading6PPenalty: low end of 6–10 · missing how the copied trade size is set for a subscriber (proportional to equity or balance, a multiplier, a fixed lot) in NordFX Social Trading.
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing any contractual statement by NordFX Ltd on whether client orders are passed to outside liquidity providers, hedged or internalised, and at whose discretion.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope NordFX · NordFX Ltd, Saint Lucia (international business company 2023-00470, formerly NFX Capital VU Ltd.): the company named in the client agreement and the introducing-broker agreement and named as owner and operator of nordfx.com, so costs, copy, abook and affiliate all rest on it. Brand-level feature review with a scope on every factor, not an account offer; the site says NordFX Ltd does not serve residents of the EU, the USA, Canada and other listed countries.
Summary Documented at NordFX Ltd (Saint Lucia): an indicative EUR/USD round trip of about USD 7.7 on the MT5 Zero account, an own Social Trading service with automatic copying, stop and suspend controls and a profit-share fee, and both a per-lot introducing-broker programme and a CPA webmaster programme; not documented are a copy sizing rule and any execution policy (external routing rests on ECN wording alone), and the number of operating jurisdictions is not settled (one found, a Mauritius company listed without a stated client function).
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: NordFX brand as a whole: NordFX Ltd (Saint Lucia) and Nord Premium LTD (Mauritius)Investigated, not settled
Every client and partner document opened names one contracting company, NordFX Ltd in Saint Lucia, and the Gazette confirms that company under registration 2023-00470. The site footer calls it part of Nord Group and lists a second company, Nord Premium LTD, licensed as an investment dealer in Mauritius, without saying what it does for clients and without saying the list is complete. One jurisdiction found and no closed list gives 0 up to the grade for one Saint Lucia jurisdiction.
Missing Whether Nord Premium LTD (Mauritius) contracts with or executes for clients of the brand, and a group statement that enumerates all operating companies of Nord Group.
Count lower bound 1
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 6Grade 6: USD over 7 to 10Scope: NordFX Ltd, Saint Lucia; MT5 Zero account, MetaTrader 5, USD balance, EUR/USD, one standard lotEstablished from documents
The MT5 Zero account page publishes a typical EUR/USD spread of 0 points in its own contract table and a commission of 0.0035% of traded value per side. On one lot (EUR 100,000) that commission is EUR 7 for the round trip, about USD 7.68 at the EUR/USD price shown on the broker's site when retrieved, and above USD 7 at any price over parity. MT5 Zero is the cheapest of the four retail accounts; MT5 Pro (typical 1.0 pip, no commission, USD 10.00) gives the same grade without any conversion, while MT4 Zero (0.3 pip plus the same commission) and MT4 Pro (1.2 pips) are dearer.
Account MT5 Zero (MetaTrader 5), NordFX Ltd, USD balance, minimum deposit USD 200Average spread pips 0Round turn commission USD 7.68Indicative cost USD 7.68
- Copy trading 6PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 6–10. Not a finding.Scope: NordFX Ltd, Saint Lucia; NordFX Social Trading (own service at nord.social, MetaTrader 4 and 5 accounts)Investigated, not settled
NordFX presents Social Trading as its own service in which a subscriber's trading account copies a signal provider's trades automatically. The page documents follower controls (stop or suspend copying at any time) and fees (a share of profit from 10%, with performance, registration or flat fees set in the provider's offer). It says subscribers set copying parameters but does not say how the copied trade size is calculated, and the settings sit behind the nord.social login.
Missing How the copied trade size is set for a subscriber (proportional to equity or balance, a multiplier, a fixed lot) in NordFX Social Trading.
4 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: NordFX Ltd, Saint Lucia; MetaTrader accounts (Zero account for the ECN wording)Investigated, not settled
NordFX Ltd publishes no execution policy. The client agreement says the firm engages in transactions with the client and offers execution-only dealing, and it may correct a trade that a liquidity provider corrects or cancels, but it makes no commitment on routing or hedging and does not describe any discretion either. The only statements on external liquidity are descriptive: 'Access to interbank liquidity (ECN)' on the Zero account page and a trading-regulations clause about banks or an ECN being unable to fill an order.
Missing Any contractual statement by NordFX Ltd on whether client orders are passed to outside liquidity providers, hedged or internalised, and at whose discretion.
6 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: NordFX Ltd, Saint Lucia (the Webmaster agreement under its former name NFX Capital VU Ltd.); Introducing Broker and Webmaster partner programmes on nordfxpartners.comEstablished from documents
Both partner models are documented in the brand's own agreements. The 'Introducing broker' agreement of NordFX Ltd pays the partner on each trade of a referred client, in points of spread or USD per lot, plus a share of second-level partners' commission. The 'Webmaster' agreement pays a CPA commission, one payment per referred client who deposits and trades a set volume, and the partner site advertises it as up to USD 700.
-
55overallequal
Swissquote
Profile Best 4 criteria 4 · weakest Structure 0
Swiss company on fileAvailability not confirmed
2.4/102 penalties
Breakdown for Swissquote
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs4TPrime: published account tariff. USD 11 tariff floor: USD 0 round-turn commission + 1.1 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 4/10 for the Prime tier: USD 0 spot-FX commission plus a published 1.1-pip EUR/USD minimum spread, giving a USD 11 tariff floor per standard lot. Prime requires a USD 50,000 minimum deposit. Standard is 1.7 pips and Premium 1.4 pips; neither is substituted for Prime. This is a published minimum, not an average all-in cost. Financing, slippage and separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the bank's own description of how copying works on its MetaTrader accounts: the sizing rule, the follower's stop or pause controls, and what copying costs.
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing whether Swissquote currently pays any partner a fixed amount per acquired client (CPA), or states that it does not.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Swissquote Bank SA (English name Swissquote Bank Ltd), Gland, Switzerland, FINMA-supervised bank: costs, copy and abook all rest on this one entity and its Swiss site (swissquote.com/en-ch). Structure and affiliate are brand-level. No fact from Swissquote Ltd (UK), Swissquote Capital Markets Ltd (Cyprus) or any other group company is used for a grade.
Summary Swissquote Bank SA is one named Swiss bank with clear documents, but its entry-level EUR/USD spread starts at 1.7 pips, its policy leaves hedging to its discretion, and the group operates in at least eight jurisdictions.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Swissquote group, all jurisdictionsEstablished from documents
The group's own structure page gives a closed list of active companies as of December 2025. Eight of them are regulated companies that take clients in eight different jurisdictions: Switzerland, United Kingdom, United Arab Emirates (DIFC), Hong Kong, Malta, Singapore, Luxembourg and Cyprus. That is well over five, so the grade is 0 and confirms the existing row; the earlier record counted five and missed the UAE, Hong Kong and Malta. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference and is not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 8
- Published costs 4TAssigned tariff grade 4; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–4.Tariff basis: Prime: published account tariff; USD 11 tariff floor: USD 0 round-turn commission + 1.1 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Prime; Swissquote Bank SA, forex accounts: all three deposit tiers (Standard, Premium, Prime; MetaTrader 4/5 and CFXD), EUR/USD, Switzerland. The bound comes from Prime.Published tariff assessment (Prime); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 4/10 for the Prime tier: USD 0 spot-FX commission plus a published 1.1-pip EUR/USD minimum spread, giving a USD 11 tariff floor per standard lot. Prime requires a USD 50,000 minimum deposit. Standard is 1.7 pips and Premium 1.4 pips; neither is substituted for Prime. This is a published minimum, not an average all-in cost. Financing, slippage and separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread for the Prime tier of Swissquote Bank SA.
Account Standard, Premium and Prime (Swissquote Bank SA; MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 or CFXD); bound from PrimeRound turn commission USD 0Pricing condition USD 50,000 minimum deposit
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Swissquote Bank SA, MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 forex accounts, SwitzerlandInvestigated, not settled
Swissquote Bank SA's own pages present automated copying as part of its MetaTrader offer: the platform comparison ticks 'Copy trading' for MetaTrader 4 and 5 (not CFXD), and the MetaTrader pages say clients can view traders' profiles and copy their deals automatically. The bank does not name the service (the wording matches MetaTrader's built-in signals feature) and documents no sizing rule, follower stop or pause control, or copying fee, and its Forex terms have no copy-trading clause. Automation is therefore taken as documented and the mechanics are open. The evidence is two short marketing lines; a reviewer who treats that as 'named only' would keep 0–10. For comparison only, the Cyprus sister company's page says these features are not available through its services; the Swiss page has no such note.
Missing The bank's own description of how copying works on its MetaTrader accounts: the sizing rule, the follower's stop or pause controls, and what copying costs.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Swissquote Bank SA, Forex and CFD transactions on all its platforms, SwitzerlandEstablished from documents
Swissquote Bank SA's Forex and CFD Execution Policy says the bank is the client's counterparty on every transaction and decides in its sole discretion whether to hedge its exposure at all, to what extent, when, and how; hedges go to third-party liquidity providers it selects, and the client is not told whether a hedge was made. The Special Terms confirm the bank acts as principal and promise no external routing. A policy that leaves hedging or internalising to the firm's discretion is the anchor for 4. This does not show that the bank actually internalises any given trade.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Swissquote brand; programme pages of Swissquote Bank SA (Switzerland), with the Rest-of-World, UK and Middle East partner hubs checked for a CPA linkInvestigated, not settled
Swissquote Bank SA documents an introducing-broker programme that pays partners commissions under a tailored reward scheme, alongside a money-manager programme; these are the only two programmes on its partner hub, and the Rest-of-World, UK and Middle East hubs link no CPA programme either. Search results point to former 'FX Marketing CPA' pages, but every such address returns 404 today, so no CPA programme is documented and none is cited. No page says CPA is not offered, so the top grade is not shown either. The bank also pays existing clients a fixed refer-a-friend bonus per funded Forex account; that is a client referral scheme and is not counted as a CPA partner programme here, but if the owner counts it the grade would be 4.
Missing Whether Swissquote currently pays any partner a fixed amount per acquired client (CPA), or states that it does not.
10 addresses tried
-
56overallequal
Switch Markets
Assessment summary Best Costs 8 · weakest Structure, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.4/102 penalties
Breakdown for Switch Markets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing which principal currently contracts with Switch Markets clients (Royal CM LTD, Royal ETP LLC or both), and a closed, current list of the companies that operate the Switch Markets brand, including whatever company stands behind the 'EU regulated website' notice.
- Published costs8TPro: published account tariff. USD 7 tariff floor: USD 7 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Pro account: USD 7 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 7 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. The Pro account minimum deposit is USD 50.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Switch Markets (switchmarkets.com) · candidate only · brand-level feature review across companies, not a single account offer for any country. The client-facing company is Switch Markets Pty Ltd (Australia, ACN 640 033 727), which acts as an agent. The site names its principal inconsistently: the footer of every page names Royal CM LTD (Vanuatu, company number 700284), while the Account Terms, Product Disclosure Statement, Financial Services Guide and about page name Royal ETP LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, 149 LLC 2019) as counterparty to all trades. A-book rests on those three client documents (Royal ETP LLC as named in them). Costs, copy and affiliate rest on the site's account, social trading and partner pages, which carry the Royal CM LTD footer and name no company in the body.
Summary The published Financial Services Guide and Account Terms let the principal either hedge a client trade or keep its risk as a "B-book strategy" (A-book 4), and the partner page documents both per-lot introducing-broker rebates and a fixed CPA payout (affiliate 4); costs, copy trading and structure stay ranges because only minimum spreads are published, the only copying described is MetaTrader Signals through MQL5, and the site names two different principals with no closed company list.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: Switch Markets brand; Switch Markets Pty Ltd (Australia), Royal CM LTD (Vanuatu), Royal ETP LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines)Investigated, not settled
Two tiers in two jurisdictions are documented for the brand: Switch Markets Pty Ltd in Australia, with which clients have their commercial relationship and whose terms govern the account, and a principal in another jurisdiction that performs the regulated services and is the counterparty. The site names that principal inconsistently: the footer gives Royal CM LTD in Vanuatu, while the Account Terms, disclosure statement, services guide and about page give Royal ETP LLC in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines. At least two operating jurisdictions is therefore firm, three are disclosed, and there is no closed list of the brand's operating companies, so the grade is 0 to 4.
Missing Which principal currently contracts with Switch Markets clients (Royal CM LTD, Royal ETP LLC or both), and a closed, current list of the companies that operate the Switch Markets brand, including whatever company stands behind the 'EU regulated website' notice.
Count lower bound 2
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: Pro: published account tariff; USD 7 tariff floor: USD 7 round-turn commission + 0 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Pro; Switch Markets brand, Pro account on MetaTrader 4/5 (one price shown for both platforms), EUR/USD, USD account; site pages carrying the Royal CM LTD (Vanuatu) footer; country eligibility not assessedPublished tariff assessment (Pro); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Pro account: USD 7 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 7 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. The Pro account minimum deposit is USD 50.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread that the page ties to the Pro (or Standard) account, with its observation period.
Account Pro (MetaTrader 4/5; no other platform offered, one price for both)Round turn commission USD 7Lower bound cost USD 7
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Switch Markets brand, live MetaTrader 4/5 accounts; MetaTrader Trading Signals (MQL5 community) as presented on the Social Trading page, which carries the Royal CM LTD (Vanuatu) footer; no client-document clause covers itInvestigated, not settled
The only copying described is MetaTrader Trading Signals: the "Social Trading" page tells clients to register at MQL5.com, choose strategy providers and start copying. That is MetaQuotes' service in the MQL5 community, not a copy service run by the broker, and the page documents no sizing rule, follower control or fee basis of the broker's own. Under the reviewer's rule MetaTrader Signals does not count as the broker's copy trading (as for Axiory and MultiBank Group), and nothing says copying is not offered, so neither a positive grade nor 0 is established.
Missing The broker's own statement of how copied trades are sized, how a follower stops or pauses copying, and the fee basis; and whether the broker treats MetaTrader Signals as its own service or as MetaQuotes'.
4 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Switch Markets Pty Ltd on behalf of Royal ETP LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) as named in the Account Terms, Product Disclosure Statement and Financial Services Guide of 24 Dec 2020; margin FX and CFDs; all account types (Standard and Pro are not distinguished); not a document of Royal CM LTDEstablished from documents
The client documents published on the site say Switch makes a market on behalf of the principal, which is counterparty to every trade; acting as principal alone does not establish a B-book. The Financial Services Guide then says the principal earns a ticket fee on the Switch client trades it hedges and may also profit where it has kept the risk of a trade 'in the form of a B-book strategy', and the Account Terms allow for a trade that is not hedged at all or only in part. Hedging or keeping the risk is therefore at the firm's choice, with no commitment to route any trade externally, which is the anchor for 4. These documents name Royal ETP LLC as the principal; the footer names Royal CM LTD, for which no execution document is published on the site.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Switch Markets brand partner programmes (CPA Affiliate, Introducing Broker, hybrid) as published on switchmarkets.com; no country statedEstablished from documents
The partner page documents two programmes side by side: a CPA Affiliate programme paying a fixed, one-off amount per qualified referred trader, and an Introducing Broker programme paying ongoing rebates on every lot the referred clients trade, with a hybrid of the two available. Both an IB (volume-based) model and a CPA model are documented for the brand, which is the anchor for 4.
3 addresses tried
-
57overallequal
iFOREX
Assessment summary Best Structure, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.2/103 penalties
Breakdown for iFOREX
- Company structure4Two
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 0 round-turn commission plus spread. All-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–4 · missing an average or typical EUR/USD spread that iCFD Limited labels for a named ordinary retail account, given to at least one decimal of a pip.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing whether the group-level statement that client positions are not hedged externally counts as the assessed route explicitly excluding external hedging, given that iCFD Limited's own agreement keeps discretion to hedge with another financial firm.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across the iFOREX group, not a single account offer. Costs, copy trading and the A-book commitment are assessed for iCFD Limited (Cyprus, CySEC licence 143/11, trading as iFOREX Europe, www.iforex.eu), the company with the most public documents. Company structure rests on the 2025 annual report of the listed parent, iFOREX Financial Trading Holdings Ltd (Guernsey). The partner programme is the group's Actively Investing programme, operated by Formula Investment House Ltd (British Virgin Islands), which states that it does not accept introducing brokers for iFOREX Europe. Nothing is carried from Formula Investment House Ltd's own client terms to iCFD Limited.
Summary The group's 2025 annual report lists two operating brokerage companies (British Virgin Islands and Cyprus) and its partner site documents both one-time CPA and spread-share IB payments; for iFOREX Europe the published minimum EUR/USD spread of 1.3 pips limits the cost grade to 4 at most and no account-labelled average was found, client trades are hedged with a group company while the group reports no external hedging (graded 0 to 4), and no description of automated copy trading was found.
- Company structure 4Grade 4: twoScope: iFOREX group (iFOREX Financial Trading Holdings Ltd and subsidiaries), brand levelEstablished from documents
The listed parent's 2025 annual report gives a closed list of active subsidiaries and says the group serves clients through two regulated operating subsidiaries: Formula Investment House Ltd in the British Virgin Islands and iCFD Ltd in Cyprus. Both sites' footers, read on 19 Nov 2026, name the same two firms. Two operating jurisdictions is grade 4; the other listed companies are a holding company, a Cyprus support company, an Israeli technology company and a Greek branch.
Count lower bound 2
2 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: iCFD Limited (iFOREX Europe), EUR/USD CFD, USD account, proprietary web and app platform, EEA; no account type is named by the brokerInvestigated, not settled
iFOREX Europe charges no commission on currency CFDs and publishes a minimum EUR/USD spread of 1.3 pips, so one standard lot costs at least USD 13 round trip, which limits the grade to 4. The site also publishes an average of 1 pip, but it is a mean over all trades of all clients in the previous month, is not tied to any account, is shown only as a whole pip and is below the stated minimum, so it is recorded and not graded. The site names no account types, and the costs document says spreads differ by client.
Missing An average or typical EUR/USD spread that iCFD Limited labels for a named ordinary retail account, given to at least one decimal of a pip.
Account none named: iFOREX Europe publishes one spread table for the site and does not describe its account typesRound turn commission USD 0Lower bound cost USD 13
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: iCFD Limited (iFOREX Europe), proprietary platform, EEA; the annual report mention is group level with no entity statedInvestigated, not settled
No iFOREX page or client document read describes automated leader/follower copying, and none says that copy trading is not offered. The 2025 annual report names 'strategy copying capabilities' as a new platform feature without saying which company offers it or how it works, which is a named feature only. The tools iFOREX Europe describes (Trading Central signals, Pulse, The Trading Expert) leave every trading decision to the client.
Missing A broker document that either describes the 'strategy copying' feature (which company offers it, whether trades are copied automatically, sizing, stop or pause controls, fees) or states that no copy trading, own or third-party, is offered.
8 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: iCFD Limited (iFOREX Europe), all CFDs, retail and professional clients, EEA; hedge counterparty Formula Investment House Ltd (BVI, same group)Investigated, not settled
iCFD Limited is principal and sole execution venue; its execution policy says each client trade is matched by an identical trade with Formula Investment House Ltd, a group company, and its client agreement, which prevails, keeps sole discretion to hedge, offset or keep positions. A route to a group company alone is 4 at most. The group's 2025 annual report says the group does not hedge client positions externally, which points to 0 if that statement is read as excluding external hedging for this route; the contract itself does not exclude it.
Missing Whether the group-level statement that client positions are not hedged externally counts as the assessed route explicitly excluding external hedging, given that iCFD Limited's own agreement keeps discretion to hedge with another financial firm.
5 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: iFOREX brand: Actively Investing partner programme operated by Formula Investment House Ltd for the group's companies; the IB plan excludes iCFD Limited (iFOREX Europe)Established from documents
The group's partner programme, Actively Investing, documents both mechanisms: a one-time CPA commission per qualified user, with amounts by client country, and an introducing-broker plan paying a share of client spreads or volume. Both documented is grade 4 for the brand. For iFOREX Europe alone the programme says introducing brokers are not accepted and iCFD's own disclosure describes payments made once per introduced client.
-
58overallequal
2.1/103 penalties
Breakdown for Bullwaves
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a closed, current enumeration of the brand's client-contracting operating entities.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing an applicable execution/hedging policy that binds the assessed account to an external-group route.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Bullwaves / Equitex Capital Limited (Seychelles); country eligibility not assessed
Summary Automated copying and both IB and CPA programmes are documented; comparable typical costs, a closed entity count and a binding external hedge commitment remain unresolved.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Bullwaves / Equitex Capital Limited (Seychelles); country eligibility not assessedInvestigated, not settled
One Seychelles broker is identified. The Cyprus representative is not counted as a second broker, and the reviewed disclosure does not prove that the brand has no other operating entities.
Missing A closed, current enumeration of the brand's client-contracting operating entities.
Count lower bound 1
2 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Bullwaves / Equitex Capital Limited (Seychelles); country eligibility not assessedInvestigated, not settled
The site provides spread minima and a Standard no-commission statement. No matched average EUR/USD spread and commission schedule for the cheapest ordinary retail account were established; the conflicting ECN minima do not supply an average.
Missing A typical/average EUR/USD spread and matching retail commission schedule, with account, platform and date window.
5 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: Bullwaves / Equitex Capital Limited (Seychelles); country eligibility not assessedEstablished from documents
The broker documents automation, three sizing modes, stop-copy/provider stop-loss controls and a strategy-specific profit split. All four documentation features are present; this is not a live execution test.
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Bullwaves / Equitex Capital Limited (Seychelles); country eligibility not assessedInvestigated, not settled
STP/ECN help pages advertise direct liquidity-provider execution. The reviewed execution clauses establish a counterparty and external pricing inputs, without settling a binding blanket or per-fill external hedge obligation. No operational route is inferred.
Missing An applicable execution/hedging policy that binds the assessed account to an external-group route.
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Bullwaves brand partner programmes; individual partner contracts are separate.Established from documents
The partner page offers a CPA affiliate programme and an introducing-broker rebate programme. Both models are documented, so IB-only exclusivity is not established.
-
59overallequal
Global Prime
Profile Best Costs 6 · weakest Structure, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedAustralian company on file
2.1/102 penalties
Breakdown for Global Prime
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a group-level primary source that lists every operating entity using the Global Prime name, to show whether the count is exactly two.
- Published costs6USD 8 round trip
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited trading as Global Prime FX (Vanuatu, company 40256): the contracting entity and the only client document set shown on globalprime.com from this location. Costs, copy and A-book are assessed on this entity. FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd (Australia, AFSL 385620) is counted for structure only; its client documents could not be retrieved.
Summary The Raw account publishes a 0.1-pip average EUR/USD spread plus USD 7 round-trip commission, while the Vanuatu disclosure statement leaves hedging to the firm's discretion, both IB and CPA partner routes are offered, and no copy-trading product is documented on the current site.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: Global Prime brand: FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd (Australia) and Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited (Vanuatu)Investigated, not settled
The brand's regulation page names two companies in two jurisdictions: FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd (Australia), which serves Australian retail and Pro clients, and Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited trading as Global Prime FX (Vanuatu), the contracting entity for other clients. The page is not worded as a closed list, and the legal hub shows only the Vanuatu document set from this location, so two is a lower bound. The Seychelles register shows no Global Prime entity. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Missing A group-level primary source that lists every operating entity using the Global Prime name, to show whether the count is exactly two.
Count lower bound 2
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 6Grade 6: USD over 7 to 10Scope: Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited t/a Global Prime FX (Vanuatu); Raw account, MT4/MT5, USD; EUR/USD, one standard lotEstablished from documents
The spreads page publishes an average EUR/USD spread of 0.1 and a Raw commission of USD 7 round turn per standard lot, giving USD 8. The table does not name its account, but the only other account, Standard, starts at 0.9 pips, so the average can only be Raw; a second published average of 0.16 on the rollover page gives USD 8.60, the same band. The '**' note, unit label and observation period are not on the page. Standard (from 0.9 pips, no commission, no average published) costs at least USD 9 and is not cheaper.
Account Raw, MT4/MT5, USD (Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited, Vanuatu)Average spread pips 0.1Round turn commission USD 7Indicative cost USD 8
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited t/a Global Prime FX (Vanuatu); globalprime.com public pagesNot established
No automated copy-trading product is described on the current website: the site map, navigation, platform pages, FAQs and the Vanuatu PDS and terms contain nothing on copying, and the earlier copy-trading page now returns 404. That is absence of documentation, not a statement that copying is not offered (an earlier page pointed to a tab inside the client area, which was not opened), so no grade is assigned.
Missing A current primary document that either describes an automated copy product for this entity (automation, sizing, follower controls, fees) or states that none is offered.
8 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Gleneagle Securities Pty Limited t/a Global Prime (Vanuatu), PDS and Financial Product Service Terms dated 28 February 2023; OTC FX and CFD products. Not FMGP Trading Group Pty Ltd (Australia).Established from documents
The Vanuatu PDS says the firm deals as principal on a market-making pricing model and 'may hedge' its exposure to clients at any time and may later change that at any time, with a Hedge Counterparty chosen case by case. That is a discretion to hedge, not a commitment to pass every trade on, and the client terms add no routing commitment. Website statements about passing on the best rates are marketing and do not change the grade. No execution or hedging policy is published for this entity, and the Australian entity's documents were not retrievable, so the grade is not carried to it.
1 address tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Global Prime brand partner programme (globalprime.com)Established from documents
The partners page documents both routes: an introducing-broker programme paid per lot (up to USD 4 on Raw, up to USD 6.50 on Standard) and an affiliate programme paid on a CPA basis. This confirms the existing grade. It describes the brand's partner programmes, not an entitlement in every country.
-
60overallequal
2.1/104 penalties
Breakdown for Headway
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–7 · missing a closed list of the companies that operate the Headway brand (or a statement that JAROCEL PTY LTD is the only one), and who the 'Affiliated Entities' are.
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 0 round-turn commission plus spread. Penalty: nothing established
- Copy trading10Automation sizing controls fees
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing any statement by JAROCEL PTY LTD of how client orders are executed: its capacity, whether positions are hedged or passed to outside liquidity providers, and whether that is discretionary or contractual.
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing either a documented payment per referred or funded client (CPA), including under the media partner route, or an affirmative statement that the brand pays partners only by revenue share.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope JAROCEL PTY LTD, South Africa (company 2021/883863/07), trading as Headway: the one legal entity used for costs, copy and abook, read on hw.site, the address its client agreement names. Brand-level feature review with a scope on every factor, not an account offer. The FSCA licence number 52108 is broker-stated; the regulator's register could not be read.
Summary Headway documents an automated copy service with sizing, stop controls and fees and a spread-share IB programme under one South African company. An average EUR/USD spread of 0.8 pips for its Standard account appears only in the page's structured data, beside conflicting minimums, so the cost grade stays open with 6 as the conditional reading; its client agreement commits to no external routing, and neither the full list of operating companies nor the absence of CPA is documented.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–7. Not a finding.Scope: Headway brand; JAROCEL PTY LTD, South AfricaInvestigated, not settled
The current client agreement names one contracting company, JAROCEL PTY LTD in South Africa, and the legal hub and every page footer name the same company as the operator; the LEI register confirms its registration. That is one operating jurisdiction found. No document gives a closed list of the brand's operating companies, and the Partnership Agreement refers to undefined 'Affiliated Entities', so one found gives 0 to the one-jurisdiction grade, which for a jurisdiction outside Europe is 7.
Missing A closed list of the companies that operate the Headway brand (or a statement that JAROCEL PTY LTD is the only one), and who the 'Affiliated Entities' are.
Count lower bound 1
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: JAROCEL PTY LTD, Standard account, MT4/MT5 (one listing for both platforms), USD account, EUR/USD, South AfricaInvestigated, not settled
The EURUSD instrument page carries, in its embedded structured data only, an average spread of 0.8 pips with no commission for the offer named "EURUSD - Standard Account", which would be USD 8 a round trip and grade 6 (the Pro account, 0.7 pips plus up to USD 1.5 per side, would also be 6). The visible table shows a minimum spread alone, no observation period is given, and the underlying page data hold the figure as 8 on five-digit quotes, so the unit rests on the page's own conversion. The published minimums for the same account disagree: 0.06 pips on the instrument page, 0.6 pips on the home page and "from 0.3" on the account page. An average that is not shown to a reader, has no period and sits beside conflicting minimums is recorded as the conditional reading, not as an exact grade; the lowest published minimum (0.06 pips) leaves 10 possible.
Missing The average EUR/USD spread for the Standard account as the rendered page shows it, with its unit and observation period, and which of the three published minimums is correct.
Account Standard (MT4/MT5, same listing for both platforms), JAROCEL PTY LTDRound turn commission USD 0
5 addresses tried
- Copy trading 10Grade 10: automation sizing controls feesScope: JAROCEL PTY LTD, Headway Copytrade (own product), real MT4/MT5 accounts, South AfricaEstablished from documents
Headway Copytrade is the broker's own service, with its own terms on the legal hub. The terms document all four elements: orders of a Trader's Strategy are repeated on the Investor's copying account, the Investor sets a proportion from 0.01 to 1000 per lot, can stop copying at any time and close or keep the open orders, and pays a fixed or profit-share commission of which Headway keeps 15%.
2 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: JAROCEL PTY LTD, MetaTrader 4 and 5 accounts, South AfricaInvestigated, not settled
The client agreement of JAROCEL PTY LTD, read in full, describes market execution on the company's own server and says nothing about its capacity, an execution venue, liquidity providers, hedging or external routing, so it commits to nothing. The legal hub lists no order execution policy. The only ECN/STP wording found is in award captions on the site, which is marketing and gives 0–6; a Partnership Agreement clause mentions the company's 'cost of hedging risks' without any commitment to clients.
Missing Any statement by JAROCEL PTY LTD of how client orders are executed: its capacity, whether positions are hedged or passed to outside liquidity providers, and whether that is discretionary or contractual.
6 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Headway Partnership Program, JAROCEL PTY LTD websiteInvestigated, not settled
The Partnership Agreement and the partnership page document an IB programme paid as a share of the spread or commission on each closed client trade, with status levels and two sub-partner levels. No payment per referred or funded client was found in the agreement, on the partnership page or in the Cashbooster terms, and no document says that CPA is not offered; absence is not proof, so the range is 4–10.
Missing Either a documented payment per referred or funded client (CPA), including under the media partner route, or an affirmative statement that the brand pays partners only by revenue share.
6 addresses tried
-
61overallequal
T4Trade
Assessment summary Best Copy 6 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.1/104 penalties
Breakdown for T4Trade
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a group-level statement or closed list of the companies that operate the T4Trade brand (or a statement that Tradeco Limited has no operating affiliates).
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading6PPenalty: low end of 6–10 · missing how the size of a copied trade is set for the follower, and whether the follower can stop, pause or cap copying.
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the brand's partner terms: whether a one-off payment per referred or funded client (CPA) is offered alongside the volume-based introducing-broker payment, or is expressly not offered.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope T4Trade · candidate only · Tradeco Limited, Seychelles (company number 8422971-1; states FSA securities dealer licence SD029), the one company named on t4trade.co and in its client documents dated 29 October 2026. Costs, copy, A-book and affiliate all rest on this company; brand-level feature review, not an account offer for any country. The former address t4trade.com no longer resolves (registry status 'client hold', record last changed 27 October 2026); the brand's site is now t4trade.co.
Summary T4Trade's current documents name one Seychelles company that is principal and sole execution venue and leaves hedging to itself (A-book 4), and its site describes an automated copy service with performance fees; structure, costs, the copy mechanics and the partner model stay ranges because no closed group list, no average spread labelled for EUR/USD, no sizing rule or follower controls and no partner programme page could be read.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: T4Trade brand; Tradeco Limited (Seychelles)Investigated, not settled
Every document read names one company, Tradeco Limited in Seychelles, as the company behind the T4Trade name and as the client's counterparty, and the Seychelles regulator lists it with the brand's websites. That is one disclosed operating jurisdiction, but it is a statement about one company and not a closed list of the group, and the About Us page could not be read. One Seychelles company found, with no closed list, gives 0 to 6.
Missing A group-level statement or closed list of the companies that operate the T4Trade brand (or a statement that Tradeco Limited has no operating affiliates).
Count lower bound 1
5 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Tradeco Limited (Seychelles); T4Trade accounts on MetaTrader 4 as published on t4trade.co; EUR/USD, one standard lotInvestigated, not settled
The account page publishes an 'Average Spread' for each account (Privilege 1.1, VIP Zero Spread 0 with a $6 commission), but the row names no instrument, and the commission's basis is not stated. The spreads page gives EUR/USD per account (Privilege 0.9 floating, 1.2 fixed) but calls the figures indicative, not average or typical, and no minimum is published. No figure is therefore a EUR/USD spread labelled average or typical for a named account, so no exact grade and no bound follows; the pages that might settle it were blocked.
Missing A statement that ties an average or typical EUR/USD spread to a named account (the instrument for the account page's 'Average Spread' row), and the basis of the $6 commission on VIP Zero Spread.
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 6PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 6–10. Not a finding.Scope: Tradeco Limited (Seychelles); T4Trade TradeCopier (Strategy Provider and Strategy Follower accounts)Investigated, not settled
T4Trade offers its own leader/follower service, TradeCopier: a follower subscribes to a Strategy Provider from a leaderboard and the provider's trades are copied automatically, and the provider earns a performance fee of up to 40% of the follower's profit on profitable trades. Automation and fees are therefore documented. The product page states no sizing rule and no follower stop or pause control, the client agreement has no copy trading clause, and the FAQ could not be read, so 8 and 10 cannot be fixed.
Missing How the size of a copied trade is set for the follower, and whether the follower can stop, pause or cap copying.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Tradeco Limited (Seychelles); all T4Trade accounts under the Order Execution Policy 2026/001 and Client Services Agreement 2026/002Established from documents
Tradeco Limited's order execution policy says the company always acts as principal and is the sole execution venue, with most trades priced and executed by its own internal systems. The policy, the client agreement and the conflicts policy each refer to financial institutions the company uses as hedging liquidity or price providers, but none commits it to hedge or pass on any order, and none excludes hedging. Hedging is thus left to the firm, which is the anchor for 4; acting as principal is not by itself counted against it, and the 'STP' in an account name is not a contractual route.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Tradeco Limited (Seychelles); introducing brokers and other referrers of T4Trade clientsInvestigated, not settled
The client agreement documents introducing-broker remuneration: the company pays introducing brokers or other third parties a fee or commission related to the volume of the referred clients' transactions and to the number of clients referred, and part of a client's charges may be passed to the introducing broker. No partner programme page, name or rate card was found on the brand's site, so whether a one-off payment per funded client is offered is not documented either way. Introducing-broker pay documented with CPA not settled gives 4 to 10.
Missing The brand's partner terms: whether a one-off payment per referred or funded client (CPA) is offered alongside the volume-based introducing-broker payment, or is expressly not offered.
5 addresses tried
-
62overallequal
2.1/10no penalties
Breakdown for XTB
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs6TStandard: published account tariff. USD 8 tariff floor: USD 0 round-turn commission + 0.8 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider. Tariff grade 6/10 for the named Standard account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0.8 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 8 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
- Copy trading0Confirmed no automated leader copying
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and abook all rest on XTB Limited (United Kingdom, FCA 522157, company number 07227848), Standard account for CFDs on the xStation platform. Structure is assessed at group level from the 2025 consolidated annual report of the listed parent, XTB S.A. (Poland). The affiliate grade rests on the group partnership programme (contracting companies XTB Services Limited, Cyprus, and XTB International Limited, Belize), the introducing-broker note in the group annual report and the introducing-broker clause of the UK terms of business.
Summary XTB Limited offsets every client trade with its parent XTB S.A., which runs a market-maker book and hedges onward only when its limits are exceeded; the group serves clients through companies in at least seven jurisdictions, says it does not offer copy trading, and documents both CPA affiliates and volume-paid introducing brokers, while for EUR/USD it publishes a 0.8-pip minimum and a 1.2-pip target spread with no commission but no current average.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: XTB brand, group level (XTB S.A. and subsidiaries), 31 December 2025Established from documents
The parent's 2025 annual report gives a closed list of the group: XTB S.A. and 12 subsidiaries. It describes seven subsidiaries as providing brokerage services to clients under a local licence, in the United Kingdom, Cyprus, Belize, the United Arab Emirates (two companies), Chile and Indonesia, and the Polish parent serves clients itself and through seven EU branches. That is seven jurisdictions; five or more is grade 0 even as a lower bound, which narrows the earlier 0-2 range built on three. This reflects the simplicity preference only, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 7
3 addresses tried
- Published costs 6TAssigned tariff grade 6; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–6.Tariff basis: Standard: published account tariff; USD 8 tariff floor: USD 0 round-turn commission + 0.8 pips published minimum spread; actual spreads can be wider.Scope: Standard; XTB Limited, Standard account (retail CFD), xStation platform, EUR/USD, United KingdomPublished tariff assessment (Standard); average spread unverified
Tariff grade 6/10 for the named Standard account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published minimum spread 0.8 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 8 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark.
Missing A current average or typical EUR/USD spread that XTB Limited labels for its Standard account, or a published definition of 'target spread' that makes it the typical spread in normal conditions.
Account XTB Limited Standard account (the only ordinary retail CFD account on the UK site), xStation platformRound turn commission USD 0
11 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0Grade 0: confirmed no automated leader copyingScope: XTB Limited, xStation web platform and mobile app, United KingdomEstablished from documents
The UK help centre of XTB Limited says in terms that copy trading is not offered. The statement is unqualified, so it covers a service of any provider offered through XTB, and the same answer says Expert Advisors are not provided and API access was discontinued in March 2025, which leaves no documented route for an outside copy service. The UK terms mention social trading platforms only in a clause excluding liability for third-party software. 'XTB Social', described in the group annual report, sends notifications about other investors' trades and is not described as automatic copying; it is group-level context and was suspended in the EU.
3 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: XTB Limited, CFDs on the Standard account, retail client, United KingdomEstablished from documents
XTB Limited is the client's counterparty and sole execution venue for CFDs and its terms say it deals on a matched principal basis. Its filed accounts name the other side: every client trade is offset by an equal trade with its parent, XTB S.A., a group company, which by the reviewer's rule is 4 on its own. Onward routing is not left open: the parent describes a market-maker model that hedges only when its limits are exceeded, the UK specification table calls the business a market-maker model, and the UK terms say only that the firm 'frequently' hedges with other institutions. Routing outside the group is therefore discretionary; this does not establish how much is actually kept in-house.
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: XTB brand partner programmes: group partnership programme (XTB Services Limited, Cyprus, and XTB International Limited, Belize), group introducing brokers, and the introducing-broker clause of the XTB Limited termsEstablished from documents
Both kinds of partner pay are documented. The group's affiliate contract sets out a CPA plan (a payment per active client) next to per-lead, flat-fee and per-publication plans, and the partnership pages advertise up to USD 600 CPA. The group's annual report says it has cooperation agreements with introducing brokers whose commissions depend on trading volume, and the UK terms provide for clients introduced by an introducing broker. CPA and volume-based introducing-broker pay together are grade 4. This is a description of the programmes, not a statement about their propriety.
5 addresses tried
-
63overallequal
Hirose Financial
Assessment summary Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest Costs, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
2.0/104 penalties
Breakdown for Hirose Financial
- Company structure2PPenalty: low end of 2–4 · missing whether Hirose Financial MY Limited (Labuan) and Hirose Solutions Limited (Antigua and Barbuda) still operate as brokers after their LION Trader and MT4 services ended, and the group's list of operating companies at a date later than 31 March 2025.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing current partner terms of Hirose Financial UK Ltd: whether an introducer programme still runs, and whether any payment per funded client (CPA) is offered or expressly excluded.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not an account offer: Hirose Financial UK Ltd (London, company 07423885, FCA firm reference 540244, hiroseuk.com) for costs, copy, abook and affiliate; structure at group level (Hirose Tusyo Inc., Osaka, and its consolidated subsidiaries). Hirose Financial UK Ltd's own 2025 MIFIDPRU disclosure says its retail services have been phased out; the retail pages still online name no account type and take account-opening enquiries by email only. The parent's annual report is used for the group list and for the parent's own hedging practice, never as a statement about a Hirose UK account.
Summary Hirose Financial UK Ltd says in its 2025 disclosure that retail services have been phased out, and its parent reports the LION Trader and MT4 services ended, so no retail spread, copy service or partner terms could be read; what the documents do establish is a back-to-back hedge of every client trade with the Japanese parent, a group company that nets part of its flow internally, while the number of operating jurisdictions (2 to 4), the cost and the partner model remain open.
- Company structure 2PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 2–4. Not a finding.Scope: Hirose brand at group level: Hirose Tusyo Inc. and its consolidated subsidiaries (Japan, United Kingdom, Malaysia, Antigua and Barbuda)Investigated, not settled
The parent's annual report for the year to 31 March 2025 gives a closed list: the group is Hirose Tusyo Inc. and nine consolidated subsidiaries, of which five provide margin FX to clients, in Japan (the parent and JFX), the United Kingdom, Malaysia (Labuan) and Antigua and Barbuda; the rest are system, call-centre, payment, research and publishing companies. That is four operating jurisdictions at that date. The half-year report to September 2025 then says the LION Trader and MT4 services of the UK, Malaysian and Antiguan companies were ended, and Hirose UK says its retail services have been phased out, so only Japan (the parent, which is also Hirose UK's hedge venue) and the UK (still an authorised firm serving institutional clients) are established as operating today. The count is therefore 2 to 4, not 5 or more.
Missing Whether Hirose Financial MY Limited (Labuan) and Hirose Solutions Limited (Antigua and Barbuda) still operate as brokers after their LION Trader and MT4 services ended, and the group's list of operating companies at a date later than 31 March 2025.
Count lower bound 2
8 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Hirose Financial UK Ltd, margin FX (CFD) account for retail clients, EUR/USD, United Kingdom; no account type is named on the current siteInvestigated, not settled
No ordinary retail account with a published EUR/USD spread exists on the pages that remain. The retail section names no account type and no spread, the execution policy says the charges are the spread, rollover and interest with no commission, and the client agreement points to 'Market Information' pages that are no longer on the site. The only figure found is a 1.0 pip assumption in a 2017 worked example, which is neither a minimum nor an average, and the firm's own 2025 disclosure says retail services have been phased out. Nothing narrows the range.
Missing A EUR/USD spread that Hirose Financial UK Ltd publishes as average or typical for a named retail account, and confirmation that a retail account can still be opened at all.
Average spread published no
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Hirose Financial UK Ltd, retail section of hiroseuk.com (MaxxTrader platforms), United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No copy service is described anywhere in the remaining retail material of Hirose Financial UK Ltd: the platform page shows only MaxxTrader, MaxxWeb and MaxxGo, and the client agreement has no clause on copying, signals or strategy following. No page says that copy trading is not offered, either as an own product or through a third party, so a grade of 0 is not supported. The firm's own disclosure says retail services have been phased out.
Missing Any statement by Hirose Financial UK Ltd on automated leader/follower copying: either a described service or an explicit statement that none is offered, including through third parties.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Hirose Financial UK Ltd, margined FX and metals (CFDs), retail and professional clients, United Kingdom; onward routing: Hirose Tusyo Inc., JapanEstablished from documents
Hirose Financial UK Ltd's execution policy, which is part of the client agreement, says the firm is principal and sole venue and hedges each client trade at once, back to back, with Hirose Tusyo Inc.; the 2024 RTS 28 report shows 100% of orders going there. Hirose Tusyo Inc. is the firm's parent, so this is a route to a group company, which alone is 4 under the reviewer's rule. Onward routing is not left open: the parent's annual report says it covers positions with outside counterparties only in principle, offsets matching positions internally and earns that internal-offset income also on flow from firms it acts as counterparty for.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Hirose Financial UK Ltd, introducers of retail CFD clients, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
Hirose Financial UK Ltd's forex key information document says it may pay partners who introduce business, based on the revenue it earns and the client's trading activity, and its conflicts policy says an introducing third party may be paid commission from the client's trades. That documents an introducer payment tied to revenue or trading, which is the IB mechanism; no payment per funded client was found, and nothing says such payments are not made. The wording is permissive, the documents are dated 2017 and 2019, and no partner page or programme terms exist on the site.
Missing Current partner terms of Hirose Financial UK Ltd: whether an introducer programme still runs, and whether any payment per funded client (CPA) is offered or expressly excluded.
5 addresses tried
-
64overallequal
easyMarkets
Assessment summary Best Costs 8 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
1.8/103 penalties
Breakdown for easyMarkets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a ruling on whether a licensed intermediary counts as an operating brokerage company.
- Published costs8TWeb / App / TradingView: published account tariff. USD 6: USD 0 round-turn commission + 0.6 pips published fixed spread. Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Web / App / TradingView account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published fixed spread 0.6 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The 0.6-pip fixed-spread band applies 04:00–22:00 GMT; the published 22:00–04:00 band is 0.8 pip and spreads may be adjusted in extreme markets. The guaranteed-stop option can widen spreads. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. The minimum deposit is USD 25.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing whether EF Worldwide Ltd (BVI) hedges or passes on client positions at all, and if so whether the counterparty is a group company or a firm outside the group.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across the easyMarkets group, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and execution rest on EF Worldwide Ltd, British Virgin Islands (company no. 2031075, BVI FSC licence SIBA/L/20/1135), the company that operates the international site www.easy-markets.com/int/. It was chosen because that is the site this connection is served (the /eu/, /au/ and /syc/ paths all redirected to /int/), and its account table, spread table, client agreement and order execution policy could all be read. The earlier row named easyMarkets Australia (easyMarkets Pty Ltd, AFSL 246566): only its home page footer was re-opened; its PDS and client agreement were not re-read and nothing from them is used. The partner programme is contracted by the Cyprus parent, Blue Capital Markets Limited, for the whole group. Nothing is carried from the BVI company to the Cyprus, Australian or Seychelles companies. The brand's main domain is now easy-markets.com; easymarkets.com did not resolve.
Summary The group names client-contracting companies in four jurisdictions plus a South African intermediary, and its partner programme pays both per-client (CPA) and spread-share commissions; the BVI company's documents describe a dealing-desk model with liquidity normally from within the group and say nothing on hedging outside it, its commission-free fixed EUR/USD spread is published only as 'from' 0.6 pips (0.8 overnight), and no copy-trading service was found or ruled out.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: easyMarkets group (Blue Capital Markets Limited and its five listed companies)Investigated, not settled
The partner agreement gives the group's own list: a Cyprus parent and five companies in Cyprus, the British Virgin Islands, Seychelles, Australia and South Africa. Four of them contract with clients (the sign-up notices and client agreements name them), which caps the grade at 2. The fifth, EF Worldwide (PTY) Ltd in South Africa, states that it is only a licensed intermediary for CFDs issued by the Seychelles company. If a licensed intermediary with a client-facing role counts as an operating brokerage company the count is 5 and the grade 0; if only contracting or executing companies count it is 4 and the grade 2. The documents settle the facts; the choice between 0 and 2 is a rubric decision for the reviewer.
Missing A ruling on whether a licensed intermediary counts as an operating brokerage company.
Count lower bound 4
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 8TAssigned tariff grade 8; average all-in cost evidence remains 0–8.Tariff basis: Web / App / TradingView: published account tariff; USD 6: USD 0 round-turn commission + 0.6 pips published fixed spread.Scope: Web / App / TradingView; EF Worldwide Ltd, British Virgin Islands; easyMarkets Web / App and TradingView account (fixed spread), with MT4 and MT5 Standard and VIP compared; EUR/USD, USD accountPublished tariff assessment (Web / App / TradingView); fixed published spread
Tariff grade 8/10 for the named Web / App / TradingView account: USD 0 round-turn commission plus published fixed spread 0.6 pips, an advertised tariff floor of USD 6 per standard EUR/USD lot. This is not an observed or published average all-in cost; actual spreads and execution can differ. The 0.6-pip fixed-spread band applies 04:00–22:00 GMT; the published 22:00–04:00 band is 0.8 pip and spreads may be adjusted in extreme markets. The guaranteed-stop option can widen spreads. Financing, slippage and any separately selected copy-provider fees are outside this intraday broker-tariff benchmark. The minimum deposit is USD 25.
Missing A statement that the fixed EUR/USD spread on the ordinary (USD 25) easyMarkets Web / App and TradingView account is 0.6 pips (04:00–22:00 GMT) and 0.8 pips (22:00–04:00 GMT), not 'from' those figures, or a broker-published all-hours typical spread for a named account.
Account easyMarkets Web / App & TradingView (fixed spread), EF Worldwide Ltd (BVI)Round turn commission USD 0Pricing condition 04:00–22:00 GMT
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: EF Worldwide Ltd, British Virgin Islands; all platforms on the international siteInvestigated, not settled
A search of the international site's home page, site map, platform pages, account page and company FAQ, and of the BVI client agreement and execution policy, found no copy-trading, signal-following or strategy-following service. The only social feature mentioned is TradingView's network for sharing ideas, which is not automated copying. Nothing says that copying is not offered, so the grade stays open.
Missing Either a broker page or terms describing an automated leader/follower copy service, or an explicit statement that easyMarkets offers no copy trading, including through third parties.
7 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: EF Worldwide Ltd, British Virgin Islands; CFDs on the easyMarkets platforms, TradingView, MT4 and MT5Investigated, not settled
The BVI client agreement describes a dealing-desk model with the company as dealer and counterparty, and the execution policy says the company is principal and sole execution venue and 'normally provides liquidity from its inter-group liquidity flow'. Neither document commits to hedging or routing client orders outside the group, so nothing supports a grade above 4, the grade for a group-internal or discretionary arrangement. Neither says that client exposure is never hedged externally, so 0 is not established either. The MT5 page's 'Direct Market Access' is unexplained marketing and is contradicted by the contract wording, so it does not raise the range.
Missing Whether EF Worldwide Ltd (BVI) hedges or passes on client positions at all, and if so whether the counterparty is a group company or a firm outside the group.
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: easyMarkets Partner Program, contracted by Blue Capital Markets Limited (Cyprus) for the group, as advertised on the international siteEstablished from documents
The partner page advertises a CPA plan, a Spreadshare plan paying a share of the spread on referred clients' trading, a Hybrid of the two and a second tier. The affiliation agreement, made with the Cyprus parent for the whole group, defines the CPA plan (paid per qualified new active user after a deposit and trading), a cost-per-lead plan and revenue share by percentage of trading revenue or per lot. Both a revenue-share and a per-client payment are documented, which is grade 4.
-
65overallequal
FPG Fortune Prime Global
Assessment summary Best 3 criteria 4 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
1.8/104 penalties
Breakdown for FPG Fortune Prime Global
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a closed, current list of the companies that operate the brand, and the name and role of the company behind the Saint Vincent and the Grenadines number 1753LLC2022.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing how copied positions are sized, how a follower stops or pauses copying, and what the service costs (performance fee, subscription or mark-up).
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing current partner terms or a current page stating that CPA is, or is not, paid.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope FPG Fortune Prime Global · candidate only · brand-level feature review, not an account offer for any country. Costs, copy, A-book and affiliate rest on fortuneprime.com and the client documents of Fortune Prime Limited, Vanuatu, company number 700507, which says its services are for international clients and are not available to residents of the USA, Japan, Ukraine, New Zealand, Australia, North Korea, Myanmar and Iran. Fortune Prime Global Capital Pty Ltd (Australia, AFSL 400364 as stated by the brand) is counted for structure only; nothing from its documents is used for costs, copy, A-book or affiliate.
Summary Fortune Prime Limited's disclosure statement calls it a market maker that may hedge at its sole discretion with no obligation to do so (A-book 4), and the brand's own pages describe both lifetime rebates for introducing brokers and CPA commissions for affiliates (affiliate 4); costs, copy trading and company structure stay ranges because no average spread is published, the copy page states automatic copying without a sizing rule, follower controls or fees, and two operating companies were found with no closed list.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: FPG Fortune Prime Global brand; Fortune Prime Limited (Vanuatu) and Fortune Prime Global Capital Pty Ltd (Australia)Investigated, not settled
Two operating companies are documented. Fortune Prime Limited in Vanuatu is the contracting company in the international terms and is on the regulator's list; Fortune Prime Global Capital Pty Ltd in Australia issues its own disclosure statement as issuer of the CFDs offered to clients in Australia. The brand also claims a Saint Vincent and the Grenadines number without naming a company, and nothing published is a closed list of group companies, so at least two jurisdictions gives 0 to 4.
Missing A closed, current list of the companies that operate the brand, and the name and role of the company behind the Saint Vincent and the Grenadines number 1753LLC2022.
Count lower bound 2
8 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Fortune Prime Limited (Vanuatu), ECN account, EUR/USD, any listed platform (MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, WebTrader: one table for all); country eligibility not assessedInvestigated, not settled
Fortune Prime Limited (Vanuatu) publishes its ECN account as "from 0.0 pips" with a commission of USD 3.5 per lot, and no average or typical spread. The account page does not say whether the commission is per side or per round trip. A per-side reading (USD 7 round trip, which would cap the grade at 8) rests on the Australian company's disclosure statement and a 2023 article, not on the Vanuatu account terms; if it is per round trip the floor is USD 3.50 and 10 stays possible. With the basis unsettled for the company assessed, the range is open.
Missing Whether the Vanuatu ECN commission of USD 3.5 per lot is per side or per round trip, and a published average or typical EUR/USD spread for that account.
Account ECN (MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, WebTrader; the page shows one table for all platforms)Lower bound cost USD 7
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Fortune Prime Limited (Vanuatu) global site; product 'Copy Trade' (portal ct.fortuneprime.com); no country statedInvestigated, not settled
The broker's own Copy Trade page says a client selects a strategy provider, sets an amount, and the provider's trades are replicated automatically in real time, with a dedicated sign-in portal. That documents automated leader/follower copying as the broker's offer. The page gives no sizing rule beyond 'set your amount', no description of how a follower stops or pauses, and no fee, so the grade runs from 4 (automation only) to 10.
Missing How copied positions are sized, how a follower stops or pauses copying, and what the service costs (performance fee, subscription or mark-up).
7 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Fortune Prime Limited (Vanuatu); Margin FX contracts and CFDs; all account types (ECN and PRO are not distinguished in the documents); country eligibility not assessedEstablished from documents
Fortune Prime Limited contracts as principal and describes itself as a market maker and product issuer; acting as principal alone does not establish a B-book. Its disclosure statement says it may hedge its liability for client positions at its sole discretion and has no obligation to do so. The terms define a hedging partner as a counterparty to which trades are passed back to back, but no clause commits the company to pass client trades to one. Hedging at the firm's discretion is the anchor for 4.
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: FPG brand partner programmes (Introducing Broker, Affiliate) as published on fortuneprime.com by Fortune Prime Limited; no country statedInvestigated, not settled
The current affiliate page documents lifetime IB rebates. CPA of up to USD 1,000 appears in a 2024 brand article and an FAQ, but not on the current affiliate page. The rubric asks for current evidence, so CPA is recorded as a dated lead rather than a current programme: IB documented, CPA neither currently documented nor excluded.
Missing Current partner terms or a current page stating that CPA is, or is not, paid.
7 addresses tried
-
66overallequal
FxPro
Profile Best 3 criteria 4 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
1.8/103 penalties
Breakdown for FxPro
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing how a follower's trade size is set, whether a follower can stop or pause copying or set a loss limit, what fees apply, and which product or platform delivers the service for clients of FxPro Global Markets Ltd.
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing whether FxPro currently offers a CPA (pay per referred client) programme, or states that it does not.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope FxPro Global Markets Ltd (Bahamas, Securities Commission of The Bahamas licence SIA-F184) for costs, copy trading and execution terms; structure at brand level; partner remuneration from the same company's conflicts policy
Summary FxPro Global Markets Ltd (Bahamas) deals as principal and only may pass orders to liquidity providers, the brand contracts through at least five jurisdictions, and its public web pages on prices, copy trading and partners could not be read today.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: FxPro brand, all entitiesEstablished from documents
Client documents read today name five FxPro companies that contract with clients in five jurisdictions: FxPro Global Markets Ltd (Bahamas), FxPro Financial Services Ltd (Cyprus), FxPro UK Limited (United Kingdom), Pro Global Ltd (Antigua and Barbuda) and FxPro Markets Direct Costa Rica Latam, SRL (Costa Rica). A Mauritius partner, Prime Ash Capital Limited, also contracts with clients on FxPro's document host, and membership terms from 2025 name two Saint Lucia companies. Five or more is grade 0 even as a lower bound, so the earlier 0-4 (two jurisdictions found) is corrected to 0.
Count lower bound 5
2 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: FxPro Global Markets Ltd (Bahamas), EUR/USD, one lot, USD accountInvestigated, not settled
No spread or commission figure for FxPro Global Markets Ltd could be read. Its execution policy says a commission is charged on forex and metals on cTrader and a mark-up is added to the spread on every platform, and its client agreement sends the reader to the website for the amounts. Every page of that website refused the request, so there is no average, typical or minimum EUR/USD spread and no commission amount to grade.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for a named retail account of FxPro Global Markets Ltd, and that account's round-trip commission in USD.
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: FxPro Global Markets Ltd (Bahamas), Copy Trading Services under the client agreement; not checked for FxPro UK Limited or FxPro Financial Services LtdInvestigated, not settled
The client agreement of FxPro Global Markets Ltd defines Copy Trading Services as one client's trades being copied automatically by another, in real time and without manual action per trade, offered on an execution-only basis and possibly on third-party software. That documents automation in the contract itself. The agreement gives no sizing rule, no follower stop or pause controls and no fees, and does not name the product or platform; the website pages that may describe them could not be read.
Missing How a follower's trade size is set, whether a follower can stop or pause copying or set a loss limit, what fees apply, and which product or platform delivers the service for clients of FxPro Global Markets Ltd.
4 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: FxPro Global Markets Ltd (Bahamas), CFDs, all platforms; not carried to FxPro UK Limited or FxPro Financial Services LtdEstablished from documents
The Order Execution Policy of FxPro Global Markets Ltd, which the client agreement makes part of the contract, says the firm acts as principal at all times, is the sole execution venue, and may transmit orders to third-party liquidity providers. 'May' leaves external transmission to the firm's discretion, and its conflicts policy describes a department that manages the firm's own exposure as principal. That is discretionary external transmission, which the anchor grades 4; it does not show that the firm actually internalises. No-dealing-desk wording on the website was not graded.
1 address tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: FxPro Global Markets Ltd (Bahamas) introducer arrangements; brand partner pages not readInvestigated, not settled
The conflicts policy of FxPro Global Markets Ltd says introducers are paid for the clients they refer, usually by rebates, and that other remuneration arrangements may exist. That documents an introducer programme paid on rebates; it neither documents nor excludes CPA. The brand's partner pages and a 2024 affiliate announcement used for the earlier assessment could not be re-opened today, so the earlier range of 4-10 is confirmed on a different document and CPA stays open.
Missing Whether FxPro currently offers a CPA (pay per referred client) programme, or states that it does not.
5 addresses tried
-
67overallequal
IG
Profile Best 3 criteria 4 · weakest Structure, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
1.8/101 penalty
Breakdown for IG
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs4USD 10.40 round trip
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope IG Markets Limited (United Kingdom, FCA 195355, company number 04008957), the IG company that provides CFD accounts on the UK site. Costs, copy and abook all rest on this entity. Spread betting (IG Index Limited) and share dealing (IG Trading and Investments Limited) are separate UK companies and are not assessed. The affiliate grade rests on the partner pages of the UK site.
Summary The UK CFD company publishes average EUR/USD spreads with no commission and keeps discretion over whether to hedge client trades, inside a group that contracts with clients in at least seven jurisdictions and pays affiliates per acquisition.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: IG brand, group levelEstablished from documents
The brand contracts with clients through separate companies in at least seven jurisdictions, each with its own legal hub on ig.com: United Kingdom, Germany, Switzerland, Australia, Singapore, Bermuda and the United Arab Emirates. Five or more is grade 0 even as a lower bound, which confirms the earlier grade and adds Bermuda and the UAE to the five already on file. This reflects the simplicity preference only, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 7
- Published costs 4Grade 4: USD over 10 to 15Scope: IG Markets Limited, CFD account (standard EUR/USD contract, web platform or MetaTrader 4), retail client, United KingdomEstablished from documents
IG Markets Limited charges no commission on forex CFDs, so the scenario cost is the spread. Its product-details page labels two EUR/USD averages for the standard contract: 1.04 pips for the whole week (Monday 00:00 to Friday 22:00 GMT) and 0.85 pips for 00:00 to 21:00 GMT. Where a broker publishes both, this review uses the broadest labelled all-hours figure, so that no favourable trading window is selected: 1.04 pips is USD 10.40, grade 4. Both averages come from the 12 weeks ending 8 January 2021, although the page is dated 8 September 2026, so the figure is old. On the session-specific average the cost would be USD 8.50 and the grade 6; that is recorded as an alternative, not adopted.
Round turn commission USD 0Average spread pips 1.04Indicative cost USD 10.4
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: IG Markets Limited, CFD account (web platform, IG app, MT4 and MT5), United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No IG Markets Limited page or document describes an automated leader/follower copying service, and none says that copy trading is not offered. Since the last check the UK site has added MetaTrader 5. Its CFD guide documents automated trading only as the client's own or third-party Expert Advisors, does not mention MetaTrader Signals and calls MetaQuotes unrelated to IG. A full crawl of the UK help centre (326 articles) found no article on copy, social or mirror trading. The client agreement bars third-party automation without IG's written consent, but that is not an explicit 'not offered', so the grade stays open.
Missing An explicit statement by IG Markets Limited or the UK help centre that automated copying of other traders (including third-party services such as MetaTrader Signals) is or is not offered to UK CFD clients.
27 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: IG Markets Limited, CFDs, retail client, United KingdomEstablished from documents
The execution policy, which forms part of IG Markets Limited's terms of business, says the firm acts as principal, market maker and sole execution venue for CFDs and may choose whether to hedge part or all of a client contract in the underlying market. It adds that orders are auto-accepted without reference to the firm's exposure where possible, and that large orders may be worked in the market. The client agreement confirms the principal and market-maker capacity and sets no duty to hedge. Hedging at the firm's discretion is grade 4 by the anchor; this does not establish how much the firm actually internalises.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: IG partner programmes as offered on the UK site (affiliate programme and IG Prime introducing broker programme)Established from documents
The UK affiliate programme pays a one-off amount per qualified client (CPA) and states that it operates no revenue share model. Separately, the UK site offers an introducing broker programme under a standard IB agreement, through which a broker earns revenue from the clients it introduces; its rates and basis are not published. Both an introducing-broker route and CPA are documented, which is grade 4.
-
68overallequal
JFD Brokers
Assessment summary Best 3 criteria 4 · weakest Structure, Costs 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
1.8/103 penalties
Breakdown for JFD Brokers
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a closed list of the JFD group's operating companies, and whether JFD Bank AG is a current group brokerage company.
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 5.40 round-turn commission plus spread. All-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–8 · missing a published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for the JFD Group Ltd account (or, for JFD Overseas Ltd, a EUR/USD average per account and the per-side basis of the Pro commission).
- Copy trading4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the sizing or allocation rule for followers and the performance-fee rate and calculation at JFD Overseas Ltd; for JFD Group Ltd, any statement on whether copying is offered.
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across two companies, not a single account offer: structure, costs and abook rest on JFD Group Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC licence 150/11, trade name JFD Europe; CySEC-approved domains jfdbrokers.com and jfdeurope.com; one live account type on MT4+ or MT5+, EEA residents). Copy rests on JFD Overseas Ltd (Vanuatu, VFSC licence 17933, jfdoverseas.com), because the JFD Group Ltd pages and client agreement describe no copy service. Affiliate is documented for both. From this connection (outside Europe) every jfdbrokers.com address redirects to jfdoverseas.com, so JFD Group Ltd was read on jfdeurope.com.
Summary JFD Group Ltd's execution policy lets it choose at its own discretion between dealing as principal and passing an order to an unnamed third-party venue, and CPA as well as IB or revenue-share partner payments are advertised; the number of operating jurisdictions (at least two), the retail EUR/USD cost (USD 5.40 round-trip commission, no average spread published) and the sizing rule and fee rate of the copy service at JFD Overseas Ltd are not settled by the documents read.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: JFD brand: JFD Group Ltd (Cyprus), JFD Overseas Ltd (Vanuatu); JFD Bank AG (Germany) noted, not countedInvestigated, not settled
Two companies contract with clients under the JFD name on their own documents: JFD Group Ltd in Cyprus (CySEC 150/11, the company behind jfdbrokers.com and jfdeurope.com) and JFD Overseas Ltd in Vanuatu (VFSC 17933), which says it belongs to the same group. JFD Bank AG in Germany carries the name and says the JFD group took it over, but it serves business clients only and no current group document states its place in the group. No closed list of the group's operating companies was found, so two is a lower bound and the grade is a range.
Missing A closed list of the JFD group's operating companies, and whether JFD Bank AG is a current group brokerage company.
Count lower bound 2
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–8. Not a finding.Scope: JFD Group Ltd, single live account (MT4+ or MT5+, same commission), USD account, Cyprus / EEA residentsInvestigated, not settled
JFD Group Ltd has one live account type with the same pricing on MT4+ and MT5+. Its forex commission on a USD account is USD 2.70 per lot per side, so USD 5.40 round trip, but it publishes no average or typical EUR/USD spread: the cost page says spreads are variable and the only spread page is a live quote table. The commission alone puts the cost above USD 5, so 10 is excluded and nothing more can be fixed. JFD Overseas Ltd publishes an average spread for forex as a class per account, not for EUR/USD, so it gives no grade either and is recorded in facts only.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for the JFD Group Ltd account (or, for JFD Overseas Ltd, a EUR/USD average per account and the per-side basis of the Pro commission).
Account JFD Europe single live account (MT4+ or MT5+), JFD Group LtdRound turn commission USD 5.4
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: JFD Overseas Ltd, JFD Overseas Copy Trading (MT4/MT5 accounts), Vanuatu; no evidence either way for JFD Group Ltd, CyprusInvestigated, not settled
This criterion uses JFD Overseas Ltd, not JFD Group Ltd: the Cyprus company's site, FAQ and client agreement describe no copy service and contain no statement that none is offered, so for it alone the answer would stay open. JFD Overseas Ltd documents its own Copy Trading service as automated copying of Strategy Providers, with follower controls (maximum loss limits, pause, unsubscribe, reconnect). It names performance fees paid by followers but gives no rate, and it describes no sizing or allocation rule. Automation is therefore documented (at least 4); 6 needs the fee statement to be accepted as fee documentation and 10 needs the sizing rule as well.
Missing The sizing or allocation rule for followers and the performance-fee rate and calculation at JFD Overseas Ltd; for JFD Group Ltd, any statement on whether copying is offered.
7 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: JFD Group Ltd, retail and professional clients, single live account (MT4+ or MT5+), Cyprus / EEAEstablished from documents
JFD Group Ltd's best-execution policy and client agreement say the same thing: on some occasions the company deals as principal and is the sole execution venue (its 'Dealing Desk Execution Model'), and on others it may decide at its own discretion to place the order with a third-party execution venue to manage its risk. That is discretionary external transmission, not a contractual external route, whatever agency or DMA wording appears elsewhere. No execution venue is named in either document, so whether a venue is a group company cannot be said.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: JFD brand partner programmes: JFD Overseas Ltd (Vanuatu) affiliate and IB programmes; JFD Partner Program on jfdpartners.com (CySEC-approved domain of JFD Group Ltd, page head only)Established from documents
JFD Overseas Ltd publishes two programmes: an affiliate programme with a 'Qualified CPA' model (a fixed payment for each referred client who meets qualification criteria) and an introducing-broker programme with multi-level IB commission on client referrals and on the trading activity of the IB's network. The JFD Partner Program on jfdpartners.com, a domain CySEC lists for JFD Group Ltd, also names CPA beside rebates and revenue sharing. Both an IB or revenue-share model and CPA are documented, which is the anchor for 4.
1 address tried
-
69overallequal
MultiBank Group
Assessment summary Best 3 criteria 4 · weakest Structure, Copy 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
1.8/105 penalties
Breakdown for MultiBank Group
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing client documents or a group statement showing which of the listed companies besides the Australian, Cyprus and Vanuatu ones contract with clients or execute their orders, and a closed list of the group's operating companies.
- Published costs4PAll-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the unit of the ECN commission (per standard lot; per side or round turn) and the amount charged on a USD account; the observation period of the published averages.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing which of the two statements governs, and the identity of the executing brokers and hedging counterparties (group companies or outside firms).
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the payment trigger of the affiliate programme, and either a published CPA plan or an affirmative statement that no CPA is paid.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope MultiBank Group / MEX Australia Pty Ltd (Australia, AFSL 416279, trading as MEX Markets) for costs, copy and abook; structure and affiliate are brand-level across the group. Brand-level feature review, not an account offer. The group's main sites (multibankfx.com, multibankgroup.com, mexatlantic.com) refused every request, so MEX Atlantic Corporation and the other companies behind them were not read; country eligibility not assessed.
Summary For MEX Australia the site gives labelled average EUR/USD spreads (1.3 pips commission-free on Classic; 0.2 pips on ECN plus an AUD 7 commission whose unit is not stated) and two conflicting descriptions of hedging; the group's main site refused every request, so the company count, copy trading and the partner payment models remain ranges.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: MultiBank Group brand, all companiesInvestigated, not settled
Three operating, client-contracting companies of the brand are documented by their own client documents: MEX Australia Pty Ltd (Australia), MEX Europe Ltd (Cyprus) and MEX Pacific (V) Ltd (Vanuatu). The group's regulation page names further licensed companies in the Cayman Islands, the British Virgin Islands, the United Arab Emirates, Singapore, Germany with an Austrian branch, Mauritius and elsewhere, but it states licences only and their client documents sit on sites that refused every request. A licence alone does not raise the count, so the documented lower bound is three and the list is not closed.
Missing Client documents or a group statement showing which of the listed companies besides the Australian, Cyprus and Vanuatu ones contract with clients or execute their orders, and a closed list of the group's operating companies.
Count lower bound 3
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: MEX Australia Pty Ltd (Australia), Classic and ECN accounts, MetaTrader 4, USD base currency available; other MultiBank companies not readInvestigated, not settled
MEX Australia publishes EUR/USD averages labelled per account: 1.3 pips on the commission-free Classic account and 0.2 pips on the ECN account. The Classic account is fully documented at USD 13, which fixes the grade at 4 or better. The ECN commission is shown on the site only as "$7 AUD" with no unit, while the company's PDS and FSG say margin FX carries no commission at all. The readings therefore run from USD 2 (no commission, grade 10) through about USD 6 to 7 (AUD 7 round turn, grade 8) to above USD 10 (AUD 7 per side, grade 4). No reading can be excluded on the documents, and no observation period is given for the averages.
Missing The unit of the ECN commission (per standard lot; per side or round turn) and the amount charged on a USD account; the observation period of the published averages.
Account Classic account, MetaTrader 4 (fully documented); ECN account, MetaTrader 4 (commission unit open)
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: MEX Australia Pty Ltd (Australia), MetaTrader 4; other MultiBank companies not readInvestigated, not settled
The MEX Australia site has a Signal Providers page that describes the MetaTrader Trading Signals service as automatic copying of experienced traders and sends the reader to mql5.com to subscribe. It presents the service as MetaTrader's, gives no sizing rule, follower control or fee, and the client agreement says the company does not support third-party tools, signals included. Under the reviewer's rule a platform feature counts only when the broker presents it as its own service, so this is not taken as a documented copy product; nothing says copying is not offered, so no 0 either. The group's social trading page is on a site that refused every request.
Missing A broker document that presents a copy service as its own offer and describes automatic copying, sizing, follower stop or pause and fees; or an explicit statement that none is offered.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: MEX Australia Pty Ltd (Australia), margin FX and CFDs, Classic and ECN accountsInvestigated, not settled
Two documents of MEX Australia dated the same day disagree. The client agreement says, in its electronic trading schedule, that the company has an agency execution model and automatically covers all client positions with executing brokers and liquidity providers. The PDS says the company is a market maker that may, but is not obliged to, hedge and has the discretion not to hedge some or all trades. The first reads as a blanket external route (6), the second as hedging at the firm's discretion (4). The executing brokers are not named, so it is also not shown that they are outside the group.
Missing Which of the two statements governs, and the identity of the executing brokers and hedging counterparties (group companies or outside firms).
2 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: MultiBank Group brand partner programmes; documented for MEX Australia Pty Ltd, with group and MEX Europe statements; the main group site was not readInvestigated, not settled
An introducing-broker model paid on client trading is documented: the MEX Australia FSG bases referrer compensation on the referred clients' trading volume, its Introducing Broker page pays a rebate commission after each closed client transaction, and the group describes an Introducing Brokers programme with commission and rebate structures. A separate affiliate programme for bloggers, marketers and comparison sites exists, but the text that could be read gives no payment trigger. No CPA payment was found in the pages that could be read and nothing excludes one; the group's main partner pages refused every request.
Missing The payment trigger of the affiliate programme, and either a published CPA plan or an affirmative statement that no CPA is paid.
5 addresses tried
-
70overallequal
World Forex
Assessment summary Best Copy 8 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
1.8/105 penalties
Breakdown for World Forex
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing a group-level closed list of the companies that currently operate the World Forex brand, or confirmation that the Existrade companies no longer operate.
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 0 round-turn commission plus spread. Penalty: nothing established
- Copy trading8PPenalty: low end of 8–10 · missing a readable World Forex or WFCopy page describing how a follower stops or pauses copying.
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing an execution policy or client-agreement clause of Exispro LTD that commits to, or excludes, passing orders to or hedging them with outside parties.
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing a statement that CPA or a per-client payment is, or is not, paid.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review of World Forex, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and A-book rest on Exispro LTD (Saint Lucia IBC, registration 2023-00137), the only company the current English, Russian and Thai public offer agreements, contacts page and site footer name as operator and contracting party. The WFCopy copy platform's operator is not named; the World Forex site presents it as the brand's own service for World Forex accounts. Existrade companies named on a 2020-dated partner page are not used for any factor.
Summary The current documents name one Saint Lucia company and show a per-lot IB programme and an automated copy service with sizing and author fees; spreads are published only as minimums, execution rests on ECN/STP marketing, and the group size and follower stop controls are not settled.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: World Forex brand; Exispro LTD, Saint LuciaInvestigated, not settled
The current English, Russian and Thai agreements and the contacts page name one operating and contracting company, Exispro LTD in Saint Lucia. A 2020-dated partner page lists Existrade companies in Vanuatu, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, the UK and the BVI, and the Financial Commission profile calls the brand part of an Existrade group, but no current document says which group companies operate. One jurisdiction found without a closed group list gives a range from 0 to the Saint Lucia grade.
Missing A group-level closed list of the companies that currently operate the World Forex brand, or confirmation that the Existrade companies no longer operate.
Count lower bound 1
5 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Exispro LTD, Saint Lucia; W-PROFI (MT4/MT5, USD), EUR/USDInvestigated, not settled
No World Forex page publishes an average or typical EUR/USD spread. The account page gives W-PROFI (no commission) only as 'floating from 0.6 pips'; the specification table shows an unlabelled spread of 0.2 pip on MT4 and 0.6 pip on MT5 for W-PROFI, and the ECN page says 'from 0.2 pips' with zero commission. The lowest published minimum, 0.2 pip, implies at least USD 2, which does not cap the grade, and W-INSTANT's conditions are not published, so the cheapest account cannot be confirmed.
Missing A EUR/USD average or typical spread that the broker labels for a named retail account, and W-INSTANT's published conditions.
Account W-PROFI (MT4/MT5, USD), cheapest named standard-lot account with a published spread; W-INSTANT conditions unpublishedRound turn commission USD 0
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 8PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 8–10. Not a finding.Scope: World Forex brand; WFCopy for World Forex (Exispro LTD) trading accountsInvestigated, not settled
World Forex presents WFCopy as its own service: subscribers' accounts automatically replicate a chosen signal author's trades, subscribers can adjust copied volumes, and authors charge a fee per copied lot, a share of profit or a fixed 30-day subscription. Follower stop or pause controls are not described on any page that could be read and verified, so the grade stays between 8 and 10.
Missing A readable World Forex or WFCopy page describing how a follower stops or pauses copying.
3 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: Exispro LTD, Saint Lucia; Forex and CFD accounts (agreement); ECN marketing page of the brand websiteInvestigated, not settled
Exispro LTD's public offer agreement has trades confirmed by the company's Dealer, who may re-quote, and makes no commitment to pass orders to or hedge them with an outside party; no separate execution policy is published among the legal documents. The only routing claim is the ECN/STP marketing page saying orders reach interbank liquidity, which is not a contractual term.
Missing An execution policy or client-agreement clause of Exispro LTD that commits to, or excludes, passing orders to or hedging them with outside parties.
2 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Exispro LTD, Saint Lucia; Internet Partner, YouTube Partner and Representative Office programmesInvestigated, not settled
Exispro LTD's affiliate agreement and the partner pages document a three-level IB programme that pays a USD amount per standard lot (up to 85% of spread) from referred clients' trades. No CPA or per-funded-client payment was found, but there is no statement excluding CPA, and the Representative Office terms are set individually.
Missing A statement that CPA or a per-client payment is, or is not, paid.
2 addresses tried
-
71overallequal
1.8/103 penalties
Breakdown for XM
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading8PPenalty: low end of 8–10 · missing a plain statement that the follower can pause copying, stop copying or set a stop on a subscription from the follower's own account.
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a statement by XM Global Limited of whether it hedges client exposure at all, and if so with whom (inside or outside the group).
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across XM companies, not a single account offer. Copy trading, execution terms and the partner programme rest on XM Global Limited (Belize, FSC), the entity for which the most could be documented; costs could not be read for any entity; structure is counted across the group. The earlier row used Trading Point of Financial Instruments Ltd (Cyprus), whose client agreement has no copy-trading chapter and whose product pages were refused on this check.
Summary XM contracts with clients through companies in at least five jurisdictions; XM Global Limited (Belize) documents automated copying with proportional sizing and manager fees, deals as market maker and sole execution venue, and pays partners both CPA and rebates, while its spreads could not be read and follower pause controls and any hedging policy are not settled.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: XM brand: XM Global Limited (Belize), Trading Point of Financial Instruments Ltd (Cyprus), XM (SC) Limited (Seychelles), XM (BVI) Limited (British Virgin Islands), Trading.com Markets Pty Ltd (Australia)Established from documents
Separate client agreements name a contracting company in Belize, Cyprus, Seychelles, the British Virgin Islands and Australia, and the Seychelles company is also on its regulator's list. That is at least five client-contracting jurisdictions, so the grade is 0 even as a lower bound. Companies named for Mauritius and Kenya in the introducer agreement were not opened, a Dubai register entry was refused, and the South African company is an intermediary for XM Global and is not counted.
Count lower bound 5
3 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: No entity or account established; XM Global Limited (Belize) was the intended entityNot established
Every page on www.xm.com and its sister domains was refused, so no account table, EUR/USD spread or commission could be read for any XM entity. The legal documents that could be read give no figures: the XM Global agreement only refers to a commission and charges schedule on the trading site. No bound is set.
Missing A EUR/USD average or typical spread that the page labels for a named XM Global retail account, and that account's round-trip commission per standard lot.
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 8PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 8–10. Not a finding.Scope: XM Global Limited (Belize), XM Copy Trading platform, Investor account. Not established for Trading Point of Financial Instruments Ltd (Cyprus), whose client agreement does not mention copy trading.Investigated, not settled
XM Global's client agreement has a copy trading chapter: trades of a Manager are recreated automatically in the follower's account, sized in proportion to the amount the follower allocates, and the follower pays the fee the Manager sets. The same chapter lists pausing new positions, closing all positions and exiting a subscription among the actions the company performs for the follower, but does not say plainly that the follower starts them, so follower controls stay unverified.
Missing A plain statement that the follower can pause copying, stop copying or set a stop on a subscription from the follower's own account.
4 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: XM Global Limited (Belize), all CFD accounts on its trading platformInvestigated, not settled
XM Global's execution policy, which is part of the client terms, says the company is always the counterparty, is the sole execution venue and does not transmit client orders to an external market; the agreement calls the company a market maker. The agreement also keeps a general discretion to deal through an intermediate broker, which may be a group associate, and mentions hedging transactions in a definition, without any commitment to hedge. The route excludes external order routing, which points to 0, but hedging is not excluded and is left to discretion, which points to 4; nothing commits to routing outside the group.
Missing A statement by XM Global Limited of whether it hedges client exposure at all, and if so with whom (inside or outside the group).
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: XM partner programme operated by XM Global Limited (partners.xm.com), global; plan availability varies by countryEstablished from documents
The XM partner site lists a CPA plan (up to USD 1,000 per client) next to lot rebates or revenue share on spread and a CPL plan, and the introducer agreement of XM Global Limited pays a fixed fee or percentage per lot, per client or per lead. Both a CPA route and an IB/revenue-share route are documented, which is grade 4. The Cyprus entity's client agreement describes its affiliates as paid a one-off fixed payment only; that is an entity-level detail and does not change the brand grade.
-
72overallequal
1.5/105 penalties
Breakdown for BDSwiss
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a closed, current list of the brand's operating and client-contracting companies, and register confirmation for the Mauritius and Mwali companies.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading6PPenalty: low end of 6–10 · missing a description of how the follower's position size is set (the 'Equity Allocation' rule), and product terms on a public page.
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing how the Affiliate programme pays (per funded client, per lot or share of revenue), and whether CPA is offered or excluded.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across the BDSwiss client portals, not a single account offer. Product text was read from the client-portal app served at dashboard.bdswiss.com, which is configured for BDS Markets (Mauritius, FSC C116016172); the Seychelles (BDS Ltd) and Mwali (BDSwiss Investments LTD) portals were read for structure only. The public website, legal hub and partner site redirect to the login portal, so no client agreement, execution policy, pricing page or partner agreement could be read. Whether new accounts can be opened, and country eligibility, were not assessed.
Summary Only the login portals and their app text could be read: they describe an introducing-broker programme and automated copying, while costs, execution terms, the copy sizing rule, CPA and a closed entity count are not established because the public site and legal documents redirect to the login page.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: BDSwiss brand: BDS Markets (Mauritius), BDS Ltd (Seychelles), BDSwiss Investments LTD (Mwali, Comoros)Investigated, not settled
The brand runs three live client portals, each configured for a different company and showing that company's risk warning: BDS Markets in Mauritius, BDS Ltd in Seychelles and BDSwiss Investments LTD in Mwali (Comoros). That is at least three disclosed client-contracting jurisdictions. No group page with a closed list could be read (the legal hub redirects to the login), and the South African intermediary's current role is not settled, so the count is a lower bound. The former Cyprus firm is listed by CySEC as withdrawn and is not counted.
Missing A closed, current list of the brand's operating and client-contracting companies, and register confirmation for the Mauritius and Mwali companies.
Count lower bound 3
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: BDSwiss client-portal app as served for BDS Markets (Mauritius); no account selectedInvestigated, not settled
No pricing page could be read: the account-types and spread pages redirect to the login portal. The portal app carries one spread figure per account subtype, shown under the label 'Average spread (EUR/USD)' in a comparison and as the level spreads 'start at' in the account description, so it cannot be relied on as an average. Commissions are quoted 'per lot' without a side basis. A figure that is labelled both ways narrows nothing.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to a named retail account, and that account's round-trip commission per standard lot.
4 addresses tried
- Copy trading 6PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 6–10. Not a finding.Scope: BDSwiss own copy product as described in the client-portal app served for BDS Markets (Mauritius); MT4 account subtypes basic and standard per the portal configurationInvestigated, not settled
The portal's own dialogs describe automated replication of a strategy provider's positions, a stop-copying control and a percentage performance fee set per strategy. The sizing rule is only named ('Equity Allocation model', a 'Multiplier' field) and not explained, so sizing is not documented. The evidence is interface text in the portal app; the public product page and terms could not be read, and whether the feature can be used on a new account today was not established.
Missing A description of how the follower's position size is set (the 'Equity Allocation' rule), and product terms on a public page.
4 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: BDS Markets (Mauritius); no document readNot established
No client agreement or execution policy of any current BDSwiss company could be read: the terms, legal-documents and PDF addresses all redirect to the login portal. The only execution policy still served is a March 2018 document of the former Cyprus firm, whose licence is withdrawn; it is not carried to another company. Account names such as 'STP' in the app are labels, not a commitment.
Missing The execution policy or client agreement clause of the named company saying whether client orders are hedged or routed outside the group, and at whose discretion.
6 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: BDSwiss partner programmes: Introducing Broker and Affiliate accounts in the portal served for BDS Markets (Mauritius); master-IB appendix of BDS Ltd (Seychelles)Investigated, not settled
An introducing-broker programme paid on referred clients' trading is described in the portal ('Up to $28 per lot', sub-partner commissions), and the Seychelles company's master-IB appendix gives a master IB 20% of its sub-partners' commissions. A separate Affiliate account with 'customised commission plans' exists, but its payment trigger is not stated and the partner agreements redirect to the login. CPA was neither found nor excluded.
Missing How the Affiliate programme pays (per funded client, per lot or share of revenue), and whether CPA is offered or excluded.
5 addresses tried
-
73overallequal
ActivTrades
Profile Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
1.2/102 penalties
Breakdown for ActivTrades
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 0 round-turn commission plus spread. Penalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope ActivTrades PLC (United Kingdom, FCA 434413) for costs, copy and abook; structure and affiliate are assessed for the brand
Summary Five separate ActivTrades companies in five jurisdictions publish their own client agreements, and the UK firm's policies leave external hedging to its discretion.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: ActivTrades brand, all group companies that contract with clientsEstablished from documents
Five ActivTrades companies in five different jurisdictions each publish their own client agreement naming themselves as the contracting party: United Kingdom, Bahamas, Mauritius, Portugal and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines. Five or more client-contracting jurisdictions is grade 0 even as a lower bound. A Brazilian company and a UAE licence are also named by the group but were not needed for the count; this reflects the simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 5
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: ActivTrades PLC, Individual (retail) CFD account (the table names no account type), EUR/USD, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
The rendered UK spreads table has no average or typical column. It has a 'Current spread' (0.8 pips for EUR/USD when read, 0.9 on the instrument page a minute later) and a 'Target spread' of 0.5 pips, under a page heading that calls the figures 'typical spreads'. The target spread is not defined, has no period and is not tied to any account type, and the live spread stood above it at both readings, so it is recorded as a fact and not used as a published average. With no forex commission the 0.5 pip figure would mean USD 5 and grade 10 if the reviewer accepts it as the typical spread of the Individual account; without that the range stays 0–10.
Missing A statement by ActivTrades PLC of what the 'target spread' is (an average, a typical value or a best case), over what period, and for which account type; or a separately published average EUR/USD spread for the Individual account.
Round turn commission USD 0
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: ActivTrades PLC, retail accounts, United KingdomNot established
No ActivTrades PLC page or document that was read describes an automated leader/follower copying product, and none says that copying is not offered. The only related items are managed (MAM) accounts for money managers, which are not leader/follower copying, and a general educational article on the global site. Absence of a mention is not evidence of absence, so the range stays open.
Missing A statement by ActivTrades PLC that an automated leader/follower copying product is offered (with its sizing, stop controls and fees), or that none is offered.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: ActivTrades PLC, all client orders, United KingdomEstablished from documents
ActivTrades PLC's order execution policy says the firm is the only execution venue, acts as principal and uses liquidity providers for prices and for hedging its own risk. Its conflicts policy says client trades are offset against each other and the remaining exposure may or may not be hedged externally. That is discretionary hedging, not a commitment to route orders out; acting as principal is not by itself counted against it.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: ActivTrades brand partner programme (ActivPartner); availability per group company not establishedEstablished from documents
The brand's partner site documents both routes: introducing brokers paid by revenue share or a rebate per lot, and affiliates paid per client (CPA), plus a hybrid. Both documented is grade 4, which confirms the existing grade. The site notes that not every model is available through every group company.
-
74overallequal
Capital.com
Profile Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
1.2/103 penalties
Breakdown for Capital.com
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established (review hold)
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing whether Capital Com SV Investments, the Cyprus group company that executes every UK order as principal, passes the risk on outside the group.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Capital Com (UK) Limited (United Kingdom, FCA FRN 793714). Costs, copy and abook all rest on this entity; the affiliate grade rests on the group affiliate agreement, which names this entity and the United Kingdom.
Summary The UK company charges no commission and publishes no average EUR/USD spread. It routes every CFD order to its Cyprus affiliate, which is inside the group, so routing outside the group is unresolved. The group contracts with clients in at least six jurisdictions and documents both CPA and an introducing-broker route.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Capital.com brand, group levelEstablished from documents
The brand contracts with clients through separate companies in at least six jurisdictions, each with its own legal hub on capital.com: United Kingdom, Cyprus, Australia, Bahamas, United Arab Emirates and Kenya. The UK firm's own regulatory disclosure names the first five and leaves the list open; Kenya was found on the site. Five or more is grade 0 even as a lower bound, which confirms the earlier grade and adds Kenya. This reflects the simplicity preference only, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 6
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Capital Com (UK) Limited, retail CFD account (one account type; prices as shown on capital.com/en-gb), EUR/USD, United KingdomHeld as a range by independent review
No commission is documented. The 0.6-pip worked example is illustrative and the 0.7-pip instrument quote is a snapshot. Neither establishes an advertised minimum or a period-average EUR/USD spread, so neither can narrow the price-score range.
11 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Capital Com (UK) Limited, retail account, United KingdomNot established
No Capital Com (UK) Limited document read today mentions a copy-trading, mirror-trading or signal-following product: not the client terms, the execution policy, the platform pages or the site navigation. The MT4 page documents Expert Advisors, which automate a client's own rules and are not leader copying. Silence is not evidence of absence, and the help centre, where such a statement would normally sit, refused the request, so the grade stays open.
Missing An explicit statement by Capital Com (UK) Limited (or the brand's help centre for UK clients) that automated copying of other traders is, or is not, offered.
9 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: Capital Com (UK) Limited, CFDs and spread bets, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
The UK execution policy, which forms part of the client terms, fixes one route: every CFD and spread bet order goes to the Cyprus affiliate Capital Com SV Investments as sole execution venue, and the terms commit to matched principal dealing for all transactions. That is a contractual blanket route with no discretion at the UK firm and no per-fill condition, which is grade 6 by the anchor. The receiving company is a group affiliate that acts as principal and gives no external hedging commitment, so the documents do not commit the group to hedge outside itself; read that way the anchor is 4. The range reflects that one open reading, not missing documents.
Missing Whether Capital Com SV Investments, the Cyprus group company that executes every UK order as principal, passes the risk on outside the group.
2 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Capital.com partner programmes as offered to UK clients and partners (Capital Com (UK) Limited; affiliate programme administered by Capital Com Services Limited)Established from documents
The affiliate agreement, which names Capital Com (UK) Limited and the United Kingdom, pays affiliates on a CPA plan (per qualified trader), a per-lead plan or a flat fee. Separately, the UK partnerships page offers an introducing broker agreement and the UK client terms provide for introducers whose agreed fees are paid through the client's account. Both an introducing-broker route and CPA are documented, which is grade 4; the introducing broker's remuneration terms are not published.
-
75overallequal
CMC Markets
Profile Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
1.2/102 penalties
Breakdown for CMC Markets
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope CMC Markets UK plc (United Kingdom, FCA 173730): CFD account and FX Active account on the Next Generation platform and MetaTrader 4. Costs, copy and abook rest on this company only. Affiliate is brand-level (the CPA and IB partner page is published by CMC Markets Bermuda Limited); structure is group-level (CMC Markets plc annual report 2026).
Summary A listed group with online-trading subsidiaries in at least eight jurisdictions; its UK company is the sole execution venue, hedges at its own discretion and publishes only minimum spreads.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: CMC Markets brand, CMC Markets plc group, as at 31 March 2026Established from documents
The group's 2026 annual report contains the statutory list of every subsidiary with its country and principal activity. Companies whose activity is 'Online trading' under the CMC Markets name sit in eight countries: England, Australia, Bermuda, Canada, Germany, New Zealand, Singapore and the UAE. Five of these (UK, Australia, Singapore, Canada, Bermuda) were also confirmed on the brand's own regional legal or partner pages as the company clients deal with. Branches (Austria, Norway, Poland, Spain, Australia branch of the UK company), the Beijing representative office, holding, nominee, service and dormant companies and the 51%-owned StrikeX companies are not counted. This is the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 8
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: CMC Markets UK plc, standard CFD account and FX Active account (web platform and MT4), EUR/USD, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
The rendered UK tables confirm what the static pages suggested: for EUR/USD CMC Markets UK plc publishes minimum spreads only, 0.5 pips on the standard CFD account with no forex commission and 0.0 pips on FX Active with US $2.50 per $100,000 of notional per side. The instrument page also labels its one spread figure 'Minimum spread'. No figure on either page is labelled average or typical for either account, so there is no exact grade. The standard account's minimum allows a cost as low as USD 5, which caps nothing, so the range stays 0–10.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread that CMC Markets UK plc ties to the standard CFD account or to FX Active.
Account Not fixed: the standard CFD account and FX Active both publish minimum spreads onlyLower bound cost USD 5
12 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: CMC Markets UK plc, CFD and FX Active accounts on the Next Generation platform and MT4, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No document of CMC Markets UK plc describes an automated leader/follower copy service, and none says that copying is not offered. The UK MetaTrader terms only acknowledge third-party expert advisors and scripts, which CMC does not endorse; the UK copy-trading article is general education. For comparison, the Bermuda company's site names the MetaQuotes community as a route to social trading without describing how copying works; that is another legal entity and a service that is only named, so it does not move the UK range.
Missing Either a CMC Markets UK plc document that describes an automated copy service (own or integrated) with its mechanics, or an explicit statement that no copy trading, including third-party integrations such as MetaTrader Signals, is offered on UK accounts.
9 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: CMC Markets UK plc, CFD margin trades on the Next Generation platform and MetaTrader 4, United KingdomEstablished from documents
The order execution policy of CMC Markets UK plc says the company is the sole execution venue and the counterparty to every client trade, at prices its own platform generates, and that no other venue is used. Its terms of business refer to hedges it enters into where it deems them necessary or appropriate, with no undertaking to hedge each client trade externally. That is hedging at the firm's discretion, which the anchor grades 4. The group annual report corroborates this (natural hedging across client flow, external hedging applied selectively through prime brokers) but the grade rests on the UK company's own documents. The hedging wording sits in a definition and a corporate-actions clause rather than in a dedicated hedging clause; acting as principal is not by itself treated as B-book.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: CMC Markets brand partner programmes; CPA and IB page published by CMC Markets Bermuda Limited (international site); institutional IB programme page naming CMC Markets UK plc and CMC Markets Germany GmbHEstablished from documents
The brand's current partner page offers a CPA affiliate model (a fixed payout per qualified funded account) and an introducing-broker model (ongoing rebates on client trading) side by side. The institutional introducing-broker page separately documents tiered net revenue sharing. Both a volume or revenue model and CPA are therefore documented, which the anchor grades 4. The CPA page is published by CMC Markets Bermuda Limited; the UK retail site's partnerships page covers sponsorships only and shows no affiliate terms.
3 addresses tried
-
76overallequal
Decode Global
Assessment summary Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
1.2/103 penalties
Breakdown for Decode Global
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–7 · missing a closed, current list of the companies that operate the brand; whether Decode Capital Pty Ltd contracts with clients or executes orders under it; and the names and roles of the companies behind the Mauritius, Saint Vincent and South Africa licence claims.
- Published costs0PAll-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–8 · missing a published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for the PRO (or STD) account, and whether the USD 7 PRO fee is per side or per round trip.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Decode Global (trading as DecodeFX at decodefx.com) · candidate only · brand-level feature review, not an account offer for any country. Costs, A-book and affiliate rest on the DecodeFX site and the client documents of Decode Global Limited, Vanuatu, company number 700415. Copy rests on the DecodeFX site and on the app-store listing of the DecodeFX app, whose seller is a different company (Decode Digital Markets USA Inc.). Decode Capital Pty Ltd (Australia) is named by the brand, but no client document of that company could be read and nothing from it is used.
Summary Decode Global Limited's own disclosure statement says it may choose not to hedge client trades (A-book 4) and the DecodeFX FAQ documents both volume rebates for introducing brokers and a CPA programme (affiliate 4); costs, copy trading and company structure stay ranges because no average spread, no description of how copying works and no closed list of operating companies is published.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–7. Not a finding.Scope: Decode Global / DecodeFX brand; Decode Global Limited (Vanuatu) as contracting company; Decode Capital Pty Ltd (Australia) named, role not settledInvestigated, not settled
One operating company is documented: Decode Global Limited in Vanuatu, which contracts with clients in the terms and is on the regulator's list. The brand also names Decode Capital Pty Ltd in Australia and says services may be provided by different legal entities, but no client document of that company could be read, its own site returns an error, and DecodeFX says it cannot serve Australian residents, so its operating role is not settled. Three more licences are claimed with no company named, and nothing published is a closed group list, so one jurisdiction found outside Europe, Seychelles and Saint Lucia gives 0 to 7.
Missing A closed, current list of the companies that operate the brand; whether Decode Capital Pty Ltd contracts with clients or executes orders under it; and the names and roles of the companies behind the Mauritius, Saint Vincent and South Africa licence claims.
Count lower bound 1
10 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–8. Not a finding.Scope: Decode Global Limited (Vanuatu), DecodeFX PRO account, EUR/USD, any listed platform (DecodeFX App, MT4, MT5, API: one fee shown for all); country eligibility not assessedInvestigated, not settled
The account page publishes no average or typical EUR/USD spread for any account, so there is no exact grade. The cheapest published combination is the PRO account: spreads 'from 0.0 pips' plus a transaction fee of USD 7 per standard lot, which puts the cost at USD 7 or more and caps the grade at 8. The STD account shows '0.9 Pips' with no fee, but the figure carries no label (neither 'from' nor 'average') and names no instrument, so it is recorded and not graded on.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for the PRO (or STD) account, and whether the USD 7 PRO fee is per side or per round trip.
Account PRO (DecodeFX App, MT4, MT5, API; the page shows one fee for all platforms)Lower bound cost USD 7
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: DecodeFX brand: site marketing (Decode Global Limited per the site) and the DecodeFX app as listed on the US App Store by Decode Digital Markets USA Inc.; not a single-company product descriptionInvestigated, not settled
Copy trading is named in two places: the DecodeFX site lists 'API copy trading' among its tools, and the app-store description of the DecodeFX app says a user can follow strategies or become a strategy provider whom others follow. Neither says that a provider's trades are opened automatically in the follower's account, and neither gives a sizing rule, a stop or pause control or a fee; the site has no copy-trading page. A service that is named with its roles but without how copying works is not documented automation, and nothing says copying is not offered.
Missing The broker's own description of the copy feature: whether follower trades are opened automatically, how they are sized, how a follower stops or pauses, what it costs, and which company provides it.
9 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Decode Global Limited (Vanuatu); Margin FX contracts and CFDs; all account types (STD, PRO, CENT are not distinguished in the documents); country eligibility not assessedEstablished from documents
Decode Global Limited contracts as principal and is the counterparty to every trade, which alone does not establish a B-book. Its disclosure statement says it may hedge some of the market risk with outside counterparties and may, at its discretion, choose not to hedge a client's transactions; it also says prices come from a market making pricing model. Hedging at the firm's discretion, with no commitment to route or hedge any trade externally, is the anchor for 4.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: DecodeFX brand partner programmes (Introducing Broker, CPA Affiliate, Hybrid Partnership) as published on decodefx.com; no country statedEstablished from documents
The DecodeFX FAQ documents an Introducing Broker programme that pays rebates on the trading volume of referred clients, a CPA Affiliate programme that pays a one-off commission for each qualified referred trader, and a Hybrid programme that combines the two. Both an IB (volume-based) model and a CPA model are therefore documented for the brand, which is the anchor for 4.
3 addresses tried
-
77overallequal
Exness
Profile Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUnavailable to retail residents
1.2/102 penalties
Breakdown for Exness
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established (review hold)
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Exness (SC) Ltd (Seychelles, FSA licence SD025). Execution and partner terms are this entity's own documents. Copy trading is only referenced in its Partnership Agreement, and its account pricing pages could not be read (exness.com refuses plain requests).
Summary Seven listed entities, a client agreement that lets the company either take the other side or pass orders on depending on account type, and both revenue-share and CPA partner programmes; costs and copy trading mechanics are not documented in the pages that could be read.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Exness brand, group levelEstablished from documents
Five Exness companies in five jurisdictions each publish their own client agreement: Seychelles, British Virgin Islands, Curacao, Belize and Kenya. The brand's own footer lists two more entities operating under the brand, in South Africa and Mauritius. Five or more client-contracting jurisdictions gives 0; this confirms the existing grade and reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 5
2 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Exness (SC) Ltd, retail accounts (Standard, Pro, Raw Spread, Zero), Seychelles entityInvestigated, not settled
No EUR/USD spread or commission amount appears in any document that could be read. The Seychelles terms say the website's contract specifications show average spreads, and the key facts statement says a commission applies only to Raw Spread and Zero accounts, but every account and contract-specification page on exness.com refused the request. Without a published average spread and commission there is no grade and no bound.
Missing The published average EUR/USD spread and the round-trip commission per lot for each retail account of Exness (SC) Ltd (Standard, Pro, Raw Spread, Zero), per platform.
11 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Exness Copy Trading service as referenced in Exness (SC) Ltd partner terms; contracting entity for the copy service not confirmedHeld as a range by independent review
A discontinued or unavailable legacy social-copy service does not, by itself, prove that the reviewed broker currently has no automated-copy product in every relevant scope. Current product availability is unresolved, so no zero or full-feature grade is assigned.
9 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Exness (SC) Ltd, all CFD account types, Seychelles entityEstablished from documents
The Exness (SC) Ltd Client Agreement says that, depending on account type, the company either takes the other side of the trade itself or passes the order to a third party and is then not the counterparty. It does not commit any named account to external routing, and the key facts statement describes the company as the counterparty to all CFD trades. A mixed internal-or-external model set out in the agreement is the anchor for 4. The account pages that might name an externally routed account type could not be read.
1 address tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Exness partner programmes on exnessaffiliates.com; Partnership Agreement of Exness (SC) LtdEstablished from documents
Exness documents both models on its partner site: a revenue share programme for introducing brokers, paid on referred clients' trading, and a CPA programme for affiliates, paid once per qualifying referred client. The Exness (SC) Ltd Partnership Agreement sets out the ongoing spread-share and per-lot formulas. Both documented gives 4.
-
78overallequal
1.2/103 penalties
Breakdown for FBS
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a group-level primary source that lists every operating company of the FBS brand, or a regulator record confirming a fifth client-contracting jurisdiction (a South African company is an unverified lead).
- Published costs0PAll-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–4 · missing tradestone Ltd's own definition of a 'point' in the specification table (a tenth of a pip or a pip), and a statement of whether any commission applies to currency pairs on the Standard account.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across Tradestone Ltd (Cyprus) and FBS Markets Inc (Belize), not a single account offer: Tradestone Ltd (CySEC licence 331/17, fbs.eu) for costs, copy trading and execution terms; FBS Markets Inc (Belize) for the partner programmes, because Tradestone publishes no partner agreement; structure at brand level.
Summary Tradestone Ltd's client terms let it offset or keep client positions at its discretion and FBS Markets Inc documents both spread-share and CPA partner pay, while the brand spans at least four jurisdictions and neither an average EUR/USD spread nor a current copy service could be documented.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: FBS brand, all disclosed client-contracting companiesInvestigated, not settled
Four client-contracting companies in four jurisdictions were confirmed: Tradestone Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC register), FBS Markets Inc (Belize, own client terms), FBS Trading (Seychelles) Ltd (Seychelles FSA register and own client terms) and Intelligent Financial Markets Pty Ltd trading as FBS Oceania (Australia, own website). No group-level list of operating entities was found, so four is a lower bound: three or four jurisdictions give 2, five or more give 0.
Missing A group-level primary source that lists every operating company of the FBS brand, or a regulator record confirming a fifth client-contracting jurisdiction (a South African company is an unverified lead).
Count lower bound 4
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: Tradestone Ltd, Standard account, Retail category, MT5, USD account, EUR/USD, Cyprus (EU)Investigated, not settled
Rendered in a browser, the EU specification table for the Standard account (Retail) does publish a typical EUR/USD spread: 11 points, beside a minimal spread of 8 points. Read as tenths of a pip, which the 0.7 pip minimum on the Standard account page and the table's lowest minimal spread of 7 points indicate, that is 1.1 pips or USD 11 a round trip, so the grade cannot be above 4. It is not given as exact for two reasons: the page does not define a point (and carries an unattached footnote about 4-digit quotes), and no page read states whether a commission applies to currency pairs. Grade 4 holds if a point is a tenth of a pip and any forex commission is USD 4 or less per round-trip lot.
Missing Tradestone Ltd's own definition of a 'point' in the specification table (a tenth of a pip or a pip), and a statement of whether any commission applies to currency pairs on the Standard account.
Account Standard (MT5), Retail category, Tradestone Ltd
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Tradestone Ltd, MT5, Cyprus (EU); the closure notice applies to FBS Markets Inc, Belize, onlyInvestigated, not settled
No copy-trading product is described on the Tradestone Ltd website, account pages or client terms, and none of them says that copying is not offered. For another company of the brand, FBS Markets Inc, a page still on the global site says its own FBS CopyTrade app closed on 22 September 2022; that covers neither Tradestone nor third-party copy services, so it does not support a 0.
Missing Either a description of an automated copy service offered by Tradestone Ltd (own or integrated), or an explicit statement that no copy trading, including third-party integrations such as MetaTrader Signals, is offered.
8 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Tradestone Ltd, CFDs and forex on MT5 (Standard and Cent accounts), Cyprus (EU)Established from documents
Tradestone Ltd's client terms say that after a trade it may, at its reasonable discretion, offset the position with another client or a counterparty or keep a proprietary position. Its execution policy says it is always the client's counterparty and the sole execution venue, and that it hedges market risk with other venues without committing to do so for each trade. Discretion between hedging and keeping the position is the anchor for 4. The liquidity providers named are LMAX Broker Europe Ltd, EXT Ltd and Finalto Financial Services Limited; the documents do not present them as group companies.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: FBS brand partner programmes as documented by FBS Markets Inc, Belize; Tradestone Ltd (Cyprus) noted separatelyEstablished from documents
FBS Markets Inc publishes two partner documents. Its Partner Agreement pays introducers 30% of the spread on every trade of an introduced client, and its Affiliation Agreement defines CPA as a fee per introduced client settled on first-time deposits. Both spread-share and CPA are documented, which is exact 4. Tradestone Ltd publishes no partner agreement; its costs policy mentions only a fixed commission to affiliates.
-
79overallequal
FXCM
Profile Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
1.2/103 penalties
Breakdown for FXCM
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 0 round-turn commission plus spread. Penalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the commission plan of the FXCM affiliate programme (whether it pays a fixed amount per referred client) and the legal entity that runs it.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across the FXCM companies, not a single account offer. Costs and execution are assessed for Stratos Markets Limited (United Kingdom, FCA 217689); the introducing-broker terms are those in that company's terms of business; no copy-trading product could be tied to any FXCM company. The UK site now carries a notice that new trading accounts are provided through Trade Nation (read as processed text only), so the UK documents describe the terms of the existing UK company, not a new-account offer.
Summary The UK company's execution policy leaves hedging to the firm's discretion and the brand contracts with clients through at least five jurisdictions; no average spread tied to an account, no copy-trading offer and no CPA terms could be read from primary pages, so costs, copy trading and the affiliate model stay open.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: FXCM brand, group level (Stratos group of companies)Established from documents
Five companies in five jurisdictions each issue their own client agreement under the FXCM name: Stratos Markets Limited (United Kingdom), Stratos Europe Limited (Cyprus), Stratos Trading Pty. Limited (Australia), Stratos Global LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) and Stratos Light Ltd (Israel). Five or more is grade 0 even as a lower bound. South Africa, counted in the earlier row, is dropped: the South African company's own disclosure says it is solely an intermediary for the UK company. Canada (Friedberg Direct, an outside firm using FXCM technology) and the Greek representative office are not counted either. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 5
5 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Stratos Markets Limited, standard CFD account (Trading Station, MetaTrader 4, TradingView), USD account, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
The UK company's ordinary retail account is the standard CFD account: no commission, cost carried in the spread. Its rate card publishes no spread figure at all, neither a minimum nor an average, and refers to the trading platform. The Active Trader account charges USD 2.50 per side per 100k (USD 5 round trip) but is open only to clients the firm designates, so it is not treated as an ordinary retail account. The spread pages on the website are live widgets that could not be read. With no minimum and no account-labelled average, the range is not narrowed.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread that the page ties to the standard account (or to the Active Trader account) of a named FXCM company, with its period.
Account Standard CFD account, Stratos Markets Limited (spread-only)Round turn commission USD 0Spread basis none published in the rate card; 'displayed on our Trading Facility'
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: FXCM brand; checked for Stratos Markets Limited (United Kingdom) and Stratos Global LLC (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines)Not established
No automated copy-trading product could be found in the documents of any FXCM company. The UK and Saint Vincent terms of business and rate cards do not mention copy trading, ZuluTrade, signals or mirroring, and the platform and account pages that could be read (as processed text) list Trading Station, MetaTrader 4, TradingView and API trading only. Nothing says copy trading is not offered, and silence is not that statement, so the criterion stays open.
Missing Either a current FXCM page or document that describes an automated copy service offered by a named FXCM company, or an explicit statement that no copy trading (including third-party integrations such as ZuluTrade or MetaTrader Signals) is offered.
8 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Stratos Markets Limited, CFD and spread-bet accounts, United Kingdom. Not Stratos Global LLC, Stratos Europe Limited, Stratos Trading Pty. Limited or Stratos Light Ltd.Established from documents
The UK company's terms of business say it deals as principal and market maker and make the order execution policy part of the agreement. That policy says the firm is the sole execution venue and that, at its discretion, it may hedge some or all of its market risk with third parties, with client trades hedged individually, in aggregate or not at all. A policy that leaves hedging to the firm's discretion is the 4 anchor. The firm's 2025 prudential disclosure says firm positions are fully hedged, but that describes practice in one year, names no counterparty and is not a contractual commitment, so it does not raise the grade.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: FXCM partner arrangements as documented in the terms of business of Stratos Markets Limited (United Kingdom); brand-level partner sites could not be readInvestigated, not settled
The UK company's terms of business document introducing brokers and say the firm may share commissions and charges on a client's transactions with the client's introducing broker; the Saint Vincent company's terms say the same. That is an introducing-broker, activity-based model documented. The brand's separate affiliate site, where search results suggest a per-client (CPA) plan is published, refused both a plain request and the fetch tool, so CPA is neither confirmed nor excluded from a page that was read. Introducing broker documented and CPA not established gives 4–10.
Missing The commission plan of the FXCM affiliate programme (whether it pays a fixed amount per referred client) and the legal entity that runs it.
6 addresses tried
-
80overallequal
FXGT
Assessment summary Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
1.2/104 penalties
Breakdown for FXGT
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing the group's own list of operating companies: whether the South African, Vanuatu and Mauritius companies named in search results operate under the FXGT brand, and whether the list is closed.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4PPenalty: low end of 4–6 · missing the name of the market maker that takes the other side of FXGT.com trades and whether it is a group company; the Order Execution Policy of GT Global Ltd; confirmation that s. 28.15 is in the version of the terms now in force.
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope FXGT · candidate only · brand-level review across GT Global Ltd (Seychelles, FXGT.com client terms and partner agreement) and GT Investment Services Ltd (Cyprus, FXGT.eu, eligible counterparties only), not a single account offer. Costs, copy, A-book and affiliate rest on GT Global Ltd; the Cyprus company is used for the structure count only.
Summary fxgt.com refused every plain request on 19 November 2026, so only documents on FXGT's file server and the Cyprus site were read: the partner agreement documents both a rebates scheme and a cost-per-acquisition scheme, the client terms call the company an intermediary to an unnamed market maker, and costs, copy trading and the full list of group companies could not be read and stay open.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: FXGT brand; GT Global Ltd (Seychelles) and GT Investment Services Ltd (Cyprus)Investigated, not settled
Two operating companies under the FXGT name were read in primary sources: GT Global Ltd in Seychelles, which runs FXGT.com and contracts with its clients, and GT Investment Services Ltd in Cyprus, which runs FXGT.eu for eligible counterparties and is listed by CySEC with the trade name FXGT. No closed group list could be read because fxgt.com refused every request, so two is a lower bound and the grade is 0 to 4. Web search results name further companies in South Africa, Vanuatu and Mauritius; none was read in a primary source, so none is counted.
Missing The group's own list of operating companies: whether the South African, Vanuatu and Mauritius companies named in search results operate under the FXGT brand, and whether the list is closed.
Count lower bound 2
5 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: GT Global Ltd, Seychelles; FXGT.com retail accounts; no account could be assessedInvestigated, not settled
No account, spread or commission page of FXGT could be read because fxgt.com refused every request. The client terms say only that spreads are floating, may include a mark-up, and that a commission is charged on the ECN account alone, and they refer to the website for the figures. Without a published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to a named account there is no grade and no bound.
Missing A broker-published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for a named retail account, and the round-trip commission of the ECN account on each platform.
4 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: GT Global Ltd, Seychelles; FXGT.com; no product identifiedNot established
Nothing about copy trading could be read. The client terms (v1.18) contain no copy-trading, signal, PAMM or MAM provisions, which is not a statement that copying is not offered, and the website, where a product page would be, refused every request. Neither a product nor an explicit 'not offered' is documented, so the range stays open.
Missing Whether FXGT offers automated leader/follower copying at all, and if so its sizing rule, follower stop or pause controls and fees; or an explicit statement that it is not offered.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–6. Not a finding.Scope: GT Global Ltd, Seychelles; CFDs on FXGT.com accounts under Terms and Conditions v1.18Investigated, not settled
The client terms read (v1.18) define a CFD as a contract between the client and the company's market maker and say the company is not the counterparty but only an intermediary. That is contract wording for passing every trade on, not marketing, but the market maker is not named, so it may be a company of the same group; an FXGT-branded Cyprus company that provides liquidity to brokers exists. A route to a group company alone is 4 and a blanket route outside the group is 6, so the grade is 4 to 6. The terms refer to an Order Execution Policy that could not be read, and it is not confirmed that v1.18 is the version in force.
Missing The name of the market maker that takes the other side of FXGT.com trades and whether it is a group company; the Order Execution Policy of GT Global Ltd; confirmation that s. 28.15 is in the version of the terms now in force.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: GT Global Ltd, Seychelles; FXGT.com Partner Program under Partnership Agreement V1.5Established from documents
The Partnership Agreement of GT Global Ltd (V1.5) documents both models in one programme. The default is the Rebates Scheme, commission plans paid on the trading of introduced clients, and a cost-per-acquisition scheme based on clients' deposits and trading applies where agreed in writing. Both an IB-type payment and CPA are documented, which is the anchor for 4. The agreement was read from FXGT's file server, not from the blocked legal page, so the version in force should be re-checked in a browser.
1 address tried
-
81overallequal
Interactive Brokers
Profile Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
1.2/103 penalties
Breakdown for Interactive Brokers
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 4.39 round-turn commission plus spread. All-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–8 · missing an average or typical EUR/USD spot spread published by Interactive Brokers (U.K.) Limited for its standard account.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing a ruling on whether a client refer-a-friend bonus or a per-click affiliate fee counts as CPA for this criterion; failing that, an Interactive Brokers partner document that pays a fixed amount per acquired client to a partner.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and abook rest on Interactive Brokers (U.K.) Limited (IBUK, United Kingdom, FCA 208159) and its own site and agreements. An IBUK client has two linked accounts: a principal trading account carried by the US affiliate Interactive Brokers LLC (IBLLC) under a three-way agreement, and a Covered Products account carried by IBUK alone (CFDs, FX Spot, precious metals, non-US index futures and options). The abook grade uses the IBUK-only Covered Products agreement and notes the matching IBLLC clause. Structure and affiliate are brand-level.
Summary IBUK publishes a commission-only spot FX schedule on passed-through quotes (about USD 4.39 round trip per EUR/USD lot) but no average spread, its agreements allow an affiliate to be the other side of an FX trade, no copy-trading product is documented, and the group carries accounts in at least nine jurisdictions.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Interactive Brokers brand, group levelEstablished from documents
The group's own FAQ says Interactive Brokers Group, Inc. does business through broker subsidiaries that carry client accounts by country of residence and lists nine of them, in the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Ireland, Australia, Hong Kong, India, Japan and Singapore. Nine account-carrying jurisdictions is five or more, which is grade 0 even as a lower bound. The earlier row counted three (0–2); the group list settles it at 0. This reflects the simplicity preference only, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 9
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–8. Not a finding.Scope: Interactive Brokers (U.K.) Limited, standard account (the entity has no FX account tiers), spot EUR/USD on IBKR's own platforms, Tier I commission (monthly trade value up to USD 1 billion), United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
IBUK prices spot FX as a commission on trade value on top of passed-through dealer quotes: 0.20 basis point with a USD 2.00 minimum per order in the first tier. For one standard EUR/USD lot that is about USD 2.19 a side, USD 4.39 round trip, at the ECB reference rate of 18 November 2026. No average or typical EUR/USD spread is published; the only figure is an advertised narrowest spread of one tenth of a pip, which adds at least USD 1.00 and puts the floor at USD 5.39, so the grade cannot be above 8. With no upper figure for the spread the lower end stays 0. If the tenth-of-a-pip floor were not counted, the commission alone (USD 4.39) would leave 10 possible.
Missing An average or typical EUR/USD spot spread published by Interactive Brokers (U.K.) Limited for its standard account.
Commission per side USD 2.19Round turn commission USD 4.39
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Interactive Brokers (U.K.) Limited, own platforms and listed third-party integrations, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No IBUK page that was read describes automated copying of a lead trader. The feature catalogue and third-party integration page list advisor tools (Model Portfolios, allocation tools), an ETF replicator, social sentiment data, TradingView and order-management integrations, none of which is leader/follower copying, and the services guide calls the service non-advised and execution-only. No page says that copy trading is not offered, including through third parties, so grade 0 is not established and the range stays open.
Missing Either an IBUK document describing automated copying of a lead trader, or an explicit IBUK statement that it offers no copy trading, including through third-party integrations.
7 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Interactive Brokers (U.K.) Limited, Covered Products account (FX Spot and Forex CFDs, carried by IBUK), United Kingdom. The principal trading account carried by Interactive Brokers LLC has the same clause (IBUK and IBLLC Client Agreement cl. E12.6, G5.3).Established from documents
IBUK's agreement for the account it carries says that in a Spot FX trade the client may be buying from or selling to a group affiliate that can make or lose money on the trade, and that IBUK itself is a counterparty only on a riskless basis. Its OTC clauses and execution policy let it route to affiliates or to unaffiliated third parties and hedge through either. So IBUK stays flat, but the other side can be a group company, another client or an outside bank, and nothing commits the fill to a party outside the group. Under the rule that A-book means outside the group, this mixed route is grade 4; it does not show that any particular trade is kept in the group.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Interactive Brokers brand, programmes as published on the site of Interactive Brokers (U.K.) Limited: introducing brokers, Refer a Friend, Influencer and CPC Publisher programmesInvestigated, not settled
Introducing brokers are paid through markups on each client trade, which is remuneration tied to trading volume, so the IB side is documented. Whether the brand also pays per acquisition in the sense of this criterion is not settled. What is published is a client Refer a Friend scheme (a flat USD 200 per referred person who opens and funds an account, capped at 30 referrals) and per-click payments to influencers and publishers. Neither is described as a CPA partner programme, and a client referral bonus was not counted as CPA for another broker in this review (Swissquote), so the same reading is applied here until the reviewer rules.
Missing A ruling on whether a client refer-a-friend bonus or a per-click affiliate fee counts as CPA for this criterion; failing that, an Interactive Brokers partner document that pays a fixed amount per acquired client to a partner.
2 addresses tried
-
82overallequal
Intertrader
Assessment summary Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
1.2/104 penalties
Breakdown for Intertrader
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a group-level closed list of the operating companies behind the Intertrader brand, and the relationship between Alvar Financial Services Limited and Tau Markets Ltd.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing the payment terms of the affiliate and IB models on the partners page: whether any model pays per funded client (CPA), or a statement that CPA is not offered.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across two companies, not a single account offer. Documents served on intertrader.com on 19 Nov 2026 name two client-contracting companies: Alvar Financial Services Limited (Gibraltar, GFSC ref FSC1108MIF, subject to limited FCA regulation under ref 597312; formerly Intertrader Limited), which trades as Intertrader on the default route, and Tau Markets Ltd (Mauritius, FSC licence GB22201294), whose retail documents the /row route links. This connection (Thailand) was redirected to /row. The A-book grade is given for each company from its own documents; the partner evidence is the /row partners page description plus Alvar's customer agreement. Costs and copy trading are not assessed for either company: the pricing and product pages are loaded by script from a content service and could not be read with plain requests. Nothing is carried from one company to the other.
Summary Intertrader's own documents name two contracting companies (Gibraltar and Mauritius) and both sets of terms leave hedging or external routing to the firm, while the site names affiliate and IB partner models without payment terms; published costs, copy trading and the full company count are not established because the site's pages could not be read with plain requests.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: Intertrader brand: Alvar Financial Services Limited (Gibraltar) and Tau Markets Ltd (Mauritius)Investigated, not settled
Documents served on intertrader.com name two client-contracting companies in two jurisdictions: Alvar Financial Services Limited in Gibraltar, which trades as Intertrader, and Tau Markets Ltd in Mauritius, whose retail documents the /row route links. No group-level list of operating companies was read, and Alvar's prudential disclosure shows unnamed subsidiaries, so two is a lower bound and the grade is 0 to 4. Alvar's UK presence is an establishment of the Gibraltar company and is not counted.
Missing A group-level closed list of the operating companies behind the Intertrader brand, and the relationship between Alvar Financial Services Limited and Tau Markets Ltd.
Count lower bound 2
8 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Not assessed for either company: Tau Markets Ltd (/row route) or Alvar Financial Services Limited trading as Intertrader (default route)Investigated, not settled
No EUR/USD spread or commission figure for an Intertrader retail account could be read. The pricing pages of both routes are filled in by script from a content service and return an empty shell to a plain request. The legal documents that could be read give no figures: Tau Markets' agreement says only that the firm takes its commission through the spread and that some FX/CFDs carry a commission, and Alvar's own site offers bespoke pricing with one worked example, which is not an average or a price list.
Missing A EUR/USD spread that the page labels as average or typical for a named Intertrader retail account, and that account's round-trip commission.
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Not assessed for either company: Tau Markets Ltd (/row route) or Alvar Financial Services Limited trading as Intertrader (default route)Investigated, not settled
No document or page that could be read describes a leader/follower copy service, and none says that copying is not offered. The site script's page list for both routes has no copy, social or signal trading page, but a missing page is not an explicit 'not offered', so the grade stays open. The platforms named are Intertrader+ (web and mobile), MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5.
Missing Either a description of an automated copy service offered by Tau Markets Ltd or Alvar Financial Services Limited under the Intertrader name, or an explicit statement that none is offered, including third-party integrations.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Alvar Financial Services Limited (Gibraltar), spread bets and CFDs, customer agreement as published on alvarfinancial.com plus the execution summary on intertrader.com; Tau Markets Ltd (Mauritius), retail CFD and FX account, /row routeEstablished from documents
Both companies' terms leave the handling of client exposure to the firm. Alvar Financial Services Limited, which trades as Intertrader, deals as principal and its customer agreement says it may choose at its sole discretion not to hedge a client's contract with its affiliates or external liquidity providers. Tau Markets Ltd's retail agreement says it is a market maker and the only execution venue, while its execution policy says orders are transmitted to third-party venues and also that the company functions as a market maker; the agreement prevails over the website, so no external route is committed to. Neither names a venue or makes a per-trade commitment.
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: Intertrader brand: /row partners page description (route of Tau Markets Ltd) and customer agreement cl. 10.6–10.9 of Alvar Financial Services Limited (Gibraltar)Investigated, not settled
Introducing-broker and revenue-share payments are documented: the site's own description of the /row partners page says the brand has a range of affiliate and IB models, and Alvar's customer agreement says it may pay partners and introducing agents a share of the revenue from a client's trading. No per-client (CPA) payment is described anywhere that could be read, and nothing says CPA is not offered. The partners page itself could not be read, so what the 'affiliate' models pay is not known.
Missing The payment terms of the affiliate and IB models on the partners page: whether any model pays per funded client (CPA), or a statement that CPA is not offered.
5 addresses tried
-
83overallequal
IUX
Assessment summary Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
1.2/103 penalties
Breakdown for IUX
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing a closed list of IUX operating companies, and a ruling on whether a licensed intermediary counts.
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 0 round-turn commission plus spread. Penalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope IUX brand-level review across IUX Markets (MU) Ltd (Mauritius, FSC investment dealer licence GB22200605) and the brand help centre, not a single account offer. Costs, A-book and affiliate rest on IUX Markets (MU) Ltd, the company its client agreement, risk management policy and partner policy name. Copy rests on a brand help-centre article that names IUX Markets Limited (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines); nothing on copying is documented for the Mauritius company.
Summary For the Mauritius company a partner policy with both an IB and a CPA programme is documented, hedging is left to the firm's discretion, and the group spans at least three operating jurisdictions with no closed list. A typical cost of USD 7 per EUR/USD round turn appears only in an undated-period cost study whose sources are gone, and the only copying described is a third-party service IUX disclaims, so costs and copy stay open.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: IUX brand: IUX Markets (MU) Ltd (Mauritius), IUX Markets Limited (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), IUX Markets ZA (Pty) Ltd (South Africa)Investigated, not settled
The legal hub publishes separate client agreements for IUX Markets (MU) Ltd (Mauritius) and IUX Markets Limited (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), two operating companies in two jurisdictions. The South African site says IUX Markets ZA (Pty) Ltd operates it as a licensed intermediary between clients and the Mauritius company; whether an intermediary counts as an operating brokerage company has not been ruled (the same question as easyMarkets, JustMarkets and Octa). No closed group list is published, so at least 2 gives 0–4; counting the intermediary would give 0–2.
Missing A closed list of IUX operating companies, and a ruling on whether a licensed intermediary counts.
Count lower bound 2
3 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: IUX Markets (MU) Ltd, Mauritius; Pro account (USD 200 minimum deposit, commission-free), all platforms; EUR/USD; global site read from outside EuropeInvestigated, not settled
IUX's own cost study (dated 2 August 2026) gives a "typical" EUR/USD spread of 0.7 pip for the commission-free Pro account of IUX Markets (MU) Ltd, USD 7.00 a round trip, which would be grade 8 and sits exactly on the band edge. The study states no observation period, the two IUX pages it cites now return 404, and the current pricing page publishes minimums only (Pro from 0.1 pip, Standard from 0.2 pip, Raw from 0.0 pip). A typical figure from a marketing comparison with no period and no live source is recorded as the conditional reading, not as a labelled account average; the published Pro minimum of 0.1 pip (USD 1.00) leaves 10 possible.
Missing A current average or typical EUR/USD spread for a named IUX Markets (MU) Ltd account, with its observation period, on a page that is still served.
Account Pro (commission-free; IUX Terminal, IUX App, web terminal and MT5 share the same pricing), IUX Markets (MU) LtdRound turn commission USD 0
5 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Myfxbook Autotrade as described by the IUX help centre; entity named IUX Markets Limited (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines); not documented for IUX Markets (MU) LtdInvestigated, not settled
The only copying described is Myfxbook Autotrade, a third-party service that the IUX help centre says clients can use "through cooperation". The article names IUX Markets Limited (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines), not the Mauritius company, and states that IUX has no responsibility for and no control over the service. Under the reviewer's rule a third-party feature the broker disclaims does not count as the broker's copy trading, and no IUX document says that copy trading is not offered, so neither a positive grade nor 0 is established.
Missing An IUX copy-trading service of its own with documented terms, or an explicit statement that copy trading is not offered.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: IUX Markets (MU) Ltd, Mauritius; CFDs on all account typesEstablished from documents
The Mauritius client agreement makes the company principal and execution venue for CFDs and says only that nothing restricts it from hedging client positions wholly or in part with third parties, which leaves hedging to the firm. Its risk management policy says straight-through processing is in place and all trades are fully offset by the liquidity provider, but the same clause list describes hedging 'if and when this is needed', natural hedging between clients and open-position exposure, and the liquidity provider is not named. Read together the documents describe discretionary, mixed internal-or-external handling, not a contractual blanket external route.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: IUX Markets (MU) Ltd, Mauritius; IUX Partner Program (Introducing Broker Program and Affiliate Program)Established from documents
The Mauritius company's partner agreement sets out two programmes. The Introducing Broker Program pays a share of spread or of the fixed per-lot commission on referred clients' trades, plus a share of sub-IB commission. The Affiliate Program pays a CPA reward of USD 50 up to USD 1,000 for each new referred client who verifies, makes a qualifying first deposit and trades a minimum volume within 30 days. Both an IB revenue-share model and CPA are therefore documented.
-
84overallequal
OANDA
Profile Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
UK company requires UK residenceUK company on file
1.2/102 penalties
Breakdown for OANDA
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPublished tariff: USD 0 round-turn commission plus spread. All-in cost benchmark penalty: low end of 0–8 · missing confirmation that OANDA Europe Limited offers a single retail pricing model, so that its division-level average is the standard account's average; or an average labelled for the account.
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope OANDA Europe Limited (United Kingdom, FCA 542574): Standard (retail) account, CFD trading on OANDA web/mobile, MT4 and MT5. Costs, copy and abook rest on this company only. Affiliate is brand-level (partners.oanda.com, published for the whole group); structure is group-level (group site and help-centre division list). Brand-level feature review, not a single account offer.
Summary A group that contracts clients through at least seven jurisdictions; its UK company deals as matched principal while group companies hedge at their discretion, and the partner site documents both CPA and volume-rebate programmes; an average EUR/USD spread and any automated copy-trading offer were not established for the UK company.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: OANDA group, all client-contracting companiesEstablished from documents
OANDA's help centre asks clients to choose the division they contracted with and offers seven companies in seven jurisdictions; the group site footer gives a regulatory statement for each of them and for a Japanese company as well. Seven or more is past the five-jurisdiction threshold, so the grade is exact even though the count is a lower bound. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 7
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–8. Not a finding.Scope: OANDA Europe Limited, Standard (retail) account, spread-only CFD pricing as quoted on its platforms (tool names no account type; MT4 and MT5 not stated separately), EUR/USD, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
OANDA Europe Limited charges no forex commission, and its minimum EUR/USD spread of 0.6 pip puts the round trip at USD 6 or more, so the grade cannot be above 8. Its historical-spread tool labels a time-weighted "Average spread" for the UK division: 0.88 pip over 24 hours for the last month (0.86 over three months), and 0.77 (0.76) excluding 5 to 7pm Eastern. All four figures give USD 7.63 to 8.82 and the same grade, 6. The tool names the division but no account type. The same gap keeps another broker's cost on hold in this review, so the 6 is recorded as conditional and the range stays until it is shown that the UK division has one retail pricing model, or the figure is labelled for the account.
Missing Confirmation that OANDA Europe Limited offers a single retail pricing model, so that its division-level average is the standard account's average; or an average labelled for the account.
Account Standard account (retail), spread-only, OANDA Europe Limited; the spread tool itself names no account typeRound turn commission USD 0
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: OANDA Europe Limited, Standard (retail) account, OANDA web/mobile, MT4, MT5 and TradingView, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No page of the UK company describes an automated leader/follower copying product, and its list of third-party platforms and tools contains none. None of these pages says that copy trading is not offered, and MT4 and MT5 are available, so the documents neither establish a copy product nor exclude one.
Missing A statement by OANDA Europe Limited that it offers, or does not offer, automated copying of another trader (own product, MetaTrader Signals or another integration).
8 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: OANDA Europe Limited, retail CFD and spread-bet orders on all its platforms, United KingdomEstablished from documents
The UK execution policy says OANDA Europe Limited is the sole trading venue, acts as matched principal, and that OANDA group companies may manage their risk as market maker and may choose to hedge some or all of a client's orders. The terms of business add that the firm may execute hedging transactions and frequently hedges with other institutions. A matched-principal route to a group company with hedging outside the group left to discretion is the anchor for 4.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: OANDA brand, partner programmes on partners.oanda.com (global, not specific to one legal entity)Established from documents
The OANDA partner site offers an affiliate programme that pays CPA rewards per referred client (up to USD 600) and an introducing-broker programme that pays rebates on referred clients' trading volume. Both models documented gives 4. The UK terms of business also allow the UK company to pay introductory fees to third parties.
1 address tried
-
85overallequal
Saxo
Profile Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Swiss company on fileAvailability not confirmed
1.2/101 penalty
Breakdown for Saxo
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0USD 23 round trip
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Saxo Bank (Switzerland) Ltd., in German Saxo Bank (Schweiz) AG (Switzerland, company no. CHE-106.787.764). Costs, copy and abook all rest on this entity and its own Swiss documents. The affiliate grade is brand-level: introducing-broker remuneration comes from the Swiss General Terms, the affiliate programme page is published on the international site of the parent Saxo Bank A/S (the Swiss-locale address returns 404).
Summary The Swiss bank publishes only minimum EUR/USD spreads in readable text (1.6 pips at best), passes every order to its Danish parent, which hedges as it sees fit, and the group contracts with clients in at least six jurisdictions.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Saxo brand, group levelEstablished from documents
The group's own disclaimer names the Danish parent Saxo Bank A/S, which contracts with clients directly and through branches, and client-serving subsidiaries in Switzerland, Italy, the UK, Japan and Singapore, and says client agreements are made with the relevant entity by country of residence. That is at least six client-contracting jurisdictions; the five branch countries are not counted. Five or more is grade 0 even as a lower bound, which confirms the existing grade and adds Denmark. This reflects the simplicity preference only, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 6
- Published costs 0Grade 0: USD over 20Scope: Saxo Bank (Schweiz) AG, FX spot, EUR/USD: all three retail tiers (Classic, Platinum, VIP), which differ by deposit threshold onlyEstablished from documents
Saxo Switzerland prices FX spot by tier, and a tier is reached by deposit alone, so all three retail tiers are compared. Its own historic display labels an all-hours EUR/USD average for the past month (21 October to 18 November 2026): Classic 2.7 pips, VIP 2.3 pips. Platinum has no historic tab; its published minimum is 2.1 pips, so its average cannot be below that. Every tier therefore costs more than USD 20 for one lot round trip on the spread alone (Classic USD 27, Platinum at least USD 21, VIP USD 23), which is grade 0 whichever tier is taken. No FX spot commission or minimum ticket fee appears on the Swiss pricing page; any fee would only add to the cost. The Classic 8:00–16:00 GMT average of 2.4 pips is also grade 0.
Average spread pips 2.3Round turn commission USD 0Indicative cost USD 23
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Saxo Bank (Switzerland) Ltd., own platforms (SaxoInvestor, SaxoTrader), TradingView integration, help centre and client terms, SwitzerlandInvestigated, not settled
Saxo Bank (Switzerland) Ltd. still documents no automated leader/follower copying: the Swiss help centre has no article on copy or social trading in English or German, trade signals open a ticket the client places himself, and the TradingView guide describes only own-order trading. The Swiss FinSA information says the bank is mainly execution-only and renders no portfolio management or advisory services, and the former SaxoSelect/AutoTrading service is gone (Swiss page 404, OpenAPI group removed). None of this is an explicit statement that copy trading is not offered, including through third parties, and the terms still allow an introducing broker or external portfolio manager to manage an account, so grade 0 is not reached and the range stays 0–10.
Missing An explicit statement by Saxo Bank (Switzerland) Ltd. that it offers no copy or social trading, covering third-party integrations, or a Swiss document describing an automated copy service. The FinSA execution-only line comes closest but names neither copy trading nor third-party routes.
22 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Saxo Bank (Switzerland) Ltd., rolling FX spot and other OTC products, SwitzerlandEstablished from documents
The Swiss execution policy fixes one route: every order is transmitted to the parent, Saxo Bank A/S, with the Swiss bank dealing as riskless principal in OTC products and using no other venue. That is a blanket route, but to a group company, which for this review is not an external route. What the parent then does is documented and is discretionary: it hedges elsewhere only as it considers most efficient and runs an internal flow aggregation book, and the Swiss General Terms keep hedging at the bank's absolute discretion, including client-against-client offsets and proprietary positions. There is no commitment to route outside the group and no per-fill external hedge condition.
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Saxo brand: introducing brokers of Saxo Bank (Switzerland) Ltd. and of the group; affiliate programme of Saxo Bank A/S (international site)Established from documents
Both partner models are documented. The Swiss General Terms define introducing brokers as remunerated for referring clients and say the bank may pay them fees or commission and share its commissions and charges with them; the group also runs an introducing-broker partnership. Separately, the Saxo Affiliate Program pays by the number of funded clients referred, monthly per successful referral, or a fixed fee, which is payment per acquisition. The page does not use the abbreviation CPA and gives no amounts; if payment per funded client is not accepted as CPA, the grade would be the range 4–10.
2 addresses tried
-
86overallequal
StoneX Trading UK
Profile Best A-book, IB-only 4 · weakest 3 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
1.2/103 penalties
Breakdown for StoneX Trading UK
- Company structure0PPenalty: nothing established
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and abook all rest on one company: StoneX Financial Ltd (United Kingdom, FCA 446717), trading as StoneX Trading (the former City Index UK brand), Standard and MT4 accounts. Affiliate rests on the same company (its client terms and its 'StoneX Marketing Partners' page). Structure is brand-level: StoneX Trading plus any City Index sites still run by other StoneX companies; FOREX.com and the rest of StoneX Group are outside the boundary. The company's general terms were read as a raw PDF; its web pages refused plain requests and were read only as processed text through the fetch tool.
Summary StoneX Financial Ltd's UK terms make it principal and sole execution venue with hedging only against large trades, and both a CPA plan and spread-sharing with introducers are documented; a typical EUR/USD spread of 0.8 is published without an account label, automated copying is neither documented nor excluded, and only the UK company was confirmed as contracting under the brand.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: StoneX Trading / City Index brand, companies that contract with clients under it; not FOREX.com and not StoneX Group as a wholeInvestigated, not settled
Brand boundary: StoneX Trading (StoneX Financial Ltd, UK) plus any City Index site still run by another StoneX company; FOREX.com and the rest of StoneX Group are left out. One jurisdiction is confirmed: the April 2026 general terms are made with StoneX Financial Ltd trading as StoneX Trading, a UK company. Three further records tie the City Index name to other StoneX companies (an Australian business-name registration, an undated Singapore referral page and a Cyprus approved trade name with no City Index domain), but www.cityindex.com refused every request, so whether any of those companies still takes clients under the name could not be read. One confirmed jurisdiction is a lower bound, so the range stays 0-10. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Missing Whether any StoneX company other than StoneX Financial Ltd still contracts with clients under the City Index or StoneX Trading name (Australia, Singapore, Cyprus or elsewhere), from a current primary page or a group-level list.
Count lower bound 1
12 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: StoneX Financial Ltd trading as StoneX Trading, Standard and MT4 accounts, EUR/USD, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
StoneX Financial Ltd offers two ordinary accounts, Standard and MT4, both without commission on FX. Its costs page lists EUR/USD at a minimum of 0.7 and a typical 0.8, but the table names no account or platform and the site says MT4 and TradingView pricing may differ, so the typical figure cannot be used for an exact grade. The only account-labelled figures are floors ('as low as 0.8pts' Standard, 'as low as 0.5pts' MT4) with no market named; a floor of 0.5 is USD 5 at least, which still allows grade 10, so nothing narrows. All web figures were read as processed text and need a browser check.
Missing A typical or average EUR/USD spread that the page ties to a named account (Standard or MT4), with the unit, read from a raw page.
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: StoneX Financial Ltd trading as StoneX Trading, Web Trader, TradingView and MT4 platforms, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No page or term of StoneX Financial Ltd read today describes a service that copies a leader's trades into a follower's account. The platform comparison mentions TradingView's community, Expert Advisors and the MetaTrader Market on MT4, and the terms allow for 'signals-based' tools; a site article describes SMART Signals, an algorithmic signal that pre-fills a ticket, which is a manual signal and does not count. Nothing says copy trading is not offered, including through third parties, so the range stays 0-10.
Missing Either a document of StoneX Financial Ltd describing an automated leader/follower service with its sizing rule, follower controls and fees, or an explicit statement that no copy trading, including third-party integrations, is offered.
7 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: StoneX Financial Ltd trading as StoneX Trading, Standard and MT4 accounts (CFD, spread bet and FX under the General Terms), United KingdomEstablished from documents
The April 2026 terms of StoneX Financial Ltd say the firm deals as principal, is the client's only execution venue and that the client does not trade on any external market. The only hedging statement is that the firm hedges against large trades, which is selective hedging at the firm's choice and no commitment to pass every trade on. That is discretionary, mixed handling in the policy: grade 4. It does not show that the firm internalises any given trade. A separate DMA service fills only after an order with a liquidity provider, but its providers are unnamed and it is not the Standard or MT4 route.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: StoneX Financial Ltd: StoneX Marketing Partners programme (StoneX Trading and FOREX.com brands) and introducers under the StoneX Trading UK terms, United KingdomEstablished from documents
Both models are documented for StoneX Financial Ltd. Its partner page pays a one-off amount per referred account, up to USD 1,000 by first-deposit size, and calls it CPA. Its client terms say the firm may share part of its spread, commissions and account fees with Introducers it appoints, which is pay from ongoing trading revenue. Both documented gives 4. The revenue-share side rests on a permissive clause in the client terms and not on a published programme with rates, and the partner page was read as processed text, so a browser check is expected; without the CPA page the range would be 4-10.
4 addresses tried
-
87overallequal
0.6/103 penalties
Breakdown for AvaTrade
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope AVA Trade EU Limited (Ireland)
Summary The Central Bank of Ireland register identifies AVA Trade EU Limited and its AvaTrade trading name under reference C53877.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreEstablished from documents
At least 5 disclosed operating jurisdictions: Ireland, Australia, Japan, South Africa, British Virgin Islands. The count excludes standalone offices and is a lower bound; penalty reflects your simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 5
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: AvaTrade retail account, EUR/USD; no entity pricing document readNot established
No AvaTrade pricing page or account document could be retrieved: every AvaTrade website returned a Cloudflare block (HTTP 403) to this session. No published average or typical EUR/USD spread and no commission statement was read from a primary source, so no cost grade or bound is given.
Missing AvaTrade's published typical or average EUR/USD spread for a named entity and retail account, and whether a commission applies on that account.
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: AvaTrade brand (AvaSocial, DupliTrade, ZuluTrade as leads); no entity product terms readInvestigated, not settled
No AvaTrade copy-trading page or product terms could be retrieved today (HTTP 403 on all AvaTrade sites, including the help centre). The earlier help-article reading of 17 Nov 2026 (av-elig: copy trading access depends on country and account eligibility) was not re-opened and does not document automation, sizing, follower controls or fees. The CySEC register shows who operates duplitrade.com but does not tie it to AvaTrade.
Missing A document of a named AvaTrade entity that describes an automated leader/follower product it offers, with the sizing rule, follower stop or pause controls and fees.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: AVA Trade EU Limited t/a AvaTrade, Ireland; register facts for the ADGM and Australian entities recorded separatelyInvestigated, not settled
No order execution policy or client agreement of any AvaTrade entity could be retrieved (HTTP 403). The Irish register shows AVA Trade EU Limited may execute client orders and deal on own account, which is a principal permission and by the anchors does not establish internalisation. The ADGM register limits Ava Trade Middle East Limited to matched-principal dealing, and the ASIC licence lets the Australian company make a market; both are regulator records for other entities, not policy commitments, and are not carried to AVA Trade EU Limited.
Missing The order execution policy or client agreement of a named AvaTrade entity, and what it says about dealing as principal, hedging and internalisation.
5 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAEstablished from documents
Both acquisition-based CPA and volume/revenue-based IB or partner arrangements are documented. The brand does not meet an IB-only preference. Brand partner programmes; not an entitlement in every country.
-
88overallequal
Fortrade
Assessment summary Best IB-only 4 · weakest 4 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
0.6/104 penalties
Breakdown for Fortrade
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing whether Fortrade DIFC LTD and Fortrade (Mauritius) Limited are operating brokerage companies of the brand, and whether the group has further operating companies; no closed group list.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across Fortrade companies, not a single account offer. The only company whose own documents could be read on 19 Nov 2026 is Fortrade Ltd (Fortrade Limited, England, company no. 08619610, FCA FRN 609970): the company structure rests on its 2025 consolidated accounts filed at Companies House plus official registers for Cyprus, Australia and Canada, and the partner programme is Fortrade Ltd's FTAffiliates programme. Costs, copy trading and the A-book commitment could not be assessed for any company, because www.fortrade.com (the site that holds the pricing pages, product pages and all linked legal PDFs, including those linked from fortrade.co.uk) refused every request. Nothing is carried from one Fortrade company to another.
Summary Fortrade's UK accounts and three official registers evidence at least four operating brokerage jurisdictions and name two more companies whose role is unconfirmed, and its FTAffiliates programme documents both per-deposit CPA and spread-based revenue share; published costs, copy trading and the execution commitment are not assessed because the main site refused all requests.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: Fortrade brand, group level: Fortrade Limited (UK) and the fellow group companies named in its 2025 accountsInvestigated, not settled
Fortrade Limited's 2025 group accounts show the UK company dealing as principal with clients and owing derivative-trading balances to fellow group companies in Cyprus, Australia and Canada, and official records confirm each of those three as a licensed client-facing firm, so four operating brokerage jurisdictions are evidenced. The same note names Fortrade DIFC LTD (derivative-trading balance, new in 2025) and Fortrade (Mauritius) Limited (GBP 8.6m of recharged costs), but their regulator records could not be read and the accounts do not state their function. Four gives 2; if either of the other two is an operating brokerage the count is five or more and the grade is 0.
Missing Whether Fortrade DIFC LTD and Fortrade (Mauritius) Limited are operating brokerage companies of the brand, and whether the group has further operating companies; no closed group list.
Count lower bound 4
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Fortrade brand; no entity, account or platform could be assessedNot established
No pricing page of any Fortrade company could be read: www.fortrade.com refused every request, and the UK site fortrade.co.uk has six pages with no account types, spreads or commissions. No average or typical EUR/USD spread and no commission figure was seen, so no grade or bound is given.
Missing A EUR/USD average or typical spread labelled for a named ordinary retail account, and that account's commission, for any Fortrade company.
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Fortrade brand; no entity or product could be assessedNot established
No product page of any Fortrade company could be read on www.fortrade.com. The UK site names only the Fortrader web and mobile platforms and says nothing about copy trading either way, which is not a statement that copying is not offered.
Missing Any official page or document stating whether an automated copy product (own or integrated) is offered, and its sizing, stop controls and fees.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Fortrade Ltd (UK) for the facts recorded; no entity's client documents could be assessedInvestigated, not settled
The grade depends on what the execution policy or client agreement commits to, and neither could be read: the UK legal page lists an Order Execution Policy and Terms and Conditions, but the PDFs sit on www.fortrade.com, which refused the request. Fortrade Limited's 2025 accounts say it acts as principal to clients, that client trades are hedged and that revenue comes from market-making activities, without naming a counterparty; that is a description in an annual report, not a commitment to clients, so it does not set the grade.
Missing The wording of the order execution policy and client agreement of a named Fortrade company on hedging, internalisation and execution venues, and whether any named venue or hedge counterparty is a group or related company.
5 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Fortrade Ltd (UK), FTAffiliates / Fortrade Affiliate Program (ftaffiliates.com and partners.fortrade.com); partner pages of other Fortrade companies on www.fortrade.com were not readableEstablished from documents
Fortrade Ltd's FTAffiliates programme documents both models: a fixed CPA for each new first-time-deposit trader (up to USD 300 to 700 by country tier, plus a progressive CPA by deposit size) and spread-based revenue share (35% for a listed set of countries), with hybrid plans combining them. The current partner portal on partners.fortrade.com lists the same deal types. Revenue share and CPA both documented is 4.
2 addresses tried
-
89overallequal
0.6/104 penalties
Breakdown for HYCM
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing the brand's own current list of companies and what each one does: whether HYCM Limited (St Vincent and the Grenadines) still contracts with clients, what HYCM Capital Markets S.R.L. (Costa Rica) does, and whether HYCM Ltd (Cayman Islands) is still part of the brand.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review,not a single account offer. Current international account prices are published on a site whose footer names HYCM Capital Markets S.R.L.(Costa Rica) and HYCM Capital Markets(UK)Limited as platform-services provider. Historical execution evidence is the November2024 HYCM Limited(SVG)Customer Agreement; partner evidence is HY Affiliates Limited. Company,account and country scopes are not combined.
Summary CPA and revenue-share or lot-rebate partner payments are both documented for the HY Affiliates programme. The November 2024 customer agreement of HYCM Limited (St Vincent and the Grenadines) lets the firm hedge at its discretion, but it could not be confirmed as the agreement in force, so the A-book grade stays open. Costs and copy trading are not graded and the jurisdiction count is only a lower bound, because hycm.com refused every page request.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: HYCM brand: HYCM Capital Markets (UK) Limited (United Kingdom), HYCM Limited (DIFC, United Arab Emirates), HYCM Limited (St Vincent and the Grenadines)Investigated, not settled
Three jurisdictions have a company with an evidenced operating or client-contracting role: the United Kingdom (HYCM Capital Markets (UK) Limited, active, the brand's FCA firm), the United Arab Emirates (HYCM Limited in the DIFC, DFSA reference F000048, addressed by a DFSA notice of 23 Sep 2026) and St Vincent and the Grenadines (HYCM Limited, the contracting party of the customer agreement still served on hycm.com, version November 2024). Two more companies are named but not counted: HYCM Capital Markets S.R.L. (Costa Rica), called a subsidiary on the affiliate site in a footer modified in September 2025 with no stated function, and HYCM Ltd (Cayman Islands), named only on an undated, partly outdated group page. The former Cyprus firm is not counted. No closed group list could be read because hycm.com refused every page, so at least 3 gives 0–2; if the Costa Rica and Cayman companies both operate alongside the other three the count reaches 5.
Missing The brand's own current list of companies and what each one does: whether HYCM Limited (St Vincent and the Grenadines) still contracts with clients, what HYCM Capital Markets S.R.L. (Costa Rica) does, and whether HYCM Ltd (Cayman Islands) is still part of the brand.
Count lower bound 3
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: International HYCM Raw account page; footer names HYCM Capital Markets S.R.L. (Costa Rica) and HYCM Capital Markets (UK) Limited for platform services.Investigated, not settled
The international account page is now readable: Raw advertises spreads from 0.1 pip and FX commission of USD 4 per round, with MT4/MT5 and USD among the base currencies. No average EUR/USD spread is published, and the card does not expressly tie the USD 4 fee to one standard lot. The footer now names a Costa Rica company and the UK platform provider; these terms are not carried into the old SVG agreement. The figures are recorded, but a comparable standard-lot tariff cannot be assigned while its unit and contracting scope remain unclear.
Missing The standard-lot unit of the USD 4 per-round FX commission, the relevant client-contracting company,and a pair-specific average or unambiguous account tariff for the common one-lot benchmark.
Account International Raw account, MT4/MT5; USD listedAverage spread published no
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Not established
No product page of the brand could be read, so neither a copy trading service nor a statement that none is offered was found. The HYCM Limited customer agreement of November 2024 does not mention copy trading; that silence is not evidence that it is not offered.
Missing Either the broker's own description of an automated leader/follower copying service, or an explicit statement that no copy trading is offered, including through third-party integrations.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: HYCM Limited, St Vincent and the Grenadines; spot forex and CFD accounts under the Customer Agreement, version November 2024Investigated, not settled
The only execution document that could be retrieved is the customer agreement of HYCM Limited (St Vincent and the Grenadines), version November 2024. It says the firm may hedge its liability with other institutions or in the underlying market and calls HYCM a CFD and spot forex market maker, which would be the anchor for 4. It is not established that this agreement is the one in force: the legal page that should link it refused every request, the separate Orders Execution Policy could not be retrieved, and a later affiliate-site footer names a Costa Rica company instead. A year-old document that cannot be tied to the current contracting company does not settle the grade, so the range stays open with 4 as the conditional reading.
Missing Confirmation of which company contracts with clients today and that its current client agreement and order execution policy contain the discretionary hedging wording.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: HYCM brand; HY Affiliates programme operated by HY Affiliates Limited; Revenue Share and Lot Rebate outside FCA jurisdiction onlyEstablished from documents
The official HYCM affiliate programme, HY Affiliates, publishes a CPA plan (up to USD 1,000 per acquired client) next to a Revenue Share plan (10–20% of net revenue for the client's lifetime) and a Lot Rebate plan (USD 6–10 per lot). Its agreement ties the per-client fee to a referred client who has registered and deposited. Both a CPA and a revenue or volume share are therefore documented, which is exact 4. Revenue Share and Lot Rebate are marked not available for FCA jurisdiction, so for UK-referred clients only CPA is shown.
-
90overallequal
Libertex
Assessment summary Best IB-only 4 · weakest 4 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmed
0.6/104 penalties
Breakdown for Libertex
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing the group's own closed list of operating brokerage companies, and whether any further company (for example another company serving clients under the Libertex name outside Europe, or a group execution company) operates today.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference4IB and CPA
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across the Libertex Group, not a single account offer. The product criteria (costs, copy trading, A-book commitment) are scoped to Indication Investments Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC licence 164/12, libertex.com, EEA and Switzerland), the company that trades under the Libertex name; libertex.com refused every plain request on 19 Nov 2026, so none of its client documents or pricing pages could be read and those three criteria stay open. Company structure is assessed at group level from the CySEC register, the Libertex Group site and the site of the group's second brand, LBX (MAEX Limited, Mauritius). The partner programme is the Libertex offer of the FPM.global network (FPM Global Limited and Marketing Partners Limited, Hong Kong). LBX facts are recorded as leads for a sister brand and are not used as Libertex terms.
Summary libertex.com refused every plain request, so the costs, copy trading and A-book commitment of Indication Investments Ltd could not be read and remain open; the group's own sites show at least two operating brokers (Cyprus under the Libertex name, Mauritius under the LBX name) without a closed list, and the partner network carrying the Libertex offer documents both a CPA plan and a revenue-share plan.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: Libertex Group (brands Libertex and LBX), group levelInvestigated, not settled
Two operating brokers of the Libertex Group in two jurisdictions were read on 19 Nov 2026: Indication Investments Ltd in Cyprus (CySEC 164/12, libertex.com) and MAEX Limited in Mauritius (lbx.com, which says it is part of the Libertex Group). The group site lists brands, not companies, and LBX says the group is regulated across multiple jurisdictions without naming them, so there is no closed list and the count is a lower bound. At least 2 gives 0–4. LBX is a second brand name of the group; under the Libertex name itself only the Cyprus company could be read, because libertex.com was blocked.
Missing The group's own closed list of operating brokerage companies, and whether any further company (for example another company serving clients under the Libertex name outside Europe, or a group execution company) operates today.
Count lower bound 2
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Indication Investments Ltd (Libertex), EUR/USD CFD, ordinary retail account, EEA and Switzerland; no account could be namedInvestigated, not settled
No pricing page, account page or costs document of Indication Investments Ltd could be read: libertex.com answered every plain request with a Cloudflare challenge. No spread, commission or account name is therefore recorded and nothing is graded. The sister brand LBX (MAEX Limited, Mauritius) publishes account pages, but they belong to another company and brand and are kept as a lead only.
Missing The account types of Indication Investments Ltd, and for its cheapest ordinary retail account an average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for that account together with the round-trip commission, per platform (Libertex platform, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5).
Account none read for Indication Investments Ltd
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Indication Investments Ltd (Libertex), Libertex platform and MetaTrader, EEA and SwitzerlandInvestigated, not settled
No product page or client document of Indication Investments Ltd could be read, so there is neither a description of automated copying nor a statement that it is not offered. The partner network's Libertex offer page lists in-app trading signals, which are manual, and does not mention copy trading. The sister brand LBX documents its own automated copy trading, but that is a product of MAEX Limited for clients outside the EU and is not carried over.
Missing Whether Indication Investments Ltd offers automated leader/follower copying, its own or an integrated third-party service, and if so its sizing rule, follower stop or pause controls and fees; or an explicit statement that none is offered.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Indication Investments Ltd (Libertex), CFDs, retail clients, EEA and SwitzerlandInvestigated, not settled
The order execution policy and client agreement of Indication Investments Ltd are on libertex.com, which refused every request, including the direct address of the execution policy summary. The CySEC register shows only that the company is authorised to deal on own account as well as to execute and transmit orders, which does not say how client orders are handled. Nothing is graded.
Missing What the current order execution policy and client agreement of Indication Investments Ltd commit to: whether it is the sole execution venue as principal, whether hedging is discretionary, and whether any named counterparty is a group company or outside the group.
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4Grade 4: IB and CPAScope: Libertex brand: Libertex offer of the FPM.global affiliate network (FPM Global Limited and Marketing Partners Limited, Hong Kong); the programme says it is not permitted in SpainEstablished from documents
The affiliate network that carries the Libertex offer, FPM.global, documents both mechanisms: a CPA plan paying a fixed commission per qualified trader by country and a revenue-share plan paying a percentage of the spread or commission revenue from referred clients, plus a hybrid of the two. Its affiliation agreement defines both. Both documented is grade 4. Libertex's own partner page on libertex.com could not be read; the link to the network is the redirect from libertex-affiliates.com and the Libertex sign-up portal on the network's host.
3 addresses tried
-
91overallequal
Plus500
Profile Best A-book 4 · weakest 4 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
0.6/103 penalties
Breakdown for Plus500
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference0PPenalty: low end of 0–4 · missing whether the referred-affiliate fee is a share of client revenue or of CPA payouts, and whether any Plus500 company pays introducing brokers a revenue or volume share (the US futures business names IBs without terms).
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and abook all rest on Plus500UK Ltd (United Kingdom, FCA 509909, company number 07024970), the counterparty in the UK user agreement for CFD accounts on the Plus500 trading platform. Structure is assessed at group level from the 2025 annual report of the parent, Plus500 Ltd (Israel, listed in London). The affiliate range rests on the group's 500Affiliates programme (contract with Plus500 Ltd) and the affiliate clause of the UK user agreement.
Summary The UK company books an identical hedge with its parent Plus500 Ltd for every client trade and the parent decides whether to hedge further, inside a group with regulated operating subsidiaries in at least twelve jurisdictions; affiliates are documented as paid per acquisition, while no published average EUR/USD spread and no statement on copy trading could be read.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Plus500 brand, group level (Plus500 Ltd and subsidiaries)Established from documents
The parent's 2025 annual report says the group works through operating subsidiaries and its capital note lists thirteen regulated subsidiaries in twelve jurisdictions: United Kingdom, Cyprus, Australia, Singapore, Israel, Seychelles, United States, Estonia, Japan, United Arab Emirates, Bahamas and Canada. The 500Affiliates site names the same companies and adds an Indonesian one. Five or more is grade 0 even as a lower bound, which narrows the earlier 0-4 range. This reflects the simplicity preference only, not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 12
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Plus500UK Ltd, CFD account (single retail account type on the Plus500 platform), EUR/USD, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No published average, typical or minimum EUR/USD spread for Plus500UK Ltd could be read. The UK execution policy and user agreement say the firm applies its own, possibly dynamic, spread and point to the instrument details on the platform and to the website FAQ for the figure; neither document states one. Every page on www.plus500.com, including the EUR/USD instrument page and the fees FAQ, refused the request. With no published spread there is no cost figure and no bound, so the range stays open.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread that Plus500UK Ltd labels for its CFD account, and an explicit statement of the commission (or of no commission) on forex CFDs.
11 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Plus500UK Ltd, CFD account on the Plus500 trading platform, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No Plus500 document read today describes an automated leader/follower copying product, and none says in terms that copy or social trading is not offered. The UK user agreement prohibits any automated data entry system and requires every transaction to be completed manually by the client acting for himself, which points away from automated copying but does not name copy trading or third-party services. The annual report describes only '+Insights', an analytics tool on customer trends. The UK website and FAQ could not be read, so the grade stays open.
Missing A statement by Plus500UK Ltd, in its FAQ or terms, that copy or social trading is or is not offered to UK CFD clients, including through third-party services.
7 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Plus500UK Ltd, CFDs on the Plus500 trading platform, retail client, United KingdomEstablished from documents
Plus500UK Ltd deals as principal and sole execution venue, and its execution policy says an identical hedge trade is booked with its parent, Plus500 Ltd, for each client trade. That is a back-to-back route to a group company, which by the reviewer's rule is 4 on its own. Onward routing is not left open: the same policy speaks of Plus500 Ltd either executing a hedge or retaining the principal risk, and the group's annual report says not all net client exposure is hedged. The user agreement only says the firm may hedge with a financial institution. Routing outside the group is therefore discretionary, which is grade 4; this does not establish how much is actually kept in-house.
- IB-only preference 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–4. Not a finding.Scope: Plus500 brand partner programmes: 500Affiliates (Plus500 Ltd and group) and the affiliate clause of the Plus500UK Ltd user agreement; US futures introducing brokers noted separatelyInvestigated, not settled
CPA is documented three times: the UK client agreement says all affiliates are paid on a cost-per-acquisition basis by Plus500 Ltd, the 500Affiliates payment plan pays a one-off amount per qualified trader, and the affiliation agreement says the plan ignores trading volume and deposit size. No introducing-broker or revenue-share plan for referred clients is published. Two points keep it from an exact 0: the agreement words the second-tier fee for referred affiliates as a percentage of the revenues their traders generate, and the annual report says the US futures business serves introducing brokers without saying how they are paid. For affiliates introducing clients to the UK CFD company alone, the documents read as CPA only.
Missing Whether the referred-affiliate fee is a share of client revenue or of CPA payouts, and whether any Plus500 company pays introducing brokers a revenue or volume share (the US futures business names IBs without terms).
7 addresses tried
-
92overallequal
ThinkMarkets
Profile Best IB-only 4 · weakest 4 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
0.6/105 penalties
Breakdown for ThinkMarkets
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a group-level list of the companies that contract with ThinkMarkets clients, and a regulator or brand record read today for South Africa (and for any Cayman, Mauritius or Saint Lucia company).
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing what the UK terms and order execution policy commit to: whether the firm may hedge or internalise at its discretion, the named execution venue or hedge counterparty, and whether TF Global Markets (Aust) Pty Ltd passes the positions on outside the group.
- IB-only preference4PPenalty: low end of 4–10 · missing a partner page or partner agreement read today that states the introducing-broker remuneration, and one that states whether a CPA or affiliate plan is offered or excluded.
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level review across regulator and company-register records, not a single account offer: TF Global Markets (UK) Limited (United Kingdom, FCA 629628) for execution; four licensed group companies for structure. www.thinkmarkets.com refused every plain request on 19 Nov 2026, so costs, copy trading and partner terms were read for no entity.
Summary Regulator registers show licensed ThinkMarkets dealing companies in at least four jurisdictions and the UK company's 2025 accounts say client positions are matched with a liquidity provider; pricing, copy trading and partner terms could not be read because the website refused retrieval.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: ThinkMarkets brand, group levelInvestigated, not settled
Four regulators list a licensed ThinkMarkets dealing company today: the FCA (United Kingdom), CySEC (Cyprus, trade name ThinkMarkets with approved domains), the Seychelles FSA (trade name ThinkMarkets) and ASIC (Australia, licensed to issue derivatives to retail clients). At least four operating jurisdictions gives 0–2. A fifth would make it 0: the 17 Nov record counted South Africa from the brand's own pages, which refused retrieval today, and the FSCA search could not be read, so South Africa is supported today only by a company-existence record. No group-level list of operating entities was readable, so the count is a lower bound. The Dubai branch of the UK company is a branch and is not counted. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Missing A group-level list of the companies that contract with ThinkMarkets clients, and a regulator or brand record read today for South Africa (and for any Cayman, Mauritius or Saint Lucia company).
Count lower bound 4
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: No entity or account established; the intended scope was TF Global Markets (UK) Limited, cheapest ordinary retail account, USDNot established
No account, spread or commission page of any ThinkMarkets entity could be read today: every address on www.thinkmarkets.com, including direct PDF links, returned a Cloudflare challenge page to plain requests. Without a published average or typical EUR/USD spread tied to a named account and its commission, no grade or bound can be given. The 17 Nov record notes that the UK costs and charges statement holds worked examples, which do not narrow the range.
Missing The account names, the commission per lot on each platform, and a EUR/USD average or typical spread that the page labels for one named account.
8 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: No entity or product established; ThinkCopy is named only in search resultsNot established
Search results point to a ThinkCopy product page and a user guide on www.thinkmarkets.com, but neither could be retrieved, and the app-store listings returned 'not found'. Search results are leads, not sources, so nothing about automation, sizing, follower controls or fees is recorded as documented, and it is not established which legal entity offers the product.
Missing A readable ThinkCopy page, guide or terms stating whether copying is automatic, how copied volume is sized, how a follower stops or pauses, what fees apply, and which entity offers it.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: TF Global Markets (UK) Limited (United Kingdom, FCA 629628), spread betting, forex and CFD accounts, financial year 2025. Not the Cyprus, Seychelles, Australian or other group companies.Investigated, not settled
The UK company's audited 2025 accounts say every client position is matched at the same time with its liquidity provider and that it holds no unhedged positions. That is a statutory report, not a commitment to clients, so like a non-binding statement it gives 0–6; the client terms and execution policy refused retrieval. The accounts do not name the provider, but a collateral deposit against client positions sits with the Australian parent and all UK turnover is a fee from that parent, which points to a route inside the group. Under the reviewer's rule a group route alone would be 4, and 6 needs routing outside the group, which nothing read today shows.
Missing What the UK terms and order execution policy commit to: whether the firm may hedge or internalise at its discretion, the named execution venue or hedge counterparty, and whether TF Global Markets (Aust) Pty Ltd passes the positions on outside the group.
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 4PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 4–10. Not a finding.Scope: ThinkMarkets partner programmes, brand level; no entity established todayInvestigated, not settled
No partner page could be read today, so nothing is confirmed or corrected. The record of 18 November graded 4–10 on documented introducing-broker remuneration (source owner-think-ib); that page refused retrieval today and was neither re-verified nor contradicted, so the earlier range stands on the earlier source.
Missing A partner page or partner agreement read today that states the introducing-broker remuneration, and one that states whether a CPA or affiliate plan is offered or excluded.
5 addresses tried
-
93overallequal
Trading 212
Profile Best A-book 4 · weakest 4 criteria 0 (penalty)
Availability not confirmedUK company on file
0.6/103 penalties
Breakdown for Trading 212
- Company structure0Five or more
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment4Discretionary or mixed routing
- IB-only preference0PPenalty: nothing established
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not a single account offer. Costs, copy and abook all rest on Trading 212 UK Ltd (United Kingdom, FCA 609146, company number 08590005), the counterparty in the UK CFD Terms for the CFD account on the Trading 212 platform. Structure is assessed at group level from each company's own client documents, the brand help centre and ESMA's register of investment firms. The affiliate criterion looks at the brand's programmes; the only terms that could be read are the Invite a Friend terms of Trading 212 UK Ltd, Trading 212 Markets Ltd and Trading 212 EU GmbH, which exclude CFD accounts.
Summary Trading 212 UK Ltd is always the principal to its clients' CFD trades and hedges only where it chooses, with outside parties or with its Irish group company, inside a brand that works through companies in at least five jurisdictions; no average EUR/USD spread, no statement on copy trading of CFDs and no affiliate payment terms could be read, because www.trading212.com refused every web page.
- Company structure 0Grade 0: five or moreScope: Trading 212 brand, group levelEstablished from documents
Four Trading 212 companies contract with clients: the UK, Cyprus, Germany and Australia. A fifth, Trading 212 Markets (Ireland) Limited, is described in the UK Order Execution Policy (clauses 10.1–10.2, 11.2 and 12) as the group execution company: it executes routed orders externally or through its own systematic internaliser and is a relied-on execution venue. That is an operating brokerage role, not just a registration, so the brand has at least five operating jurisdictions and the grade is 0. Five is a lower bound, not an exact count; Bulgaria is on the register and is not counted without operational evidence. The grade reflects the owner's simplicity preference and is not a safety finding.
Count lower bound 5
1 address tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Trading 212 UK Ltd, CFD account on the Trading 212 platform, EUR/USD, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No published average, typical or minimum EUR/USD spread for Trading 212 UK Ltd could be read. The help centre says CFD trades carry no commission, that all CFD spreads are floating and that an average spread per instrument is published on the Trading Instruments page of www.trading212.com; that page and the CFD 'Terms and Fees' page refused every request. The UK execution policy says the firm adds its own mark-up to the reference price and gives no figure. With no spread figure there is no dollar cost and no bound, so the range stays open.
Missing The average EUR/USD spread that Trading 212 publishes for its CFD account on the Trading Instruments page, with the period it covers and a label tying it to the UK company's CFD account.
Average spread published Said to be on the Trading Instruments page of www.trading212.com; not read
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Trading 212 UK Ltd, CFD account on the Trading 212 platform, United KingdomInvestigated, not settled
No Trading 212 document read today describes automated copying of another trader's CFD trades, and none says in terms that copy or social trading of CFD trades is not offered. Two documents point away from it: the help centre says copying Pies is not available on CFD accounts, and the UK CFD Terms prohibit algorithmic trading and running an account for someone else. The first covers only the Pie feature and the second is a ban on client algorithms, so neither is an explicit 'not offered' that also covers third-party services. Pies with AutoInvest and Pie copying are shareable portfolios of shares on the investing side, where the copier must accept each change; they are recorded as a comparison and do not count as automated leader copying.
Missing A statement by Trading 212 UK Ltd, in its help centre, product pages or terms, that copy or social trading of CFD trades is or is not offered, including through third-party services.
10 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 4Grade 4: discretionary or mixed routingScope: Trading 212 UK Ltd, CFD account on the Trading 212 platform, retail client, United KingdomEstablished from documents
The UK execution policy, which is part of the client agreement, says Trading 212 UK Ltd is always the principal counterparty and sole execution venue for CFD orders and that it 'may choose' to hedge part or all of its CFDs, with external third parties or with other group companies such as Trading 212 Markets (Ireland) Limited. The disclosure notice repeats that it may hedge or offset with the Irish group company. Hedging is therefore discretionary and may stay inside the group; nothing commits the firm to route any trade outside the group. That is the anchor for discretionary or mixed internal-or-external hedging, grade 4. It does not establish how much the firm actually keeps on its own book.
- IB-only preference 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Trading 212 brand: affiliate programme (not read) and the Invite a Friend programme of Trading 212 UK Ltd, Trading 212 Markets Ltd and Trading 212 EU GmbHInvestigated, not settled
The brand runs two things. Its Invite a Friend programme is a client referral scheme: a one-off reward, a share worth EUR 8 to 100 or cash, to the referrer and the new client once the new client funds an Invest, Stocks ISA or SIPP account, capped at five referrals and closed to CFD accounts. That is a fixed reward per referred client in kind, not a share of revenue or volume, and as for other brokers in this review a client referral bonus is not counted as a CPA partner programme. The same terms say a referrer can apply to become an 'Affiliate of Trading 212', so a partner programme exists, but its page on www.trading212.com refused every request and no document read says whether affiliates are paid per acquisition, by revenue share or by volume. Neither payment type is verified, so the range stays open.
Missing How Trading 212 pays its affiliates and partners: per acquired client (CPA), by share of revenue or spread, by volume, or a mix, and for which account types and companies.
8 addresses tried
-
94overallequal
0.0/105 penalties
Breakdown for AdroFx
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–7 · missing a closed, current list of the companies that operate the AdroFx brand, and the name of the company that contracts with clients in the client terms.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: low end of 0–6 · missing adroFx's own order execution policy, or any clause saying whether client orders are hedged or passed to a party outside the group.
- IB-only preference0PPenalty: nothing established
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope AdroFx · candidate only · brand-level review of the one site still reachable (adrofx.club), which names ADROMKT Limited, Vanuatu, company number 700546; not an account offer for any country. The adrofx.com address named in the FCA warning is parked for sale.
Summary The brand's main site, adrofx.com, was parked for sale when checked on 19 November 2026, and the only live official site carries a home page, footer pages and one client-terms document. All five criteria were investigated and stay ranges; this candidate is listed and cannot be ranked on the documents that exist.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–7. Not a finding.Scope: AdroFx brand; ADROMKT Limited (Vanuatu) as named on adrofx.clubInvestigated, not settled
The one reachable AdroFx site names a single company, ADROMKT Limited in Vanuatu, so one operating jurisdiction is disclosed. Nothing published is a closed group list: the client terms name no company, the site's legal pages speak of 'Affiliated Partners' and a 'group of companies' without listing them, and the former main site at adrofx.com is parked for sale. One company found, outside Europe, Seychelles and Saint Lucia, gives 0 to 7.
Missing A closed, current list of the companies that operate the AdroFx brand, and the name of the company that contracts with clients in the client terms.
Count lower bound 1
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: AdroFx brand as published on adrofx.club; no account namedInvestigated, not settled
No account page, contract specification or spread table of AdroFx can be read: adrofx.com is parked and adrofx.club has no such pages. The only price statement is a lowest-spread claim of 0.4 pips with no commission, tied to no account and no instrument. That is not an average or typical EUR/USD spread, and as a minimum it would allow a cost as low as USD 4, which does not narrow the range.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for a named ordinary retail account, with that account's round-trip commission.
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: AdroFx brand as published on adrofx.club; product and platform not namedInvestigated, not settled
The reachable site names copy trading and says a client can choose traders to follow, but it does not describe the product: nothing says trades are replicated automatically, and there is no sizing rule, stop or pause control, or fee. A service that is only named is not documented automation, and there is no statement that copying is not offered, so neither a grade of 4 or more nor 0 is supported.
Missing The broker's own description of the copy product: whether follower trades are opened automatically, how they are sized, how a follower stops or pauses, and what it costs.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–6. Not a finding.Scope: AdroFx client terms for MT4 accounts as linked from adrofx.club; contracting company not named in the document (site footer: ADROMKT Limited, Vanuatu)Investigated, not settled
The client terms linked from the current site make the company the principal and the sole execution venue and contain no undertaking to route or hedge orders externally; acting as principal alone does not establish a B-book. The only sign of external routing is an 'ecn/stp' award caption on the home page, which is marketing. The order execution policy the terms refer to could not be read for this brand, so the range a marketing statement allows is kept.
Missing AdroFx's own order execution policy, or any clause saying whether client orders are hedged or passed to a party outside the group.
5 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: AdroFx brand partner programme as published on adrofx.clubInvestigated, not settled
A partner programme exists: the site advertises affiliate plans that pay commission, lists a partnership team, and the client terms allow fees to people who introduce clients. None of these says what triggers the payment, so neither an IB or revenue-share model nor a CPA model is documented. The partner site the menu links to does not resolve.
Missing The partner terms: programme name, payment trigger (per funded client, per lot, share of revenue) and who can take part.
5 addresses tried
-
Breakdown for Finam
- Company structure0PPenalty: nothing established
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference0PPenalty: nothing established
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not an account offer: FINAM FOREX LLC (ООО «ФИНАМ ФОРЕКС», Moscow, Russia, Bank of Russia forex-dealer licence 045-13961-020000, finamfx.ru) for costs, copy, abook and affiliate; structure at brand level (Finam group), where only Russian companies could be read. FINAM FOREX LLC states that its clients can only be adult citizens of the Russian Federation. No fact from AO FINAM (securities broker) or Bank FINAM is used for the product criteria.
Summary Only the public pages of FINAM FOREX LLC on finamfx.ru and the Bank of Russia records could be read: they document a Russian licensed forex dealer open to Russian citizens only and a no-commission statement, while its framework agreement, tariffs, any copy-service terms and partner terms sit on finam.ru hosts that refused plain requests, so no criterion has an exact grade.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Finam brand as a whole; companies read: FINAM FOREX LLC and AO FINAM, both RussiaInvestigated, not settled
FINAM FOREX LLC, the brand's forex dealer, is a Moscow company on the Bank of Russia record and says it belongs to the Finam group; the brand's securities broker, AO FINAM, is also a Moscow company on the same register. No operating company outside Russia was found, but every group page on finam.ru (about, licences, annual report) answered plain requests with a script challenge, so no group list was read and one jurisdiction is only a lower bound. The anchor defines Europe geographically and both companies are registered in Moscow, so the ceiling used is the one-European-jurisdiction grade; if the reviewer classes Russia as 'one other jurisdiction' the ceiling is 7.
Missing A group-level list of the Finam group's operating brokerage companies, in particular whether any operating or client-contracting company exists outside Russia (including companies trading under other brand names).
Count lower bound 1
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: FINAM FOREX LLC, trading account on MT4 or MT5, EUR/USD, Russia; whether a USD-denominated account is offered was not establishedInvestigated, not settled
finamfx.ru shows one trading account route on MetaTrader 4 or MetaTrader 5 with no account tiers, names 'Отсутствие комиссии' (no commission) among its advantages and shows the EUR/USD spread only as a live ask-minus-bid figure calculated in the browser. No minimum, average or typical EUR/USD spread is published on the pages that could be read, and the tariff document sits on forex.finam.ru, which could not be read. A live quote does not narrow the range, so no bound can be set.
Missing A EUR/USD spread that FINAM FOREX LLC publishes as average or typical for its trading account, the tariff confirming that no commission is charged, and whether a USD account exists.
Account Single trading account of FINAM FOREX LLC on MetaTrader 4 or MetaTrader 5; no account tiers are published on finamfx.ruAverage spread published no
9 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: FINAM FOREX LLC, MT4 and MT5 trading accounts, Russia; the group's 'Автоследование' service (comon.ru) is a separate offer whose legal entity and eligible accounts were not readInvestigated, not settled
No copy service for FINAM FOREX accounts is described on finamfx.ru. The MetaTrader 4 page lists trading signals as a platform feature in one line without describing how copying works, and the site header links 'Автоследование' to comon.ru, a group site that refused the request, so neither its operator nor the accounts it serves were read. A service that is only named is not documented automation, and no page says that copying is not offered, so the range stays open.
Missing Whether FINAM FOREX LLC offers automated leader/follower copying on its forex accounts (own service, MetaTrader Signals presented as its service, or the group's autofollow service), or an explicit statement that it does not.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: FINAM FOREX LLC, forex-dealer contracts (currency pairs and CFDs) on MT4 and MT5, RussiaInvestigated, not settled
FINAM FOREX LLC's disclosure describes its service as concluding over-the-counter forward contracts with clients under its framework agreement, which makes the company the client's counterparty. Acting as principal alone is not B-book and says nothing about hedging. The framework agreement and service terms, which would say whether and where client positions are hedged, are published on forex.finam.ru, and that host could not be read.
Missing The clauses of the FINAM FOREX LLC framework agreement and service terms on how client orders are executed and whether positions are hedged with an outside counterparty, at the firm's discretion or not at all.
6 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: FINAM FOREX LLC and the Finam group's partnership offer as linked from finamfx.ru, RussiaInvestigated, not settled
No partner programme terms could be read. The dealer's disclosure mentions an 'Agent (Representative)' of the forex dealer as a place where clients can deal with the company, and the site footer invites visitors to start a joint business in their city through a finam.ru page that answered with a script challenge. Neither says how a partner is paid, so neither a revenue-share or per-lot programme nor a per-client payment is documented, and nothing says that either is absent.
Missing The terms on which FINAM FOREX LLC or the Finam group pays agents or partners for forex clients: the trigger (per funded client, per lot, share of revenue), who can take part, and the programme's name.
5 addresses tried
-
96overallequal
0.0/105 penalties
Breakdown for Fintana
- Company structure0PPenalty: nothing established
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference0PPenalty: nothing established
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Fintana brand-level review, not an account offer. Fintana Trading Ltd (Mauritius, company C197666) is the only entity confirmed from a register on 19 Nov 2026; its client-contracting role could not be re-read because fintana.com refused every request.
Summary No criterion could be graded: fintana.com refused every request on 19 Nov 2026, so only the Mauritius company registration is confirmed and costs, copying, execution policy and partner programmes remain unread.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Fintana brand; Fintana Trading Ltd, Mauritius (registration only)Investigated, not settled
The LEI register confirms that Fintana Trading Ltd is a registered, active Mauritius company (C197666), but a registration alone does not show an operating or client-contracting role. The documents that would show it (the legal centre and the April 2026 client agreement noted on 17 Nov 2026) and the Mauritius FSC register could not be read today, and the CySEC entry for the Cyprus firm named by a lead does not mention Fintana. If the client agreement is re-read and names Fintana Trading Ltd as the contracting party, the range becomes 0–7 (one non-European jurisdiction found, no closed group list).
Missing A document read today that names the company or companies contracting with Fintana clients, and a closed list of the brand's operating companies.
Count lower bound 0
6 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Fintana brand; no account or entity establishedNot established
No account or pricing page of the broker could be read: every address on fintana.com returned a Cloudflare block. No spread, commission or account name is recorded, and none is guessed.
Missing The account types a retail client can open, with an EUR/USD spread labelled as average or typical for a named account and its round-trip commission.
5 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Fintana brand; no product or entity establishedNot established
No product page could be read, so it is not known whether Fintana offers automated leader/follower copying. Absence of a readable page is not evidence that copying is not offered.
Missing Whether the broker documents an automated copy service (own or integrated) and, if so, its sizing rule, follower controls and fees; or an explicit statement that none is offered.
4 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Fintana brand; Fintana Trading Ltd, Mauritius is the entity the unread agreement is expected to coverNot established
The client agreement and any order-execution policy could not be read today. The 17 Nov 2026 screening note describes a Capacity section about transmitting orders to a principal acting as execution venue and inconsistent principal and STP wording elsewhere in the same agreement; that is a lead that was not re-opened, so nothing is graded on it.
Missing The wording of the current client agreement and order-execution policy on capacity, execution venue and hedging, and whether the named venue is a group company.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Fintana brand partner programmesNot established
No partner page or partner terms could be read. Neither an IB or revenue-share programme nor a CPA programme is documented or excluded.
Missing The brand's partner programme pages or terms, with the payment trigger of each programme (per lot, share of revenue, per funded client).
3 addresses tried
-
97overallequal
0.0/105 penalties
Breakdown for FOREX.com
- Company structure0PPenalty: low end of 0–2 · missing a current reading of the brand's regional legal pages (or a group-level list) naming the company that contracts with clients in each region, to re-confirm the United Kingdom, United States and Japan and to settle whether a fifth jurisdiction (Singapore, Canada, Australia or the Cayman Islands) uses the FOREX.com brand.
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference0PPenalty: nothing established
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review across the FOREX.com companies, not a single account offer. Intended company for costs, copy and abook: StoneX Financial Ltd (United Kingdom), as in the earlier record. None of its documents could be re-read on 19 Nov 2026: www.forex.com and www.stonex.com answered every plain request with a Cloudflare challenge, so those three factors and affiliate stay open. Structure is brand-level; StoneX Europe Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC licence 400/21) was confirmed on the regulator's register as using the forex.com trade name.
Summary The brand's own sites refused plain requests on 19 Nov 2026, so costs, copy trading, A-book commitment and affiliate model are not documented here; the CySEC register adds a Cyprus company using the forex.com trade name to the UK, US and Japan companies recorded earlier.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: low end of the evidence range 0–2. Not a finding.Scope: FOREX.com brand, companies that contract with clients under the brand; not StoneX Group as a wholeInvestigated, not settled
Read today: the CySEC register lists StoneX Europe Ltd with forex.com as an approved trade name and three forex.com country sites as approved domains, so Cyprus is a client-contracting jurisdiction of the brand. The United Kingdom, United States and Japan come from the dataset's record of 18 Nov 2026 (the brand's UK regulation page and UK legal centre); that page could not be re-opened today because www.forex.com answered with a Cloudflare challenge, so those three are carried forward and not re-verified. Together that is at least four jurisdictions, which keeps the earlier range of 0-2; only one of the four was verified on 19 Nov 2026. A fifth jurisdiction would make the grade an exact 0, and the regional sites that would show it could not be read. This reflects the owner's simplicity preference, not a safety finding.
Missing A current reading of the brand's regional legal pages (or a group-level list) naming the company that contracts with clients in each region, to re-confirm the United Kingdom, United States and Japan and to settle whether a fifth jurisdiction (Singapore, Canada, Australia or the Cayman Islands) uses the FOREX.com brand.
Count lower bound 4
11 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Intended: StoneX Financial Ltd (United Kingdom), cheapest ordinary retail account, EUR/USD; not readNot established
No pricing page, account page or costs document of any FOREX.com company could be read on 19 Nov 2026: every address on www.forex.com answered a plain request with a Cloudflare challenge. No account, spread or commission figure was seen on a primary page, so nothing is recorded and the range stays 0-10. Figures that appeared in search-result summaries are leads only and are not used.
Missing For one named FOREX.com company: the cheapest ordinary retail account, a published average or typical EUR/USD spread that the page labels for that account, and its round-trip commission per standard lot.
7 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Intended: StoneX Financial Ltd (United Kingdom), all retail platforms; not readNot established
No platform page, help page or product terms of any FOREX.com company could be read on 19 Nov 2026 because www.forex.com refused plain requests. Neither a documented automated copy service nor an explicit statement that none is offered was seen, so the range stays 0-10. A search result points to a copy-trading help page on the Irish and German sites; it was not read and is a lead only, for a different company than the UK one.
Missing A document of the named company that describes an automated leader/follower service (own or integrated) with its sizing rule, follower stop or pause controls and fees, or an explicit statement that no copy trading, including third-party integrations, is offered.
6 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Intended: StoneX Financial Ltd (United Kingdom), retail CFD and forex accounts; not readNot established
The order execution policy and client agreement of the FOREX.com companies could not be read on 19 Nov 2026: the UK legal centre, the UK best-execution page and the StoneX best-execution page all answered with a Cloudflare challenge, and the group annual report could not be fetched from the investor relations host or from EDGAR. No statement on execution venue, routing or hedging was seen, so the range stays 0-10.
Missing The wording of the named company's order execution policy and client agreement on execution venue, on whether client orders are routed or hedged outside the group, and on whether that is a commitment or at the firm's discretion.
7 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: FOREX.com brand partner programmes; not readNot established
No partner page or partner terms of the FOREX.com brand could be read on 19 Nov 2026: www.forex.com and www.stonex.com refused plain requests, including a StoneX marketing-partner terms PDF, and no separate partner host was found. Neither an introducing-broker or revenue-share model nor a CPA model was seen on a primary page, so the range stays 0-10. Search results point to partnership pages on the global and Australian sites; they were not read and are leads only.
Missing The brand's current partner pages or partner terms, showing whether an introducing-broker, revenue-share or per-lot model is offered, whether a CPA model is offered, and which company publishes each.
6 addresses tried
-
98overallequal
0.0/105 penalties
Breakdown for Skilling
- Company structure0PPenalty: nothing established
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference0PPenalty: nothing established
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Brand-level feature review, not a single account offer. All five criteria are scoped to Skilling Ltd (Cyprus, CySEC licence 357/18, approved domain www.skilling.com), the only company found trading under the Skilling name. skilling.com, static.skilling.com, support.skilling.com and partners.skilling.com answered every plain request on 19 Nov 2026 with a Cloudflare challenge, so none of Skilling Ltd's client documents, pricing, copy or partner pages could be read and every criterion stays open. The former non-EU address skilling.com/row now redirects to TradingMoon (TM Trading Limited, Seychelles, FSA licence SD042); that company's pages were read and are recorded as leads for a separately named broker, never as Skilling Ltd terms.
Summary skilling.com and its document host refused every plain request, so the costs, copy trading, execution commitment and partner programme of Skilling Ltd could not be read and all five criteria remain open; the CySEC register confirms the Cyprus company, and the brand's former non-EU address now redirects to a separately named Seychelles broker, TradingMoon, whose terms are recorded as leads only.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Skilling brand; Skilling Ltd, Cyprus, with TM Trading Limited (TradingMoon, Seychelles) recorded as a linked company that is not countedInvestigated, not settled
One operating company trades under the Skilling name in the documents read: Skilling Ltd in Cyprus, which CySEC lists with licence 357/18 and the domain www.skilling.com. One company found never proves a one-jurisdiction group, so the range is 0 to the one-European-jurisdiction grade. The brand's former non-EU address redirects to TradingMoon (TM Trading Limited, Seychelles), and the Seychelles register shows a skilling.com contact address for that company, but no document read states that it belongs to the same group; if the reviewer counts it, the bound becomes at least 2 and the range 0–4.
Missing A group-level statement from Skilling Ltd or its owners listing the operating companies of the group, and whether TM Trading Limited (TradingMoon) is one of them.
Count lower bound 1
5 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Skilling Ltd, Cyprus, ordinary retail accounts; EUR/USD, one standard lot, USD accountInvestigated, not settled
Skilling Ltd's account and pricing pages are on skilling.com, which refused every plain request, so no spread or commission of a Skilling account could be read. The only pricing read belongs to another company: TradingMoon (TM Trading Limited, Seychelles) publishes minimum spreads only, which would not give an exact grade even for that company. Nothing is carried over to Skilling Ltd.
Missing A EUR/USD average or typical spread labelled for a named Skilling Ltd retail account, and that account's round-trip commission.
5 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Skilling Ltd, Cyprus, copy trading offerInvestigated, not settled
Whether Skilling Ltd offers automated copying, and on what terms, could not be read because skilling.com and its document host refused every plain request. TradingMoon (TM Trading Limited, Seychelles) describes an automated copy service with follower limits and pause and stop controls, but that is another company's product and is not carried over.
Missing Whether Skilling Ltd offers an automated leader/follower service to EU clients, and its sizing rule, follower controls and fees.
4 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Skilling Ltd, Cyprus, CFD execution for retail clientsInvestigated, not settled
Skilling Ltd's Best Execution Policy and client agreement are on static.skilling.com, which refused every plain request, so its execution commitment could not be read; the CySEC register only shows that the firm is authorised both to execute orders and to deal on own account, which settles nothing. The earlier screening note that the policy names Skilling as sole execution venue could not be re-opened, and acting as principal alone is not B-book. TradingMoon's agreement lets that company offset or keep positions at its discretion, but it is another company's contract and is not carried over.
Missing The wording of Skilling Ltd's Best Execution Policy and client agreement on execution venue, hedging and whether orders are passed to a company outside the group.
3 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Skilling partner programme (Skilling Ltd, Cyprus)Investigated, not settled
No partner page of Skilling Ltd could be read: the skilling.com partnership page and partners.skilling.com returned a Cloudflare challenge and skillingpartners.com did not answer. TradingMoon's partner page documents both a revenue-share introducer plan and a CPA affiliate plan, but that is the programme of another company under another name and is not carried over.
Missing The payment mechanisms of the Skilling partner programme open to EU-facing partners: revenue share or per-lot, CPA per funded client, or a statement that one of them is not offered.
4 addresses tried
-
99overallequal
0.0/105 penalties
Breakdown for Sway Markets
- Company structure0PPenalty: nothing established
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference0PPenalty: nothing established
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope Sway Markets · candidate only · brand no longer operating: swaymarkets.com has no web address record and no official page could be read. Brand-level review from regulator and business registers only (Sway Markets Pty Ltd, Australia, authorisation ceased; CFTC record giving Saint Vincent and the Grenadines as origin); not an account offer for any country.
Summary The brand's site, swaymarkets.com, had no web address record when checked on 19 November 2026, and its Australian company's ASIC authorisation and business number both ended in June 2025. No account, pricing, execution, copy or partner document could be read, so those four criteria stay fully open and structure is a range from register entries alone; this candidate is listed and cannot be ranked on the documents that exist.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Sway Markets brand as recorded by the CFTC (origin Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) and Sway Markets Pty Ltd (Australia) as recorded by ASIC and the Australian Business Register; historical, the brand's site is offlineInvestigated, not settled
The brand is not operating as far as public sources show: swaymarkets.com has no web address record and no Sway Markets document can be read. The only evidence is regulator records of what the brand was: a CFTC warning-list entry giving Saint Vincent and the Grenadines as origin without naming a company, and an Australian authorised-representative status that ceased on 30 June 2025. The protocol says to grade nothing that cannot be read for a brand that has stopped; historical register entries do not describe a current operating structure, so the criterion stays open.
Missing Any current document of a company operating the Sway Markets brand.
Count lower bound 1
8 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Sway Markets brand; no account, entity or country could be namedNot established
No account page, contract specification or spread table of Sway Markets can be read: the brand's site has no web address record and its help centre is gone. No spread or commission figure of any kind was retrieved from a primary source, so nothing narrows the range.
Missing A published average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for a named ordinary retail account of Sway Markets, with that account's round-trip commission.
Average spread published no
5 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Sway Markets brand; no product, entity or country could be namedNot established
No product page or terms of Sway Markets can be read, so there is neither a description of an automated copy product nor a statement that copying is not offered. A brand that has stopped is not explicit evidence of 'not offered', so 0 is not supported either.
Missing The broker's own description of a copy product (automatic replication, sizing, stop or pause, fees), or an explicit statement that no copying, including third-party integrations, is offered.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Sway Markets brand; no contracting entity could be namedNot established
No client agreement or order execution policy of any Sway Markets company can be read, and no execution statement of the brand, marketing or contractual, was retrieved. The ASIC rows show the Australian company acted as a representative of another licensee, which says nothing about how orders were routed or hedged.
Missing The client agreement or order execution policy of the company that contracted with Sway Markets clients, stating whether orders were hedged or passed to a party outside the group.
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: Sway Markets brand partner programmes; none could be readNot established
No partner page or partner agreement of Sway Markets can be read, so neither an IB or revenue-share model nor a CPA model is documented, and there is no statement that the brand had no partner programme. The 'Affiliates' link on the separate Sway Funded site belongs to a challenge business that says it is not a broker and is not used.
Missing The partner terms of Sway Markets: programme name, payment trigger (per funded client, per lot, share of revenue) and who could take part.
4 addresses tried
-
100overallequal
0.0/105 penalties
Breakdown for TriumphFX
- Company structure0PPenalty: nothing established
- Published costs0PPenalty: nothing established
- Copy trading0PPenalty: nothing established
- A-book commitment0PPenalty: nothing established
- IB-only preference0PPenalty: nothing established
Evidence and sources
Assessed scope TriumphFX · candidate only · brand no longer operating on the check date, so nothing is graded and this is not an account offer for any country. No TriumphFX site could be reached (triumphfx.com and tfxi.com have no web address). The Cyprus company that used the trade name is now Shine Trades (CY) Ltd (CySEC 293/16, formerly Triumph Int. (Cyprus) Ltd); CySEC lists only the trade name 'Shine Trades (CY)' and the domain shinetrades.com for it. The Seychelles licence of Triumph Int. (SC) Limited (SD080) was revoked on 7 November 2024. Documents of Shine Trades (CY) Ltd were read and are recorded in the facts of each criterion as the present trade name of the same Cyprus company; they are not carried to the TriumphFX name.
Summary The TriumphFX brand was not operating when checked on 19 November 2026: its two sites do not resolve, CySEC lists the former Cyprus company only under the trade name Shine Trades (CY), and the Seychelles licence was revoked in 2024, so all five criteria were investigated and stay open ranges; what Shine Trades (CY) Ltd documents today is recorded for reference and not graded under this name.
- Company structure 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: TriumphFX brand; formerly Triumph Int. (Cyprus) Ltd (Cyprus) and Triumph Int. (SC) Limited (Seychelles)Investigated, not settled
No company was found operating under the TriumphFX name on the check date. CySEC ties the trade name Triumph FX and triumphfx.com to the Cyprus company, which is now named Shine Trades (CY) Ltd and is listed with the trade name Shine Trades (CY) and the domain shinetrades.com only; the Seychelles licence of Triumph Int. (SC) Limited was revoked on 7 November 2024 and the firm is not on the current Seychelles list. A count of operating jurisdictions cannot be made for a brand that is not operating, so the range stays 0–10.
Missing Any company that currently offers accounts under the TriumphFX name, and the group's own list of operating companies.
Count lower bound 0
7 addresses tried
- Published costs 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: TriumphFX brand; no account readableInvestigated, not settled
No TriumphFX account or pricing page could be read, because the brand's sites do not resolve, so no cost can be graded under this name. For reference only, the Cyprus company's present site (Shine Trades) shows EURUSD with a minimum of 0.4 and an average of 0.6 pips in a table with no account label, says elsewhere that all account types share the same spreads with no commissions, and in a cost example shows a USD 6 commission per lot. Those figures belong to another trade name and are not graded here.
Missing A TriumphFX account page with an average or typical EUR/USD spread labelled for a named account, and its commission.
6 addresses tried
- Copy trading 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: TriumphFX brand; no product page readableInvestigated, not settled
No TriumphFX product page could be read, so neither a copy service nor a statement that none is offered can be documented for this name. For reference only, the Cyprus company's present site (Shine Trades) offers cTrader alone and its pages and terms do not mention copy trading at all, which is silence and not an explicit 'not offered'.
Missing Any current TriumphFX document that describes an automated copy service or says that none is offered.
5 addresses tried
- A-book commitment 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: TriumphFX brand; no client agreement readableInvestigated, not settled
No TriumphFX client agreement or execution policy could be read, so nothing can be said about what a TriumphFX contract commits to. For reference only, the order execution policy of the Cyprus company under its present name, Shine Trades (CY) Ltd, sends all client orders to one named venue, GBE Brokers Ltd, by opening an identical order there per order or in aggregate, and says the company acts as agent and not as principal. That policy is published under the Shine Trades name and is not graded here.
Missing A current client agreement or execution policy issued under the TriumphFX name.
4 addresses tried
- IB-only preference 0PPenalty grade: nothing established, so 0. Not a finding.Scope: TriumphFX brand; no partner programme readableInvestigated, not settled
No TriumphFX partner page or partner terms could be read, so no programme can be documented for this name. For reference only, the Cyprus company's present site (Shine Trades) describes an Introducing Broker programme that pays commission each time a referred client trades, and a separate Affiliates programme paid on 'successful conversion' whose trigger and amounts are not stated. Those programmes run under another trade name and are not graded here.
Missing Any current partner programme terms issued under the TriumphFX name.
5 addresses tried
No broker matches “”.